Trespass bans and shoplifting fines: Tough new retail crime laws on the way
Stronger trespass powers on the way
Retailers have long argued that existing trespass laws are toothless, allowing repeat offenders to flout bans with little consequence. Now, the government says it's time to change that. Under a proposed overhaul of the Trespass Act, businesses will soon be able to ban offenders from not just one store but every branch of a chain – a move supermarket giants like Woolworths NZ have long championed, saying current laws are 'not fit for purpose.'
The maximum trespass period will increase from two years to three, and fines for refusing to leave or lying about one's identity will double. Justice minister Paul Goldsmith says the changes aim to curb the rising tide of violence and theft that many retailers argue threatens workers daily. Sunny Kaushal, chair of the Ministerial Advisory Group which drove the law change, said the current act was 'a joke' and the changes would bring New Zealand more in line with other countries like Australia and Canada, RNZ reports.
Shoplifting fines and new offences
The trespass reforms are only part of the government's latest tough-on-crime push. Earlier this week, Goldsmith announced new measures targeting shoplifting, including on-the-spot fines of up to $1000 and a new offence of aggravated theft for offenders who use threatening or violent behaviour. The changes aim to end what Goldsmith calls 'apparent impunity' for low-level theft, Katie Ham reports in The Post (paywalled). The new infringement scheme will allow police to issue instant fines on the spot, much like speeding tickets, while the maximum punishment for theft will rise to one year in prison for goods worth $2000 or less, or seven years for more serious cases. A new aggravating theft offence will also be created for high-value theft carried out in an 'offensive, threatening, insulting, or disorderly' manner.
Greens push back
Not everyone is applauding the crackdown. Green Party MP Tamatha Paul has called the shoplifting measures 'criminalising poor people', arguing that penalising those who steal out of desperation won't solve deeper issues of poverty and food insecurity. Paul, who has attracted attention for previous comments on crime – including claiming a woman was jailed for stealing $12 worth of items, which she later admitted to the Herald's Jamie Ensor she couldn't verify – says the government's approach ignores the underlying drivers of petty crime. As Stuff's Bridie Witton notes, 'her comments come as food banks report struggling to meet demand – even before the peak winter surge – and continue to call for increased and guaranteed government funding'.
Her criticism of the shoplifting law triggered a sharp response from National. Goldsmith accused Paul of 'giving shoplifting the green light,' and noted that Labour and the Greens had opposed other recent law-and-order changes like reinstating Three Strikes and banning gang patches. 'We can only assume this week will be more of the same.'
Part of a broader law-and-order push
The retail crime measures come as the government rolls out a flurry of law-and-order announcements. This week alone, ministers confirmed plans for new penalties targeting 'coward punches' and stronger sentences for those who assault first responders. At the same time, the Ministry of Justice quietly released analysis of February's controversial citizen's arrest law, another measure championed by Kaushal's advisory group. As RNZ's Russell Palmer reports, the analysis suggests allowing members of the public to arrest or detain thieves stealing from retail stores will do little for public safety. In fact, the analysis found, it could increase risks of force being used inappropriately, particularly against youth and Māori.
Undeterred, the government is hoping to send a message: shoplifters, trespassers and repeat offenders won't get a free pass anymore. Whether it makes a dent in offending, or simply criminalises the most vulnerable, is something both sides of the debate will be watching closely.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Election battle lines are slowly being drawn
It's one of a shrinking number of election issues on which National still currently outpolls Labour. So, it's no wonder they've pulled out all the stops after a few weeks of shaky results and a fair amount of time spent on defence. The problem for Labour with crime is simple: nobody trusts them. The facts are as follows: crime went nuts. Labour's policy? Cut the prison population. Sure, there's more to it than that, but this is clearly how voters feel. Which is what is making this such a hard week for Labour, not the Greens and TPM, who sing a different song on law and order, and for Chris Hipkins. How do you credibly stand up and argue against longer sentences for thugs who bash first responders? How do you oppose getting tough on coward punches? How do you oppose on-the-spot fines for people stealing booze from the supermarket? The answer for Labour so far has been to continue to oppose these things. They have come out against almost every single change. And that plays into the perception they're still weak on crime. That they haven't been to the gym to get stronger, tougher and meaner. They've been at the salon painting their nails, feeling sorry for all the misunderstood baddies who just need a big wraparound hug. Of course, this problem could be solved if we knew anything about what Labour is planning, policy-wise. But Chippy's strategy is going to be one of shock and awe – holding cards very close to the chest until the election. I asked Hipkins on my Herald NOW breakfast show this week about Labour's record on crime and he was adamant they were on the right track but Covid simply got in the way. The problem for Labour with crime is simple: nobody trusts them. Photo / Getty Images I wonder how this level of accountability will go down with voters? I asked Chloe Swarbrick this week whether it was okay to steal food if you're hungry. She refused to answer the question, instead saying that she would not give 'soundbites'. Meanwhile, her colleague Tamatha Paul, the MP singularly most likely to re-elect a coalition Government, was happy to dish out soundbites promoting food theft like it was some sort of God-given right. Put these pieces together and you can understand why National's picking this scab. It's fertile ground. Cost of living is proving a much harder dial to shift for the right. Not because the numbers haven't returned to more normal-looking levels – they have. Inflation is 2.5%. The Official Cash Rate is near neutral at 3.25%. But recent surveys show voters aren't feeling it yet. The onset delay is hurting National, with Labour overtaking the leaderboard on a king-hit issue. The battle lines are slowly being drawn and we can expect to hear a lot more from National on crime and a lot more from Labour on the cost of living.
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
PM Christopher Luxon to speak after slew of law and order announcements
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is set to speak in Auckland following his Government's barrage of law and order announcements. Luxon is expected to front media about 12.45pm following an engagement with St John. A livestream can be found at the top of the article. One of the first law and order announcements of the week was proposing longer prison sentences for people who assault first responders, such as paramedics, firefighters and prison officers. The changes would create a new offence for assaulting an on-duty first responder or prison officer. The maximum sentences for assaulting with intent to injure, or injuring with intent to injure, would be increased by two years. Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith described violence against first responders and prison officers as 'heinous'. 'Where others may flee, first responders and prison officers run towards danger to help those who need urgent assistance,' Goldsmith said. 'Assaulting them puts multiple lives at risk, so there must be greater consequences for these heinous acts of violence. Our hardworking police officers, firefighters, paramedics and prison officers deserve better.' The proposed changes include: Assaulting a first responder or prison officer to have a maximum sentence of three years' imprisonment. This expands an existing provision on assaulting police to cover all first responders and prison officers. Assaulting a first responder or prison officer with intent to injure will have a maximum sentence of five years' imprisonment. This is a two-year increase in penalty from the standard offence. Injuring a first responder or prison officer with intent to injure will have a maximum sentence of seven years' imprisonment and will be added to Three Strikes. This is also a two-year increase in penalty from the standard offence. Goldsmith, along with other ministers from NZ First and Act, announced several more measures aimed at increasing punishments for those committing offences, particularly retail crime. They included specific coward punch offences, strengthening trespass laws and introducing a new fines regime for shoplifters.
The Spinoff
2 days ago
- The Spinoff
Trespass bans and shoplifting fines: Tough new retail crime laws on the way
The government is introducing sweeping changes to tackle retail crime – but not everyone agrees it's the right approach, writes Catherine McGregor in today's extract from The Bulletin. Stronger trespass powers on the way Retailers have long argued that existing trespass laws are toothless, allowing repeat offenders to flout bans with little consequence. Now, the government says it's time to change that. Under a proposed overhaul of the Trespass Act, businesses will soon be able to ban offenders from not just one store but every branch of a chain – a move supermarket giants like Woolworths NZ have long championed, saying current laws are 'not fit for purpose.' The maximum trespass period will increase from two years to three, and fines for refusing to leave or lying about one's identity will double. Justice minister Paul Goldsmith says the changes aim to curb the rising tide of violence and theft that many retailers argue threatens workers daily. Sunny Kaushal, chair of the Ministerial Advisory Group which drove the law change, said the current act was 'a joke' and the changes would bring New Zealand more in line with other countries like Australia and Canada, RNZ reports. Shoplifting fines and new offences The trespass reforms are only part of the government's latest tough-on-crime push. Earlier this week, Goldsmith announced new measures targeting shoplifting, including on-the-spot fines of up to $1000 and a new offence of aggravated theft for offenders who use threatening or violent behaviour. The changes aim to end what Goldsmith calls 'apparent impunity' for low-level theft, Katie Ham reports in The Post (paywalled). The new infringement scheme will allow police to issue instant fines on the spot, much like speeding tickets, while the maximum punishment for theft will rise to one year in prison for goods worth $2000 or less, or seven years for more serious cases. A new aggravating theft offence will also be created for high-value theft carried out in an 'offensive, threatening, insulting, or disorderly' manner. Greens push back Not everyone is applauding the crackdown. Green Party MP Tamatha Paul has called the shoplifting measures 'criminalising poor people', arguing that penalising those who steal out of desperation won't solve deeper issues of poverty and food insecurity. Paul, who has attracted attention for previous comments on crime – including claiming a woman was jailed for stealing $12 worth of items, which she later admitted to the Herald's Jamie Ensor she couldn't verify – says the government's approach ignores the underlying drivers of petty crime. As Stuff's Bridie Witton notes, 'her comments come as food banks report struggling to meet demand – even before the peak winter surge – and continue to call for increased and guaranteed government funding'. Her criticism of the shoplifting law triggered a sharp response from National. Goldsmith accused Paul of 'giving shoplifting the green light,' and noted that Labour and the Greens had opposed other recent law-and-order changes like reinstating Three Strikes and banning gang patches. 'We can only assume this week will be more of the same.' Part of a broader law-and-order push The retail crime measures come as the government rolls out a flurry of law-and-order announcements. This week alone, ministers confirmed plans for new penalties targeting 'coward punches' and stronger sentences for those who assault first responders. At the same time, the Ministry of Justice quietly released analysis of February's controversial citizen's arrest law, another measure championed by Kaushal's advisory group. As RNZ's Russell Palmer reports, the analysis suggests allowing members of the public to arrest or detain thieves stealing from retail stores will do little for public safety. In fact, the analysis found, it could increase risks of force being used inappropriately, particularly against youth and Māori. Undeterred, the government is hoping to send a message: shoplifters, trespassers and repeat offenders won't get a free pass anymore. Whether it makes a dent in offending, or simply criminalises the most vulnerable, is something both sides of the debate will be watching closely.
