logo
Military asked to consider dismissing members after 1st offence of unwanted sexual touching

Military asked to consider dismissing members after 1st offence of unwanted sexual touching

CBC3 days ago
Social Sharing
Defence Minister David McGuinty wants the military to review a trend in civilian court toward judges supporting workplaces firing Canadians for any unwanted sexual touching on the job — even if it happened once.
The Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) is launching new advisory panels this fall to discipline military members for sexually inappropriate behaviour.
The minister is supportive, his office said, of an external monitor's recent recommendation that if the military wants to modernize its conduct process, it could look at a clear pattern in civilian court over the past decade.
"Now, more than ever, any type of non-consensual touching of a sexual nature within the context of one's employment is likely to lead to dismissal, even for a single event and even if there are mitigating factors," external monitor Jocelyne Therrien wrote in her June report.
Victims and experts have long raised concerns that the military has moved members involved in cases like groping to other units, given them warnings or other remedial measures. Therrien wrote that gone are the days where that's a "viable solution" and it could expose the victim or other staff to risk.
The government hired Therrien to track the military's progress implementing changes to try and reform its handling of sexual misconduct.
Retired Supreme Court justice Louise Arbour's landmark 2022 report made sweeping recommendations after a series of senior military leaders were removed from prominent roles amid allegations, causing a damaging and high-profile crisis.
Therrien estimates the military is on track to meet "the intent" of Arbour's recommendations by the end of the year. But she flags one of the biggest challenges for military is that files related to misconduct are scattered across different databases which makes it difficult to get a clearer picture of the current state of the issue.
WATCH | Can the military change how it handles sexual misconduct?:
Is the military capable of changing how it handles sexual misconduct?
3 years ago
Therrien's latest report said case law has "rapidly" and "significantly" evolved over the past 10 years.
"In reviewing these judgments, I note a clear trend towards supporting dismissal for any sexual touching in the workplace," she wrote.
More civilian judges are using the logic that sexual harassment involving unwanted touching is "unequivocally" considered sexual assault which is a criminal offence in Canada, she wrote.
Changes to the Canadian Labour Code in 2021 also require federally regulated workplaces to ensure they are harassment-free. Not dismissing people in some cases can lead to liability claims, wrote Therrien.
"The fact that similar cases in the past were dealt with through administrative measures other than dismissal no longer carries any weight," Therrien said.
The minister's office says McGuinty supports Therrien's recommendation that "the significant evolution in workplace harassment case law should be considered as the CAF continues modernization."
McGuinty's office told CBC News the minister will be looking for the upcoming panels "to yield real results." They will include law and sexual misconduct experts, the office said.
Therrien's report also said the military is considering launching a "scale of severity" to help determine if members should be kicked out or otherwise reprimanded.
People moved around
Megan MacKenzie, a professor at Simon Fraser University who specializes in military culture, says the CAF should adopt a one-strike-you're-out policy for unwanted sexual touching.
"This is a really significant recommendation," said MacKenzie.
"There is just no ambiguity for anyone in any workplace at this point in time that inappropriate touching, touching of a sexual nature, is not OK."
In the past, these kinds of cases were often called "low-level harassing behaviours" and the military dealt with it internally including by shuffling people around as a temporary solution, she said.
"That doesn't solve the problem," she said. "It moves the problem to a different unit and the alleged victim and the accuser may still have interactions with each other."
The CAF has been grappling with sexual misconduct for decades while saying it has a "zero-tolerance policy," she said.
MacKenzie said kicking out people for unwanted touching would demonstrate that policy.
Supporting victims
Retired master corporal Sherry Bordage, who reported being groped by her superior, said it's time for the military to act.
"Why allow predators to continue to hide within the ranks? What possible good could that serve?" she said.
Bordage reported her platoon commander touched her breast and made inappropriate comments at a mess dinner in 2010 at CFB Borden.
In military court, a Canadian Armed Forces judge stayed proceedings for the criminal sexual assault charge against Master Warrant Officer D.J. Prosser, according to the court martial documents.
Prosser pleaded guilty to a lesser military service offence for ill treatment of a subordinate, the records show.
Military judge Lt.-Col. Louis-Vincent d'Auteuil noted he took into consideration several mitigating factors, including that it was "an isolated incident" and "unusual" for Prosser who had spent 30 years serving in the military at that time, his reason for sentencing said.
The military judge gave Prosser a reprimand and a $1,500 fine — and allowed him to continue serving.
Bordage said she left the forces in 2014 because she didn't feel safe and faced reprisals from her chain of command for reporting the incident.
She says the military should kick out members for unwanted sexual touching to keep others safe.
"This decision, had it been implemented during my time, would have been night and day," said Bordage.
The CAF has not yet responded to a CBC News request for comment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

2 men stabbed, 1 arrested after fight in Montreal's Sud-Ouest borough
2 men stabbed, 1 arrested after fight in Montreal's Sud-Ouest borough

CBC

time13 minutes ago

  • CBC

2 men stabbed, 1 arrested after fight in Montreal's Sud-Ouest borough

Montreal police say a 23-year-old man stabbed two people in the Sud-Ouest borough on Monday morning. A police spokesperson said multiple people called 911 around 11 a.m. to report a fight at the corner of Atwater Avenue and Delisle Street, near Lionel-Groulx Metro station. At the scene, officers found two men, aged 35 and 48, suffering from significant upper-body injuries. They also located and arrested a 23-year-old. Police say witnesses told them the three men were involved in a fight that escalated, leading the 23-year-old to stab the two other men with a sharp object. The two victims were transported to the hospital. Their health status is currently unknown.

Surrey police searching for 2 missing Indigenous girls
Surrey police searching for 2 missing Indigenous girls

CBC

time13 minutes ago

  • CBC

Surrey police searching for 2 missing Indigenous girls

Surrey police are asking for the public's help in finding two missing 12-year-old Indigenous girls. The Surrey Police Service (SPS) says Aliyah Babisky and Anastasia Louis were last seen at around 11:30 p.m. PT on Sunday in the 14500 block of 106 Avenue in Surrey, and have not been seen or heard from since. Police say both of the girls live in Surrey, one of them at a home in the area where they were last seen. Babisky is described as an Indigenous girl with black hair just past her shoulders and brown eyes. She's about five feet five inches tall and weighs approximately 120 pounds. Louis is described as an Indigenous girl with long black hair and brown eyes. Police say she's about five feet nine inches tall and weighs approximately 110 pounds. Police say they don't know what the girls were wearing or where they may have gone — and that their families are concerned for their safety.

Windsor mental health and addictions counsellor charged with sexual assault
Windsor mental health and addictions counsellor charged with sexual assault

CBC

time13 minutes ago

  • CBC

Windsor mental health and addictions counsellor charged with sexual assault

The Windsor Police Service says it has charged a local mental health and addictions counsellor in connection with the sexual assaults of two patients. The alleged incidents occurred while 66-year-old Tim Baxter was providing counselling services to individuals seeking support for addiction and anger management issues in the Windsor-Essex area, according to a news release issued Monday by the Windsor Police Service. The offences are reported to have taken place between 2024 and 2025, police said. Baxter has been charged with four counts of sexual assault. Investigators say they believe there may be "additional victims who have not yet come forward." They are urging anyone who believes they may have been sexually assaulted or victimized to contact the major crimes unit at 519-255-6700, ext. 4830. They say all reports will be treated with the highest level of sensitivity and confidentiality. Sexual assault is defined as any non-consensual touching of a sexual nature that violates the sexual integrity of an individual, Windsor police note. This can include a broad range of behaviours, from unwanted sexual contact to assault involving penetration. Police are encouraging anyone in need of support to call Victim Services Windsor Essex County at 519-723-2711 or the Windsor police Victim Assistance Unit at 519-255-6700, ext. 4879.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store