'Poor budgeting' has Government spending money faster than planned, says watchdog
In an assessment of the State's financial health, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) said spending has increased by 6% so far this year, well above the 1.4% implied by Budget 2025. IFAC said the rapid spending is because earlier overruns were not properly built into the forecasts, and Government estimates were 'simply not credible'.
The exchequer returns for May, published last week, show spending of €37.3bn to the end of May — €2.1bn (5.9%) above the same period last year.
'This pace far exceeds the growth rate that would be consistent with Budget 2025 forecasts, given the final level of spending in 2024,' IFAC said, adding that the overruns are in most areas of spending, not just health.
Presenting the returns last week, Jack Chambers, the public expenditure minister, said the increases were in line with the amount profiled by departments to be spent at this stage in the year.
IFAC said the Irish economy is in a strong position, but it warned of growing risks, saying that tariffs and trade tensions are a threat to investment and exports, and only 'phenomenal levels' of excess corporation tax are keeping Ireland in surplus.
'Without these revenues, there would be a substantial deficit, despite a strong economy,' IFAC said.
'Without these factors, there is a structural deficit of 2.4% of GNI — equivalent to €2,500 per worker.
"In the short term, corporation tax is likely to grow further. However, these receipts remain high risk.
A handful of large US firms pay most of the corporation tax
IFAC also raised concerns about Ireland's fiscal rules, saying the framework is not effective and that EU budgeting rules will not help as they rely on GDP and ignore the risks from volatile corporation-tax receipts.
'The reality is that both the new EU fiscal rules and their mirror in domestic legislation no longer provide any credible constraint for Ireland,' IFAC said, adding that the Government appears to have abandoned the national spending rule introduced by the last government, which set a 5% limit for net spending growth.
Extra stimulus
Regarding Budget 2026, IFAC said the Government should adapt its approach to the state of the economy.
'If the economy stays strong, there's no need for extra stimulus,' the council stated. 'In that case, budgetary policy should show some restraint. But if the economy takes a downturn, budgetary policy should provide support.'
IFAC said the Government should commit to a fiscal rule, use budgetary policy to reduce the ups and downs of the economic cycle, focus on infrastructure and competitiveness, and set realistic spending forecasts. Recent forecasts have ignored previous overruns and been unrealistic.
IFAC's chairman Séamus Coffey said: 'The Irish economy is in a strong position going into a period of uncertainty. The Government needs to ensure that budgetary policy reduces the ups and downs of the economy. Introducing a rule would help guide fiscal policy in the coming years.'
Read More
David McNamara: ECB ready to take a pause on rate cuts
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Major pack of cigarettes price alert for Budget 2026 as Govt officials advise €1 hike trend end amid black market fears
SMOKERS can breathe a sigh of relief as the Government's tax papers have poured cold water on the idea of hiking up the price of a pack of cigarettes in the upcoming Budget. The Department of Finance today published the annual Tax Strategy Group Papers which provide advice and costings for possible changes that the Government could make in the 2 A price of 20 cigarettes now costs more than €18 in Ireland Credit: PA:Press Association In recent years, Governments have repeatedly jacked up the price of a pack of cigs including a whopping €1 bump in price in last year's Budget. A price of 20 However, the Government's tax strategists have warned that prices are now so high that increasing them any further is likely to push more people into buying illegal cigs on the black market. They estimate that a 25 cent rise would return €18million and a €1 increase would bring home €73million – however, these numbers are no longer guaranteed. Read more in Money A survey from last year found that 37 per cent of all cigarettes consumed in Ireland were either illegally imported or brought in through duty free from another Some 45million cigarette packs consumed in Ireland last year were illegal – which represents a loss to the Exchequer of €590million. The excise duty on cigs brought in an incredible €976million for the Exchequer last year. However, this return on cigs has actually fallen from over €1billion that was taken in by the State in 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020 and 2021. Most read in Money The On the back of this, the Department of Finance report warns the Government that jacking up the price of a pack of cigarettes again in the upcoming budget may not actually raise any more cash for the exchequer. Risk factors for cancer you need to know The report said: 'In this environment, taking into consideration latest trends it is important to note that further increases in excise duties may not lead to increased revenue.' The tax papers quotes an industry body named Retailers Against Smuggling who have called for a freeze on tobacco excise prices in the upcoming budget. The tax papers notes the lobby group's call for better smuggling detection to tackle illicit trade may increase revenue for the tax man as it will reduce the number of illegal cigarettes in Ireland. 2 Some 45million cigarette packs consumed in Ireland last year were illegal Credit: Getty Images - Getty
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
EU sanctions envoy says Ireland must 'beef up' Naval Service
The European Union's Sanctions Envoy has said Ireland needs to make significant improvements to its Naval Service in order to better monitor its maritime zone and address the ongoing movement of sanctioned Russian vessels off the west coast. David O'Sullivan told RTÉ that Ireland "really needs to beef up our capacity and patrol and police our territorial waters," and described the Naval Service as in "poor shape." Mr O'Sullivan, a former EU Ambassador to the United States, is now responsible for trying to stop Russia's attempts to evade European sanctions which are designed to cut off funding for its war in Ukraine. Earlier RTÉ reported that vessels belonging to Russia's so called 'shadow fleet' regularly transited through the Irish maritime Exclusive Economic Zone – a large area extending into the Atlantic off the west coast which is the site of major undersea cables and shipping lanes. The shadow fleet vessels are used to help Russia export oil and circumvent oil price caps imposed as part of western sanctions. Asked about what Ireland could do to help tackle the activities of shadow fleet vessels off Ireland, Mr O'Sullivan said "unfortunately I think the Irish Naval Serice is not equipped to be able to deal with this at the present time". There are "many reasons" why the Irish naval service needs to be revamped, he said, adding the shadow fleet is a "new imperative to which Ireland will have to respond." Non-military vessels – including sanctioned vessels – can legally transit through an EEZ but are required to have the correct insurance in place when moving through certain areas, including busy shipping lanes like those off the west coast. However, analysts say the vessels in the Russian shadow fleet are typically poorly maintained and lack proper insurance. 'Shadow fleet' vessels have also conducted activities considered risky at sea, including turning off location transponders and conducting ship-to-ship oil transfers. The data reported earlier by RTÉ showed that some 245 shadow fleet vessels passed through Ireland's maritime Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) more than 450 times so far this year. The figures were provided by maritime intelligence company Windward which uses satellite imagery and AI technology to spot, analyse and monitor ships, including those which turn their transponders off. Windward's data included information on routes taken through the Irish EEZ by 72 vessels which have been directly named on sanctions lists. Experts have warned that the movement through Irish waters of shadow fleet vessels poses a serious environmental risk and undermines international efforts to isolate Russia's energy sector which is used to fund the country's war in Ukraine. David O'Sullivan accepted there "would, in any event, be limits to what the naval service could do," to a non-military vessel within an EEZ, before adding "but obviously this pleads, yet again, our vulnerability to this kind of activity, to the risks to undersea cables, and the fact that we really need to beef up our capacity and patrol and police our territorial waters." He said the European Union wants to stop the transit of these shadow fleet vessels but said it is a difficult task to completely stop their transit. "Member states are tightening their controls. The UK has done that through the English Channel" he said. "I think what is now happening in the Irish case, is that the Russian ships are going around the coast of Ireland into Ireland's economic zone, but not our territorial waters, and escaping the kind of checks say in the Baltic Sea.... or that the British are doing, of asking to see proof of the insurance." Asked about its monitoring of 'shadow fleet' activity within the Irish EEZ, the Defence Forces said: "While it is our policy not to comment on specific operational matters, all relevant information gathered in support of Maritime Domain Awareness is shared in a timely manner with the appropriate national and international authorities. "The Defence Forces, through the deployment of Naval Service and Air Corps assets, maintains a continuous presence and vigilance within Ireland's maritime domain. We monitor all activity within our Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) as part of our routine operations to ensure the security and integrity of our waters."
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Housing charity says it has prevented almost 1,000 households from becoming homeless since April
The housing charity Threshold says it has prevented almost 1,000 households from becoming homeless since April alone. And it says tenancy termination remains the biggest issue facing renters, accounting for just over a third of all the queries it has dealt with in the second quarter of this year. The details are contained in its impact report for the period April to June of this year, published on Thursday. It shows Threshold advisers have supported more than 8,500 households, including over 11,400 adults, and more than 7,000 children. Of the new households that contacted the charity since April, 1,595 were at risk of homelessness, and the charity helped the occupants of 951 households to stay in their home or find a new home, where possible. Tenancy termination accounted for 35% of all queries, with other queries including advice on leases, accessing social housing, and general rent queries. Single-occupant households accounted for 40% of households helped, with one-parent families accounting for 20% of the cases. Threshold's national advocacy manager Ann-Marie O'Reilly said while the charity was still concerned about the strains on renters, she was encouraged to see people contacting them for support and guidance around their rights as private-sector renters. 'Our Q2 impact report highlights the need for continued work and advocacy to support private renters across Ireland, even with the updated rent pressure zone [RPZ] legislation, which extends the RPZ rent controls across the nation,' she said. Since June 20, 2025, all counties have been classified as an RPZ, meaning all tenancies benefit from the cap on rent increases — rent cannot be raised by more than 2%, or the rate of inflation if lower, every 12 months. Any rent increase must be issued through an official rent review, with a formal notice provided to tenants at least 90 days in advance. In the areas newly designated as RPZs, landlords must wait 24 months from the date of the last rent review before issuing another. This must also be delivered as a formal physical document, as informal methods such as text messages or phone calls do not meet the legal requirements. Ms O'Reilly said the national extension of the RPZ was welcome, and provided crucial protection to an additional 41,000 households. 'We now want to ensure that all renters know that they are protected by the 2% rent increase cap and encourage renters to get in touch if they have any questions, worries, or concerns,' she said. 'We support the revised National Development Plan, given the importance of delivering housing and infrastructure to support housing development. 'We will continue to engage with the Government and other stakeholders in the coming months on further proposed changes to seek the best outcome for the rental sector as a whole.' Threshold's service is available by phone, Monday to Friday, 9am-9pm at 1800 454 454, or online at
