Deceptive claims: CCP imposes Rs40m fine on Al-Ghazi Tractors
In a detailed final order passed by a two-member bench comprising Dr Kabir Ahmed Sidhu (Chairman) and Salman Amin (Member), the Commission found that Al-Ghazi Tractors Limited (AGTL) advertisement published on January 24, 2022, falsely claimed that its new Holland tractor models offered 'up to 30 percent extra diesel savings compared to any competitor's tractors.'
The misleading claim was widely circulated in media and referenced a report by the Agriculture Mechanization Research Institute (AMRI), Multan, giving it an air of official credibility. However, the Commission's investigation revealed that AMRI never endorsed the claim, nor did its report support the fuel-saving comparison being advertised. In rural Pakistan—where over 60% of the population relies on agriculture—tractors are long-term investments, and such exaggerated claims can have serious financial consequences for small farmers.
These communities are particularly vulnerable to misleading advertisements due to limited access to technical verification or alternative sources of information. A 30 percent fuel-saving claim could mean thousands of rupees of projected savings to a farmer—yet no such advantage existed.
After receiving complaints from stakeholders and conducting a thorough investigation, the CCP determined that the AMRI report only compared AGTL tractors to those of one other manufacturer (Millat Tractors) in limited settings.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan's growth reboot: the SIFC surge
In an era where optimism often flickers under the weight of uncertainty, Pakistan seems to have finally turned the dial in its favour. The country's new economic momentum structured around reform-driven governance, investor-centric policy frameworks, and an assertive geopolitical posture is beginning to spark a rare confluence of confidence and credibility. At the heart of this strategic recalibration lies the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC), a state-level institutional mechanism that is now proving to be far more than a bureaucratic symbol. The government's ambition to attract US$ 5 billion in foreign direct investment (FDI) is not just rhetorical it is now backed by tangible indicators, from soaring remittances and bullish capital markets to an unprecedented Rs 4.2 trillion development outlay for FY2025–26. Unlike previous economic plans that often stumbled at the altar of execution, this one appears both technically sound and politically backed, signalling a determined move from stagnation to structured growth. The post-budget environment in Pakistan tells a compelling story of market revival and strategic foresight. The KSE-100 index, long seen as a bellwether of investor sentiment, soared past the 125,000 mark a record high that is not merely symbolic but reflects deep-rooted optimism in the financial ecosystem. It is no coincidence that this surge was led by foreign investors, underlining Pakistan's emerging credibility in global markets. The budget has been well received across sectors, with economists and market strategists identifying key policy anchors that aim to shift the economy from short-term consumption patterns to sustainable, production-led growth. The IMF's endorsement of recent reforms further consolidates Pakistan's reformist narrative, while the active dismantling of red tape through SIFC's oversight is removing historical bottlenecks that once stifled both local and foreign investment. In this new configuration, SIFC has become the cornerstone of investment confidence not only fast-tracking approvals but also improving inter-agency coordination, a chronic structural weakness in the past. This forward-looking investment strategy is not confined to rhetoric or theoretical frameworks. It is underwritten by the Rs 4.2 trillion development envelope, of which Rs 1.4 trillion is allocated to the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP), while Rs 2.8 trillion will be channelled through non-PSDP instruments like public-private partnerships and foreign-funded initiatives. Balochistan, often pushed to the economic periphery despite its geostrategic significance, is now taking centre stage in this paradigm. Federal Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal's assertion that 'no region will be left behind' is not just political grandstanding but is backed by project-specific commitments in water management, solarisation of remote districts, higher education, and accelerated execution of the second phase of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) in Gwadar and Makran. This includes the creation of a new Climate Change Fund by the provincial government a significant move that aligns regional sustainability priorities with the federal development matrix. For the first time in decades, Balochistan is no longer merely a line item but a strategic axis in the national development strategy. The broader narrative is equally encouraging. Pakistan's manufacturing base once a victim of policy inertia and energy shortfalls is being recalibrated to support export-led growth, with the textile, food processing, and IT sectors receiving focused policy attention. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb's unveiling of a Rs 50 billion Industrial Revival Fund is a clear message that the government intends to walk the talk. Special tax incentives, capital repatriation ease, and a renewed focus on digital exports are now forming the architecture of a 21st-century industrial strategy. With IT exports projected to cross $3 billion this fiscal year, there is a credible roadmap in place. More importantly, these initiatives are being undertaken with a view to restructuring Pakistan's growth model from a reliance on consumption and external debt to value-added exports and foreign investment inflows. Analysts at Moody's, Fitch, and JP Morgan forecast a 30–40 percent increase in FDI over the next year a projection contingent, of course, on continued fiscal discipline and uninterrupted policy continuity, both of which now seem more plausible given the institutional backing of the current economic plan. While challenges such as inflationary pressures, external debt servicing, and uneven revenue generation persist, they are no longer defining the economic conversation. Instead, the narrative has decisively shifted towards opportunity, structure, and long-term resilience. Pakistan appears to be in the early stages of what could be described as a strategic economic reset transitioning from a reactive, stabilisation-focused approach to one that is proactive, structured, and regional in outlook. The recent promotion of Chief of Army Staff Syed Asim Munir co-chair of the SIFC to Field Marshal adds another layer of strategic continuity to the reform process. With military stability, political alignment, and institutional reforms now moving in tandem, Pakistan's path forward looks less precarious and more purpose-driven. The historic capital market rally, coupled with visible improvements in fiscal planning and provincial integration, suggests that Pakistan is not just scripting a new chapter it is attempting to rewrite the entire playbook of its economic future. If current trends sustain and policy discipline holds, the country may well be on the brink of its most transformative economic decade in recent memory. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Wafi Energy Pakistan
Wafi Energy Pakistan Limited (formerly Shell Pakistan Limited) has released its first annual report under new ownership, marking a transition point for the company following its acquisition by Abu Dhabi-based Wafi Energy Holding Limited. The transaction, completed in October 2024, involved the purchase of a 77.42 percent stake from Shell Petroleum Company, followed by an additional 10.36 percent acquired from public shareholders, bringing Wafi's total holding to 87.78 percent. Despite the change in ownership and rebranding, Wafi Energy Pakistan continues to operate under the Shell name through an exclusive licensing arrangement for fuels and lubricants. The company's retail and lubricant operations remain largely unchanged in branding, while management has emphasized continuity in operations. The report highlights efforts to balance the legacy of the Shell brand with a shift toward regional ownership. While rebranding transitions of this nature often involve operational or reputational challenges, Wafi has so far focused on stabilizing its presence and setting the groundwork for localized growth, investment, and expansion in Pakistan's downstream energy sector. Financial Recovery and Performance Wafi Energy Pakistan's financial results for 2024 indicate a relatively stable transition under new ownership, with the company reporting revenues of Rs 427.9 billion and a profit after tax of Rs 3.3 billion. Pre-tax earnings stood at Rs 7.15 billion, aided in part by one-off credits linked to cost waivers during the transfer process from Shell Group entities. These results follow a period of volatility. Shell Pakistan had recorded back-to-back losses of Rs 1.5 billion in 2019 and Rs 4.8 billion in 2020, largely due to global oil market disruptions, inventory revaluation losses, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Since then, the company has shown signs of recovery, posting a profit of Rs 4.5 billion in 2021, followed by a marginal loss of Rs 72 million in 2022, and a profit of Rs 5.85 billion in 2023. The 2024 figures suggest financial resilience, though the outlook remains contingent on how the company adapts to market conditions without the backing of its former parent. The annual report also notes a gross profit of Rs 23.5 billion and a rise in shareholder equity from Rs 19.7 billion in 2023 to Rs 23.1 billion. Earnings per share came in at Rs 15.41, signaling shareholder returns in a year marked by structural change. Governance and Strategic Direction Wafi Energy Pakistan's board, chaired by Ghassan Al Amoudi, reported adherence to corporate governance standards in its latest annual disclosure, stating that there were no material deviations from regulatory protocols during the reporting period. While such declarations are routine, they serve to signal stability during what has been a significant ownership and branding transition for the company. Al Amoudi, in a statement accompanying the annual report, acknowledged the challenges of operating in a changing energy landscape but identified opportunities for growth in Pakistan's downstream sector. He also noted that the company's focus in the near term would remain on consolidation and execution of its strategic roadmap, particularly in retail and distribution operations. The parent entity, Wafi Energy Holding, has existing regional operations, including a licensing agreement with Shell Brands International AG that allows it to manage Shell-branded fuel stations in Saudi Arabia—an experience that could shape its operational approach in Pakistan as it navigates market competition and regulatory shifts. Retail and Consumer Services Wafi Energy Pakistan continues to operate a nationwide network of over 600 Shell-branded fuel stations. In 2024, the company expanded its retail footprint with the addition of 15 new outlets and upgrades at nine existing locations. These developments appear aimed at enhancing service delivery and aligning with rising demand in the retail fuel and mobility sectors. The company also reported growth in its convenience retail segment, reflecting broader shifts in consumer behavior toward faster, digitally enabled services. In line with this trend, Wafi Energy rolled out several marketing initiatives and entered into partnerships with platforms such as Oladoc and Faysal Bank, enabling features like contactless payments and bundled offerings at retail sites. In the lubricants segment, the company maintained its market presence through established product lines such as Shell Helix and Shell Rimula. A notable development was a strategic partnership with MG Motors, under which Shell Helix was named the official lubricant for MG vehicles in Pakistan—a move likely to reinforce brand visibility within a growing automotive segment. In response to ongoing concerns over counterfeit lubricant products, Wafi Energy launched an awareness campaign targeting both retailers and consumers, with the aim of promoting product authenticity and protecting brand integrity in key markets. Sustainability and Renewable Energy Projects Wafi Energy Pakistan has incorporated renewable energy and sustainability as central pillars of its post-acquisition strategy. A key development in this area was the solarization of its Karachi head office, which now operates on a 250 kW solar system producing around 387,000 kWh annually. Beyond its headquarters, the company has extended solar energy solutions to over 250 fuel retail sites nationwide. These systems are estimated to generate approximately 36 MWh of electricity each year, supporting station operations and helping to reduce reliance on the national grid. Terminals in Kemari, Daulatpur, Machike, and Shikarpur are among those now partially powered by solar installations. These initiatives align with Pakistan's national target of achieving 30 percent renewable energy generation by 2030 and reflect the expanding role of the private sector in supporting that goal. In addition to energy projects, Wafi Energy has also pursued environmental restoration efforts. In early 2025, the company sponsored the planting of 30,000 mangrove trees at Karachi's Clifton Urban Forest. The mangroves, which continue to be maintained by the company, contribute to biodiversity and coastal protection, and are estimated to sequester between 9 to 15 metric tons of carbon dioxide annually—based on an absorption rate of 0.3 to 0.5 kilograms per tree per day. In another sustainability-focused initiative, Wafi Energy partnered with Concept Loop to build a retail fuel station in Karachi using more than 6,500 kilograms of recycled plastic. Located on Shahrah-e-Faisal, the site repurposed an estimated 1.3 million pieces of plastic waste that would otherwise have contributed to landfill volumes. The project integrates environmental considerations into retail infrastructure and reflects a broader push toward incorporating circular economy practices within the company's operations. Community and Social Impact Wafi Energy Pakistan continued to advance its corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives in 2024, focusing on access to clean energy, road safety education, and community engagement. Through its 'Access to Clean Energy' program, the company extended support to four off-grid villages—Basti Tooba, Adam, Katimar, and Bullah Baloch—by installing solar-powered infrastructure such as water pumps, flour mills, and milk chillers. The initiative aims not only to provide energy access but also to enable local economic activity and improve living standards in underserved communities. As part of its outreach near operational sites, the company worked with schools located around its terminals in Kemari and Chaklala. Educational sessions on road safety were organized in collaboration with The Citizens Foundation and the Railway Terminal School. These sessions, which reached over 120 students, used interactive tools such as art competitions, storytelling, quizzes, and the distribution of an illustrated children's book, Once Upon a Road, to promote awareness in younger audiences. On the health, safety, and environment (HSE) front, Wafi Energy reported zero workplace incidents during the year. This outcome was attributed to ongoing training, emergency preparedness drills, and coordination with response agencies including Rescue 1122 and the National Highways & Motorway Police. Broader safety awareness campaigns were also held, including one during Ramadan and another focused on visibility issues related to tractor-trolleys. The company's youth development efforts were reflected in the induction of 20 interns and 8 management trainees under its 'Powering Future Leaders' program. These placements are part of a broader strategy to cultivate a pipeline of talent aligned with future organizational needs. Looking Ahead As Pakistan's energy sector continues to undergo structural and policy shifts, Wafi Energy Pakistan occupies a unique position—retaining the familiarity of a globally recognized brand while operating under new regional ownership. The company's recent financial recovery, visible investments in sustainability, and increased community outreach suggest a more localized and measured approach to operating in a complex and often unpredictable market. That said, the broader challenge lies in sustaining this trajectory without the operational support and institutional backing previously provided by its former parent, Shell. The ability to adapt to market dynamics, regulatory developments, and competitive pressures will determine how successfully Wafi Energy can transition from a legacy brand operator to a self-directed player within Pakistan's evolving energy landscape. For now, the company appears to be building the foundations for a more resilient and diversified role in the country's energy future. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
ECP asks parties to submit wealth statements
ISLAMABAD: The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has asked the political parties to submit their annual wealth statements for the last fiscal year, a mandatory requirement under the law. The political parties, to this effect, are required to submit their consolidated statements of accounts for the last financial year; from 1 July 2024 to 30 June 2025, latest by this August 29, the ECP said. The poll body, in a statement, quoted Section 210 of the Elections Act 2017 which provides that a political party shall submit to the Commission, within 60 days from the close of a financial year, a consolidated statement of its accounts audited by a chartered accountant — on the prescribed form. The submission of their annual wealth statements by the political parties to the ECP is regarded as a ceremonial exercise amidst lack of well-defined laws for the electoral body's Political Wing to proceed against any tax-related discrepancies in the related wealth statements. The existing laws, however, bar the political parties from receiving funds from foreign entities. The Section 204 of the Elections Act 2017 provides that any contribution or donation made, directly or indirectly, by any foreign source including any foreign government, multinational or public or private company, firm, trade or professional association, or individual, shall be prohibited and that any contribution or donation which is prohibited under this law shall be confiscated in favour of the government. This law explains that the term 'foreign source' does not include overseas Pakistanis. In August 2022, the ECP finally announced the much-hyped and long-awaited yet controversial verdict in the Prohibited Funding Case (formerly known as Foreign Funding Case) — around eight years after the case landed in the electoral body in November 2014 — wherein the Commission did not find the PTI guilty of being a foreign-aided political party. Still, the electoral entity issued PTI a show cause notice for explaining its position over receiving prohibited funds. After the verdict was issued, the Commission came under massive criticism from the PTI and public circles over alleged discrepancies in the 70-page written order in the Prohibited Funding Case. Scores of overseas Pakistanis appeared on electronic and social media to lambaste the electoral body for wrongly naming them as foreign donors and accusing them of sending illegal donations to PTI in the written order. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
