Why the courts stepped in when a 12-year-old wanted an abortion
Will Murray
, ABC
In rare cases, the courts must become involved in deciding whether a child can have an abortion. (ABC News: Pete Mullins)
Photo:
ABC News: Pete Mullins
Earlier this year, the Queensland Supreme Court gave permission for a hospital to perform a surgical abortion on a 12-year-old girl who was nine weeks pregnant.
The girl, known as "E", wanted an abortion, and her mother consented. However, the court was still required to assess whether a termination was in the child's best interests.
According to Australian law, children are empowered to make their own decisions about the healthcare they receive - regardless of parental consent - so long as they fully understand what is being done.
This is known as being "Gillick competent".
In the case of E, medical professionals were concerned about her understanding, so the decision was referred to the courts.
This term comes from a legal precedent set in 1985 by the UK's House of Lords, which found against Victoria Gillick.
Ms Gillick wanted assurances from doctors that her children under 16 would not be given contraceptives or abortion advice without her consent.
The House of Lords found that a child's rights supersede those of their parents, as long as they have "sufficient understanding and intelligence".
It's been the standard in Australia ever since. When a pregnant child approaches a GP or abortion provider, their comprehension must first be established.
MSI Australia estimates around 2 per cent of abortions they provide are for people younger than 18. (ABC News: Pete Mullins)
Photo:
ABC News: Pete Mullins
Not all states keep information about teenage terminations, but in Queensland, just over 800 were performed in hospitals in 2023.
Around 160 of those were on children aged between 12 and 16.
MSI Australia is a private not-for-profit provider of both medical and surgical terminations whose services are available to anyone over the age of 14.
They estimate around 2 per cent of their clients are under 18, and a tiny fraction under 16.
Alison Fonseca, MSI's Head of Psychosocial Health, is a qualified psychologist who works alongside medical practitioners to help young people through the process.
Ms Fonseca said it is a "a really big step" for young people to make the choice to seek expert care, and in most cases, they will bring a parent or trusted friend for support.
It is part of her job to make young people feel safe and assess how "they weigh up the risks and benefits of receiving" the treatment or not.
"Young people aren't always able to consider future consequences as they have a still developing brain," she said.
The initial assessment includes understanding the young person's ability to process and retain information; understand the responsibilities of pregnancy care and parenthood; and asks about their social context including housing, education, family, safety, and any alcohol and drug use.
In complex situations, testing must be done to establish whether a child seeking an abortion understands the procedure. (ABC News: Pete Mullins)
Photo:
ABC News: Pete Mullins
Based on that information, a doctor will then have a medical consultation with the young person to ask further questions to determine their competency.
Other times, complexities in a young person's life may necessitate a formal and comprehensive assessment with input sought from social workers, counsellors, educators or other trusted adults.
The young person is aware and contributes to this type of assessment.
However, a young person who is a "mature minor" has the right to both decide the healthcare they receive, and if they wish, to keep these decisions confidential.
"It's about bodily autonomy, and respecting that children and young people have rights," Ms Fonseca said.
"However, we must be satisfied their best interests are being met, and that they are safe and supported. Sometimes this means negotiating what information can be shared with a legal guardian."
If it is determined a child is not Gillick competent, the law states that it is possible for a parent or guardian to make decisions about their medical treatment.
When it comes to medical treatment for a minor, it must be ascertained whether the young person's parent or guardian is acting in their best interest.
When it comes to abortion care, the circumstances around the pregnancy must also be determined.
"There could be a whole set of other circumstances for that young person that are not immediately apparent, so we would be taking into account as many opinions as possible," Ms Fonseca said.
If there is no appropriate guardian who can make that decision on the young person's behalf, or parents don't agree on the best way forward, a court may decide on what's best for the young person.
In Australia, a surgical abortion is available up to between 22 and 24 weeks gestation, depending on the jurisdiction.
Medical abortions, which involves taking a combination of drugs known as MS-2 Step to induce a miscarriage, is only available up to nine weeks.
The medication MS-2 Step is used for abortions in the first nine weeks of a pregnancy. (ABC News: Lani Oataway)
Photo:
ABC News: Lani Oataway
MS-2 Step can be prescribed by a GP, and accounts for an increasing proportion of terminations.
However, Dr Danielle Mazza - a professor at Monash Health and chair of the Royal Australian College of GPs preventative medicine guidelines - said there's no legal requirement for clinics to prescribe it.
"If you've got hypertension, you can be pretty certain that most GPs are going to manage your hypertension, but if you need an abortion … you can't be certain that every GP is going to be able to provide that."
Dr Mazza said there's still a stigma around abortion, and while improving, prescribing MS-2 Step is not "part of the culture of general practice".
Under time pressure, a young person is required to not only find a willing provider but also spend hundreds of dollars on treatment.
"Teenagers lack agency, they don't have their own credit card," Dr Mazza said.
"So, access to abortion for teenagers … is limited by system issues, cost, transparency and stigma."
-
ABC
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
?Widow wants men to be braver about going to the doctor
After Mike Riddell died in 2022 of complications from prostate cancer treatment, his wife Rosemary published his manuscript, hoping his humour would inspire more men to get checked. It's a story people and their support going through cancer will be familiar with: constant check-ups and tests, difficult drugs and their side effects. But Mike tells the story in a typically blokey and funny way, making light of his life-threatening cancer. He was a writer with several published books. His widow, Rosemary Riddell, a former District Court Judge, said she wanted to publish the book in the hope other men would read it and feel more comfortable about going to get checked out. Wonky Ponk Down Under is available on Amazon . Photo: Supplied by Rosemary Riddell
RNZ News
17 hours ago
- RNZ News
Fears Vitamin B6 levels in energy drinks linked to rise in blood toxicity
By Tom Hartley of ABC Energy drinks like these can contain high levels of Vitamin B6. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Concerns are mounting in Australia over an ingredient in energy drinks that has been linked to a growing number of life-altering blood toxicity cases. Vitamin B6 is considered an essential vitamin and is widely available in a balanced diet, with a recommended daily intake of just 1.3mg - 1.7mg per day for adults. But debilitating health problems can occur when a manufactured form of B6 - also known as pyridoxine hydrochloride, pyridoxamine, or pyridoxal - is consumed in excess. A 250ml can of Red Bull contains 5 milligrams of Vitamin B6, a 500ml can of Mother 4.3 milligrams per serve and a 500ml can of BSC Energy 10mg. "There's no good reason why energy drinks need to have six times the recommended daily intake of B6 in them," Australia's George Institute food policy researcher, Associate Professor Alexandra Jones told ABC's 7.30 . Dr Alexandra Jones says there is no reason for such high levels of Vitamin B6 as there are in some energy drinks. Photo: ABC News / Craig Hansen "And while it's unlikely that you would exceed the upper limit by drinking energy drinks alone, there is a subset of the population that are likely to be simultaneously consuming energy drinks and other supplements which could also contain high levels of B6," she said. B6 is added to thousands of vitamin supplements and fortified food products - from magnesium and zinc to breakfast cereals and protein bars. Blood test data obtained by 7.30 from Australian pathology labs Sullivan Nicolaides has revealed more than 2700 'probable' cases of neuropathy or other health issues attributed to B6 blood toxicity have occurred since January this year. "Typical consumption patterns mean people are getting much higher doses, not just from the individual products but multiple products," Dr Terri-Lynne South, a dietitian and GP said. Dr Terri-Lynne South is an advocate for greater warnings about levels of Vitamin B6. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Dr South is one of several health practitioners advocating for tighter regulations - as more cases of B6 toxicity emerge. "For the energy drinks containing 10mg of B6 - if they were vitamin supplements - they'd have to show a warning on the label," Dr South told 7.30 . "There's only one reason to have a supplement for B6 - and that's if there is proven deficiency or risk of deficiency." The Australian and New Zealand Food Standards agency (FSANZ) set the limit for B6 in energy drinks at 10mg per day, around the time Red Bull entered the Australian market. "Formulated caffeinated beverages must carry an advisory statement that no more than a 'one-day quantity' should be consumed if they contain certain substances, including vitamin B6," a spokesperson told 7.30 . Last month the country's medicines regulator, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), made several recommendations. It called for vitamin supplements with more than 50mg of B6 to be taken off shelves and moved behind pharmacy counters. Supplements take up major space in pharmacies. Photo: ABC News / Jerry Rickard A TGA delegate last month wrote that FSANZ should consider the "appropriateness of the 10 mg limit for vitamin B6 in formulated caffeinated beverages, considering the risks from the use of multiple products containing Vitamin B6". The same delegate also described the benefits of synthetic B6 as 'negligible', said labelling is 'inconsistent' and 'confusing' and called on the multi-billion-dollar complementary medicines sector to initiate education campaigns. A spokesperson for FSANZ said: "If evidence emerges that consumers are regularly exceeding safe intake levels, FSANZ would consider raising a proposal to review the current permissions." FSANZ did not answer questions regarding how it monitors such evidence. Jones said the agency typically prioritises cases where the adverse effects are immediate, not cumulative. "They're very focused on the immediate health risks of a product, so whether it would make you sick overnight, for example," she said. B6 levels in food and drink could become an issue for the food standards body. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang "But the energy drinks market has changed quite a lot since the first products emerged, and our consumption of them is growing, so if new health risks are emerging, it would be reasonable for FSANZ to review that standard." Geoff Parker, the chief executive of the Australian Beverages Council issued a statement on behalf of Australia's energy drinks companies. He didn't answer 7.30' s questions and instead compared his sector's products against complementary medicines. "Laws regulating energy drinks in Australia are among the most stringent in the world," he told 7.30 . "Some popular multivitamin supplements contain about 25 mg of B6 - at least five times the average B6 in energy drinks sold in Australia. "The ... upper level of safe intake [is] 50 mg a day for adults. The average level of B6 in energy drinks sold in Australia is approximately 2.1mg for a 250ml serve." The regulations however don't prevent unprecedented or unlikely cases. Matthew was taking Berooca daily and his use resulted in peripheral neuropathy. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Matthew* began taking Berocca daily last August after a colleague recommended it for an afternoon energy boost. The 56-year-old has a prominent public profile and asked 7.30 not to use his real name. "I work in a high-pressure environment ... by mid-afternoon, the energy levels start to wane ... one of my colleagues was having a Berocca - he said 'it gives you a boost', so I tried it, and it turned into a habit." What started as a daily pick-me-up soon escalated - at times, he was having two Beroccas in one drink. Then came the symptoms. "I felt a tingle - some pins and needles - in my left hand, it moved up my arm, then to my right hand, then into my legs, there were terrible burning sensations." Concerned about stroke or heart problems, he underwent tests for blood cancer and multiple sclerosis. His doctor eventually suggested a neurologist. "I was at work and my whole body would be burning inside - pins and needles - but with this burning sensation in my limbs." "I was poisoning myself while [I was] trying to work out how I've poisoned myself." Still, he continued taking Berocca but concedes he was likely taking too much of the product. Supplements with high levels of B6 in them have caused cases of B6 toxicity. Photo: ABC News / Tom Hartley After months of suffering came the call from his GP. "He said 'you have to stop taking vitamin supplements'… I said, 'what are you talking about? I've never taken vitamins' And he said 'it's Vitamin B6'." Tests revealed Matthew had nearly three times the toxic level of B6 in his bloodstream. He stopped taking Berocca immediately. And while his symptoms improved within weeks, some burning sensations remain. "I haven't had any peripheral neuropathy for a month," he said. The mental toll though has been severe. "This has rocked my world, mentally … how could I be this f***ing stupid? … I never in the life of me thought it was dangerous … I just thought you'd urinate it out. "I am so careful about the food that I put in my mouth, the restrictions I have on drinking, the fact I exercise religiously. "I've never had serious mental issues - I'm a glass-half-full person - I don't think I've got a propensity towards depression or anything like that. "But I certainly was depressed about this - this has rocked my world, mentally." There are no warnings on Berocca packaging. Instead, it claims to improve physical energy "when consumed daily for 28 days". Berocca's parent company, pharmaceutical giant Bayer, said it is "committed to consumer safety and regulatory compliance". "All our over-the-counter products ... comply fully with TGA labelling requirements, including ingredient disclosure, dosage, and safety warnings. We will continue to abide by TGA rules and requirements." In 2020 Monique's blood became toxic after consuming protein shakes and multivitamins, she never realised the combined B6 levels were extreme. Monique has battled issues with B6 toxicity. Photo: ABC News "It took about a year to be diagnosed," the 35-year-old told 7.30 . "The worst state that I was in was being bed-bound for about six months, once the vestibular migraine started and I lost my balance completely." Monique believes during her recovery her symptoms were exacerbated when unwittingly consuming small amounts of B6 in a fortified drink. "I was doing really well, I was exercising again, and carefully checking everything I was eating, but after nine months of improvement I became complacent - I didn't think to check the back of the label," she said. Monique could not provide evidence concluding the fortified drink was a causal factor. Dr South believes much of the marketing around B6 is misleading. "Most of these products, promoting B-vitamins, are marketed as 'energy-giving', and that comes from the understanding that a lot of these vitamins are co-factors of generating energy in cells," she told 7.30 . "We're starting to see it in multivitamin minerals from the chemist, but we need better regulations in these higher food products, especially energy drinks. "This increases the impetus for regulators like Food Standards Australian New Zealand the Therapeutic Goods Administration to coordinate together, because it's about the cumulative risks of this amount of B6 being in our food supply. "People are inadvertently overdosing and now we're starting to see the consequences." - ABC
RNZ News
17 hours ago
- RNZ News
Fears Vitamin B6 levels in energy drinks could contribute to rise in toxicity cases
By Tom Hartley of ABC Energy drinks like these can contain high levels of Vitamin B6. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Concerns are mounting over an ingredient in energy drinks that has been linked to a growing number of life-altering blood toxicity cases. Vitamin B6 is considered an essential vitamin and is widely available in a balanced diet, with a recommended daily intake of just 1.3mg - 1.7mg per day for adults. But debilitating health problems can occur when a manufactured form of B6 - also known as pyridoxine hydrochloride, pyridoxamine, or pyridoxal - is consumed in excess. A 250ml can of Red Bull contains 5 milligrams of Vitamin B6, a 500ml can of Mother 4.3 milligrams per serve and a 500ml can of BSC Energy 10mg. "There's no good reason why energy drinks need to have six times the recommended daily intake of B6 in them," George Institute food policy researcher, Associate Professor Alexandra Jones told 7.30 . Dr Alexandra Jones says there is no reason for such high levels of Vitamin B6 as there are in some energy drinks. Photo: ABC News / Craig Hansen "And while it's unlikely that you would exceed the upper limit by drinking energy drinks alone, there is a subset of the population that are likely to be simultaneously consuming energy drinks and other supplements which could also contain high levels of B6," she said. B6 is added to thousands of vitamin supplements and fortified food products - from magnesium and zinc to breakfast cereals and protein bars. Blood test data obtained by 7.30 from Australian pathology labs Sullivan Nicolaides has revealed more than 2700 'probable' cases of neuropathy or other health issues attributed to B6 blood toxicity have occurred since January this year. "Typical consumption patterns mean people are getting much higher doses, not just from the individual products but multiple products," Dr Terri-Lynne South, a dietitian and GP said. Dr Terri-Lynne South is an advocate for greater warnings about levels of Vitamin B6. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Dr South is one of several health practitioners advocating for tighter regulations - as more cases of B6 toxicity emerge. "For the energy drinks containing 10mg of B6 - if they were vitamin supplements - they'd have to show a warning on the label," Dr South told 7.30 . "There's only one reason to have a supplement for B6 - and that's if there is proven deficiency or risk of deficiency." The Australian and New Zealand Food Standards agency (FSANZ) set the limit for B6 in energy drinks at 10mg per day, around the time Red Bull entered the Australian market. "Formulated caffeinated beverages must carry an advisory statement that no more than a 'one-day quantity' should be consumed if they contain certain substances, including vitamin B6," a spokesperson told 7.30 . Last month the country's medicines regulator, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), made several recommendations. It called for vitamin supplements with more than 50mg of B6 to be taken off shelves and moved behind pharmacy counters. Supplements take up major space in pharmacies. Photo: ABC News / Jerry Rickard A TGA delegate last month wrote that FSANZ should consider the "appropriateness of the 10 mg limit for vitamin B6 in formulated caffeinated beverages, considering the risks from the use of multiple products containing Vitamin B6". The same delegate also described the benefits of synthetic B6 as 'negligible', said labelling is 'inconsistent' and 'confusing' and called on the multi-billion-dollar complementary medicines sector to initiate education campaigns. A spokesperson for FSANZ said: "If evidence emerges that consumers are regularly exceeding safe intake levels, FSANZ would consider raising a proposal to review the current permissions." FSANZ did not answer questions regarding how it monitors such evidence. Jones said the agency typically prioritises cases where the adverse effects are immediate, not cumulative. "They're very focused on the immediate health risks of a product, so whether it would make you sick overnight, for example," she said. B6 levels in food and drink could become an issue for the food standards body. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang "But the energy drinks market has changed quite a lot since the first products emerged, and our consumption of them is growing, so if new health risks are emerging, it would be reasonable for FSANZ to review that standard." Geoff Parker, the chief executive of the Australian Beverages Council issued a statement on behalf of Australia's energy drinks companies. He didn't answer 7.30' s questions and instead compared his sector's products against complementary medicines. "Laws regulating energy drinks in Australia are among the most stringent in the world," he told 7.30 . "Some popular multivitamin supplements contain about 25 mg of B6 - at least five times the average B6 in energy drinks sold in Australia. "The ... upper level of safe intake [is] 50 mg a day for adults. The average level of B6 in energy drinks sold in Australia is approximately 2.1mg for a 250ml serve." The regulations however don't prevent unprecedented or unlikely cases. Matthew was taking Berooca daily and his use resulted in peripheral neuropathy. Photo: ABC News / Cameron Lang Matthew* began taking Berocca daily last August after a colleague recommended it for an afternoon energy boost. The 56-year-old has a prominent public profile and asked 7.30 not to use his real name. "I work in a high-pressure environment ... by mid-afternoon, the energy levels start to wane ... one of my colleagues was having a Berocca - he said 'it gives you a boost', so I tried it, and it turned into a habit." What started as a daily pick-me-up soon escalated - at times, he was having two Beroccas in one drink. Then came the symptoms. "I felt a tingle - some pins and needles - in my left hand, it moved up my arm, then to my right hand, then into my legs, there were terrible burning sensations." Concerned about stroke or heart problems, he underwent tests for blood cancer and multiple sclerosis. His doctor eventually suggested a neurologist. "I was at work and my whole body would be burning inside - pins and needles - but with this burning sensation in my limbs." "I was poisoning myself while [I was] trying to work out how I've poisoned myself." Still, he continued taking Berocca but concedes he was likely taking too much of the product. Supplements with high levels of B6 in them have caused cases of B6 toxicity. Photo: ABC News / Tom Hartley After months of suffering came the call from his GP. "He said 'you have to stop taking vitamin supplements'… I said, 'what are you talking about? I've never taken vitamins' And he said 'it's Vitamin B6'." Tests revealed Matthew had nearly three times the toxic level of B6 in his bloodstream. He stopped taking Berocca immediately. And while his symptoms improved within weeks, some burning sensations remain. "I haven't had any peripheral neuropathy for a month," he said. The mental toll though has been severe. "This has rocked my world, mentally … how could I be this f***ing stupid? … I never in the life of me thought it was dangerous … I just thought you'd urinate it out. "I am so careful about the food that I put in my mouth, the restrictions I have on drinking, the fact I exercise religiously. "I've never had serious mental issues - I'm a glass-half-full person - I don't think I've got a propensity towards depression or anything like that. "But I certainly was depressed about this - this has rocked my world, mentally." There are no warnings on Berocca packaging. Instead, it claims to improve physical energy "when consumed daily for 28 days". Berocca's parent company, pharmaceutical giant Bayer, said it is "committed to consumer safety and regulatory compliance". "All our over-the-counter products ... comply fully with TGA labelling requirements, including ingredient disclosure, dosage, and safety warnings. We will continue to abide by TGA rules and requirements." In 2020 Monique's blood became toxic after consuming protein shakes and multivitamins, she never realised the combined B6 levels were extreme. Monique has battled issues with B6 toxicity. Photo: ABC News "It took about a year to be diagnosed," the 35-year-old told 7.30 . "The worst state that I was in was being bed-bound for about six months, once the vestibular migraine started and I lost my balance completely." Monique believes during her recovery her symptoms were exacerbated when unwittingly consuming small amounts of B6 in a fortified drink. "I was doing really well, I was exercising again, and carefully checking everything I was eating, but after nine months of improvement I became complacent - I didn't think to check the back of the label," she said. Monique could not provide evidence concluding the fortified drink was a causal factor. Dr South believes much of the marketing around B6 is misleading. "Most of these products, promoting B-vitamins, are marketed as 'energy-giving', and that comes from the understanding that a lot of these vitamins are co-factors of generating energy in cells," she told 7.30 . "We're starting to see it in multivitamin minerals from the chemist, but we need better regulations in these higher food products, especially energy drinks. "This increases the impetus for regulators like Food Standards Australian New Zealand the Therapeutic Goods Administration to coordinate together, because it's about the cumulative risks of this amount of B6 being in our food supply. "People are inadvertently overdosing and now we're starting to see the consequences." - ABC
