Changes to Hong Kong's NET scheme should not dilute its integrity
[email protected] or filling in
this Google form . Submissions should not exceed 400 words, and must include your full name and address, plus a phone number for verification
Advertisement
I refer to 'English teacher grants to be based on sector's median pay' (
March 21 ). While the proposed revisions to the native English-speaking teacher (NET) scheme aim to give schools flexibility, I believe they undermine the programme's goals and risk compromising Hong Kong's educational standards.
Past Education Bureau evaluations have shown strong support for the NET scheme among principals and local teachers, especially in fostering professional growth and a more dynamic learning environment. Parents and students have commended the scheme for enhancing English confidence and proficiency, and for its
innovative teaching methods
Critics who claim the scheme has
fallen short frequently fail to account for the structural and environmental challenges NETs face: inflexible school cultures, an excessive focus on examination results and limited opportunities for integration. These limit NETs' ability to implement transformative strategies.
NETs are on the same pay scale as local teachers. Delinking NET salaries from the master pay scale,
eliminating benefits and allowing schools to hire less experienced individuals could erode professional standards.
Advertisement
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
3 days ago
- HKFP
Lawmaker urges more English-language TV, radio programming, two years after gov't cuts to required broadcast hours
A lawmaker has called on the government to ensure more English-language TV and radio programming, two years after the government relaxed rules for programming hours. At a legislative meeting on Wednesday, pro-Beijing lawmaker Starry Lee said Hong Kong needed to capitalise on its strengths and position as a international hub for high-calibre talent ahead of the upcoming 15th National Games and other international events. Lee, who heads the DAB party, urged the 'setting up of well-established English information channels for [the] demonstration of Hong Kong's cultural diversity, openness and inclusiveness…,' including a 24-hour RTHK English-language channel and the use of social media platforms. It comes two years after the required broadcast hours for English programming on English-language stations was reduced from 80 per cent to 55 per cent. Public consultation According to a written response by Acting Secretary for Commerce and Economic Development Bernard Chan, there are a total of five English-language TV channels and three radio channels in Hong Kong. 'These help exhibit Hong Kong's diversity and global vision, proactively telling good stories of the country and Hong Kong and enabling non-Chinese speaking persons in Hong Kong to have a better understanding of various information about Hong Kong and Mainland China,' Chan's response said. As for international talent, The Hong Kong Talent Engage (HKTE) provides them comprehensive support services aiding their integration into local society, he added: '[T]he HKTE's promotional and publicity materials, including its online platform, TV Announcements in the Public Interest, social media posts, etc, are already fully available in English, and its themed seminars on living in Hong Kong also offer online livestreaming and simultaneous interpretation services.' According to Chan, the Information Services Department and the Leisure and Cultural Services Department will continue producing more English-Language social media content, including for promoting the upcoming National Games. In the third quarter of this year, the Office of the Communications Authority will launch a public consultation on the free-to-TV licence renewals.
HKFP
4 days ago
- HKFP
Nat. security guidelines not ‘targeted' at specific events, says education chief after school's US consular event warning
National security guidelines for Hong Kong schools do not target specific events, education minister Christine Choi said, following reports that school principals had been warned against joining US Independence Day celebrations. The US consulate in the city has slammed what it called 'repression' by local authorities In an interview with select media outlets, Choi addressed allegations that schools were warned not to take part in Independence Day activities hosted by Washington's diplomatic mission, saying that the authorities were only addressing 'doubts' from the schools. An unnamed school principal's remarks were quoted last month in a post by Edu Lancet, a social media page which describes itself as a platform for 'voicing concerns' about Hong Kong's education sector. The message cited a reminder from the Education Bureau reminding teachers to be 'careful' about the consulate's Independence Day celebrations. The principal advised against taking part in the celebrations 'to avoid violating the national security law and Hong Kong laws.' The message said: 'If you learn that there are students participating, please put the protection of students first and discourage them from doing so.' Earlier, the Education Bureau only said that 'schools have the responsibility to properly carry out their role as gatekeepers and enhance teachers' and students' sensitivity to national security.' A US Consulate spokesperson responded: 'We condemn the Hong Kong government's repression of U.S. Independence Day celebrations and interference in U.S. Consulate General-hosted events. Its attempts to characterize these activities as 'unlawful' only further reveals its insecurity and fear of freedom.' The spokesperson said that US embassies and consulates worldwide celebrate the occasion every year. 'Other foreign missions do the same. This year is no different,' the statement read. 'Self-evaluation checklist' Education chief Choi said that the authorities had 'never' issued notices targeting specific persons or events, but would regularly address schools' queries. Choi said that a self-evaluation checklist on national security affairs issued to schools was updated in April, with updated terms on procurement, manpower, and school outings, though it did not target specific organisations or individuals. According to an April announcement, the evaluation checklist sets out suggestions 'covering national security work planning, monitoring mechanisms, learning and teaching and related resources, school activities, personnel management and training, and home-school co-operation.' She also questioned whether the incident amounted to a 'diplomatic crisis,' as described by The Chaser, without naming the diaspora media outlet. 'I don't see how this could become a crisis. For this to become a political crisis because an online media outlet said so, wouldn't that be an exaggeration?' she said. In an earlier interview with Beijing-backed newspaper Wen Wei Po, Choi said that the EDB had issued 'clear guidelines' to schools, including ordering them to conduct background checks on external organisations to ensure there were no 'anti-China disruptors' and to review their own off-campus activities and books to prevent the proliferation of 'illegal and harmful information'.
RTHK
6 days ago
- RTHK
Canada axes tech tax in push for US trade deal
Canada axes tech tax in push for US trade deal Mark Carney listens to Donald Trump at the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alberta, in June. File photo: Reuters Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said trade talks with the United States have resumed after Ottawa rescinded its plan to tax American technology firms. The rescindment came after US President Donald Trump said on Friday that he was suspending trade talks with Canada over its plans to continue with its tax on technology firms, which he called 'a direct and blatant attack on our country'. The Canadian government said 'in anticipation' of a trade deal 'Canada would rescind' the Digital Services Tax. The tax was set to go into effect on Monday. Carney and Trump spoke on the phone on Sunday, and Carney's office said they agreed to resume negotiations. 'Today's announcement will support a resumption of negotiations towards the July 21, 2025, timeline set out at this month's G7 leaders' summit in Kananaskis,' Carney said in a statement on Sunday. Carney visited Trump in May at the White House, where he was polite but firm. Trump travelled to Canada for the G7 summit in Alberta, where Carney said that Canada and the United States had set a 30-day deadline for trade talks. Trump, in a post on his social media network on Friday, said Canada had informed the United States that it was sticking to its plan to impose the digital services tax, which applies to Canadian and foreign businesses that engage with online users in Canada. The tax was due to hit companies such as Amazon, Google, Meta, Uber and Airbnb with a three-percent levy on revenue from Canadian users. It would have applied retroactively, leaving US companies with a US$2 billion bill due on Monday. 'Rescinding the digital services tax will allow the negotiations of a new economic and security relationship with the United States to make vital progress,' Canadian Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne said in a statement. Champagne also spoke with US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Sunday. (AFP)
