Who is Senate parliamentarian? What to know about staffer Trump seeks to overrule
The low-profile congressional official has been thrust into the spotlight after issuing a procedural decision on the GOP-backed spending bill, drawing sharp responses from some Republicans.
President Donald Trump himself has even weighed in, calling for the 'unelected senate staffer' to be ignored.
Who is the Senate parliamentarian? What powers do they have? And why are Republicans up in arms? Here is what to know.
Who is the parliamentarian?
The Senate parliamentarian is a nonpartisan advisor who makes recommendations to lawmakers regarding the interpretation of rules and precedents in the upper chamber.
The role was established in 1935 amid the passage of a slew of New Deal-era laws, which 'expanded opportunities for procedural confusion and mischief,' according to Senate records.
The parliamentarian is appointed by the Senate majority leader and serves at their pleasure, according to the National Constitution Center.
The official's rulings are not necessarily final.
The presiding officer of the Senate — typically the vice president or the president pro tempore — can simply ignore their advice, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center.
This has happened a few times in recent history, including in 2017, when GOP lawmakers changed Senate rules to allow Supreme Court nominees to be confirmed with a simple majority.
That said, the Senate typically adheres to the parliamentarian's guidance, according to Time. This included in 2021, when the staffer rejected Democrats' attempt to include a pathway to citizenship for illegal immigrants in the 'Build Back Better' bill.
Currently, the office of the parliamentarian is held by Elizabeth MacDonough, who has served in the position since 2012. She was appointed by then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, a Democrat.
MacDonough formerly worked at the Senate library and as a trial attorney, according to the Wall Street Journal. She also advised former Vice President Al Gore during a recount dispute following the 2000 election.
Why are Republicans upset?
Some Republicans expressed outrage at the parliamentarian after she issued rulings on the 'Big Beautiful Bill,' which is currently being considered by the Senate, following its passage in the House in May.
In late June, MacDonough ruled that a series of provisions in the bill violate the Senate's Byrd Rule, which prohibits 'extraneous' provisions from being included in budget reconciliation bills.
One such provision would have charged immigrants a $1,000 fee to apply for asylum in the U.S., according to The Hill.
MacDonough also ruled against several provisions that affect Medicaid. One was a proposed cap on provider taxes, which states use to fund Medicaid, according to CNBC. Another would block noncitizens from accessing Medicaid in addition to other health programs, according to USA Today.
In response to these proposed changes, multiple GOP lawmakers telegraphed their frustration with MacDonough.
'The WOKE Senate Parliamentarian, who was appointed by Harry Reid and advised Al Gore, just STRUCK DOWN a provision BANNING illegals from stealing Medicaid from American citizens,' Sen. Tommy Tuberville, a Republican from Alabama, wrote on X, formerly Twitter, on June 26. 'THE SENATE PARLIAMENTARIAN SHOULD BE FIRED ASAP.'
Rep. Greg Steube, a Florida Republican, also singled out MacDonough for criticism.
'How is it that an unelected swamp bureaucrat, who was appointed by Harry Reid over a decade ago, gets to decide what can and cannot go in President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill?' he wrote on X.
He then called on Vice President JD Vance — using his power as the presiding officer in the Senate — to ignore the proposed changes.
Trump appeared to concur with this view.
'Great Congressman Greg Steube is 100% correct,' he wrote on Truth Social on June 29. 'An unelected Senate Staffer (Parliamentarian), should not be allowed to hurt the Republicans Bill. Wants many fantastic things out. NO!'
However, Senate Majority Leader John Thune, a South Dakota Republican, poured cold water on the push to sideline MacDonough.
When asked by Politico about overruling her on June 26, Thune said, 'No, that would not be a good option for getting a bill done.'
Meanwhile, other Republicans have defended MacDonough.
North Carolina Sen. Thom Thillis, who recently announced he will not seek reelection, called her a 'straight shooter,' according to Reuters. And Louisiana Sen. John Kennedy told reporters, 'Nah, never overrule the parliamentarian.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
28 minutes ago
- CNBC
Jim Cramer unpacks Tuesday's 'countertrend' market rally
CNBC's Jim Cramer reviewed Tuesday's Wall Street action, suggesting the market is experiencing a "countertrend" rally as investors rotate out of Big Tech and into sectors that have been lagging. "If this countertrend rally continues, so many stocks that sat out the first half will keep running, while this year's big winners go through a temporary cooling off period," he said. While the S&P 500 dipped 0.11% and the tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite lost 0.82%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average gained 0.91%. According to Cramer, some of this action came as a result of President Donald Trump's tax and spending bill, which could bode well for the housing market. The Senate passed the megabill on Tuesday. However, it is now headed back to the House, where it is certain to face scrutiny. A number of GOP lawmakers are wary of the bill because of its potential to increase the U.S.'s deficit, which is already substantial. Cramer said the bill's victory in the Senate helped propel housing stocks, certain retailers and banks. But some of the rally was "nothing more than the left behind stocks playing catch-up," saying drug stocks, for example, "had a rare day in the sun." He picked out a few stocks in these reinvigorated sectors that he feels are "best of breed" in their industries. For housing, he pinpointed Toll Brothers, saying the high-end homebuilder put up a solid quarter, and it might be poised to do well if wealthier consumers receive tax breaks. He said he liked retailers Home Depot and Kontoor Brands, which owns Wrangler and Lee jeans. According to Cramer, Home Depot usually works in the long term, praising the retailer's ability to reinvent itself. He said he's positive on Kontoor Brands in part because of its recent acquisition of Helly Hansen, an outdoor gear brand. Cramer also said there are a number of winners from the first half of the year that are likely to finish out the year much higher, such as GE Vernova, Palantir and Howmet. He told investors to let these stocks cool off and return to them "when the rotation has run its course." However, he said Palantir has taken a "rare dip" and can be bought as soon as Monday. "You are witnessing, or, I hope, participating in, one of the most equal opportunity bull markets I have ever seen," Cramer said. Click here to download Jim Cramer's Guide to Investing at no cost to help you build long-term wealth and invest The CNBC Investing Club holds shares of Home Depot and GE Vernova.
USA Today
29 minutes ago
- USA Today
Groups express 'deep concern' about 2026 World Cup in US due to Trump's policies
More than 80 civil rights and labor groups sent a letter to FIFA on July 1 expressing "deep concern" over the U.S. government's immigration policies ahead of the 2026 World Cup in men's soccer. In the letter, which was first reported by The Athletic, the groups cited President Donald Trump's executive order banning visitors from 12 countries as well as the ongoing raids by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in communities across the country, some of which are slated to host World Cup matches next summer. They called on FIFA to "use its influence to encourage the U.S. government to guarantee the fundamental rights of the millions of foreign visitors and fans." "If FIFA continues to stay silent, not only will millions be placed at risk, but the FIFA brand will also be used as a public relations tool to whitewash the reputation of an increasingly authoritarian government," the civil rights and labor groups wrote. Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, the American Civil Liberties Union and the NAACP were among the most prominent national organizations to sign the letter, which was also endorsed by eight fan clubs of soccer teams. The United States is currently hosting the FIFA Club World Cup for men's soccer. FIFA did not immediately reply to an e-mail seeking comment on the letter. The organization and its president, Gianni Infantino, have repeatedly said foreign spectators and teams will have no issues entering the country next summer. "The world is welcome in America," Infantino told reporters on May 15. "Of course, the players, of course, everyone involved, all of us, but definitely also all the fans." The Trump administration has echoed that sentiment, albeit with the caveat that fans will not be allowed to overstay their visas or otherwise remain in the country following the tournament. "I know we'll have visitors probably from close to 100 countries," Vice President J.D. Vance said in May. "We want them to come, we want them to celebrate, we want them to watch the game(s). But when the time is up, they'll have to go home, otherwise they will have to talk to (U.S. Homeland Security) Secretary (Kristi) Noem." FIFA also faced questions and criticism from human rights advocacy organizations ahead of the last men's World Cup, in Qatar. The 2026 edition of the event, which will be co-hosted by Canada and Mexico, begins June 11. Contact Tom Schad at tschad@ or on social media @
CBS News
32 minutes ago
- CBS News
Minnesota hospitals brace for potential cuts after Senate passes Trump's "big, beautiful bill"
President Trump's massive tax and spending plan is a step closer to his desk after the U.S. Senate narrowly approved its version of the bill Tuesday morning. In response, protesters rallied outside the state health department in St. Paul. They demonstrated against what could be more than $1 trillion in cuts to programs like Medicaid. At Hennepin Healthcare, nearly 100,000 people use that insurance option. "I am kind of shocked to be honest," Joel Williams, a Medicaid user, said. Williams served as a Chicago police officer for 25 years. He is now disabled with severe asthma, is a kidney transplant recipient and he depends on Medicaid and Medicare. When asked if he was scared about cuts, Williams said, "Definitely. This is major, this is major major. I never thought after years of working... It's unbelievable to me. I'm trying to grasp it." Interim Hennepin Healthcare CEO Dr. Thomas Klemond is also scared. "We are looking at 100 million or more potential losses," Klemond said. "These are projections and the bills are still evolving. We are looking at, can we keep doing what we are doing?" Klemond says as Minnesota's largest safety net hospital, they will continue to treat everyone regardless of ability to pay. He adds that as people lose insurance, emergency room visits will soar. That means other hospital programs, even Hennepin Healthcare's renowned poison center and its burn unit, could be eyed for cuts. Klemond said. "Can we continue doing all of the things we are doing? Can we continue doing most of the things we are doing? Can we survive?" Klemond said. At Hennepin Healthcare and at hospitals around the state and country, this latest vote just raises the level of uncertainty over how they are going to be able to care for patients in the future. Klemond says he expects to start losing Medicaid reimbursements as soon as January 2026 in Minneapolis. There are concerns that some hospitals in small communities will close down altogether. The major health provider for rural Minnesota says they're still processing what is in the bill.
