Backlash after German minister suggests cap on immigrant students in schools
Welt
tv program over the weekend, Germany's Education Minister Karin Prien (CDU) said she was open to introducing a cap on the number of students with a migrant background in school classes.
Her comments came in response to a question from
Welt's
editor-in-chief, who had referenced similar efforts in Denmark.
Prien suggested that a cap of 30 to 40 percent was a 'conceivable model,' emphasizing that the decisive factor for school success is that children should be able to speak German when they start school.
She called for early, mandatory language tests for four-year-olds and binding language learning support measures for those identified as needing help.
Prien argued that looking at the experiences of other countries—specifically Denmark—could provide valuable insights.
What's happening in Denmark?
While Denmark does not have a formal, nationwide quota for children with a migrant background in schools, it has implemented
similar measures
in certain areas.
In neighbourhoods with a very high proportion of children with a migrant background, the Danish government reportedly required schools to pause the admission of new students and develop plans to attract more 'ethnically Danish' students.
However, these were localised interventions, and not a blanket national quota system.
READ ALSO:
What parents in Germany should know about the planned schools shake up
Reaction in Germany
Prien's remarks were met with immediate and widespread criticism.
The Federal Government's Integration Commissioner, Natalie Pawlik (SPD), rejected the proposal, arguing that 'Germany does not need quotas in the classroom' and that integration is best achieved through targeted support, not exclusion.
The president of the German Teachers' Association, Stefan Düll, said that using a child's foreign roots as a benchmark was not helpful. He called the idea of quotas 'problematic', noting the logistical challenges in areas where almost half the population has a migrant background.
READ ALSO:
How German leaders are blaming foreigners for country's woes
Advertisement
He and other education experts stressed that language skills, not background, should be the main criterion for school admission.
Opposition parties and associations also voiced strong concerns.
The Left Party called the proposal unworkable, especially in urban centres, and warned of stigmatization and exclusion.
The anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD), on the other hand, criticized Prien's proposal as 'too lax', called for a significantly lower limit of ten percent.
READ ALSO:
More childcare, less paperwork - How Germany can make life easier for foreign parents
In fact media reports, including one by the German teachers' magazine
News4teachers
,
have pointed out that the idea of introducing migrant quotas in Germany was first suggested by the AfD.
Not constitutional
Despite the polarised debate that Prien's comments sparked, the legal, practical, and political obstacles to introducing school quotas in Germany appear insurmountable.
Germany's Basic Law (
Grundgesetz
) prohibits discrimination based on origin, meaning that the constitutional court would almost certainly challenge the legality of mandating migrant quotas in schools.
Advertisement
Additionally, in Germany education is primarily the responsibility of states rather than the federal government. So only the states (
Länder
) can implement binding rules on quotas or mandatory language tests.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
DW
10 hours ago
- DW
Germany updates: EU ministers talk migration in Denmark – DW – 07/22/2025
Germany's Alexander Dobrindt, a migration hard-liner, is attending a meeting of EU interior ministers on the issue in Denmark. DW has this and more in its blog on German current affairs. EU interior ministers are meeting in the Danish capital, Copenhagen, on Tuesday for talks on how best to combat irregular migration and organized crime. Among them is be German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, who last week already advocated a harsher European migration policy in talks with several counterparts, including on repatriations of rejected asylum-seekers to countries like Syria and Afghanistan. Meanwhile, a cyber espionage operation targeting Microsoft server software has compromised a large number of organizations, including some in Germany. A German Air Force flight made an emergency landing in Leipzig on Monday night after a warning message went off in the cockpit, a spokesperson said. Speaking with the German press agency DPA, the Airbus A319 was on its way back from Berlin to its base in Cologne. Earlier, the plane had been carrying Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig, who had been on her first official visit to Poland. She had disembarked in Berlin. The spokesperson said that the plane would be inspected today, after which a decision will be made if the aircraft needs repairs. German military equipment has long been the butt of international jokes for being run-down and out of date. Former Chancellor Angela Merkel famously had to break off a journey to a G20 summit when her plane experienced technical issues. The German media group Südwestdeutsche Medienholding (SWMH), which owns daily among other publications, has been the target of a "critical IT security incident," it said on Tuesday. The group said its internal network was briefly accessed by unauthorized individuals in mid-July, affecting all the companies connected by it, including the and dailies. It said the attack had been stopped and that all online reporting and newspaper production had continued without disruption. The attack has been reported to the police cybercrime unit and the incident is being investigated by external IT security experts, it said. SWMH is one of Germany's largest newspaper publishers and employs some 4,500 people. Germany's Constitutional Court has upheld a three-year jail sentence handed to a former doctor convicted of assisting in the suicide of a mentally ill patient. The man had filed a complaint with the court claiming that his basic rights had been violated by his punishment. The court said the man had failed to prove sufficiently that this was the case. The former doctor was sentenced in 2024 by a regional court in Essen for having assisted the patient to commit suicide in 2020, although the latter suffered from paranoid schizophrenia and was considered by the court to be incapable of taking a free decision to take his life. Physician-assisted suicide is legal in Germany under some circumstances, but the patient has to be determined to be mentally sound enough to make the decision. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 videoEuropean countries have massively increased their defense spending amid fears of further Russian territorial aggression. Several startups in Germany are seeking to exploit the trend but face many challenges. DW has this video analysis: To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The German Association of General Practitioners (Hausärztinnen- und Hausärzteverband) has warned that a newly introduced system aimed at allowing health care providers to more easily exchange patient data is in danger of "crash landing." "The number of active users is sobering," association chairman Markus Beier told the daily . "If those in charge keep on as they have been, one of the most important care projects of the past years will fail slowly but surely." He said this would be bad news for patients, as "a well-implemented electronic patient file indubitably would have the potential to tangibly improve and simplify care." He called on health insurance companies to conduct a "big and coordinated information campaign" for their customers. Beier, however, also criticized the system itself as being over-complicated to use, saying that barely a week went by in which doctors' practices didn't have problems accessing patient files. Electronic patient fileswere rolled out nationwide in April of this year. The files contain the entire medical history of a patient, with aim of facilitating treatment coordination between physicians and other health care providers. Internet security experts say there have been dozens of hacking attacks on self-hosted servers using Microsoft's SharePoint software, affecting several organizations, including government bodies, mostly in Germany and the US. The SharePoint servers are widely used by organizations, including government bodies, major industrial firms, banks, auditors and health care companies, for the internal sharing of documents and to facilitate collaboration. Security researchers warn that the hacking operation, reportedly known as "ToolShell," is a serious one and can allow actors to fully access SharePoint file systems, including services connected to SharePoint, such as Teams and OneDrive. The hack allows the perpetrators to potentially drop a so-called backdoor to give them continuous access to victim organizations. Microsoft said it had "provided security updates and encourages customers to install them," a company spokesperson said in an emailed statement. It said the vulnerability affects only on-site SharePoint servers used within businesses or organizations and not Microsoft's cloud-based SharePoint Online service. Eye Security, a Netherlands-based cybersecurity firm that helped uncover the operation, has declined to identify the affected organizations, but said the relevant national authorities had been notified. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Interior ministers from the 27 EU member states are set to meet in the Danish capital,Copenhagen, for talks focusing on migration and European security. Discussions are to center on how best to repatriate people who have had their asylum requests refused and how to combat irregular migration. The fight against organized crime and the drug trade will also be on the agenda. Proposals on the table include the possibility of setting up so-called repatriation centers outside the EU. German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt is expected to be among the attendees. Dobrindt has already implemented controversial pushback measures at Germany's borders that a court has ruled to be illegal. Last Friday, the conservative politician from Bavaria's Christian Social Union (CSU) also pushed for much harsher European migration policies in talks with counterparts from Austria, France, Denmark, Poland and the Czech Republic during a summit hosted in Germany. This included proposals to be more rigorous in sending people back to home countries whose security situation is fragile, such as Syria and Afghanistan. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video from the DW Bonn newsroom on the banks of the Rhine! Riding high after sealing an agreement from a German business alliance to invest €631 billion ($733 billion) in Germany over the next three years, Chancellor Friedrich Merz is turning to foreign diplomacy on Tuesday, hosting Czech Prime Minister Petr Fiala in Berlin. Meanwhile, Merz's interior minister, Alexander Dobrindt, is set to attend a meeting in Denmark with his EU counterparts to talk migration. German Development Minister Reem Alabali Radovan is also setting off, headed to South Africa as part of the Just Energy Transition Partnership. He's also planning to take part in the G20 development ministers' summit taking place in Johannesburg. For the latest developments, explainers and analysis from Germany, keep reading.
DW
11 hours ago
- DW
'Made for Germany': German Companies show optimism – DW – 07/22/2025
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has joined forces with the country's top business leaders, who pledge major investment to pull Germany out of recession. There is always an element of psychology in economics. If companies are confident they can do good business in the future, they will strongly invest. If prospects look poor, they will hold on to the money. The COVID-19 pandemic with its collapse of international supply chains, the war in Ukraine, the subsequent energy crisis and inflation, the weakening economy in China — all took a heavy toll on the export-oriented German economy. Economic activity nosedived. Germany slid into a lasting recession. Since then, optimism has not returned. The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) registered a lower investment ratio for Germany in 2024 than all other 38 member countries. That will soon change, according to the heads of leading companies in Germany. A total of 61 of them, including corporations such as Airbus, BASF, BMW, Deutsche Börse, Mercedes-Benz, Rheinmetall, SAP, Volkswagen but also the US corporations Nvidia, Blackrock and Blackstone — have launched the initiative "Made for Germany." The name is reminiscent, deliberately, of the slogan "Made in Germany" which has become a symbol of quality. Together, the corporations representing a third of the German economy want to invest €631 billion ($733 billion) in Germany over the next three years. The money will go toward new and existing factories, as well as research and development. "We want economic growth, we want to strengthen Germany's competitiveness, we want to defend our technological leadership or extend it further," one of the alliance's two initiators, Siemens chief executive Roland Busch, said following a meeting of the initiative with government politicians at the chancellery. Christian Sewing, chief executive of Deutsche Bank and co-initiator of the alliance alongside Busch, expects even more businesses to join. "Germany is back. It's worth investing in Germany again," said Chancellor Friedrich Merz of the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU) after the meeting. "We stand here before one of the largest investment initiatives that we have seen here in Germany in recent decades. We are not a location of the past, but a location of the present and above all the future," he added. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The mood in the chancellery was clearly positive. However, the economic situation in Germany remains sluggish; the country is facing its third year in a row without growth. Given the tariff policies of US President Donald Trump, the outlook is anything but good. Reviving the economy is the top priority for Germany's new government. The coalition of the center-right Christian Democrats and Christian Social Union (CDU/CSU) and the center-left Social Democrats has been in office since early May. They have made their first steps: The Bundestag federal parliament and Bundesrat upper house have authorized the borrowing of €500 billion ($580 billion) for a special fund for government investment in infrastructure and climate protection. Its intended focus is to whip the country's ailing transport routes into shape, invest in energy networks, digitization and research. Energy prices for the industry will be reduced, and businesses are set for massive tax relief. Initially, investment in production facilities, machinery, equipment, research and development will be accounted for during tax assessments. In the medium term, taxes on business are to be reduced. In Friedrich Merz, Germany now has a chancellor who himself spent many years in business. Among other roles, the lawyer formerly chaired the supervisory board of the US financial investor BlackRock. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video "Today we have begun a new form of cooperation," Siemens head Busch said. "The conversation has shown that politics and business are on the same page." Deutsche Bank CEO Sewing added: "In my view, we are experiencing a government that is moving quickly. The most important things — growth and competitiveness — are right at the top of the agenda." To release the announced billions, politicians should ease up on regulations and give companies more freedom, Sewing said. Businesses are calling for reforms, especially concerning bureaucracy and social security contributions which push up the cost of labor. In Germany, employers and employees each pay half of worker contributions to health insurance, unemployment insurance and pensions. Due to higher costs for healthcare, health insurance contributions increased across the board at the beginning of this year. Contributions to long-term care insurance are expected to rise in 2026. In Germany, 42% of the gross national product goes toward social services. Pension funds are the biggest driver of this. Germany is an ageing society, and the baby boomer generation will retire from the workforce in the coming years. In addition, life expectancy is increasing. To afford the old-age pension, the government must contribute more money to the pension funds each year. According to the OECD, reforming social insurance is the biggest challenge for Germany. If nothing changes, the government will need to keep taking on more debt to keep social systems afloat. Chancellor Friedrich Merz has announced that reforming the social system is next on his coalition's political agenda. Initial findings are expected in the coming you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter, Berlin Briefing.
DW
12 hours ago
- DW
Slovakia: Fico uses anti-EU rhetoric as diversionary tactic – DW – 07/22/2025
After holding out for weeks, Slovak PM Robert Fico dropped his veto on new EU sanctions against Russia. There's likely to be more of the same in the future as such maneuvering diverts attention from domestic problems. Slovakia's veto of the EU's package of sanctions against Russia is not something entirely new. After all, the bloc is already well familiar with such maneuvering from the prime minister of neighboring Hungary: Viktor Orban has in the past blocked EU decisions that have to be agreed unanimously, promising his supporters that he will "never" back down. Then, at the last minute, he does a U-turn and drops his veto. In many cases, it is not clear what he got in return. Then, back home, Orban portrays his "fight against the Brussels bureaucrats" as a "victory." But this is the first time that Orban's friend and ally Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico has played this card. For weeks, Fico — formally a Social Democrat but in practice a right-wing populist — kept the EU on tenterhooks, declaring that he would not approve the EU's 18th package of sanctions against Russia, even if that would trigger a "major crisis in the EU." Fico's reasoning was that the sanctions would have a massive impact on Slovakia's economy and, above all, on its energy supplies. He also claimed that it would damage the EU itself, not Russia. Fico made his veto stance out to be a question of national sovereignty and national pride. The U-turn came in the form of a social media post late on Thursday evening just hours before the planned vote on the package. Speaking in a video, Fico said that even though the European Commission's sanctions plan against Russia was "nonsensical," it would be "counterproductive" to vote against it. He explained the concessions that Slovakia would get in return and finished by saying, "When in Rome, do as the Romans do." There was great relief in the EU at Fico's surprise U-turn. Some — such as the German Chancellor Friedrich Merz — even voiced understanding for Slovakia's tough economic situation. But within Slovakia itself, both opposition politicians and many political commentators have been extremely cutting about Fico's maneuvering. The general tone of what was said was that he had alienated Slovakia's European partners, done Russian President Vladimir Putin a favor that did nothing for Slovakia and isolated the country. Michal Simecka, leader of the country's largest opposition party, Progressive Slovakia (PS), posted on Facebook that Fico was "amateurish, lacked direction, frustrated and unsuitable to hold office and to defend Slovakia's interests." A commentator for the daily broadsheet called Fico's maneuvering a "show for the voters back home and to divert people's attention away from other problems." But what was the purpose of Fico's maneuvering and what did it ultimately achieve? The aim of the EU's 18th package of sanctions against Russia was above all to stop the sale of Russian oil in the EU, to cut off the Russian armaments industry from key imports, and ban transactions with Russian banks that have not so far been on the list of sanctioned institutions. Fico and his coalition government had agreed to the package in principle. The bone of contention was a set of measures included in a plan known as RePowerEU, which Brussels tabled some time ago. Among other things, this plan seeks to stop the flow of Russian gas to EU member states from 2028. Slovakia wanted an exemption from this plan because it has a gas supply contract with the Russian company Gazprom that runs until 2034 and is completely dependent on Russian gas. But even before Fico agreed to back the 18th sanctions package, the EU had assured Slovakia assistance in this respect, allowing the country to use some of the financial aid from the EU to subsidize energy prices. Brussels has also promised Slovakia assistance in the event of litigation with Gazprom. So, why the "show for the voters back home"? On the one hand, Slovakia is in considerable financial difficulty and in the middle of a profound structural economic crisis. Fico's coalition government has been able to solve neither problem since coming to power in late 2023. Above all, it is dragging its heels on the issue of fixing the country's public finances. Last year, Slovakia's budget deficit stood at 5.3% of GDP, which is well over the 3% limit for the eurozone. Even though Fico's government has already introduced financial consolidation measures, which included raising a number of taxes and social security contributions and canceling some public holidays, it has also made some expensive gifts to its voters, including support to cope with high energy prices and a 13th monthly pension payment for senior citizens. The government is also currently under pressure among other things because of a controversial tax on financial transactions. Economically, the crisis in the automotive industry has brought huge problems for Slovakia, which relies heavily on exports. Plants in Slovakia produce for Volkswagen, Kia, Jaguar and Peugeot. Indeed, car production is by far the most important economic sector in the country. However, because of the upheaval on the automotive market, competition from China, falling sales in the US, and US President Donald Trump's tariff policy, the Slovak automotive production model is facing growing problems. Fico's government has yet to table a long-term plan for fundamental economic reform. But Fico and his government are also under pressure because of a series of corruption scandals — both old and new. After the murder of investigative journalist Jan Kuciak and his fiancee Martina Kusnirova in February 2018, Fico was forced to resign. In the years that followed, it became clear just how close the links between politics and organized crime are in Slovakia. Since Fico returned to power in late 2023, one of his top-priority projects has been to stop the fight against corruption and to silence opponents. Peter Bardy, editor-in-chief of the web portal Aktuality, says that Fico is "obsessed with revenge," which is also the title of his current bestseller about the prime minister. Actuality recently reported on a scandal concerning a luxury villa of obscure ownership on the Croatian Adriatic coast with alleged links to the prime minister. Fico sees himself as a victim and a man surrounded by enemies. This has intensified since he was the victim of an assassination attempt in May 2024. He feels that the opposition, independent media, liberalism, "LGBTQ ideologues" and the EU are all conspiring against him. Fico has repeatedly taken sides with President Putin and was the only EU head of government to travel to Moscow for the Victory Day parade there on May 8. After a visit to Uzbekistan in June, he praised its political system, calling it a model, and reflected on how "European democracy" could be reformed, for example by reducing the number of parliamentary parties. This fall, Fico is planning to erect a "dam against progressivism" with amendments to the constitution. Among other things, he is planning to only recognize two genders: male and female. Slovak-Hungarian journalist and writer Laszlo Barak sees both this move and Fico's strategy of first opposing and then agreeing to the EU's sanctions against Russia as part of the same policy. "This is how the Fico reality is constructed: with slogans, half-truths and cheap lies," he said, writing for the online media outlet Parameter. "That's his policy: manipulation, Russophilia and cynicism."
