Putting people before cars — finally
The first time I encountered the barriers at Portage and Main was in September of 2004 when I was visiting Winnipeg for research interviews. I walked from my hotel to city hall after consulting Google Maps (remember those?), feeling confident that it was a straightforward jaunt down Main Street. I couldn't have been more wrong.
I was confounded when I was forced to go underground into a dark, nearly empty mall that had me going in circles to find way out and finally in desperation, with the clock ticking, I gave up.
I got out, above ground on the south side of Main, pulled my skirt above my knees, carefully watching for traffic and jumped the barriers, to cross safely. That was my introduction to the famous Portage and Main.
I, for one, am not sad to see those barriers go. I say this as a longtime resident of this city, living in the southside. I regularly drive downtown. I will be happy to cross the intersection come Friday as a pedestrian, without having to hike up my skirt. I have never understood the logic.
In 2014, former mayor Brian Bowman pledged to open Portage and Main within five years of winning office. Of course, he failed to do that. Instead of championing the opening as a way of reinvigorating the downtown, he turned it into a plebiscite question in 2018 — with 65 per cent of Winnipeggers supporting the status quo.
Fast forward to 2024. A new city report revealed that carrying out repairs on the intersection while maintaining the underground walkway would cost $73 million and disrupt traffic for up to five years. Much of the work would involve repairing a leaky membrane that prevents the underground from flooding.
That changed the ball game. Closing the underground mall and opening up the intersection became a no-brainer after that.
The problems with the leaks, by the way, were no surprise to the Vote Open group advocating for the barriers to come down. It was well known at the time of the plebiscite that the membrane was going to cost considerable dollars to fix but just how much was not clear.
As Dan Lett has already argued in a column earlier this week, Winnipeg has made it to the 'bigs' now — following in the footsteps of other major cities like Boston, San Francisco, Halifax and Milwaukee who have also deconstructed their monuments to the automobile and envisioned a downtown that's people-friendly. Even when it's -50 with the windchill.
Ian McCausland was a tireless advocate for the Vote Open Team in 2018 and has become a voice for making this city more accessible and less reliant on vehicles in the years since. Does he feel a certain degree of satisfaction now that the historic corner is opening after all the debate?
'While I wouldn't have loved to see the Yes vote win in 2018, I am still very excited to see the changes happen now. Winnipeg doesn't change very fast, sometimes that a good thing sometimes it's a frustrating thing, it's very much a Winnipeg thing.'
Yes, it's a Winnipeg thing. In 2014, the Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce unveiled its 'Bold' campaign outlining policy initiatives that it hoped city leaders would implement to — in part — transform the downtown into a livable, organic neighborhood. It seems that more than 10 years later, it's finally starting to take place with Portage and Main opening and other new initiatives like the closure of Graham Avenue to create a pedestrian mall.
McCausland sees this as exciting. 'I think we're seeing a beginning, a move toward a more walkable, friendly and equitable downtown. As the city continues to grow in population, we have to find ways for everyone to get out of the 'one person/one car commute.' These are positive steps towards that.'
Wednesdays
A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom.
Also part of the 2014 'Bold' vision from the chamber was the implementation of active-transportation initiatives and that goes directly to how we can become a more inclusive city.
McCausland explains: 'Since 2018 I have learned so much about how transportation is a reflection of our community. How we move round each other is just as important as when we get there. Transportation equity is where we factor in the 25 per cent of the population that doesn't own a car and make efforts of inclusion and accessibility.'
This week marks my 20th anniversary in this city. I am still somewhat baffled yet enraptured by all its proclivities. And I am glad I am living here as it makes its 'Bold' transformation. And just like most things Winnipeg, I also know there will be a ton of naysayers on the sidelines telling us it will never be successful.
That too is a Winnipeg thing.
Shannon Sampert is a political scientist. She can be reached at shannon@mediadiva.ca
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
9 hours ago
- CBC
Scott Gillingham will seek 2nd term as Winnipeg mayor
Social Sharing Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham says he will seek a second term in 2026, when the city holds its next general election. The former pastor and St. James councillor announced his re-election plans with zero fanfare on Wednesday, issuing a one-word email in response to a CBC News query about whether intends to run again. "Yes," said Gillingham spokesperson Colin Fast in a statement, declining further comment. Gillingham was elected mayor in 2022, winning an 11-candidate race to succeed former mayor Brian Bowman, who now sits as a judge on Manitoba's Court of King's Bench. The margin of victory in that election was the closest for a Winnipeg mayoral race since 1977. Gillingham slipped past former Winnipeg mayor and Ontario Liberal MPP Glen Murray by 4,391 votes, attracting 27.5 per cent of the vote compared to Murray's 25.3 per cent. Gillingham's share of the popular vote in 2022 was also the lowest for any mayor in recent Winnipeg memory. Susan Thompson collected the second-lowest percentage in 1995, when she garnered 38.3 per cent of the popular vote. It is unclear whether the tight nature of the 2022 race will encourage other candidates from that election to try again. CBC News could not reach Murray for comment. He divides his time between Winnipeg and Toronto. Kevin Klein, a former city councillor and PC MLA who finished third in Winnipeg's 2022 mayoral race with 14.8 per cent of the popular vote, did not respond to queries about his potential interest in another run. Klein is now president and CEO of the Klein Group, which owns the Winnipeg Sun. Shaun Loney, who finished fourth in the 2022 race with 14.7 per cent of the vote, said Wednesday he will not run again in 2026. Loney, a founder of several social enterprises, said while he was initially encouraged by early outreach efforts from Gillingham, he is no longer playing an advisory role at city hall. "My door remains open to helping the city reduce crime and with social enterprises and keeping young people at home with green jobs," Loney said in a statement. "My efforts to partner with the mayor and council in these areas — which the city sorely needs — have unfortunately not borne fruit." The other seven mayoral candidates in 2022 earned a combined 17.7 per cent of the popular vote. The last time an incumbent mayor was defeated in an election in Winnipeg was in 1956, when Stephen Juba defeated George Sharpe after the latter completed a single two-year term. Juba and his successors — Bill Norrie, Thompson, Murray, Sam Katz and Brian Bowman — went on to win every election they contested while they served as mayor. It remains to be seen whether Gillingham is more vulnerable to a challenge than previous incumbents. On one hand, the former St. James councillor has largely avoided scandal. His largest crisis, the anger over the Winnipeg Police Service's decision not to search the Prairie Green landfill for the remains of murdered Indigenous women, largely stuck to former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson. On the other hand, this city continues to struggle with social disparity, homelessness, crime, a shortage of capital to finance major infrastructure projects and increases to the cost of living, including this year's property-tax hike, the largest in Winnipeg in decades. The next civic election is slated for Oct. 28, 2026.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Kananaskis G7 put spotlight on Manitoba art, architecture
At the 51st G7 summit in June, when world leaders from Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, the European Union and the United States met to discuss global economic and geopolitical issues, they did so in a space designed by Prairie architects and artists. Winnipeg firm 1×1 Architecture was commissioned to design the renovation of the Pomeroy Mountain Lodge at Kananaskis, Alta., for the summit. The team was engaged by Public Services and Procurement Canada to transform the lodge's existing 13,500-square-foot conference centre into a welcoming space that would help foster positive conversations between political leaders. GOVERNMENT OF CANADA A wood backdrop from 1x1 Architecture and an Indigo Arrows drum stool by Destiny Seymour were centre stage when Prime Minister Mark Carney met with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni at the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. last month. GOVERNMENT OF CANADA A wood backdrop from 1x1 Architecture and an Indigo Arrows drum stool by Destiny Seymour were centre stage when Prime Minister Mark Carney met with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni at the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. last month. The brief was to create a 'retreat-style' summit with a focus on intimate settings. Principal architect Travis Cooke, interior designer Ashley Jull and architectural intern Evan Schellenberg took on lead roles in the project. The trio was also tasked with creating four bilateral rooms used for smaller meetings. Winnipeggers Destiny Seymour, founder and owner of Indigenous-led design and textile studio Indigo Arrows, and designer Thom Fougere, who is now based in Montreal, were commissioned by the firm to create furniture for the spaces. SUPPLIED Destiny Seymour, founder and owner of design and textile studio Indigo Arrows SUPPLIED Destiny Seymour, founder and owner of design and textile studio Indigo Arrows 'There was an energy coming from our side to try and showcase as much Canadian content and Canadian manufacturers as possible,' Cooke says. 'We met with Destiny and Thom on our own to see if they were interested in delivering specific furniture pieces for the summit. They were both excited about the opportunity.' Seymour's drumming stools, made from Manitoba ash wood, were reimagined for the summit. Previously covered in easy-to-clean leatherette material, the new iteration sees the wood encased in wool blankets from Seymour's Elements line. The blankets feature ancestral Indigenous pottery patterns, ranging from 400 to 4,000 years old, from this region. 'Global Affairs Canada liked that I was reviving the pottery and bone tool patterns and giving them a fresh take,' Seymour says. Thom Fougere Studio Designer Thom Fougere chose to work with Tyndall stone, which is unique to Manitoba. Thom Fougere Studio Designer Thom Fougere chose to work with Tyndall stone, which is unique to Manitoba. The Earth blanket range comes in neutral, creams, earthy and brown tones; the designer used both sides of the blankets so some of the stools feature one design and the other feature its reverse. The stools were placed in each of the bilateral rooms and the design has already garnered interest online; Seymour has been busy fielding orders. 'I will have to start a line of those blanket stools now,' she laughs. The interior designer established her own studio in 2016 to address the lack of Indigenous representation in the industry. Unable to source products with an Indigenous theme, she decided to create her own home decor line, highlighting historic patterns from this territory. SUPPLIED Manitoba's 1x1 Architecture designed the renovation for Pomeroy Mountain Lodge during the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. SUPPLIED Manitoba's 1x1 Architecture designed the renovation for Pomeroy Mountain Lodge during the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. She now has a commercial fabric line as well as a flooring line. 'I think that representation is very important,' she says. 'I feel honoured and proud that our Indigenous designs were on a global stage, that I got to do that. I got a lot of positive feedback from the community. People are proud, because these patterns are from this land.' Thom Fougere's three-piece table collection was also created exclusively for the summit. Honed from Tyndall Stone, the set features two 2.5-metre-long display tables and a matching side table, which doubles as a vessel for flowers. Geologically referred to as the upper mottled limestone of the Red River Formation of the Ordovician system of the Paleozoic Era, Tyndall Stone is only quarried in Manitoba. According to a spokesperson from the Summits Management Office, Fougere's piece, along with other works by other Canadian designers and artists, 'was selected to highlight contemporary Canadian design and craftsmanship, and to showcase the beauty of the Canadian materials used.' SUPPLIED The G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. featured design work by 1x1 Architecture. SUPPLIED The G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. featured design work by 1x1 Architecture. 'Tyndall Stone has been in my life for a long time,' Fougere says. 'It's a material that's pervasive throughout the Prairies, so for the longest time I overlooked it, as it was just a common, everyday thing. It wasn't until I started to travel often for work, and to factories producing furniture around the world, that I started to look at what I took for granted back home in a new light. 'It's a beautiful material, and it's only found in the Canadian Prairies, just outside Winnipeg.' The Winnipeg-born designer, who moved to Montreal in 2021, worked with Gillis Quarry to locate stone pieces large enough for the design he had in mind. The tables were ground shipped in crates and driven carefully to the site, where a team of nine people were waiting to set up the 545-kilogram display tables and 225-kg side table. Fougere explains that a lot of his design decisions were pragmatic in nature, such as splitting the long display tables into a composition of two gestures, making them easier to manufacture, install and later move. 'I wanted to really show off the material with these pieces, so I elected to use fairly large heavy blocks of stone, and positioned them in a fairly brutal but balanced fashion,' he explains. 'The side table took a few forms, but I eventually landed on a vase-like piece that would hold a flower arrangement and also function as a practical side table.' The tables will eventually be moved and used in a government building in Ottawa. Thom Fougere Studio Thom Fougere furniture was prominent at the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. Thom Fougere Studio Thom Fougere furniture was prominent at the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta. The G7 summit design project has been the most high-profile commission 1×1 Architecture has been involved in, Cooke says. It was also one with the swiftest turnaround time. 'Federal projects usually take multiple years to deliver, so for this one to have started in October and finished in June is an extremely aggressive schedule,' Cooke says. 'We had to get design signoff from the federal government on the chosen scheme, then we had to produce construction drawings so that the contractor — who had only 14 days to construct the entire project — could build it.' Their main scope of work was the Outreach Room where the G7 Nations and Outreach Countries came together on the last day of the summit. The conference room had windows overlooking the Rocky Mountains, which were fitted with rough-sawn spruce timbers in front of an existing curtain wall. 'These timbers were culled from a firebreak initiative around the town of Canmore, which is only 30 miles away from Kananaskis,' Cooke says. Thom Fougere Studio Thom Fougere's side table doubles as a vase. Thom Fougere Studio Thom Fougere's side table doubles as a vase. 'Watching the news, it's hard to ignore the forest fires that we're currently dealing with annually. So it was a nice way to also tell the story of Canada's commitment to forestry stewardship,' Jull adds. The impermanent nature of the redesign reinforced the team's commitment to creating products that could be removed and repurposed. 'We were thinking what the next lifespan of that product could be,' Jull says. 'Could the hotel make use of it, or could that go somewhere else? Could it be donated to a school? We were considering a lot of modules, just thinking of the future use of that product, so that it does not end up in a landfill. 'Part of the government's commitment on this summit was to be a very green summit. So we were always trying to consider the reuse, recyclability or the next life value of it.' AV KitchingReporter AV Kitching is an arts and life writer at the Free Press. She has been a journalist for more than two decades and has worked across three continents writing about people, travel, food, and fashion. Read more about AV. Every piece of reporting AV produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Street names and recognizing public figures
Opinion 'A rose by any other name would smell as sweet,' William Shakespeare famously wrote in his play, Romeo and Juliet. The problem is, sometimes the bloom falls off the rose, and other times, the smell becomes something that isn't sweet at all. A year ago, Bishop Grandin Boulevard was renamed Abinojii Mikanah, a name that translates to 'children's way' in Anishinaabemowin. Bishop Grandin Trail became Awasisak Meskanôw — 'the children's road' in Ininimowin, or Cree, and Grandin Street, which runs from Taché Avenue to St. Joseph Street in St. Boniface became Taapweewin, which means 'truth' in Michif. Russell Wangersky / Free Press A street sign for Wolseley Avenue The name changes all came because of the recognition of the extent of Bishop Vital Grandin's troubling role in establishing residential schools. With that change in mind, it may well be a reckoning is coming for Wolseley the school, Wolseley the avenue, and maybe even Wolseley the neighbourhood — to cite just one other troubling name from the past. Wolseley School's parent council has looked at the possibility of changing the school's name, and the Winnipeg School Division has collected feedback on the idea, because the school is named after Col. Garnet Wolseley, who led a campaign of repression against Manitoba Métis. (Interestingly, the Manitoba Métis Federation has argued the name should stay, arguing that renaming landmarks and removing statues is a way of erasing a history of wrongdoing.) But one thing has arisen out of the renaming process that should also be considered by the city going forward. The WSD set renaming criteria for the Wolseley school that said prospective names 'should represent the neighbourhood and community; should connect to learning for the students' and 'must avoid the names of people.' The last one is an idea whose time may have come — avoiding the names of people. Because, more than anything else, people are complicated. Right now, the City of Winnipeg website devotes more than 300 words to explaining how it chooses to name a street after a person, saying that it wants 'to honour and commemorate noteworthy people associated with the city of Winnipeg.' That includes 'a person who demonstrates excellence, courage or exceptional dedication to service in ways that bring special credit to the city of Winnipeg; a person who volunteers and gives extraordinary help or care to individuals, families or groups, or supports community services or humanitarian causes; a person who fosters equality and reduces discrimination' and even 'an early pioneer or group or settlers who have contributed to the development of the city.' The city is so keen on naming streets after worthy Winnipeggers that the $200 fee for adding a name to the suggested street name reserve list is waived 'for applications recognizing individuals.' But maybe streets shouldn't be named after people at all, because history is a long road, and our viewpoints — and our knowledge about the character and behaviour of people who may seem like great examples today — can change with the years and with new knowledge. We've certainly seen that here. It's been recognized in other places as well. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. St. John's, the capital of the province of Newfoundland and Labrador, has taken the approach of changing its street naming policy this month to exclude naming streets after individuals. Simply put, it can be fraught with difficulties. 'Naming streets after people carries a number of risks,' St. John's Coun. Ron Ellsworth said during a June 17 council meeting, including ' problematic legacies, political polarization, disparity in representation and cultural marginalization.' The council vote in St. John's was unanimous, following the advice of the city's legal staff and the advice of the city's senior management. Maybe it's not an approach that will garner much support from Winnipeg's council. But maybe it's an idea whose time has come.
