Backlash after German minister suggests cap on immigrant students in schools
Welt
tv program over the weekend, Germany's Education Minister Karin Prien (CDU) said she was open to introducing a cap on the number of students with a migrant background in school classes.
Her comments came in response to a question from
Welt's
editor-in-chief, who had referenced similar efforts in Denmark.
Prien suggested that a cap of 30 to 40 percent was a 'conceivable model,' emphasizing that the decisive factor for school success is that children should be able to speak German when they start school.
She called for early, mandatory language tests for four-year-olds and binding language learning support measures for those identified as needing help.
Prien argued that looking at the experiences of other countries—specifically Denmark—could provide valuable insights.
What's happening in Denmark?
While Denmark does not have a formal, nationwide quota for children with a migrant background in schools, it has implemented
similar measures
in certain areas.
In neighbourhoods with a very high proportion of children with a migrant background, the Danish government reportedly required schools to pause the admission of new students and develop plans to attract more 'ethnically Danish' students.
However, these were localised interventions, and not a blanket national quota system.
READ ALSO:
What parents in Germany should know about the planned schools shake up
Reaction in Germany
Prien's remarks were met with immediate and widespread criticism.
The Federal Government's Integration Commissioner, Natalie Pawlik (SPD), rejected the proposal, arguing that 'Germany does not need quotas in the classroom' and that integration is best achieved through targeted support, not exclusion.
The president of the German Teachers' Association, Stefan Düll, said that using a child's foreign roots as a benchmark was not helpful. He called the idea of quotas 'problematic', noting the logistical challenges in areas where almost half the population has a migrant background.
READ ALSO:
How German leaders are blaming foreigners for country's woes
Advertisement
He and other education experts stressed that language skills, not background, should be the main criterion for school admission.
Opposition parties and associations also voiced strong concerns.
The Left Party called the proposal unworkable, especially in urban centres, and warned of stigmatization and exclusion.
The anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD), on the other hand, criticized Prien's proposal as 'too lax', called for a significantly lower limit of ten percent.
READ ALSO:
More childcare, less paperwork - How Germany can make life easier for foreign parents
In fact media reports, including one by the German teachers' magazine
News4teachers
,
have pointed out that the idea of introducing migrant quotas in Germany was first suggested by the AfD.
Not constitutional
Despite the polarised debate that Prien's comments sparked, the legal, practical, and political obstacles to introducing school quotas in Germany appear insurmountable.
Germany's Basic Law (
Grundgesetz
) prohibits discrimination based on origin, meaning that the constitutional court would almost certainly challenge the legality of mandating migrant quotas in schools.
Advertisement
Additionally, in Germany education is primarily the responsibility of states rather than the federal government. So only the states (
Länder
) can implement binding rules on quotas or mandatory language tests.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Germany
5 hours ago
- Local Germany
What Americans need to know about studying in Germany
Germany is a popular choice for aspiring learners from abroad – not least because it offers free or low-cost tuition fees to both domestic and international students. In the 2023/2024 winter semester, around 469,485 international students were registered in Germany, according to statistics compiled by the Wissenschaft Weltoffen. The Bundesrepublik is also home to some of the world's top universities. According to an international university ranking for 2025 by Times Higher Education, the Technical University of Munich (TUM) ranked 26th in the world, while Heidelberg University took the 47th spot. Add to that a solid jobs market with opportunities for English speakers, it's no wonder that Americans are hopping over the Atlantic for a few years or longer. This longing to move among some US citizens and residents has intensified since Donald Trump was re-elected as US President. With the crackdown on immigration, turbulent politics and the rising cost of living showing no signs of dampening down, it's no wonder that many Americans are eyeing Germany to continue their education. READ ALSO: 'I will never move back' - How do Americans in Germany feel about Trump win? Here's what any Americans thinking about applying to study in Germany need to know: You don't have to pay tuition fees (in many cases) When deciding on where to study in Germany, you'll no doubt be thinking about the subject you want to specialise in, where you'd like to live and, of course, how much it's going to cost. In the United States, the cost of going to college depends on factors such as whether it's a public or private institution, and where it's situated. Students on average have to shell out around 38,270 US Dollars per year for their tuition, as well as other expenses like books and supplies, according to recent statistics on education. In Germany, you'll be glad to hear that it's a lot less expensive. In fact, at public universities, you don't even have to pay any tuition fees. Keep in mind, though, that students usually have to pay a Semesterbeitrag (semester fee) which covers administrative costs and other services. This could be anywhere from around €100 to €400, and often includes a public transport ticket. Advertisement Many of these also offer courses in English. If you're up to the job, you can also apply for a course in German, although a B2 level German language certificate will likely be required. Note that non-native English speakers will likely need to show proof of their English language skills. Public universities that provide free tuition and programmes in English include: Berlin's Free University, the University of Hamburg, the University of Göttlingen and University of Freiburg among others. A few universities, such as the Technical University of Munich, have different fee rules for international students so make sure you read the small print. READ ALSO: What international students should know about scholarships in Germany The 'best' universities in Germany for 2025 Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Julian Stratenschulte Even private university tuition in Germany is relatively affordable Budding students in the US may find that one of Germany's many accredited private universities are a better choice for them. That could be down to several reasons such as their varied selection of courses or because there are more English-language opportunities. Some private universities include: Bucerius Law School in Hamburg, Frankfurt School of Finance and Management and Bard College Berlin. There are also some private practical and technical schools - often with Hochschule in the name - offering English-language programmes. Fees are set at the discretion of the university but can be anywhere around €5,000-€7,000 per semester which is lower than many other countries (including the US). Advertisement You'll need a student residence permit As an American, you can enjoy visa-free travel to Germany. Citizens of countries including the US, UK, Canada, Australia, Brazil and Japan are allowed to spend 90 days in the EU in every 180 without needing a visa (although bear in mind that you'll have to get familiar with the EU's new Exit and Entry System rules known as EES). However, Americans do need a student residence permit to attend university. After you've arrived in Germany and registered your address, you'll need to get an appointment at the local immigration office (Ausländerbehörde) – and make sure you have your documents ready to go! CHECKLIST: How to move to Germany as an American The most important one for students is your certificate confirming your enrolment to an accredited study programme in Germany. Bring that along with an application form, biometric pictures and a valid passport. You'll also need to meet other requirements such as having health insurance and some money saved (more on that below). Check the requirements of your local authority because you may need other documents such as proof of your rental contract or a letter from your landlord confirming your address. You'll also have to pay the fee for the permit. Some German universities offer support for their students coming from abroad, including helping them prepare residence permit applications. Advertisement Get familiar with key rules Americans coming to Germany – like other internationals – have to prove that they have enough money to support themselves. This often needs to be stored in a so-called 'blocked account' ( Sperrkonto ), which is a a special type of bank account for international students and other visa applicants. According to the latest figures, internationals starting university generally need a total of €11,904 per year in their account. This amounts to €992 per month for living expenses. Alternatively, some students lean on parental support to prove their financial stability. In this case, you can skip setting up the blocked account and instead provide a guarantee letter ( Verpflichtungserklärung ) from a guardian in which they confirm that they take full financial responsibility for you. The guarantor will need to provide a bank statement or other proof that they have enough money to do so. It is also a requirement in Germany for everyone, including students coming from abroad, to have health insurance. Depending on your age and other factors, you may qualify for public health insurance. Students over 30 generally have to take out private insurance. On average, the cost of student health insurance in Germany is between €130 and €150 per month, according to estimates from October 2024. READ ALSO: How much money do international students need to study in Germany? Be aware of the semester dates and deadlines If you're applying for university in Germany, you need to know when the semesters run, and the deadlines for joining classes. In Germany the academic year is split into two: The winter semester is from October to March and the summer semester runs from April to September. The semesters include a lecture-free period, known as a Semesterferien , when exams are typically scheduled. The deadlines can vary depending on the institution, but many schools have an application deadline around July 15th for courses starting in the autumn/winter period, and around January 15th for courses starting in the spring/summer period. A woman works on her laptop. Photo: Pixabay You can work part-time Students in Germany regularly find a part-time job to boost their bank account. International students, such as those from the US, are allowed to work up to 140 full days or 280 half-days per year without extra approval from authorities. A simpler way to think about it is that students from non-EU countries are allowed to work up to 20 hours per week. During the semester break there are no limits on the number of hours that students can work. READ ALSO: Weimar to Heidelberg - The best German university towns for foreign students Advertisement Many students opt for a minijob, which allows them to earn extra cash without paying full social security contributions. These can be found at bars and cafes, for example. From January 2025, students can earn up to €556 per month in a minijob, working around 43.3 hours per month at the new minimum wage. That works out at around 11 hours per week, which is below the 20 permitted for international students. Alternatively, depending on your industry, there may also be 'working student' ( Werkstudent ) jobs to be found. These jobs can be especially convenient for those on a student residence permit, because they are designed to be aligned with the working time limits mentioned above. They are also intended to let students get their foot in the door and gain some entry-level experience before graduating. Are you an American who has studied in Germany? Share in the comments about how you've found the experience – and any tips.
DW
5 hours ago
- DW
Germany updates: Sabotage suspected in major rail disruption – DW – 07/31/2025
A fire on the main railway line between Düsseldorf and Duisburg has caused major disruptions to train services across western Germany. Police now suspect sabotage. A fire on a rail line between Duisburg and Düsseldorf has paralyzed Deutsche Bahn's main north-south corridor, causing widespread disruptions. A railway spokesperson said train traffic would face massive delays, with the disruption expected to last throughout the day. Long-distance services are also affected. It comes on the same day that Deutsche Bahn reported that 63.4% of its long-distance trains are now arriving within 15 minutes of schedule. In its first-half results, the company also reported a reduced loss of €760 million, nearly €1 billion less than in the same time last year. More than 30,000 people in Germany have signed a petition calling for the return of a Yazidi family deported to Iraq. The family was deported despite a court having lifted their obligation to leave the country on the same day. On Tuesday, last week, 43 people were deported to Iraq on a charter flight from Leipzig to Baghdad. The Yazidi family was among those on board. The Yazidis are a religious minority that suffered genocide at the hands of the so-called "Islamic State" (IS) militant group in Iraq in 2014, making such deportations particularly contentious. Classmates of the family's 6-year-old child appear to have created a petition on stating that the family was deported "for no apparent reason" and urging German authorities to work toward bringing them back. Last week, Brandenburg's Interior Minister Rene Wilke said he wanted to bring the family back quickly in coordination with the federal government. Police in Germany are investigating an alleged act of sabotage targeting a major railway line between Düsseldorf and Duisburg, which has disrupted both regional and long-distance services. The fire broke out in a cable duct near Düsseldorf and was discovered when a train driver noticed smoke and raised the alarm. Deutsche Bahn warned of significant delays, rerouted trains, and suspended stops at several stations in the region. High-speed rail lines to Berlin and Frankfurt am Main, as well as connections to northern and southern Germany and the Netherlands, have also been impacted, the rail operator announced. The cables in the affected tunnel segment were destroyed and will need to be replaced. German lawmakers in the Bundestag's Budget Committee have unlocked €1.1 billion ($1.2 billion) for urgent bridge repairs. It comes after Autobahn GmbH halted contract tenders for 2025 in mid-July due to a lack of funds. The state-owned company warned of major delays to bridge renovations as billions in infrastructure funding remained unavailable. The German government said Thursday's approval means Autobahn can fully spend the €2.5 billion earmarked in the special fund this year for bridge and tunnel rehabilitation, including on major traffic arteries such as the A7 and A3 motorways. As many as 5,000 of the 40,000 bridges along the country's autobahns are in such poor condition that they urgently need repair. More than half of the autobahn bridges were built before 1985, including most of the major valley bridges in former West Germany. Autobahn reported a "dramatic increase" in the maintenance backlog on highways, which could severely impact traffic safety. German inflation remained unchanged in July, preliminary data from the Federal Statistics Office Destatis showed. Annual inflation in Europe's top economy came in at 2.0%. Unemployment in Germany rose by 65,000 in from June to July, just shy of a total of 2.979 million, according to the Federal Employment Agency in Nuremberg. The unemployment rate now stands at 6.3%, with Bremen and Berlin the cities with the most unemployed people. That's 171,000 more than the same time last year. Experts expect the total number of unemployed to top 3 million in August. "Unemployment has risen due to the start of the summer break. Companies remain cautious about reporting new jobs, and employment subject to social insurance contributions is hardly increasing at all," Andrea Nahles, the head of the Federal Employment Agency said. More than 200 celebrities have signed an open letter to Friedrich Merz, stating that "words alone won't save lives" in Gaza. They are urging the German chancellor to halt arms deliveries to Israel over its military actions in Gaza. "We too condemn the horrific crimes committed by Hamas in the strongest possible terms. But no crime justifies collectively punishing millions of innocent people in the most brutal manner," the letter states. Actors Daniel Brühl and Heike Makatsch, along with musicians Shirin David and Zartmann, are among the artists and media personalities who co-signed the letter, which was organized by the campaign group Avaaz. Germany approved €326.5 million ($374 million) in arms exports to Israel in 2023, a sharp increase from previous years. In 2024, approvals fell by half amid mounting legal and political pressure. In addition to calling for a ban on weapons deliveries, the signatories want Merz to support suspending the European Union's Association Agreement with Israel. They also demand an immediate cease-fire and unrestricted access for humanitarian aid. "These steps are deeply in line with European values and would make it unmistakably clear to the Israeli government that even its closest allies can no longer accept the suffering, and that words are not enough," the letter reads. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Once renowned for its punctuality, Germany's rail operator has struggled in recent years to maintain its reputation. However, Deutsche Bahn reported a slight improvement over the past six months, with 63.4% of long-distance trains arriving within 15 minutes of schedule, according to its first-half results. This marks a modest increase from 62.7% in the first half of 2024. The state-owned rail operator said it aims to raise punctuality to between 65% and 70% by the end of the year. Despite ongoing issues with delays, passenger numbers rose to 943 million in the first half of 2025, reflecting continued demand for rail travel. The company also reported a reduced loss of €760 million for the period, nearly €1 billion less than in the same time last year. Revenue increased by 3.4% to €13.3 billion, although it still fell short of internal targets. CEO Richard Lutz emphasized the urgent need to modernize the country's aging rail infrastructure. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Lufthansa, Germany's flagship carrier, reported a 27% increase in second-quarter operating profit year-on-year, reaching €871 million ($995 million). It beat analysts' average forecast of 805 million euros. "Although the second quarter was again marked by geopolitical crises and economic uncertainties, we are today confirming our positive outlook for the full year," Chief Executive Carsten Spohr said in a statement. All airlines belonging to the Lufthansa group, including Swiss, Austrian Airlines, Brussels Airlines, and Ita Airways, reported profits in the period. A German delegation, led by Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul is headed to Israel and the occupied West Bank on Thursday for talks with representatives from the Israeli government and the UN. Wadephul said his "main goal is definitely a ceasefire," but also said something needs to be done "to ease the suffering of people" in Gaza. "The number of victims in the Gaza Strip is too high." Wadephul, from the center-right CDU, will be joined by a member of the Social Democrats (SPD) with whom they govern in a coalition. SPD deputy parliamentary group leader Siemtje Möller told public broadcaster ARD before the two-day trip that "real pressure" was needed to end the suffering in Gaza. Möller gave six aims that Germany has: large-scale humanitarian aid for the Gaza Strip, a ceasefire, the release of hostages held by Hamas, the disarmament of Hamas, peace negotiations, and an end to Israeli settlements in the West Bank that violate international law. Despite its commitment to a two-state solution, Germany has not joined the growing number of Western countries that have pledged to recognize Palestinian statehood in response to the humanitarian crisis caused by Israel in Gaza. However, Möller suggested that Germany could consider recognizing a Palestinian state sooner than expected. "The recognition of a Palestinian state is not a taboo and doesn't necessarily have to come at the end of a [two-state] process," she said before the flight. A helicopter used by the German military that crashed into the Mulde River the town of Grimma in the eastern German state of Saxony, has been removed, the Air Force said. Two people were killed in the crash Tuesday, and one person remains missing. Divers have been scouring the river, while soldiers have combed the riverbanks in search of the missing crew member. The helicopter was flying at a low altitude when it went down near a bridge over the A14 motorway. The cause of the crash is under and the international sports community have reacted with shock to the news that Laura Dahlmeier has died in a mountaineering accidentin Pakistan. The two-time Olympic gold medal-winning German biathlete was confirmed dead on Wednesday, two days after being caught in a rockslide high in the mountains of northern Pakistan. The 31-year-old was swept away by falling rocks on Monday at an altitude of around 5,700 meters (18,700 feet) while ascending the 6,069-meter-high Laila Peak. German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier offered his condolences to Dahlmeier's parents, writing that she "was an exceptional sportswoman." "Laura Dahlmeier was an ambassador for our country in the world, a role model for peaceful, cheerful and fair coexistence across borders," he said. International Olympic Committee president Kirsty Coventry described the news as "deeply shocking for all of us in the Olympic Movement." "Laura made history at the Pyeongchang 2018 Winter Olympics as the first female biathlete to win sprint and pursuit gold at the same Games edition. She will be remembered forever. Our thoughts are with her family and friends at this very difficult time," Coventry said. The International Biathlon Union (IBU) said, "throughout her career and following her retirement, Laura's drive to push beyond limits and embrace challenges touched and inspired countless lives around the world." The German Ski Federation DSV said they were "shocked and deeply saddened" to learn about Dahlmeier's death. "In Laura, the German Ski Federation has not only lost an outstanding athlete, but also a very special person. Her legacy will reach far beyond sport. We will honour her memory," the DSV said. Magdalena Neuer, who also won two Olympic golds and 12 world titles in biathlon, posted a photo of herself and Dahlmeier along with a heart emoji on Instagram. Gray skies and steady rain over Bonn this morning, . Germany is mourning the loss of Olympic biathlon champion Laura Dahlmeier, who died in a climbing accident while ascending Laila Peak in Pakistan's Karakoram range. President Frank-Walter Steinmeier led tributes, calling her a role model and a national treasure. Rescue teams confirmed her death on Wednesday, but due to harsh weather conditions, they were unable to recover her body. In today's blog, we'll reflect on Dahlmeier's legacy and how she'll be remembered by fans, fellow athletes, and the wider public. Later this morning, we're expecting fresh data from Germany's statistics office: an early estimate of July's inflation. Analysts are predicting a slight slowdown in price growth, though not enough to bring real relief to consumers still grappling with high costs for food and services.
Local Germany
9 hours ago
- Local Germany
Kitas and Deutschlandticket: What Germany plans to spend money on in 2026
If you're feeling like you've heard a whole lot of federal budget news as of late, you're not wrong. It was only a month ago that the federal budget plans for this year were approved , and then at the top of July further changes were made to that budget. READ ALSO: Tax cuts and pensions - How Germany's budget changes could impact you Germany's previous traffic light government failed to pass a budget for 2025 when talks broke down between the Social Democrats (SPD), the Greens and the Free Democrats (FDP). So now the new black-red coalition, of the Christian Union parties (CDU/CSU) and the SPD, have been moving to draft and approve budgets for both 2025 and 2026. The draft budget approved on Wednesday July 30th is for 2026. To sum it up concisely, it promises more money for just about everything: from bridges and railway lines, to the German army, as well as digitalisation and education. In this sense, the budget agreement can be seen as the conservatives trying to make good on their previous campaign promises to stimulate the economy and boost Germany's infrastructure and defences. Presenting the draft budget in Berlin, Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD) said, "We are investing in the future now so that our country will be more modern, fairer and safer tomorrow." German Finance Minister and Vice Chancellor Lars Klingbeil arrives to present a draft of Germany's federal budget for the year 2026. (Photo by John MACDOUGALL / AFP) However, the spending requires that the government take on significant new debt, and there still isn't funding for key tax cuts that had been proposed. Here's the plan as things stand: Big figures A total expenditure of €520.5 billion is planned for 2026, which is 3.5 percent more than is expected for this year. The biggest portion of the budget is to go to the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, at around €197.4 billion. Most of that is for an increase in subsidies to the pension insurance scheme. Around €41 billion is budgeted for the long-term unemployment benefit (known as Bürgergeld ), including support for accommodation and heating in 2026. This is around €1.5 billion less than is planned for the current year because the government is counting on a revival of the labour market and a falling number of benefit recipients. FACT CHECK: Are immigrants in Germany taking advantage of the welfare state? Large investments are also planned, including in the renovation of Germany's rundown bridges and railway lines , and towards improving digitalisation and education. Advertisement The German army ( Bundeswehr) is to receive significantly more money next year - its budget is set to be increased by about 32 percent to around €128 billion. Strengthening the German military was among the chief reasons that government leaders pushed to relax the debt brake earlier this year. Defence spending is expected to continue to rise massively in the coming years amid the geopolitical instability in Europe. READ ALSO: Germany has ditched the debt brake, but what will the consequences be? What services are being funded? Several projects announced in the black-red government's coalition agreement are expected to be funded next year. Among these are subsidies for social housing, more money for Kitas, and a continuation of the Deutschlandticket . A reduction of VAT on food in restaurants is also planned, plus an increase in the commuter allowance. What's not being funded? The draft notably does not include funding for a reduction in taxes on flights. Last year, an aviation tax was increased. There is also no mention of an electricity tax reduction for private households, which was suggested in the conservative's election campaign. This would cost an additional €5.4 billion. "At the moment, there is no foreseeable room for manoeuvre in the federal budget," government sources told DPA. Cuts are planned for development spending, and job cuts are planned in the federal administration, and in security agencies. Advertisement Can Germany afford it? To help fund next year's budget, the government plans to take out €89.9 billion in new loans, as well as taking €84.4 billion from the special funds recently set up for infrastructure and climate protection. German leaders are faced with mounting budget constraints, as their plans for boosting the economy, defence and revitalising infrastructure are quickly adding up to a hefty price tag. In the following years, from 2027 to 2029, a €127 billion gap is forecast. "The 2027 budget will be an enormous challenge for the government," Finance Minister Klingbeil said, hinting that austerity measures are likely to follow. READ ALSO: How could welfare reforms in Germany affect you? With reporting by DPA.
