Pfizer, BioNTech lose UK appeal in Moderna patent case
Last year, the High Court ruled that one of Moderna's patents relating to the messenger RNA (mRNA) technology which underpinned its Covid-19 vaccine was valid and that Pfizer and BioNTech's Comirnaty vaccine had infringed it, meaning Moderna is entitled to damages in relation to sales after March 2022.
The High Court also ruled that the other Moderna patent under challenge in the case was invalid. Moderna was refused permission to appeal against that decision.
But Pfizer and BioNTech were granted permission to appeal in an attempt to try and invalidate Moderna's second patent and appealed earlier this month, arguing Moderna's developments of mRNA technology were obvious developments of previous work, rendering the patent invalid.
Judge Richard Arnold, however, rejected Pfizer and BioNTech's appeal.
Pfizer and BioNTech said in a joint statement that the decision 'does not change our unwavering stance that this patent is invalid' and the companies will seek to appeal.
'This decision has no immediate impact on Pfizer and BioNTech or Comirnaty,' the companies added.
Moderna did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Friday's decision in the latest ruling in the legal dispute between the two sides over their competing vaccines, which helped save millions of lives during the pandemic.
The companies have also been involved in proceedings in Germany – where a court ruled in Moderna's favour in March – the United States Patent Office, which held that two Moderna Covid-19 vaccine patents were invalid, and elsewhere. - Reuters
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Chinese EV maker marks 10 years in Europe
MUNICH, Germany, Aug. 4 (Xinhua) -- Chinese electric vehicle (EV) manufacturer NIO commemorated its 10th anniversary in Europe on Monday, underscoring a decade of technological advancement, infrastructure development, and strategic regional partnerships as it strengthens its presence in the European mobility sector. The company, which established its European headquarters and global design center in the Munich region, now operates 60 battery swap stations across Europe. It also runs 20 "NIO Houses" in Europe, brand experience spaces that combine showrooms, lounges and customer services. Globally, it manages nearly 3,500 fully automated battery swap sites. Bavarian Deputy Minister President Hubert Aiwanger praised the company's innovation and long-term investment in the region. "We welcome companies that bring high-quality products and create local value," Aiwanger said. "The best results come from fair competition." He added that Germany should focus on strengthening its industrial competitiveness through reform, innovation and collaboration. Kurt Kapp, head of the Munich Economic Development Department, described Nio as a "flagship pioneer" among Chinese companies operating in the area. "From the start, it has exemplified how Chinese and European corporate cultures can integrate successfully," he said. NIO's European journey began in 2015 with the launch of its Global Design Center in Munich. Its full-scale market rollout, including vehicle sales, user support, and battery swap infrastructure, was initiated in 2021, starting in Norway and later expanding to Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, and Sweden. Zhang Hui, vice president of NIO Europe, reaffirmed the company's commitment to the region, saying that NIO's German base remains a central hub for its global innovation efforts.
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
German minister: EU must become stronger in Trump tariff talks
Containers are stacked, after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened on Saturday to impose a 30% tariff on imports from Mexico and the European Union starting on August 1, in the harbour of Duisburg, Germany, July 14, 2025. REUTERS/Thilo Schmuelgen WASHINGTON (Reuters) -German Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil said the European Union had been too weak during trade negotiations with the United States and it should become stronger, as much still needed to be clarified on the deal the two sides struck last month. "Overall, as Europeans, we must become stronger," Klingbeil said in Washington ahead of a meeting with U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. "Then we can also stand up to the U.S. with more self-confidence. Not against the U.S., but in dialogue with the U.S." Klingbeil said there needed to be a quick solution to the trade conflict with the U.S. as companies needed planning certainty. "Even though I am not the one negotiating today — that is the task of the European Commission — a close line of communication between me and Scott Bessent can help clarify things," he said, emphasizing the importance of the Transatlantic relationship. Apart from tariffs, Klingbeil and Bessent will discuss how to deal with cheap Chinese goods that are flooding the markets in both the U.S. and Europe, as well as the G20 presidency that the U.S. will take at the end of the year. "I believe it is important that we, from the German side, keep sending a clear signal: We want to work closely with the American government, we seek dialogue, we do not shy away from difficult topics and are looking at how we can solve problems together," Klingbeil said. The EU's trade deal with Trump in July was greeted with a mix of relief and anger, with tariffs set at 15% for most products but negotiations continuing for certain sectors, including steel and aluminium, which carry tariffs of 50%. Klingbeil would advocate for a quota system on steel exports to be included in the trade deal, he told reporters. (Reporting by Maria Martinez; Writing by Matthias Williams; Editing by Alex Richardson)
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Bosch's India unit posts higher quarterly profit on strong auto parts sales
FILE PHOTO: Bosch logo is seen on packets in this illustration taken June 19, 2025. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo (Reuters) -Bosch reported a higher first-quarter profit on Monday, helped by strong sales of spare auto parts to passenger and off-highway vehicles as well as demand for its consumer electronic goods. The Indian unit of German automotive supplier Robert Bosch reported a pre-tax adjusted profit of 8.38 billion rupees ($95.7 million) in the April-June period, up from 6.11 billion rupees a year ago. The profit figure does not include a one-time gain of 5.56 billion rupees tied to the sale of its video solutions business. Quarterly revenue climbed 11%, led by the automotive business' 13.5% rise. For further earnings highlights, click here. KEY CONTEXT Bosch, India's top auto parts maker by market valuation, is the first among its peers to report results in a quarter where overall auto sales by manufacturers to dealers dropped 5%. Analysts at Motilal Oswal said the company likely benefited from higher after-market sales of auto parts. The automotive business, Bosch's biggest segment, contributes more than 80% of overall revenue. India is a key hub for Bosch, with a focus on cost-effective making of parts ranging from fuel injectors to spark plugs. The unit gets 90% of its revenue from local sales. PEER COMPARISON Estimates (next 12 Analysts' sentiment months) RIC PE EV/EBI Revenue Profit Mean # of Stock to Div TDA growth (%) growth rating* analyst price yield (%) s target** (%) Bosch Ltd 49.13 40.89 10.46 13.11 Hold 4 1.34 1.27 Samvardhana 21.02 8.86 7.89 20.35 Buy 21 0.84 0.58 Motherson International Ltd UNO Minda Ltd 46.41 25.17 18.21 26.70 Buy 16 0.92 0.22 Sona BLW Precision 35.71 19.75 23.01 17.43 Buy 16 0.81 0.71 Forgings Ltd * The mean of analysts' ratings standardised to a scale of Strong Buy, Buy, Hold, Sell, and Strong Sell ** The ratio of the stock's last close to analysts' mean price target; a ratio above 1 means the stock is trading above the PT APRIL-JUNE STOCK PERFORMANCE -- All data from LSEG -- $1 = 87.5790 Indian rupees (Reporting by Nandan Mandayam in Bengaluru; Editing by Harikrishnan Nair and Sahal Muhammed)
