Google ordered to pay ₹10 lakh to police officer. Here's why
Google will have to pay a compensation of $12,500 ( ₹ 10 lakh) to the man, a police officer by profession, for the violation of his dignity.
The incident occurred in 2017 in a small town of Argentina when a Google camera captured him in the buff, from behind in his own backyard.
The man had sought payment from the internet giant for harm to his dignity, arguing he was behind a two-meter (6.6-foot) wall when his naked image was captured along with his house number and street name.
The picture and the incident was later broadcasted on Argentine TV and shared widely on social media. He claimed that this public exposure led to ridicule at work and among his neighbors, causing harm to his dignity.
Initially, another court dismissed the man's claim last year, ruling he was to be blamed for "walking around in inappropriate conditions in the garden of his home." Google also argued that the perimeter wall was not sufficiently enough.
However, an appeals court overturned this decision, strongly asserting that the man's dignity had been 'flagrantly violated'.
"This involves an image of a person that was not captured in a public space but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of privacy... is blatant," the court wrote.
The judges said "there is no doubt that in this case there was an arbitrary intrusion into another's life."
The appeals judge found no justification for Google to evade responsibility for this serious error that involved an intrusion into the plaintiff's house, within his private domain, undermining his dignity.
"No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born."
Crucially, the court pointed to Google's existing policy of blurring the faces and license plates of people and vehicles in Street View as evidence that the company was aware of its duty to avoid harm to individuals.
In this particular case, the judges stated that "it was not his face that was visible but his entire naked body, an image that should also have been prevented."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
7 hours ago
- Mint
Google ordered to pay ₹10 lakh to police officer. Here's why
A man captured naked in his yard by a Google Street View camera has been awarded compensation by a court after his naked behind was published over the internet for all to see. Google will have to pay a compensation of $12,500 ( ₹ 10 lakh) to the man, a police officer by profession, for the violation of his dignity. The incident occurred in 2017 in a small town of Argentina when a Google camera captured him in the buff, from behind in his own backyard. The man had sought payment from the internet giant for harm to his dignity, arguing he was behind a two-meter (6.6-foot) wall when his naked image was captured along with his house number and street name. The picture and the incident was later broadcasted on Argentine TV and shared widely on social media. He claimed that this public exposure led to ridicule at work and among his neighbors, causing harm to his dignity. Initially, another court dismissed the man's claim last year, ruling he was to be blamed for "walking around in inappropriate conditions in the garden of his home." Google also argued that the perimeter wall was not sufficiently enough. However, an appeals court overturned this decision, strongly asserting that the man's dignity had been 'flagrantly violated'. "This involves an image of a person that was not captured in a public space but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of privacy... is blatant," the court wrote. The judges said "there is no doubt that in this case there was an arbitrary intrusion into another's life." The appeals judge found no justification for Google to evade responsibility for this serious error that involved an intrusion into the plaintiff's house, within his private domain, undermining his dignity. "No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born." Crucially, the court pointed to Google's existing policy of blurring the faces and license plates of people and vehicles in Street View as evidence that the company was aware of its duty to avoid harm to individuals. In this particular case, the judges stated that "it was not his face that was visible but his entire naked body, an image that should also have been prevented."
Mint
9 hours ago
- Mint
Google ordered to pay ₹10 lakh to police officer. Here's why
A man captured naked in his yard by a Google Street View camera has been awarded compensation by a court after his naked behind was published over the internet for all to see. Google will have to pay a compensation of $12,500 ( ₹ 10 lakh) to the man, a police officer by profession, for the violation of his dignity. The incident occurred in 2017 in a small town of Argentina when a Google camera captured him in the buff, from behind in his own backyard. The man had sought payment from the internet giant for harm to his dignity, arguing he was behind a two-meter (6.6-foot) wall when his naked image was captured along with his house number and street name. The picture and the incident was later broadcasted on Argentine TV and shared widely on social media. He claimed that this public exposure led to ridicule at work and among his neighbors, causing harm to his dignity. Initially, another court dismissed the man's claim last year, ruling he was to be blamed for "walking around in inappropriate conditions in the garden of his home." Google also argued that the perimeter wall was not sufficiently enough. However, an appeals court overturned this decision, strongly asserting that the man's dignity had been 'flagrantly violated'. "This involves an image of a person that was not captured in a public space but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of privacy... is blatant," the court wrote. The judges said "there is no doubt that in this case there was an arbitrary intrusion into another's life." The appeals judge found no justification for Google to evade responsibility for this serious error that involved an intrusion into the plaintiff's house, within his private domain, undermining his dignity. "No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born." Crucially, the court pointed to Google's existing policy of blurring the faces and license plates of people and vehicles in Street View as evidence that the company was aware of its duty to avoid harm to individuals. In this particular case, the judges stated that "it was not his face that was visible but his entire naked body, an image that should also have been prevented." The court absolved co-accused telecoms company Cablevision SA and news site El Censor, ruling that their actions in spreading the image actually "helped highlight the misstep committed by Google."
Hans India
a day ago
- Hans India
Misled by Google Maps, car falls into ditch near Mumbai
Mumbai: A woman drove her car into a ditch in Navi Mumbai on Friday as she was following directions through Google Maps. The incident took place while she was on her way from Belapur to Ulwe. The woman was supposed to take the Bay bridge in Belapur, but Google Maps navigated her through a route beneath the bridge - leading to Dhruvatara Jetty. Unaware, she continued to follow the directions. Minutes later, the woman drove into the water. The marine security officials witnessed the accident and quickly engaged in pulling the woman out of the ditch - who was seen floating in the water. She was rescued within a few minutes and was not injured. Her car was also pulled out of the ditch. This isn't the first time Google Maps has mislead people and caused accidents - some even tragic. Last year, three people died after the car, being navigated using Google Maps, climbed onto a damaged bridge and plunged into the river flowing 50 feet below in Faridpur when it was travelling from Bareilly to Dataganj in the Badaun district. Google, responding to the accident, had asserted that it was assisting the authorities in the investigation. "Our deepest sympathies go out to the families. We're working closely with the authorities and providing our support to investigate the issue," it said. In another incident, a tourist group from Hyderabad drove into a swollen stream while following Google Maps in Kerala. The road they were travelling on was covered by water overflowing from the stream due to the heavy rains and since the tourists were unfamiliar with the area, they drove right into the water body while navigating using Google maps. All four escaped unharmed.
