Could an old sod*my case explain PMX's reluctance to extend T. Maimun's service tenure?
This was when the late Karpal Singh who was the Opposition leader's lead counsel had on Sept 17, 2013 applied to have Tengku Maimun recused from the panel hearing the appeal.
This piece of information was shared on X by former Barisan Nasional (BN) strategic communication deputy director Datuk Eric See-To probably to insinuate PMX's reluctance to extend Tengku Maimun's service term which ended on Tuesday (July 1) upon her reaching the mandatory retirement age of 66.
'Karpal argued that the reason for the application was Tengku Maimun's previous involvement in a civil suit filed by Anwar against twice former premiere Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad back in 2007,' penned the pro-Datuk Seri Najib Razak blogger.
In 2013, Anwar Ibrahim's lead counsel at the time, the late Karpal Singh, successfully applied to have Justice Tengku Maimun recused from the panel hearing the appeal in the Sodomy II case.
Karpal argued that the reason for the application was Tengku Maimun's previous… pic.twitter.com/hAN8nyqUTl
— Eric SeeTo Lim Sian See (@LimSianSeeEric) July 2, 2025
'He pointed out that in her judgment for that case, Tengku Maimun had adopted findings suggesting that Anwar had a homosexual tendency. Henceforth, Karpal argued that it would be inappropriate for Tengku Maimun to preside over the case'.
Following Karpel's submission, Tengku Maimun eventually recused herself from hearing the prosecutor's appeal 'which Anwar eventually lost'.
Whether the past has any bearing on today's development is as good as anybody's guess.
However, for the record, PMX has hit out at both the legal fraternity and Malaysians at large who rallied for Tengku Maimun's extension on ground of having rendered impeccable service for politicising the matter when an extension is never automatic.
On her part, Tengku Maimun has accepted her retirement in good faith while justifying that extending her service a further six months 'is not significant at all' compared to her having completed her six-year tenure as Malaysia's first female chief justice.
All-in-all, good governance advocate ksampoh@MyOwn Inc(@ksampoh) verified as true what was shared by the opposition-slant See-To who also goes by the moniker Lim Sian See.
'Now, he (PMX) says no extension for her as chief justice. Officially, it's about respecting retirement age. But fair question – does DSAI still carry a personal grudge from that old court history?' wondered ksampoh@MyOwn Inc.
'Only he knows – but history leaves marks.' – July 3, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
4 hours ago
- The Sun
Malaysia succeeds in attracting RM8.13b potential investments from Italy
ROME: Potential investments worth RM8.13 billion have been achieved through the Malaysia-Italy economic cooperation roundtable meeting and meetings with companies here, said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. The roundtable meeting involved the participation of 41 Italian companies and agencies, comprising 23 companies from the manufacturing sector, nine companies from the service sector, two companies from the trade sector as well as five government agencies and two industrial organisations. 'The potential investments achieved through these two meetings are worth RM8.13 billion in the petrochemical, machinery and equipment, electrical and electronics, and oil and gas services and equipment sectors,' he said at a press conference at the end of his visit to Rome, Italy. Anwar, who is also the Finance Minister, said the potential exports generated were worth RM425 million for oleochemical products, renewable energy, biofuel feedstocks, animal feed additives and food. The roundtable meeting allowed potential companies in Italy an opportunity to express their desire to collaborate with Malaysian companies in various sectors such as high-tech manufacturing, renewable energy, digital economy and sustainable infrastructure. Meanwhile, Anwar said that in a bilateral meeting with his counterpart Giorgia Meloni, Rome and Putrajaya would increase cooperation in the energy, solar, geothermal and hydrogen sectors. Among the collaborations are the Petronas and Eni SpA joint venture in Pengerang, Johor in the sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) sector; Perodua and Magna Styer for electric vehicle batteries; and collaboration and investment in the modernisation of the electricity grid, including the ASEAN Power Grid (APG). In the discussion, the Prime Minister said he also applied for recognition of the Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) certification from Italy, in addition to requesting support for a fairer assessment of the European Union Deforestation-Free Products Regulation (EUDR) Implementation. Malaysia aims to be in the low-risk category in the EUDR benchmark system when the rating is reviewed by 2026. Meanwhile, Malaysia has also sought Italy's support in concluding negotiations on the Malaysia-European Union Free Trade Agreement (FTA). The Prime Minister arrived here on Tuesday for a three-day working visit to Italy, the third largest economy in the EU. The visit was at the invitation of Meloni. Throughout the visit, Anwar was accompanied by Foreign Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan, Transport Minister Anthony Loke, Agriculture and Food Security Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Sabu, Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin and Investment, Trade and Industry Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz. Also joining the delegation was Deputy Energy Transition and Water Transformation Minister Akmal Nasrullah Mohd Nasir. In 2024, total trade between Malaysia and Italy recorded an increase of two per cent to US$3.18 billion (RM14.61 billion) compared to the same period in 2023. For the period from January to May 2025, total trade between the two countries continued to show positive performance with an increase of 3.3 per cent to US$1.48 billion (RM6.5 billion) compared to the same period in 2024. The Prime Minister departed for France for an official visit on July 3 and 4 after concluding his visit to Italy.
Free Malaysia Today
6 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
I no longer have to carry this burden, says Tengku Maimun
Former chief justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat reached the mandatory retirement age of 66 yesterday, with Tuesday being her last day in office. KUALA LUMPUR : Former chief justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat says it is now up to the government, and her successor, to carry on the duty of upholding judicial independence. Tengku Maimun – who became the first woman to helm the judiciary when she was appointed chief justice in 2019 – reached the mandatory retirement age of 66 yesterday, with Tuesday being her last day in office. Speaking at the launch of her book today, Tengku Maimun said she and her former colleagues had worked tirelessly to uplift the judiciary's image over the past six years. 'I no longer have to carry this burden,' she said. 'I still find it hard to fathom that I spent six years of my life as chief justice, and that I am now retired from a lifetime of service.' Her book, Beyond The Gavel, consists of some of her written judgments from the High Court until Federal Court, as well as some of her speeches. She also thanked her peers – consisting of lawyers and judges – who contributed to the book. Tengku Maimun's retirement was followed by that of Court of Appeal president Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim, whose judicial tenure ended yesterday. Both vacated their office on the eve of their 66th birthday. Chief Judge of Malaya Hasnah Hashim, currently the highest ranked judge in the judiciary, is now the acting chief justice. Hasnah, whose office ranks third in the judicial hierarchy, created history today by occupying the top three positions in the judiciary simultaneously. Hasnah herself reached the mandatory retirement age on May 13, but she secured a six-month extension which allowed her to remain in office until Nov 14.
New Straits Times
6 hours ago
- New Straits Times
'I can now breathe a sigh of relief', says Tengku Maimun
KUALA LUMPUR: Former Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat said she can now breathe a sigh of relief, as she no longer bears the heavy responsibility of upholding judicial independence and integrity. Speaking at the launch of her book Behind the Gavel, Tengku Maimun reflected on her time at the helm of the judiciary, noting that she and her colleagues had worked tirelessly to restore public confidence in the institution. The Kelantan-born judge reiterated that she had never aspired to the top judicial post. "As I have said before, I never sought the position of Chief Justice. It was never in my wildest dreams to imagine that someone like me would be selected to hold the position. "I accepted the job as a test from Allah, to measure my commitment to the rule of law and the principles of the Islamic faith, such as honesty and integrity. "I still find it hard to fathom that I spent six years of my life as Chief Justice, and that I am now retired after a lifetime of service. "I am happy to reach the time when I must finally hang up my judicial robe. From the book, I hope it is clear that I have done my part for the country and the rule of law," she said. Chief Justice of Singapore, Sundaresh Menon, was also present at the event and officiated the launch of the book. Tengku Maimun said public attention, including her own, is now on the government and the incoming Chief Justice. "It is about how they uphold the standards of judicial independence and integrity," she said. Tengku Maimun retired upon turning 66 on July 2, the mandatory retirement age for judges. Earlier, the Chief Registrar's Office announced that Chief Judge of Malaya, Tan Sri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim, has assumed the role and is carrying out the duties of Chief Justice following Tengku Maimun's retirement. The Chief Registrar's Office said the appointment was made in accordance with Article 131A of the Federal Constitution and Sections 9(1)(b) and 9(3) of the Courts of Judicature Act.
