Thunder Bay City Council changes mind on shelter village site again
Council approved the site — which was recommended by city administration — at its July 14 meeting.
However, on Monday night, councillors voted against ratifying that decision, instead voting in support of a location next to 8th Avenue, known as the Hillyard site.
"City council voted for the status quo, so at least in the south core, we're just looking at more of the same," said Coun. Brian Hamilton, who represents the McKellar Ward.
The Miles Street East site is part of that ward.
"Tough moment for those of us that have been listening to the experts, consulting with the organizations, and really trying to advocate for a well-balanced solution that balances the needs of ... business as well as helping people move their lives forward," Hamilton said. "Tough, emotional night here."
Hamilton voted to ratify the Miles Street East site on Monday. Councillors Greg Johnsen, Kristen Oliver, Kasey Etreni, Shelby Ch'ng, and Andrew Foulds also voted in favour of ratification.
Councillors Rajni Agarwal, Mark Bentz, Albert Aiello, Dominic Pasqualino, Michael Zussino, Trevor Giertuga, and Mayor Ken Boshcoff voted against.
City Manager John Collin said city administration chose Miles Street East because it was the site that offered the best chance for the project to succeed.
Administration has noted in the past that the site is close to services that the occupants regularly access.
The village would include about 80 sleeping cabins for use by the city's unhoused population, with the goal of helping them transition to permanent housing.
In addition, the Miles Street East site is ready for construction, and easy to access by emergency services.
Regarding the Hillyard site, Bentz said it has some positives.
"It doesn't put revitalization at risk," he said during the meeting. "It offers three times the land area compared to Miles."
"It's rather isolated from residential uses."
There are some challenges, however, Bentz said, including the site being located near to an active transportation corridor and an off-leash dog park.
In addition, Bentz said, there is limited information available in terms of environmental concerns with the site, and it's further away from services.
Hamilton had concerns about choosing a new site "on the fly."
"I'm certainly not interested in spending money on a site that is not tested," he said. "It has not passed the consultation publicly, and passed the smell test of our senior leadership, and the organizations that are about to serve the people."
"This is just throwing spaghetti on the wall. I'm not interested in in throwing good money after bad."
Hamilton voted against the Hillyard site, as did Foulds, Johnsen, and Giertuga.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
3 minutes ago
- National Post
Canada's justice system is bringing itself into disrepute: Full Comment podcast
Article content Article content Article content Article content One-day sentences for aiding and abetting the Islamic State terror group, a few short years for murder, but possibly more if you're an anti-vaccine trucker: these stories and loads of others from recent Canadian court cases seem to be undermining the public's faith in our justice system. Brian Lilley chats with Postmedia columnists Jamie Sarkonak and Chris Selley about how things went so wrong and what to do about it. They also discuss the recent acquittal of the five hockey players for sexual assault, and how the judge's exceptional handling of the case shows that all is not lost if we want to fix the system — if anyone in government is ever willing to try. (Recorded July 25, 2025.) Article content Article content Article content Article content
CBC
12 minutes ago
- CBC
Ottawa makes good on promise to cut Confederation Bridge tolls, ferry fares in Eastern Canada
The federal government is slashing tolls on the Confederation Bridge and lowering ferry fares in Eastern Canada, Prime Minister Mark Carney announced while in Prince Edward Island on Monday. Effective Aug. 1, the cost of crossing the bridge which connects P.E.I. with New Brunswick will fall to $20 from $50.25. Fares for passengers, cars and commercial traffic on ferry services in Eastern Canada that are federally supported will go down by 50 per cent. Those ferries provide service between: Îles-de-la-Madeleine, Que., and Souris, P.E.I. Wood Islands, P.E.I., and Caribou, N.S. Saint John, N.B., and Digby, N.S. The federal government also announced it was scrapping fuel surcharges on those routes. "By cutting tolls on the Confederation Bridge and ferries in Atlantic Canada, Canadians and businesses will save millions of dollars. That means more travel and trade between provinces," Carney said in a written release. Fares for passengers and vehicles on the ferry that operates between Nova Scotia and Newfoundland and Labrador are also going down. Ottawa has pledged to increase funding to the operator, Marine Atlantic, to lower the price by 50 per cent. Ottawa is also freezing commercial freight rates on that route. This is Carney's first time on P.E.I. as prime minister. The announcement makes good on his pledge during the federal election campaign to reduce tolls on the Confederation Bridge and cut ferry fares.
CTV News
25 minutes ago
- CTV News
Permanent move or daily dismantling?: Chatham-Kent mulls encampment response
A response to the latest site of a homeless encampment in Chatham-Kent will be the topic of discussion at a meeting on Monday evening. Darrin Canniff, the municipality's mayor, called a special meeting to address growing concerns over the Chatham-Kent Public Utilities Commission property along Grand Avenue. 'While we must show empathy and understanding for those experiencing homelessness, I believe Chatham-Kent Council also has a responsibility to support the safety, well-being, and quality of life for neighbouring residents and businesses,' Canniff posted to social media on Friday. 'Chatham-Kent is one of the only municipalities that has created a protocol to deal with encampments, but I believe it needs to be strengthened to offer further protection for homeowners, businesses, and neighbourhoods.' On June 14, those living in an encampment along the Thames River were forced to relocate to facilitate slope stabilization work along the waterway. Without direction on where they must go, many people ended up at the PUC property. It's been estimated that upwards of 40 tents are pitched at the site ahead of Monday's meeting. Under an encampment protocol developed by the municipality, unhoused individuals cannot shelter within 10 metres of a private property line. A notice of motion Canniff plans to present to council asks for the protocol to be amended to raise the limit to 100 metres. It also calls for individuals to be limited to one tent each, and that all personal items be stored within their tent. 'This is a complex and constantly evolving situation, and I'm committed to continuing efforts until Chatham-Kent develops a solution to end the need for encampments entirely,' Canniff wrote. The mayor's motion further calls for added work to ensure all housing options are exhausted, more bylaw officers are hired to enforce the protocols, and new CCTV cameras are installed at the discretion of the Chatham-Kent Police Service. When encampment residents moved to the PUC property, those living nearby told CTV News they were concerned about how it would impact the neighbourhood. On July 16, Chatham-Kent police issued a reminder to the public that 9-1-1 is for emergencies only, after receiving calls regarding people camped out on the PUC property. A separate notice of motion by Coun. Michael Bondy seeks to have those living in encampments dismantle their tents each morning, with permission to return each night. Since the encampment moved, Bondy said he's been inundated by messages from 'very upset' residents. 'First of all, they weren't notified. There was zero consultation with the residents in that area of town, and, of course, there's many businesses too that are affected,' Bondy told CTV News. Through his motion, bylaw and police officers will have the power to 'remove, seize, and impound' items that are still there during unpermitted hours. Bondy believes his motion 'strikes a balance' between those residing in nearby homes and those in tents. He noted residents feel a sense of 'intimidation' that prevents them from using nearby trails. 'So that would eliminate stuff in these parks during the course of the day, which is when the general public typically uses these things,' Bondy said. 'The motion stipulates that that would be effective, one hour before sundown and up until one hour after sunrise.' Referencing time he spent working at a homeless shelter in London, Bondy noted those using the services would have to leave during the day. 'It gave them like some structure, so they had to sleep at night, and during the day they were out and about,' he explained. The councillor admitted constituents he's spoken with want to see an outright ban rather than a daily limitation. The motions will both go before council at Monday's meeting , which starts at 6 p.m. in council chambers. — with files from CTV's Chris Campbell.
