Industrial-scale Mussel farm is ‘completely incompatible' with Kinsale Harbour, campaigners say
Campaigners are calling on the minister for agriculture and the marine to revoke a licence for a 23 hectare industrial-scale mussel farm in Kinsale Harbour, directly in front of the popular Dock Beach.
Health, environmental, and economic concerns for the locality have been raised, along with fears that it may jeopardise access to one of the town's most popular beaches and surrounding water used for swimming, kayaking and sailing.
The licence should be revoked pending a full Environmental Impact Assessment, a marine navigation risk study, a cultural heritage survey, and a social and economic impact analysis, campaigners say.
A licence was granted in May to Waterford-based Woodstown Bay Shellfish Ltd for bottom-culture mussel farming using dredging across a zone long used by swimmers, kayakers, sailors, and crab fishers.
No marine safety or navigational impact assessment has been conducted, campaigners say.
The proximity to a wastewater treatment facility lacking UV disinfection further raises serious sanitary concerns under EU directives, they say.
They are appealing for Minister Martin Heydon to revoke the licence, which they say was granted on highly flawed grounds.
The window for appeals closes this week.
And while the industrial mussel farm is expected to create some six new jobs, the town is heavily reliant on its €70m annual tourism economy, which campaigners say the mussel farm may jeopardise.
Appeals have been submitted to the Aquaculture Licence Appeals Board (ALAB), citing legal, ecological, economic, and procedural grounds.
The licence should be revoked pending a full Environmental Impact Assessment, a marine navigation risk study, a cultural heritage survey, and a social and economic impact analysis, campaigners say. Picture: Eddie O'Hare
'This farm is completely incompatible with the heritage, ecology, and economy of Kinsale Harbour,' said local environmental advocate Dr Marc Ó Riain.
'We're asking minister Heydon to exercise his authority to revoke this licence in the public interest.'
Under Section 7.3 of the Fisheries (Amendment) Act, the Minister may revoke a licence if it is deemed contrary to the public interest — a clause now being urgently invoked by campaigners.
Protected seagrass beds, a priority habitat under the EU Habitats Directive which play a vital role in marine biodiversity and carbon capture, have been found recently in the proposed dredging area but this was not reflected in the original environmental screening, they say.
'There was no Environmental Impact Assessment. The data relied on is over six years old,' said one appeal letter submitted to ALAB. 'This violates the precautionary principle of EU law.'
The site is also adjacent to the 17th-century James Fort, a designated national monument, and the remains of a historic blockhouse at the mouth of the Bandon River.
No underwater archaeological survey was undertaken — a 'serious procedural omission' according to one submission, potentially placing unrecorded heritage at risk.
The area is one of Ireland's busiest mixed-use harbours, with sailing schools, kayak tours, angling trips, and marine wildlife excursions operating daily. The site overlaps traditional crab pot grounds, and no alternative fishing areas or mitigation measures have been proposed, campaigners say.
Appeals also raised the danger of mussel larvae clogging raw water intakes on leisure and commercial vessels — a hazard which can cause overheating and engine failure.
A decision from the Appeals Board is expected later this year.
Read More
Watch: Mussel Farm protest in Kinsale Harbour
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
37 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Microsoft sued in landmark Irish case over alleged unlawful processing of personal data
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) has brought the action claiming Microsoft operates an advertising business, through its Xandr platform, which allows it to sell advertising slots to individual advertisers in a real-time bidding system for a fee. It is claimed that Microsoft's "search and news advertising" business generated some $10.2bn (€8.7bn) in the nine months ending March 2025. The ICCL is seeking declarations and orders against Microsoft Ireland Operations Ltd directing it to cease such data processing and/or adjust its processing to comply with GDPR and Irish law. In May, the ICCL obtained High Court approval deeming its action admissible as a representative action under the 2023 Protection of the Collective Interests of Consumers Act. This is the first such case to be brought under that Act. On Monday, the case was admitted to the fast track Commercial Court list on the application of James Doherty SC, for the ICCL. Declan McGrath SC, for Microsoft, said he did not object to the entry of the matter into the list but he wanted time to write to the ICCL to set out why it is Xandr that should be the defendant and not Microsoft. Mr McGrath also said his side had separately written to the ICCL about its sources of funding for the proceedings and that is expected to be provided within a week. Microsoft may have to bring an application in relation to that, he said. Ms Justice Eileen Roberts said it was a rather unusual case but one that not only has a commercial aspect but will benefit enormously from the case management jurisdiction of the Commercial Court. She adjourned it for three weeks but did not make directions on how it is to proceed to allow the parties exchange correspondence in relation to funding and the correct defendant. In an affidavit seeking entry of the case to the commercial list, Johnny Ryan, senior fellow with the ICCL and director of its privacy and data protection programme, Enforce, said the $10.2bn from Microsoft's search and news advertising business was contained in the company's '10-Q' submission to the US Securities and Exchange Commission. He said further publicly available documents provided by the defendant, which Microsoft claims sufficiently sets out the lawfulness of its processing activities, failed to satisfy the ICCL's concerns. Mr Ryan said the claim that Microsoft is not the correct defendant is an attempt to delay the prosecution of the proceedings and also delay the vindication of the rights of Irish consumers. If another party is to be added or substituted as a defendant, Mr Ryan believes this can be done during the currency of the proceedings.
Agriland
4 hours ago
- Agriland
Stena Line set to withdraw Rosslare-Cherbourg sailing
Ferry operator Stena Line has confirmed today (Monday, June 30) that it will withdraw its Rosslare to Cherbourg ferry service from the end of September this year. The decision will come as a significant blow to Irish-based calf exporters who depend on the service to get large volumes of calves to key markets in mainland Europe. The ferry route is also used to transport significant numbers of other livestock to mainland Europe including weanlings, older cattle and horses. In a statement the company said: 'Following a strategic route review, Stena Line has announced that from September 30, 2025, the ferry operator intends to withdraw its existing three-day Rosslare – Cherbourg service. 'The last sailing will depart Cherbourg on September 29, arriving in Rosslare on September 30. 'These plans have been developed after an extensive review with the intention of strengthening the company's investment in the Irish Sea, whilst delivering the most efficient use of the company's resources.' Stena Line Commenting on the announcement, Johan Edelman, Stena Line trade director said: 'Our priority is, as always, the care of our people and customers. 'We've already met with our colleagues and over this period of consultation we will be working with any individual affected to consider all options, including redeployment opportunities. 'As we work through this change we will continue to support our colleagues at every stage. 'Our customer service team will be helping customers who have booked travel after September to keep any inconvenience to a minimum.' According to the Stena Line trade director the company will continue to 'strengthen its Irish Sea network'. 'We have recently announced investments of almost £40 million in our Liverpool and Belfast terminals, as well as the upgrading of the Fishguard port infrastructure. 'We will also be increasing capacity across the Irish Sea with two new freight vessels planned for the Belfast – Heysham route and an additional freight vessel for the Dublin – Liverpool route. 'Our Rosslare – Cherbourg service is one that we will always be proud of, and we will continue to deliver the same high-quality service over the coming months,' he added.
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
German inflation eases to 2% in June, defying forecasts
German inflation eased in June, preliminary data from the federal statistics office showed today, despite forecasts suggesting a slight increase in price pressures in Europe's largest economy. German inflation fell to 2% year on year. Analysts polledby Reuters had forecast EU-harmonised inflation increasing from the previous month to 2.2%. Germany's core inflation rate, which excludes volatile food and energy prices, eased to 2.7% in June from 2.8% the previous month. The German data comes ahead of the euro zone inflation release tomorrow. Inflation in the bloc is expected at 2% in June, the European Central Bank's goal, up from 1.9% the previous month, according to economists polled by Reuters. Data published on Friday showed that EU-harmonised inflation rose in France and Spain. Inflation was unchanged in Italy, data showed today. Overall, the figures add to the evidence that inflation in the euro zone has sustainably returned to the target, said Franziska Palmas, senior Europe economist at Capital Economics. "Barring a renewed surge in energy prices we expect the headline rate to average 2% this year and the ECB to make one final rate cut in September," Palmas said. The ECB cut interest rates at the beginning of June but hinted at a pause in its year-long easing cycle. "The German figure signals to the ECB that it has done its job," said Alexander Krueger, chief economist at Hauck Aufhaeuser Lampe, who forecast the inflation rate in Germany would remain at 2% or even dip lower in the coming months,"right where it is supposed to be." Inflation data show that German energy prices fell by 3.5% in June compared to the previous year. While food prices rose 2%, that marked a significant decline from the 2.8% year-on-year increases recorded in May and April. Services inflation, which has been stubbornly high, fell to 3.3% in June from 3.4% in the previous month. "People may still complain about service prices, but due to the relief from energy prices, their still-high increase is hardly noticeable," said Krueger. Despite the positive developments, Commerzbank's chief economist Joerg Kraemer warned that core inflation could remain higher than targeted "for longer than the ECB intends" due to the emerging economic recovery in Germany. German retail sales in surprise 1.6% drop in May Earlier figures showed that German retail sales unexpectedly fell by 1.6% in May compared with the previous month, dampening hopes for strong growth in the second quarter for Europe's largest economy. Analysts polled by Reuters had predicted a 0.5% increase, after sales declined by 0.6% in April. While there could be some recovery in June, a large and sustained jump in consumption is not expected for the time being, said Hauck Aufhaeuser Lampe economist Alexander Krueger. That could spell problems for economic growth in the second quarter after unexpectedly robust growth in the first, thanks in part to consumer spending. "The strong growth seen in the first quarter will not be repeated," said VP Bank economist Thomas Gitzel. "The German economy will have to scale back its ambitions in the second quarter," he added. Consumer sentiment in Germany dipped to -20.3 points heading into July in the most recent survey conducted by the GfK market research institute and the Nuremberg Institute for Market Decisions (NIM). That survey of around 2,000 people found an increased willingness to save - due to continuing uncertainty - was counteracting positive momentum in income prospects.
