Thunder Bay City Council changes mind on shelter village site again
Council approved the site — which was recommended by city administration — at its July 14 meeting.
However, on Monday night, councillors voted against ratifying that decision, instead voting in support of a location next to 8th Avenue, known as the Hillyard site.
"City council voted for the status quo, so at least in the south core, we're just looking at more of the same," said Coun. Brian Hamilton, who represents the McKellar Ward.
The Miles Street East site is part of that ward.
"Tough moment for those of us that have been listening to the experts, consulting with the organizations, and really trying to advocate for a well-balanced solution that balances the needs of ... business as well as helping people move their lives forward," Hamilton said. "Tough, emotional night here."
Hamilton voted to ratify the Miles Street East site on Monday. Councillors Greg Johnsen, Kristen Oliver, Kasey Etreni, Shelby Ch'ng, and Andrew Foulds also voted in favour of ratification.
Councillors Rajni Agarwal, Mark Bentz, Albert Aiello, Dominic Pasqualino, Michael Zussino, Trevor Giertuga, and Mayor Ken Boshcoff voted against.
City Manager John Collin said city administration chose Miles Street East because it was the site that offered the best chance for the project to succeed.
Administration has noted in the past that the site is close to services that the occupants regularly access.
The village would include about 80 sleeping cabins for use by the city's unhoused population, with the goal of helping them transition to permanent housing.
In addition, the Miles Street East site is ready for construction, and easy to access by emergency services.
Regarding the Hillyard site, Bentz said it has some positives.
"It doesn't put revitalization at risk," he said during the meeting. "It offers three times the land area compared to Miles."
"It's rather isolated from residential uses."
There are some challenges, however, Bentz said, including the site being located near to an active transportation corridor and an off-leash dog park.
In addition, Bentz said, there is limited information available in terms of environmental concerns with the site, and it's further away from services.
Hamilton had concerns about choosing a new site "on the fly."
"I'm certainly not interested in spending money on a site that is not tested," he said. "It has not passed the consultation publicly, and passed the smell test of our senior leadership, and the organizations that are about to serve the people."
"This is just throwing spaghetti on the wall. I'm not interested in in throwing good money after bad."
Hamilton voted against the Hillyard site, as did Foulds, Johnsen, and Giertuga.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Cabinet minister who criticized interpreter says she is focused on doing better
Nahanni Fontaine is photographed at the Manitoba Legislature in Winnipeg on Tuesday, November 15, 2016. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods< WINNIPEG — A Manitoba cabinet minister who criticized a sign language interpreter says she is focused on doing better and improving services for people with disabilities. Nahanni Fontaine, the minister responsible for services for people with disabilities, has repeatedly apologized for remarks she made last month while hosting a celebration for Indigenous women graduates. While preparing to speak to reporters after, Fontaine told one of her staff that she was thrown off by a sign language interpreter's presence and that the woman should not have been on stage. Fontaine held a news conference today to announce $820,000 in grants this year under an annual program that funds groups who help reduce barriers for people with disabilities. Fontaine says work is underway to better enforce accessibility standards, which could mean fines for businesses who fail to have a wheelchair ramp where required by law, for example. She also says her department will have sign language interpreters at all public events and the government will hire two dedicated interpreters to support all departments. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025 Steve Lambert, The Canadian Press
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘We have his back': Prime minister, premiers take united approach in trade talk strategy
The Council of the Federation's three-day summer session in Huntsville, Ont., wrapped up Wednesday. The primary focus of the meetings has been the ongoing negotiations with the White House. On July 10, President Donald Trump announced the U.S. will charge a 35 per cent tariff on Canadian imports starting Aug. 1. 'Well, look, if President Trump has taught us anything, it's that we shouldn't get hung up on anything because he can change his mind at the drop of a hat and a deal isn't a deal,' said New Brunswick Premier Susan Holt. 'So that's the real challenge for all of New Brunswick's entrepreneurs is, no matter what happens on Aug. 1, are we going to be able to trust that that's then going to stay in place for any foreseeable length of time?' Holts says the consensus is the end result is more important than the speediness of the result. 'I think we've realized that there is a possibility to end up in a much worse situation than the one that we're in now, while we push to end up in a better situation,' said Holt. 'So, it's figuring out what is that push to get a better deal to get rid of those tariffs that doesn't risk us finding ourselves in a much worse position.' Holt says Canada needs to reach a place where there is confidence that the deal that is struck is going to be adhered to by the president of the United States. 'Canada has been under U.S. tariffs for a very long time. This isn't new, as much as it might seem new, and the folks in softwood lumber could speak to that. There's different tariffs that have been in place for different sectors. In some cases, on and off,' said Holt. 'The goal is a tariff-free environment, certainly for softwood lumber, but also for all of the Canadian economy.' 'We have his back' Prime Minister Mark Carney has shifted the goal post in the trade talks between Canada and the United States from a tariff-free deal to getting the best deal possible. 'We are only going to accept the best deal for Canada. We'll take stock if there isn't one. A good deal is something that preserves, reinforces and stabilizes those relationships as much as possible. A good deal is also one that doesn't tie our hands,' said Carney. 'There's always a possibility for this to go sour. So, I think the premiers gave the PM the reassurance that we want the best deal possible. We have his back. We don't want him to take a deal that isn't good for New Brunswick or Canada because of a deadline,' said Holt. Several other premiers shared a similar message Wednesday afternoon, including Ontario Premier Doug Ford. 'With a united Team Canada approach, we're going to build and protect the true north strong and free,' said Ford. Former New Brunswick premier Brian Gallant said Canada needs the U.S., but shouldn't forget tariffs would cause economic pain on the other side of the border, too. 'To see the premiers at and the PM stay united despite the fact there are many political parties represented in the group of 14, so I think that's the number one outcome from these meetings,' said Gallant. 'I think it's also putting Canadians on notice that we may indeed have more uncertainty.' 'Similarly impatient' Holt said the premiers are 'similarly impatient' about a new internal trade agreement. '(We) want to come up with that new Canada free-trade agreement that is simple and clear and eliminates every barrier possible, recognizing that we're each unique provinces,' said Holt in an interview with CTV Atlantic's Todd Battis. 'We each have a thing, whether it's land in P.E.I. or fish in Newfoundland, that needs to be treated differently, but everything else has to go. Particularly in the transport sector. We need to be able to move New Brunswick products to the people in Manitoba or Saskatchewan or B.C. who really want them without that truck having to go through red tape and barriers and change flags and change first aid kits. We're all impatient for that work to be done and to bear fruit.' Memorandum of understanding Holt signed a memorandum of understanding with Premier Wab Kinew of Manitoba to expand the market opportunity for New Brunswick entrepreneurs, without adding administrative burden or new cost. 'I think anytime that we can introduce a new province to our goods and in such a way that makes it easy for entrepreneurs here who might have thought, 'Ah, it's not worth me learning the regulations of Manitoba and figuring out what different packaging I'd have to create for my product in order to sell it there,' said Holt. 'Or, now they can take the product they're already making, the packaging that they already have, and they can send it to Manitoba to sell to new customers without that added cost or added work.' With files from CTV Atlantic's Todd Battis and Nick Moore.
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Gatineau, Que. residents raise concerns over concert by controversial artist at Jacques-Cartier Park
Christian musician Sean Feucht of California sings to the crowd during a rally at the National Mall in Washington, Sunday, Oct. 25, 2020. (Jose Luis Magana/AP Photo) Controversial Christian musician Sean Feucht is set to perform at Jacques-Cartier Park in Gatineau, Que. this weekend, but the show is stirring up frustration from people living in the national capital region. 'My issue isn't that his values don't align with mine or that I have a difference of opinion politically. It's that it's a public space,' said Melissa, a Gatineau resident who asked CTV News Ottawa not to include her last name. 'If it was in a private arena or a private room, I wouldn't be upset by that. People have the right to exist, and they have the right to say whatever they want to say as long as it falls within hate speech laws.' On social media, Feucht describes himself as a missionary, musician, author and 'founder of global movements.' He unsuccessfully ran for congress in 2020 as a Republican candidate in California and has faced criticism for speaking out against abortion rights and the LGTBQ2+ community. He has also grown in popularity within the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement as a prominent figure with nearly 600,000 followers on Facebook and another 166,000 followers on X. Feucht's shows on the east coast have also faced significant pushback, with Parks Canada revoking his permit to perform at the York Redoubt National Historic Site in Halifax for safety and security reasons. He then found a different venue near Halifax to hold his event on Wednesday but permits to perform in both Moncton and Charlottetown on Thursday were reportedly also revoked. 'Theses are worrisome messages. They're very popular in the states. It's popular to beat up on small minority groups as target victims. We saw that in the 1930s in other parts of the world, we just don't feel that's where Canadians want to go,' said lay minister David-Roger Gagnon with St. Paul's United Church in Riverview New Brunswick. 'If this gentleman wants to promote that message, he's welcome to do that in his own country. But in Canada, I don't think those values resonate with us.' Some residents in Gatineau and Ottawa want the National Capital Commission (NCC) to follow suit by calling off his planned performance on July 26 in Jacques-Cartier Park. Sam Feucht Melissa, a Gatineau, Que. resident, says she's concerned over a planned concert by singer Sam Feucht this weekend. (Brad Quinn/CTV News Ottawa) 'It's not about cancelling or holding someone accountable because they don't agree with the same things we agree with. It's that it's in a public space,' said Melissa. 'Our tax dollars are going to fund this space that this person is performing in.' Melissa also expressed scepticism over Feucht's claims on social media that pushback to his shows is rooted in anti-Christian bigotry. 'I'm Christian. Most of my friends are Christian,' she said. 'I don't think there's anything Christian about his public stances on women or marginalized groups.' The NCC did not provide a response to CTV News Ottawa before deadline. With files from The Canadian Press
