School review cost 'not in public interest'
Daphne Caine has defended her department's decision not to release the amount paid to external validators Etio in response to a Tynwald question for written answer.
She told the House of Keys that as her department was in the second of a three year contract with the firm it was "not in the public interest" to release the information.
But MHK Lawrie Hooper said the costs were "routinely made available by the UK in relation to the exact company and the services they provide".
Hooper said the rationale was "nonsense", and said based on figures released by the UK government indicated the Manx services would "probably cost between £150,000 and £250,000".
Cain suggested she could share the figure confidentially with the Public Accounts Committee.
During Tuesday's sitting, Kate Lord-Brennan called for the minister to provide a cost range for the report, arguing releasing the information was about "education delivery, standards, and public money, not about Etio".
Chris Thomas MHK said it was "unusual" not to share the costs even when a contract was live, and noted that Treasury had published the terms of contracts in the past.
Concerns were also raised by Julie Edge MHK, who said she did not understand why there was "so much resistance when it is such an important piece of work for our schools".
Tim Glover MHK questioned how released the figure confidentially would restore and maintain public confidence.
Caine said it was not in the public interest if it "breached" commercial confidentiality, and the competitiveness of future bids was "compromised".
She said the department would "likely" go out for tender in the next six months, and sharing the cost could limit the "commercial competitiveness so that all bids come in within a ball park".
That was "not serving the best interest of the Isle of Man community", she said.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
School reviews 'foundation' for future improvement
School review framework to be published in July
Manx school processes external reviews to begin
Covid review backs up teachers' concerns - union
Department for Education, Sport and Culture
Tynwald
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
07-07-2025
- Yahoo
Crowds to gather for annual Tynwald Day ceremony
Hundreds of people are expected to attend Tynwald's annual open-air sitting later. The ancient ceremony, which has its roots in the Isle of Man's Viking links, will take place at St John's. Presided over by the Lieutenant Governor, the proceedings see members of the Manx parliament, joined by representatives of the judiciary and the clergy, gather on Tynwald Hill. President of Tynwald Laurence Skelly has encouraged people to travel to the fair field to celebrate the island's national day. The Captains of the Parish, Coroners and representatives of the island's local authorities also take part in the ceremony, which dates back more than 1,000 years. The reading of the island's newest laws from the hill in both English and Manx - known as the Promulgation of the Acts - remains a crucial part of the proceedings. If an act is not promulgated within 18 months of being given Royal Assent, it falls from the statute book. Ahead of the ceremony, the island's secondary schools will be represented in a processional march to the fair field, led by Onchan Silver Band. The pageantry of the day begins with the arrival of the visiting military band, which this year is the Band of the Royal Air Force College, accompanied by a fanfare team from The Band of the Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment. The musicians are set to lead the Guard of Honour - this year from the King's Colour Squadron - and the standard bearers of all the Manx units and organisations to the ceremonial precinct. The formalities get under way with the arrival of Lieutenant Governor Sir John Lorimer, who will inspect the Guard of Honour following an RAF flypast. After a short wreath-laying ceremony at the island's National War Memorial, Sir John will then take his place in the Royal Chapel of St John's for a short church service. It will include a solo performance by Cleveland Medal winner Ruth Tickle. The procession to the hill will then begin, followed by the ceremony itself, which begins with the fencing of the court. As well as the proclamation of the laws to the people, the proceedings include the ancient right for citizens to hand over petitions for redress of grievance, which are collected by the Clerk of Tynwald at the foot of the hill. The official proceedings are rounded off with the Captioning of the Acts, which takes place in the Royal Chapel and sees the new laws signed by both the President of Tynwald and the Speaker of the House of Keys. As well as the ceremony, St John's is set to play host to a number of other events to celebrate the island's national day. They include music on Tynwald Green by the Isle of Man Wind Orchestra and Castletown Metropolitan Silver Band. The afternoon will also see performances by Scran, Claasagh and the Lon Dhoo Male Voice Choir in the Royal Chapel. The arboretum will play host to the One World Centre's celebration of cultures from around the world in its Global Village, and there is a chance to visit a replica Viking village encampment at Cooil Y Ree. The Manx Tent, situated adjacent to Tynwald Hill, will offer a variety of activities and information about the island's language, culture and heritage. The day's events will be rounded off by a performance by the Ellan Vannin Pipes and Drums from 22:00 BST. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X. Celebrations mark Isle of Man's national day Tynwald Day 2025
Yahoo
27-06-2025
- Yahoo
Is Mohawk Industries Stock Underperforming the Nasdaq?
Mohawk Industries, Inc. (MHK) is the world's largest flooring manufacturer, headquartered in Calhoun, Georgia. Valued at a market cap of $6.5 billion, the company operates through three main segments, Global Ceramic, Flooring North America, and Flooring Rest of the World, producing a wide range of products including ceramic and porcelain tiles, natural stone countertops, carpet, vinyl, laminate, wood flooring, insulation, and panels Companies valued between $2 billion and $10 billion are generally classified as 'mid-cap stocks," and Mohawk Industries fits this criterion perfectly. Its competitive edge lies in its scale, geographic reach, diversified brand portfolio, and vertically integrated operations, all backed by consistent cash flow and a disciplined capital structure. Tesla's Robotaxis Reportedly Sped and Veered Into the Wrong Lanes. Does This Crush the Bull Case for TSLA Stock? Dear Micron Stock Fans, Mark Your Calendars for June 25 Warren Buffett Warns 'Thumbsucking' is 'the Cardinal Sin' in Business Because It's 'Delaying the Correction of Mistakes' Stop Missing Market Moves: Get the FREE Barchart Brief – your midday dose of stock movers, trending sectors, and actionable trade ideas, delivered right to your inbox. Sign Up Now! But it's not all sunshine and rainbows for the stock. MHK touched its 52-week high of $164.29 on Oct. 21 and is currently trading 37.5% below the peak. It has declined 11.6% in the past three months, underperforming the broader Nasdaq Composite's ($NASX) 9.3% rise over the same time frame. Mohawk Industries has declined 13.9% in 2025, trailing the Nasdaq's 3.4% gain. Over the past 52 weeks, the stock is down 3.5%, significantly underperforming the Nasdaq's 12.7% increase during the same period. MHK has remained below its 200-day moving average since December and has also traded under its 50-day moving average since late January, both signaling a sustained downward trend. On May 28, Mohawk Industries' shares fell over 3% as homebuilding stocks and suppliers came under pressure from rising Treasury yields, which raised concerns about weakening housing demand. Its top rival, MasterBrand, Inc. (MBC), has lagged behind MHK, dropping 25.7% over the past 52 weeks and 25.4% on a YTD basis. The stock has a consensus rating of 'Moderate Buy' from the 15 analysts covering it, and its mean price target of $127.07 implies a premium of 23.8% from the prevailing price levels. On the date of publication, Kritika Sarmah did not have (either directly or indirectly) positions in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. This article was originally published on Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
11-06-2025
- Yahoo
School review cost 'not in public interest'
Publishing the costs of a contract with an education review provider could reduce the government's ability to get "best value for money" in future, the education minister has said. Daphne Caine has defended her department's decision not to release the amount paid to external validators Etio in response to a Tynwald question for written answer. She told the House of Keys that as her department was in the second of a three year contract with the firm it was "not in the public interest" to release the information. But MHK Lawrie Hooper said the costs were "routinely made available by the UK in relation to the exact company and the services they provide". Hooper said the rationale was "nonsense", and said based on figures released by the UK government indicated the Manx services would "probably cost between £150,000 and £250,000". Cain suggested she could share the figure confidentially with the Public Accounts Committee. During Tuesday's sitting, Kate Lord-Brennan called for the minister to provide a cost range for the report, arguing releasing the information was about "education delivery, standards, and public money, not about Etio". Chris Thomas MHK said it was "unusual" not to share the costs even when a contract was live, and noted that Treasury had published the terms of contracts in the past. Concerns were also raised by Julie Edge MHK, who said she did not understand why there was "so much resistance when it is such an important piece of work for our schools". Tim Glover MHK questioned how released the figure confidentially would restore and maintain public confidence. Caine said it was not in the public interest if it "breached" commercial confidentiality, and the competitiveness of future bids was "compromised". She said the department would "likely" go out for tender in the next six months, and sharing the cost could limit the "commercial competitiveness so that all bids come in within a ball park". That was "not serving the best interest of the Isle of Man community", she said. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X. School reviews 'foundation' for future improvement School review framework to be published in July Manx school processes external reviews to begin Covid review backs up teachers' concerns - union Department for Education, Sport and Culture Tynwald
