
John Swinney at centre of fresh secrecy row after SNP's deleted Covid WhatsApp scandal
WIPE OUT John Swinney at centre of fresh secrecy row after SNP's deleted Covid WhatsApp scandal
JOHN Swinney is at the centre of a fresh secrecy row over the use of an app that automatically deletes content after five days.
A decision by the First Minister to allow the Microsoft Teams instant messaging service for Scottish Government business is being probed by Scotland's transparency watchdog.
Advertisement
3
First Minister John Swinney
Credit: Michael Schofield
3
Nicola Sturgeon was among those who deleted their WhatsApp messages
Credit: PA
It comes after Nats chiefs faced a huge backlash for scrubbing WhatsApp messages during Covid.
Critics blasted the latest tech move and said it provides a 'deliberate loophole'.
Scottish Tory finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: 'The SNP need to come clean on this state-sponsored automatic deletion of messages and why it is still being allowed.
'It looks as though a deliberate loophole has been left in place to allow senior figures to avoid scrutiny over key decisions. That is typical of this sleekit and secretive SNP government who only announced this apparent change in policy after already deleting Covid-related messages on an industrial scale.'
Advertisement
Information Commissioner David Hamilton confirmed the SNP's use to Teams messages forms part of an ongoing probe.
He said: 'This issue is currently subject of my investigation into how messaging apps are used in Scottish Government. It will be helpful to understand the rationale for such a short retention period and how compliance with any policies will be assured.
'Both will form part of my enquiries.'
In their new guidance, Nats chiefs say MS Teams chat is the 'core messaging functionality' of their internal system, allowing civil servants to 'message, call, screen share' others in the organisation.
Advertisement
Ministers say the chat function can be used for 'general day-to-day activities' with colleagues external stakeholders, as well as and 'urgent work communications'.
It is also allowed to be used with 'ministerial support or advice', including when ministers are in the Holyrood chamber.
Damning screenshots expose Jason Leitch's 'pre-bed WhatsApp ritual' during pandemic as SNP bosses branded 'shameful'
Civil servants and ministers can use the chat function for 'communication of urgent work issues' out of normal hours.
The change in rules means messages on government business, including advice to ministers or key discussions among senior civil servants, could be auto-deleted — potentially undermining any future inquiries into scandals.
Advertisement
It comes after Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes reconfirmed last month the ban on WhatsApp on government phones.
Former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon deleted Covid WhasApps despite telling Scots on TV that she would hand all of them over.
We told how mountains of messages between key ministers, including Ms Sturgeon, her successor Humza Yousaf, and Mr Swinney showed they joked about deleting the messages to avoid publishing them through transparency rules.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government's approach to Microsoft Teams is similar to the approach taken by UK Government departments.
Advertisement
'Microsoft Teams is a corporate system which operates under the direct control of the Scottish Government and in line with its published policies in respect of records management.
Jason Leitch, the National Clinical Director, also angered Covid bereaved groups for saying deleting his WhatsApps was a 'pre-night' ritual.
We also revealed in October how the UK's chief medical officers rallied round disgraced adviser Catherine Calderwood after her lockdown-busting trip to Fife, also revealed by The Scottish Sun.
3
Jason Leitch was at the centre of the covid WhatsApp row
Credit: Andrew Barr
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Rhyl Journal
6 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
It's great to be here, I love standing on the soil of Scotland, Trump says
Ian Murray told the PA news agency what the US President's first words were after disembarking from Air Force One in Prestwick. The UK Government minister was the first person to greet the president in Scotland as he begins his visit to the country. Speaking after meeting the American leader, Mr Murray told PA: 'The president came off the flight, and I said, 'Mr president, welcome to Scotland – the home country of your dear mother', and he said, 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland'. 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Mr Murray said Mr Trump was given a warm reception as he got off his presidential plane. Hundreds gathered on the Mound overlooking Prestwick Airport for the president's arrival. A Trump flag was flown while a few spectators wore 'Make America Great Again' hats, although many of those attending were locals and aviation enthusiasts, including some who had travelled from England. Mr Murray said: 'Spotters hills, as it's called, where all the plane spotters come to Prestwick, was absolutely full. 'You could see that from the tarmac and as Air Force One came in, people were snapping away on their photographs. 'To see all that happening is quite a spectacle in itself. 'It's really good to have that kind of focus on Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his trip to discuss the UK-US trade deal as Britain hopes to be spared from the president's tariff regime. The Scottish Secretary said: 'Really, the purpose of this weekend, the purpose of greeting the president off the plane, the purpose of the Prime Minister's relationship with the president is to build that close relationship, to make sure that that old alliance is nurtured, and to do that for the benefit of the national interest, which is about jobs and growth here in the UK, and particularly Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Scottish First Minister John Swinney during his trip as he opens a new golf course in Aberdeenshire. Before flying to Prestwick, Mr Trump said in Washington that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Mr Swinney, describing him as a 'good man' – the same phrase he used for the Prime Minister after landing in Scotland. Asked about the president's relationship with the UK, Mr Murray said: 'The Prime Minister has taken a very pragmatic approach to the relationship with the president of the United States, because it's in our national interest to do so, whether it be on defence, security, trade, cultural, historic ties. 'It's a historic alliance, and that alliance has to be nurtured and continue through to the future, because it's quite clear that our relationship with United States is good for jobs and growth here in Scotland and across the UK. 'The Prime Minister knows that, and knows that working very closely with the US is in our national interest.' Asked about protests, which are expected across the country, Mr Murray said people had a right to demonstrate, adding: 'Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom to protest is a key cornerstone of both countries, America and the UK, and the right to be able to protest if they so wish to so.'


South Wales Guardian
6 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
It's great to be here, I love standing on the soil of Scotland, Trump says
Ian Murray told the PA news agency what the US President's first words were after disembarking from Air Force One in Prestwick. The UK Government minister was the first person to greet the president in Scotland as he begins his visit to the country. Speaking after meeting the American leader, Mr Murray told PA: 'The president came off the flight, and I said, 'Mr president, welcome to Scotland – the home country of your dear mother', and he said, 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland'. 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Mr Murray said Mr Trump was given a warm reception as he got off his presidential plane. Hundreds gathered on the Mound overlooking Prestwick Airport for the president's arrival. A Trump flag was flown while a few spectators wore 'Make America Great Again' hats, although many of those attending were locals and aviation enthusiasts, including some who had travelled from England. Mr Murray said: 'Spotters hills, as it's called, where all the plane spotters come to Prestwick, was absolutely full. 'You could see that from the tarmac and as Air Force One came in, people were snapping away on their photographs. 'To see all that happening is quite a spectacle in itself. 'It's really good to have that kind of focus on Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his trip to discuss the UK-US trade deal as Britain hopes to be spared from the president's tariff regime. The Scottish Secretary said: 'Really, the purpose of this weekend, the purpose of greeting the president off the plane, the purpose of the Prime Minister's relationship with the president is to build that close relationship, to make sure that that old alliance is nurtured, and to do that for the benefit of the national interest, which is about jobs and growth here in the UK, and particularly Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Scottish First Minister John Swinney during his trip as he opens a new golf course in Aberdeenshire. Before flying to Prestwick, Mr Trump said in Washington that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Mr Swinney, describing him as a 'good man' – the same phrase he used for the Prime Minister after landing in Scotland. Asked about the president's relationship with the UK, Mr Murray said: 'The Prime Minister has taken a very pragmatic approach to the relationship with the president of the United States, because it's in our national interest to do so, whether it be on defence, security, trade, cultural, historic ties. 'It's a historic alliance, and that alliance has to be nurtured and continue through to the future, because it's quite clear that our relationship with United States is good for jobs and growth here in Scotland and across the UK. 'The Prime Minister knows that, and knows that working very closely with the US is in our national interest.' Asked about protests, which are expected across the country, Mr Murray said people had a right to demonstrate, adding: 'Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom to protest is a key cornerstone of both countries, America and the UK, and the right to be able to protest if they so wish to so.'


Scotsman
6 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Ian Murray reveals what Donald Trump said to him on the Prestwick tarmac
Donald Trump has arrived in Scotland, and Scottish Secretary Ian Murray was there to meet him off Air Force One at Prestwick Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Donald Trump has said he 'loves standing on the soil of Scotland' after landing in the country on Friday evening, according to the Scottish Secretary. Ian Murray revealed what the US President's first words were after disembarking from Air Force One in Prestwick. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The UK Government minister was the first person to greet the president in Scotland as he begins his visit to the country. Speaking after meeting the American leader, Mr Murray said: 'The president came off the flight, and I said, 'Mr president, welcome to Scotland – the home country of your dear mother', and he said, 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland'. 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Mr Murray said Mr Trump was given a warm reception as he got off his presidential plane. Hundreds gathered on the Mound overlooking Prestwick Airport for the president's arrival. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A Trump flag was flown while a few spectators wore 'Make America Great Again' hats, although many of those attending were locals and aviation enthusiasts, including some who had travelled from England. Mr Murray said: 'Spotters hills, as it's called, where all the plane spotters come to Prestwick, was absolutely full. 'You could see that from the tarmac and as Air Force One came in, people were snapping away on their photographs. 'To see all that happening is quite a spectacle in itself. 'It's really good to have that kind of focus on Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his trip to discuss the UK-US trade deal as Britain hopes to be spared from the president's tariff regime. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish Secretary said: 'Really, the purpose of this weekend, the purpose of greeting the president off the plane, the purpose of the Prime Minister's relationship with the president is to build that close relationship, to make sure that that old alliance is nurtured, and to do that for the benefit of the national interest, which is about jobs and growth here in the UK, and particularly Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet First Minister John Swinney during his trip as he opens a new golf course in Aberdeenshire. Before flying to Prestwick, Mr Trump said in Washington that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Mr Swinney, describing him as a 'good man' – the same phrase he used for the Prime Minister after landing in Scotland. Asked about the president's relationship with the UK, Mr Murray said: 'The Prime Minister has taken a very pragmatic approach to the relationship with the president of the United States, because it's in our national interest to do so, whether it be on defence, security, trade, cultural, historic ties. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'It's a historic alliance, and that alliance has to be nurtured and continue through to the future, because it's quite clear that our relationship with United States is good for jobs and growth here in Scotland and across the UK. 'The Prime Minister knows that, and knows that working very closely with the US is in our national interest.'