Miami Herald report on Alligator Alcatraz confirms what we suspected
According to the list, published by the Herald/Times in an urgently needed act of watchdog journalism, more than 250 of the detainees have immigration violations but no criminal convictions or charges in the U.S. Some are asylum seekers. Others arrived under humanitarian parole, or thought they were here with permission awaiting the result of ongoing legal cases.
In other words, the portrayals by President Donald Trump, Gov. Ron DeSantis, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and others that this detention center in the Everglades is a necessary tool for detaining 'vicious' people and 'deranged psychopaths' is a gross overstatement, underscoring the reasons that due process is so important.
No doubt there are some bad characters in the bunch. A third of the detainees on the list, which fluctuates as the population of the detention center changes, have various criminal convictions, the Herald/Times reported, with charges ranging from attempted murder and illegal re-entry to traffic violations. Hundreds of others only have pending charges.
But overall, the idea that more than a third of those being held had no pending U.S. charges or convictions should be chilling to Americans. Just how indiscriminate has the U.S. immigration system become?
Democratic and Republican members of Congress from Florida and state legislators were given a guided tour of the camp on Saturday, after several Democrats were initially turned away during an unannounced visit earlier in the week. Those on the tour came away with varying conclusions on the conditions, ranging from some Democrats characterizing it as an abomination while some Republicans said the air-conditioned facility meets all prison standards.
Conditions aside, the list published by the Herald offers some concrete information on who is being held at the detention center that cuts through the rhetoric surrounding Alligator Alcatraz, which is being run by Florida — the president's home state — and paid for by taxpayers.
As Walter Jara, the nephew of a 56-year-old Nicaraguan man taken to the facility following a traffic stop in Palm Beach County, told the Herald: 'That place is supposedly for the worst criminals in the U.S.' The list indicates that his uncle, Denis Alcides Solis Morales, has immigration violations but makes no mention of convictions or pending criminal charges. Jara said his uncle came to the U.S. legally in 2023 under a humanitarian parole program, and has a pending asylum case.
Are those people so dangerous that they should be housed in a place called Alligator Alcatraz?
DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin insisted to reporters that the absence of a criminal charge in the U.S. doesn't mean migrants have done nothing wrong. She said in a statement that some are 'actually terrorists, human rights abusers, gangsters and more' who 'just don't have a rap sheet in the U.S.' And, she added, 'every single one of these individuals committed a crime when they came into this country illegally.'
Trump was elected promising to deport illegal immigrants who committed crimes. Once in office, he revoked Temporary Protected Status ( TPS) and humanitarian parole from thousands of people from places like Venezuela, Nicaragua and Haiti, effectively creating a whole new class of people without legal status.
According to polls, Americans overwhelmingly support deporting immigrants with violent criminal records. But the Herald/Times findings reveal a broader dragnet at work — one that ensnares farm workers, people stopped for traffic violations and those who simply attend their immigration hearings. In our state, they are being rounded up with the same zeal used for violent offenders.
If we are holding undocumented people in an isolated camp who have no charges or convictions in the U.S., that's a moral and legal failure.
Click here to send the letter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Obama slams Big Law attorneys who won't fight Trump because they want to 'finish that kitchen rehab' at their Hamptons homes
Former President Barack Obama took aim at Big Law firms that have tried to work with President Donald Trump. He said some firms capitulated to protect their attorneys' careers and lavish lifestyles. Some firms have struck deals with Trump and promised to do pro bono legal work for conservative causes. Former President Barack Obama ripped Big Law firms for caving to the Trump administration just to protect their careers and fund their lavish lifestyles. Obama was speaking at a private fundraiser in New Jersey on Friday when he expressed disappointment at how some of the country's top law firms had "set aside the law" in the face of President Donald Trump's attacks. Obama said some lawyers were giving way to Trump not because they were "going to be thrown in jail, but because they might lose a few clients and might not be able to finish that kitchen rehab at their Hampton house." "I'm not impressed," Obama said, per remarks obtained by MSNBC. Obama's ties to Big Law go back to his Harvard Law School days. After his first year of law school, the former president worked as a summer associate at Sidley & Austin. Before entering politics, Obama worked as a civil rights attorney at the litigation firm Miner, Barnhill & Galland. Since February, Trump has issued executive orders targeting Big Law firms like Paul Weiss, Perkins Coie, and Covington & Burling. In his orders, Trump accused the firms of weaponizing the judicial system and stripped them of their security clearances. He also ordered reviews of each firm's contracts with the government. Some law firms, such as Paul Weiss and Kirkland & Ellis, struck deals with Trump and promised to do pro bono legal work for conservative causes. Others, like Perkins Coie and WilmerHale, chose to fight back and filed lawsuits against the Trump administration. In his remarks, Obama took aim at universities that chose to find room for compromise with Trump. Obama's alma mater, Columbia University, gave in to the administration's demands after it slashed $400 million in federal funding. The Trump administration said the cuts were because of the university's failure to combat anti-semitism when protests over Israel's war in Gaza erupted on campus. "If your core mission, if your core value is to teach, you may teach without compromising values of academic independence. Yeah, you may lose some grant money temporarily. That's why you have those big endowments," Obama said on Friday. Obama has continued to be a vocal critic of Trump and his administration. Last month, Obama told attendees at The Connecticut Forum on June 17 that the US was on the verge of becoming an autocracy under Trump. "We're not there yet completely, but I think that we are dangerously close to normalizing behavior like that," Obama said. Representatives for Obama did not respond to requests for comment from Business Insider. Read the original article on Business Insider
New York Post
21 minutes ago
- New York Post
Eric Adams again denies $3.4 million in matching funds as probe digs into alleged misconduct
Mayor Eric Adams was denied millions in public matching funds in the latest obstacle for his uphill re-election bid as an independent – after his team celebrated a legal decision they thought would help fill his campaign coffers. The Campaign Finance Board refused to provide $3.4 million during Tuesday's meeting, saying the campaign still had yet to provide documents and information to the oversight agency as it continues a probe into alleged misconduct during his first campaign four years ago. 'The board investigation is ongoing,' said board chair Frederick Schaffer, adding the cache of documents remaining 'outstanding.' Eric Adams speaks at an event on July 14, 2025. Gregory P. Mango 'Mayor Adams' campaign has failed to qualify for matching funds,' he continued. The denial by the board comes just days after a federal judge ruled that the indictment — which spells out a slew of illegal fundraising allegations but has been formally killed — could not be used as a reason to deny the funds. Adams' camp was denied the funds in December last year, with the five-member panel citing delinquent requests for documents from the campaign and a 'reason to believe' that wrongdoing had occurred during Adams' run for City Hall in 2021. Schaffer addressed the late Friday ruling from the judge, noting the order determined that the board could deny funding based on the lack of cooperation with the board in its investigation and Adams' failure to fill out a conflict of interest form. Eric Adams sued Campaign Finance Board for denying him millions in matching funds Campaign Finance Board Insiders in Hizzoner's campaign celebrated the ruling, telling The Post Friday they were up to date with their paperwork and expected the funds to be unlocked this week. The ruling could prove — at least eventually — to be a boost for the mayor, who is running as an independent in the general election, where he will try to topple the current frontrunner and Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani. Adams will face an uphill battle, though, with three others — ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo, GOP nominee Curtis Sliwa and prominent attorney Zohran Mamdani — looking to beat the upstart socialist. All four are expected to cut into each other's votes and have jockeyed to get one another to drop from the ballot — but none are believed to answer the call to coalesce behind a single candidate to stave off a Mamdani majority
Hamilton Spectator
22 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
The Latest: Mike Waltz faces questions over Signal chat at Senate hearing for new UN job
Mike Waltz, President Donald Trump's nominee for U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, is facing questions from lawmakers Tuesday for the first time since he was ousted as national security adviser in the weeks after he mistakenly added a journalist to a private Signal chat used to discuss sensitive military plans. The hearing before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee will provide lawmakers an opportunity to grill Waltz over revelations in March that he added The Atlantic editor-in-chief Jeffrey Goldberg to a private text chain on an unclassified messaging app that was used to discuss planning for strikes on Houthi militants in Yemen. Waltz has spent the last several weeks meeting with Democrats and Republicans on the Foreign Affairs committee. If confirmed, Waltz would head to the U.N. at a moment of great change, as the world body is reeling from Trump's decision to slash foreign assistance. Here's the latest: The stakes of Waltz's UN hearing If confirmed, Waltz would head to the U.N. at a moment of great change. The world body is reeling from Trump's decision to slash foreign assistance — affecting its humanitarian aid agencies — and it anticipates U.S. funding cuts to the U.N. annual budget. Under an 'America First' foreign policy realignment, the White House has asserted that 'some of the U.N.'s agencies and bodies have drifted' from their founding mission and 'act contrary to the interests of the United States while attacking our allies and propagating anti-Semitism.' Facing financial instability, the U.N. has spent months shedding jobs and consolidating projects while beginning to tackle long-delayed reforms. The U.N. is also facing growing frustration over what critics describe as a lack of efficiency and power in delivering on its mandate to end conflict and prevent wars. Sen. Mike Lee introduces Waltz and issues a warning to the U.N. The Republican from Utah , a friend of Waltz, called him 'one of the most well-qualified U.S. ambassador nominees to the United Nations ever,' before listing off his military service as a Green Beret in the Army and praising his work on national security issues during his time in Congress. Lee lambasted the efficacy of the U.N. and said the Trump administration 'has some legitimate concerns' about the international body, which Lee called 'a disaster and a detriment' to U.S. interests. 'Instead of progressive political virtue signaling, the Security Council has the chance to prove its value, and settling disputes and brokering deals,' Lee continued. Waltz enters Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing Trump's pick for U.N. ambassador entered the chamber alone and sat alongside the administration's ambassadorial nominees to Portugal and Sweden. Senators from both parties are also coming in. Members of Waltz's family sat behind him alongside kin of the other nominees. Trump responds to inflation report showing price pressures by calling for Fed rate cuts The monthly inflation report showed signs that tariffs are pushing up prices, but Trump is declaring victory over inflation anyway. 'Consumer Prices LOW,' Trump posted on Truth Social. 'Bring down the Fed Rate, NOW!!!' The consumer price index report for June showed a 2.7% annual inflation rate, meaningfully higher than the Fed's 2% inflation target based on a separate measure of prices. However, Trump has brushed aside concerns about tariffs and pressured Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell to instead cut the short-term interest rates, a move that could accelerate inflationary pressures. Trump further posted that the 'Fed should cut Rates by 3 Points. Very Low Inflation. One Trillion Dollars a year would be saved!!!' It was unclear whether Trump wanted a 3-percentage point cut to the rate, which is effectively 4.33% right now. The Fed usually cuts rates in .25-percentage point increments. Inflation rose last month to its highest level in 4 months Worsening inflation poses a political challenge for Trump, who promised during last year's presidential campaign to immediately lower costs. Higher inflation will also likely heighten the Federal Reserve's reluctance to cut its short-term interest rate, as Trump is loudly demanding. The Labor Department said Tuesday that consumer prices for things like gas, food and groceries rose 2.7% in June from a year earlier, up from an annual increase of 2.4% in May. On a monthly basis, prices climbed 0.3% from May to June, after rising just 0.1% the previous month. Trump's sweeping tariffs are also pushing up the cost of a range of goods, including furniture, clothing, and large appliances. Trump urged supporters to see conspiracies everywhere. With Epstein, that's coming back to haunt him As his supporters erupt over the Justice Department's failure to release much-hyped records in Jeffrey Epstein's sex trafficking investigation, President Trump's strategy has been to downplay the issue. His problem? That nothing-to-see-here approach doesn't work for those who have learned from him that they must not give up until the government's deepest, darkest secrets are exposed. On Saturday, Trump used his Truth Social platform to again attempt to call supporters off the Epstein trail amid reports of infighting between Attorney General Pam Bondi and FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino over the issue. He suggested the turmoil was undermining his administration, but that did little to mollify Trump's supporters, who urged him to release the files or risk losing his base. The political crisis is especially challenging for Trump because it's one of his own making. The president has spent years stoking dark theories and embracing QAnon-tinged propaganda that casts him as the only savior who can demolish the 'deep state.' Now that he's running the federal government, the community he helped build is coming back to haunt him . It's demanding answers he either isn't able to or does not want to provide. ▶ Read more about Trump's response to the Epstein conspiracy Trump sounds more positive about NATO Trump hailed as 'amazing' the news from the NATO summit last month that member countries will increase defense spending to 5% of their gross domestic product. 'Nobody thought that that was possible,' Trump told the BBC. He has complained for a long time that the U.S. shoulders too much of the NATO burden and has demanded that countries devote more of their budgets to defense. Reminded that he previously had called NATO 'obsolete,' Trump said, 'I think NATO is now becoming the opposite of that. I do think it was past.' Trump says he wants to have a 'good time' on his upcoming UK state visit Speaking about British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Trump noted in the BBC interview, 'I really like the prime minister, even though he's a liberal.' Trump and Starmer have met several times, including in the Oval Office, and the prime minister was quick to negotiate a trade framework with the United States to avoid the steep tariffs Trump is imposing on other countries. Trump is due to visit Britain in mid-September for an unprecedented second state visit . Asked about his goals for the trip, Trump said, 'I want to have a good time and respect King Charles, because he's a great gentleman.' Trump and his wife, first lady Melania Trump, are set to visit the U.K. between Sept. 17 and 19 and will be hosted by King Charles III and Queen Camilla at Windsor Castle. No U.S. president has been invited for a second state visit. Trump previously enjoyed state visit pomp and pageantry in 2019 during his first term when he was hosted by Charles' late mother, Queen Elizabeth II . Trump says he's 'disappointed' but not 'done' with Putin, dodges on whether he trusts Russia's leader Asked about Putin in a telephone interview with the BBC that aired on Tuesday, Trump said, 'I'm disappointed in him. But I'm not done with him, but I'm disappointed in him.' Trump said he thought he and Putin had reached a deal several times to end Russia's invasion of neighboring Ukraine, only to find out that Russia had just attacked Kyiv again. The president dodged when asked if he trusts Putin. 'I trust almost nobody, to be honest with you,' Trump said. The Kremlin says more US weapons for Ukraine will extend the war The Kremlin said Tuesday that new supplies of U.S. weapons to Ukraine announced by President Trump will extend the conflict. Asked about comments by Trump, who threatened Russia with steep tariffs if it fails to agree to a peace deal in 50 days and announced a rejuvenated pipeline for American weapons to reach Ukraine, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that 'such decisions made in Washington, in NATO members and in Brussels are perceived by the Ukrainian side as a signal for continuing the war, not a signal for peace.' He reaffirmed that Russia is open to continuing the talks with Ukraine in Istanbul, but is still waiting for Kyiv to offer a date for their new round. 'We are ready to continue the dialogue,' he said, adding that 'we haven't yet received signals about the third round and it's hard to say what's the reason.' Supreme Court allows Trump to lay off nearly 1,400 Education Department employees The Supreme Court is allowing President Donald Trump to put his plan to dismantle the Education Department back on track and go through with laying off nearly 1,400 employees. With the three liberal justices in dissent, the court on Monday paused an order from U.S. District Judge Myong Joun in Boston, who issued a preliminary injunction reversing the layoffs and calling into question the broader plan. The layoffs 'will likely cripple the department,' Joun wrote. A federal appeals court refused to put the order on hold while the administration appealed. The high court action enables the administration to resume work on winding down the department, one of Trump's biggest campaign promises. ▶ Read more about dismantling the Education Department Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
