Yong: Clarity and compassion needed in tax policy
KOTA KINABALU (June 17): Former Chief Minister Datuk Seri Panglima Yong Teck Lee said
recent announcements on new taxes, suspensions and postponements of policies have left Malaysians and business owners, including himself, bewildered.
He observed that the recently announced Sales and Service Tax (SST) is imposed inconsistently even on the same category of products. For example, local and imported avocados are subject to different rates, creating confusion for both consumers and businesses, he said in a statement on Tuesday.
Meanwhile, tax enforcement actions are pressing forward despite the unclear guidelines and the current weak economic conditions.
Yong said the first essential principle of any proper tax system is that rules must be clear enough for people and businesses to understand their obligations without confusion.
A second foundational requirement is that tax rates be set at levels taxpayers can reasonably afford, especially in a fragile economy where many are already struggling.
A third guiding tenet is that the government's collection process must be simple and predictable, avoiding enforcement actions that punish those who genuinely wish to comply.
The ongoing shifts in SST rules, e-invoicing deadlines, fuel subsidy adjustments and stamp duty regulations fail to meet these three core standards, he pointed out.
This persistent uncertainty undermines trust, deters investment and deepens the hardship faced by struggling families and small enterprises.
'We call on the government to pause further tax changes, engage meaningfully with stakeholders and restore clarity, affordability and ease of collection in order to stabilise the economy and rebuild public confidence,' said Yong.
He also urged the Inland Revenue Board to desist from enforcement on the new taxes until rates and procedures are clarified, taxpayers can afford them and collection is effective rather than punitive, as harsh enforcement risks destroying businesses and livelihoods.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
US revises tariff rate to 19%
However, nation must urgently diversify its export destinations PETALING JAYA: Malaysia's revised tariff rate of 19% on exports to the United States offers a temporary competitive edge in the region but underscores the urgency for export diversification amid signs of growing US protectionism, economists warn. Prof Emeritus Dr Barjoyai Bardai said the revised rate, down from 25% previously, positions Malaysia on par with neighbouring countries such as Thailand, Indonesia, Cambodia and the Philippines. He said the rate is still more favourable than those imposed on Myanmar (40%), Vietnam (20%) and Taiwan (20%). 'We seem to be able to compete with our neighbouring countries. But we are far behind Singapore at 10%, as well as Japan and South Korea at 15%. 'With India at 25%, we are in a better position,' he said when contacted. What we really want to see is that the tariff imposed on Malaysia is as low or better than that of countries that are our competitors because we are exporting to the United States. 'So, if those countries have equal or higher tariffs than us, then our ability to compete remains intact,' he added. However, he said that certain Malaysian exports may be vulnerable, especially low-margin products such as solar panels, and electrical and electronic goods. On the trade balance with the US, he said it depends on whether Malaysian imports from the US increase significantly, especially luxury goods, following the government's decision to scrap the luxury tax. 'Although the luxury tax has been included in the expanded SST, the rate is still low,' he added. He said Malaysia must urgently diversify its export destinations, as the US moves towards a more self-sufficient economy. Barjoyai said semiconductors should be directed to countries with growing demand, such as China, India and Europe. CLICK TO ENLARGE For other items like solar panels, he said Malaysia should consider Latin America, Canada and Europe. 'There are still many untapped markets. In the long run, the United States will become a domestic-driven economy where they will seek to reduce imports. 'Today, they are already about 80% self-sustaining,' he added. Echoing similar concerns, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid said the tariff adjustment signals that the United States remains open to dialogue, but the economic implications for Malaysia remain. 'As a result of recent discussions, the previously imposed retaliatory tariffs of 25% have now been reduced to 19%. 'Consequently, the negative impact on Malaysia's economy is expected to be slightly mitigated. 'In this regard, Bank Negara has revised its GDP forecast for 2025 to a range of 4.0% to 4.8%, down from the earlier projection of 4.5% to 5.5%,' he said. Afzanizam also highlighted the potential global impact of US tariffs. 'The 19% import tariff is expected to impact American consumers' purchasing power. 'This may, in turn, dampen economic momentum in the US, which is the world's largest economy. It poses a potential risk to global economic growth in the coming years,' Afzanizam said. He also called for a balanced approach to foreign relations and economic strategy. 'It is crucial to preserve strong bilateral ties with the United States, while simultaneously exploring new opportunities with countries in Europe, the BRICS bloc, and strengthening economic and diplomatic cooperation within Asean. 'At the same time, efforts to boost productivity, build capacity and enhance economic resilience must be intensified to safeguard Malaysia's economic sovereignty. 'These measures will reinforce investor and business confidence, underpinned by pragmatic policies and the government's proactive response to emerging challenges,' he added. Centre for Market Education chief executive officer Carmelo Ferlito, meanwhile, said the tariff revision reflects a political strategy rather than a pure economic measure. 'The reciprocal tariff on Malaysia to 19% is the proof of what I have mentioned earlier,' he said, adding that US President Donald Trump was not interested in tariffs per se, but to reopen negotiating tables. He said this is to show that the United States is the biggest consumer in the world and force countries to get closer to the United States as well as grant commercial facilitations. Ferlito criticised the use of tariffs as a policy tool, arguing that they hurt both consumers and workers. 'Tariffs are bad, not just for Malaysia, but for the world,' he said, adding that ultimately, tariffs reduce trade opportunities. 'This means less choice for consumers, but also job losses, on both sides,' he added.
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Cautious spending keeping costs manageable amid new SST rate
PETALING JAYA: One month after the scope of the Sales and Service Tax (SST) was expanded, some households have reported a slight increase in expenses, while others did not. For lecturer Muhammad Syafiq Imran Abdul Rahim, his grocery bill for July has seen an increase of about RM40. 'I usually spend about RM400 a month, and I've noticed an increase last month (July). 'Subsidised items like eggs and chicken are still affordable, but items like fruits have seen some differences,' the 31-year-old from Ipoh said. 'It used to cost me about RM9 for 10 green apples, but it's about RM11 now. 'While it's not a huge jump and still manageable for me, I think it's important to spend moderately,' he added. Auxiliary policeman M. Moganadass, 48, said his household spending has remained fairly consistent, though he estimates that there has been a 15% increase overall. 'Our monthly groceries used to be around RM500, but we're spending a bit more now,' he said. 'We mostly eat at home now and try to cut back on eating out,' he added. Retiree N. Manimaran, 67, said his grocery bill for July has also increased slightly to about RM520 from about RM500 in previous months. While describing the increase as insignificant, he said he will try his best to keep his expenditure to a minimum. 'I will try to avoid imported goods or items like avocados. I do hope the government could reconsider the SST rate, which would benefit the broader population. 'Governments worldwide are struggling with their economies, but reducing tax could really help ease the people's burden,' he added. Personal assistant R. Chitra, 46, said she noticed an increase in her household spending, particularly on groceries and medical treatment. 'The cost of treatment at private clinics is no longer within RM100, and it has gone up beyond that. This is especially burdensome for families with children. 'Groceries from mid-range supermarkets have also become more expensive. For example, the price of breakfast cereal went up from RM2.15 to RM3.45, while powdered coconut milk (santan) rose from around RM1.20 to RM2.30,' she said. Chitra added that although these may seem like small items, they contribute significantly to the overall increase in grocery expenses. To cope with rising costs, Chitra said she adjusted her spending, prioritising basic necessities and having more home-cooked meals. 'I have cut down on eating out. Instead, I stock up on basic ingredients and cook more at home,' she said. The mother of three also urged the government to place more emphasis on maximising the country's natural resources for economic benefit. 'Malaysia has lost its focus on agriculture and now we (the people) are facing the consequences. 'We have an abundance of natural resources, especially in agriculture, which could help increase national revenue if better managed,' she said. Contractor Zipo A. Aziz, 51, said despite the SST prices, his grocery has remained stable. 'It has been nearly a month, and I still have not seen grocery prices go up. 'In fact, I remain firm in my choice to support local products instead of spending unnecessarily on imported goods. 'I believe the choice lies in our hands. As consumers, we need to be smart in making decisions by choosing to spend within our means and buy wisely,' he said. Lee Li Lian from Shah Alam said she too has not seen much of a difference in her expenses. 'There wasn't much of a difference so far when I went shopping last weekend. I guess being mindful helps,' said the 38-year-old content executive.
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Malaysians are not retirement-ready
MOST Malaysians feel uncertain about their retirement. This is no surprise – it's a phase of life with no active income, potentially lasting 20 to 30 years, or even longer. That uncertainty often drives people to take action, seeking ways to secure their future: buying insurance, topping up their Employees Provident Fund (EPF), investing in unit trusts, or even purchasing property. These steps feel productive, responsible and reassuring.
