US appeals court sides with Moderna on COVID patent claims
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit upheld, opens new tab a Delaware federal court's decision to interpret Alnylam's two patents in a manner that foreclosed its infringement arguments.
Alnylam lost a similar dispute in a related Moderna case last year. It has filed separate, ongoing patent lawsuits over Pfizer's COVID shots.
An Alnylam spokesperson said the company is reviewing the Wednesday ruling and considering its options. A Moderna spokesperson said it was pleased with the decision and that its vaccine was "a product of many years of pioneering mRNA platform research and development."
Cambridge, Massachusetts-based Alnylam first sued Moderna and Pfizer for patent infringement in 2022 for allegedly using its lipid nanoparticle (LNP) technology in their vaccines to deliver genetic material into the body. The lawsuits are part of a web of patent disputes between biotech companies over COVID shots, which includes a lawsuit filed by Moderna against Pfizer later that year.
Moderna and Alnylam jointly agreed to dismiss Alnylam's patent claims in the first case in 2023 after U.S. District Judge Colm Connolly interpreted the patents to cover a type of lipid that Spikevax did not have. A three-judge Federal Circuit panel upheld Connolly's interpretation on Wednesday.
The case is Alnylam Pharmaceuticals Inc v. Moderna Inc, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, No. 23-2357.
For Alnylam: Paul Hughes of McDermott Will & Emery
For Moderna: Jeffrey Lamken of MoloLamken
Read more:
Alnylam files patent infringement lawsuits against Pfizer, Moderna
Alnylam to appeal ruling on patents related to Moderna's COVID vaccines
Moderna fends off Alnylam US patent lawsuit over COVID shots, for now
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Macron branded 'naive' and accused of risking UK lives after 'botched' Iran call
Emmanuel Macron has been branded 'naive' after holding a phone call with Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian - the first time the two leaders have spoken since the end of the 12-day war with Israel Emmanuel Macron has been slammed for his "naive', after holding talks with Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian. The French President spoke with his Iranian counterpart on Sunday, the first time since the end of the " approach following discussions with Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian. The French President engaged in talks with his Iranian counterpart on Sunday, marking the first interaction since the conclusion of the "12-day war" with Israel. In a subsequent social media post, Macron implored Iran to "maintain the ceasefire, in order to help restore peace to the Middle East." He also urged Tehran "to return to the negotiating table to discuss and address nuclear and ballistic missile issues". Despite Macron's appeals, Iran announced it was severing all ties with the UN nuclear inspectorate, including prohibiting its members from visiting any nuclear sites. Ellie Borhan, a British-Iranian activist, delivered a blistering critique of Macron's failed diplomacy, arguing that attempts to placate Tehran would result in further fatalities - including those of British nationals. "A Government that kills their own people is not trustworthy," she stated, reports the Express. "When they are not a democratic regime, you cannot expect a democratic solution. You cannot be so naïve to say 'Let's talk'. If you do, you will only witness more people losing their lives. "This will not just be innocent people in Iran - this will be innocent people in the UK, Europe and the US if Iran is emboldened." Iran's ruthless mullah regime has presided over a broad campaign of terror and suppression of internal opposition. The United Nations has reported that a staggering 901 people were put to death in 2024, with around 40 executions occurring in just one week of December. According to the Norway-based Iran Human Rights group (IHRNGO), there's been a shocking 75% surge in executions within the first four months of 2025 compared to the same timeframe last year. French President Macron, spearheading Europe's diplomatic initiatives on Iran, has openly criticised the Israeli and US bombings of Iranian nuclear sites, arguing that only through political dialogue can enduring peace be achieved. Ms Borhan, however, has outright rejected the notion that Iran would honour any potential deal, stating, "This dictatorship has never stayed true or respected any negotiation or diplomacy. Every time we have an uprising they kill their own people. Where is Macron then? How can he trust this government?". She has urged Western powers to show their strength and exert "maximum pressure" on the Iranian regime. "We've seen sanctions but that is not enough, we need to put more pressure on the Islamic Republic," she insisted. Ms Borhan's activism in the UK has had personal repercussions, as her mother and brother in Iran face accusations of espionage for Israel. Macron previously directed criticism at former US President Donald Trump following American strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, cautioning that such actions would only escalate Tehran's nuclear threat.
Scotsman
4 hours ago
- Scotsman
Scotland's economic growth 'weaker' than rest of UK as business 'falters' from Donald Trump tariffs
Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A slowdown in growth in Scotland's economy has been blamed on 'higher global uncertainty', with experts branding the recovery from the Covid pandemic as 'weaker' than the rest of the UK and 'particularly' linked to Donald Trump's trade tariffs. The Fraser of Allander Institute (FAI) has downgraded their forecasts for growth in Scotland, as Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes demanded 'decisive action' from the UK government to counter business uncertainty. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It comes as First Minister John Swinney, writing exclusively for The Scotsman, said Labour could have avoided the "fiscal nightmare' being wrestled with by Sir Keir Starmer's UK government if they 'had the courage to do what the SNP have done, and ask higher earners to pay more tax'. Buchanan Street in Glasgow's city centre. The Fraser of Allander Institute has said Scotland's economy has experienced a 'weaker recovery' from Covid compared to the rest of the UK. Picture: John Linton/PA Wire Economics experts at the Strathclyde University-based think tank FAI highlighted a recent rise in inflation this year as having 'played a role' as the economy 'faltered'. Speaking as its latest quarterly economic commentary was published, institute director Professor Mairi Spowage said: 'After a strong start to the year, the Scottish economy has faltered in March and April and is essentially the same size in real terms as it was six months ago. 'Unfortunately, the wider business environment and global events are still taking a toll on businesses and consumers, which is having a dampening effect on spending and business investment.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The economic assessment comes after Mr Trump's decision to introduce a 10 per cent levy on most UK goods, including Scottish whisky and salmon, came into affect from April. The FAI now expects economic growth of 0.8 per cent in 2025 and 1 per cent in 2026, which is a slight downgrade from its April forecasts of 0.9 per cent and 1.1 per cent. The think-tank noted Scottish real GDP grew 0.4 per cent in the first quarter of 2025, compared to 0.7 per cent in the UK as a whole. The think-tank said: 'A pattern of lower growth in Scotland has persisted, leading to a weaker recovery from the pandemic than the UK generally.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Looking at the latest data, it found Scotland's economic growth had 'remained slow', with rises in the first months of this year having been 'partially offset' by falls in March and April. The report said: 'The slowdown in growth this year is largely due to higher global uncertainty, particularly from the announcement of tariffs in the US and elsewhere. 'With the CPI [Consumer Prices Index] rate at 3.4 per cent in May 2025 after staying below 3 per cent throughout 2024, an uptick in inflation has also played a role.' The think-tank said its latest forecasts 'reflect greater uncertainty and difficult economic circumstances'. The body also noted that businesses had reported a slowdown of activity in the first quarter of this year compared to the same period last year. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The report said this 'decline in activity may reflect the impact of increases to employer national insurance contributions as well as uncertain conditions, particularly from trade and tariff decisions taken by the US government'. It said the 'difficult conditions for business have been echoed in the labour market', with the think tank noting pay growth has been 'slow' and the number of employees has fallen 0.9 per cent from last year. It also said there was 'some indication that the proportion of people living beyond their means in Scotland may have increased compared to this time last year'. Ms Forbes said: 'It is clearer than ever that Scotland's economy is being impacted by challenging global trading conditions and uncertainty – conditions mirrored across the rest of the UK. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'We are taking ambitious steps to grow the economy by pursuing new investment, building export potential and driving and capitalising on the Scottish innovation at the forefront of many key global industries. 'But we are doing all of this without the full economic powers needed to fully address the issues facing Scottish businesses. We need decisive action from the UK government to counter the damaging economic impacts of Brexit and business uncertainty. 'This includes reversing its decision to increase employers' national insurance contributions which, as the Scottish Chambers of Commerce has highlighted, is severely damaging business confidence, investment, growth and jobs.' Scottish Conservative shadow finance secretary Craig Hoy said: 'While there's no question external factors are impacting Scotland's economy, it's clear anti-business SNP policies are also stifling growth. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The Nationalists' failure to fully pass on the rates relief available to businesses south of the Border, coupled with them making Scotland the highest taxed part of the UK, explains why the growth rate here is even lower than the anaemic rate Keir Starmer is presiding over.
Scottish Sun
6 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Renters left stunned by sky-high monthly rent for studio flat in Glasgow
The price tag on this property has sparked outrage online 'RIDICULOUS' Renters left stunned by sky-high monthly rent for studio flat in Glasgow Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HOUSE-HUNTERS have been left stunned after spotting the eye-watering price of a month's rent for a tiny bedsit in Glasgow's Southside. This one-bedroom studio flat in Govanhill is just minutes from the popular Queen's Park and promises "brand new and recently modernised" living. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 The flat is situated on Dixon Avenue in the Govanhill area of Glasgow Credit: rightmove 3 The flat boats a double bed, ensuite toilet and a four-stove hob Credit: rightmove 3 It is newly renovated and comes with an added "all inclusive" benefit Credit: rightmove Marketed by London-based OpenRent, the Dixon Avenue property packs a surprising amount into a very small space. The studio comes fully furnished with a four-hob stove and oven, an under-counter fridge, a wardrobe, and a TV mounted above a small desk. It boasts a double ottoman bed with an orthopaedic mattress and "ample storage," along with an en-suite toilet and shower. The fresh sage green walls and grey hardwood flooring complete the look. Initially listed for a staggering £1,235 per month, the rent has since been reduced to £1,100. While the listing boasts an "all-inclusive" perk with utility bills and Wi-Fi included, tenants will still need to fork out for council tax and provide a £750 deposit to secure the flat. And the price tag on this property has sparked outrage online. Punters took to Reddit to slam the price of the flat. One user said: "Absolute joker of a landlord charging over a grand for this "studio". "Glasgow rent is ridiculous and it's forcing people out of the communities they've lived in for years." Woman's home and belongings left covered in mould as she blasts Scots council Another added: "Heard rents were out of control but I didn't know it was this bad. I used to see Dixon avenue for like £250-400 a month. Wow, I feel sorry for people renting!" A third wrote: "Wow, that's London prices 5 years ago." A fourth fumed: "This is like a prison cell. Literally why would anyone work 5/7 days a week for all their savings and income to be usurped from them only to live in this room?"
