
Water body or low-lying land? A dispute that lies at the heart of Delhi's depleting wetlands
A long-running tug of war between two government agencies in Delhi over Tikri Khurd lake, which spans over 40 acres in Narela,is symptomatic of why wetlands and water bodies are depleting in the national capital.
It's been eight years since the Centre formulated wetland rules –which made it mandatory for all States and Union Territories to form State wetland authorities and identify and notify all wetlands – but not a single wetland has been notified in the Capital.
Over six years have elapsed since the National Green Tribunal (NGT) directed authorities to conserve Tikri Khurd lake. No action has been taken, and the Delhi Development Authority (DDA), which owns the lake, continues to deny that it is a water body.
'We are of the view that the Wetland Authority of Delhi (WAD) must look into the matter. Even if it is found thatthe area in question is not technically a wetland, the lake is required to be preserved as a water body,' the NGT had said in an order dated March 29, 2019.
A similar stand taken by the DDA in 2019 was flayed by the NGT as showing lack of commitment for conserving the water body and 'focusing on technicalities and shifting responsibility'.
Expertshave highlighted that the role of wetlands is vitalin the city's hydrological cycle, which provides a wide range of ecosystem services likewater storage, purification, groundwater recharge and helps prevent waterlogging and floods.
Dwindling numbers
The situation of the Tikri Khurd lake is not unique.
Diwan Singh, a Delhi-based environment activist, criticised the authorities for not trying to revive water bodies. 'The government is not doing anything to revive water bodies. Even water bodies mentioned in government records are being legally or illegally filled up in many cases,' Mr.Singh said.
The WAD is supposed to notify water bodies that fit the definition of 'wetlands'. It should also provide legal protection from encroachments and facilitate efforts to rejuvenate them. But Delhi has lost several wetlands to unplanned growth and encroachments, say experts.
Meanwhile, the government agencies in charge ofwater bodies in Delhi have reportedly requested WAD for the 'deletion'of 232 out of 1,045 water bodies — over 22% — from the official records, due to encroachment and other reasons.
Agencies at odds
The DDA describes Tikri Khurd lake as a 'low-lying land' where sewer water has accumulated.
'It is hereby requested to kindly not issue the notification declaring the Tikri Khurd lake under the Wetlands (Conservation & Management) Rules, 2017 since the said area is the acquired land of DDA,' the DDA told WAD in a communication dated November 29, 2024, accessed byThe Hindu.
WAD officials say obstacles like the one they are facing with Tikri Khurd lake are causing the delay in notifying water bodies as wetlands in the Capital.
However, a WAD official asserted that the lake is a water body and they have donea ground-truthing exercise, whichinvolves verifying data by comparing it to real-time observations or measurements.
'A technical committee of the Wetland Authority of Delhi had in 2021 recommended to notify the lake as a wetland after its assessment. It has remained in our records as a water body and the DDA cannot say that it is not a water body. We will push for notifying it as a wetland,' the official said.
There was no response when The Hindu reached out to a DDA spokesperson and vice-chairperson's office.
Meanwhile, when The Hindu visited the area, a large shallow waterlogged area was found.
Residents recalled the destruction of smaller ponds as the village grew, while the current lake gradually filled the remaining low-lying land.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
41 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Ludhiana district sees two-fold surge in resource saving farm practice
The district has experienced a significant increase in the area dedicated to Direct Seeded Rice (DSR) cultivation this Kharif season, more than doubling last year's figures. With the transplantation process still halfway complete, the DSR cultivated area has already reached 4,000 acres, a considerable jump from the 1,800 acres recorded last Kharif season. The Direct Seeded Rice method utilises specialised machines that plant seeds directly with drills. (HT Photo) Chief agricultural officer Gurdeep Singh noted that while the total area under DSR was only 1,800 acres last year, this year has seen a substantial rise to 4,000 acres, even with transplantation expected to continue until July 15. The department anticipates that 2.58 lakh hectares of land will be cultivated with paddy this Kharif season, and Ludhiana district has already covered 50%-52% of this expected area. Paddy experts highlight the multiple benefits of the DSR practice. Dr Buta Singh Dhillon from Punjab Agricultural University explained that DSR saves between 10%-20% of water in irrigation. This is primarily because it eliminates the need for nursery raising, which requires significant irrigation, and the subsequent puddling process to prepare fields for transplanting. Beyond water conservation, farmers also save on labour costs for nursery raising and transplanting, as well as on machine inputs for puddling and their associated maintenance. Dr Dhillon pointed out that DSR reduces the reliance on fuel-guzzling tractors for ploughing and intensive puddling, which often leads to tractors getting stuck and needing repair. Furthermore, DSR practice aids in groundwater recharge. Singh elaborated that puddling creates a hardpan in the subsoil layer, over 15 cm below the surface, which prevents rainwater from seeping into the ground. When puddling is avoided, the subsoil remains porous, allowing water to infiltrate rather than evaporate, thereby replenishing groundwater. Fields cultivated using DSR also show a slight increase of 1-1.5 quintals in the yield for the succeeding wheat crop in the Rabi season. This is because the absence of puddling means the subsoil retains its pores, providing better conditions for wheat, which unlike paddy, cannot tolerate excessive water and often turns pale after initial irrigation if the ground is compacted. The DSR method utilises specialised machines that plant seeds directly with drills. Singh explained that this process, unlike traditional seed spraying, employs a geometric approach to ensure seeds are equally distanced, allowing them to optimally benefit from soil nutrition and solar radiation.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Buddha Dariya pollution: PAC files plea against PPCB & CETP directors in NGT
Ludhiana: The Public Action Committee (PAC) filed a contempt petition against the concerned PPCB officials and directors of the Bahadur Ke Road Common Effluent Treatment Plant for intentionally violating National Green Tribunal (NGT) orders on effluent discharge into Buddha Dariya. The original petition was filed against three CETPs: Bahadur K Road, Tajpur Road, and Focal Point. However, PAC members have now filed a contempt petition against Bahadur Ke Road CETP members because it received a separate environment compensation in 2014, which mandated Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) — a condition it consistently failed to meet. All three CETPs were funded by central and state govts yet failed to honour mandatory conditions due to the active connivance of PPCB officials. PAC members Jaskirat Singh and Kapil Arora shared that Ludhiana's dyeing industry clusters have been illegally discharging effluent into Buddha Dariya for decades. After sustained citizen efforts, three CETPs were constructed, but PPCB failed to place their Environmental Clearance (EC) documents in the public domain. It also allowed three unauthorized outlets to discharge into the waterbody. Even after CPCB directions, PPCB gave undue time for clusters to appeal closure orders instead of enforcing environmental compliance. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Perdagangkan CFD Emas dengan Broker Tepercaya IC Markets Mendaftar Undo The PAC filed three separate cases against each CETP, following which NGT directed PPCB to act strictly in line with EC conditions. They also pointed out that the state govt has repeatedly changed its lawyers before the Tribunal to stall proceedings and protect violators. PAC members Kuldeep Singh Khaira and Preet Dhanoa said that despite the NGT's clear orders in November 2024, the PPCB and state govt misread the directions and permitted continued effluent discharge into Buddha Dariya. This amounts to contempt of court and reflects how public health has been sidelined in favour of polluters. Dr Amandeep Singh Bains and Gurpreet Singh said that the NGT reiterated that EC conditions are binding and ruled that no coercive action would be taken against the CETP only if it fully complied with environmental norms. It further clarified that violating the zero discharge condition amounts to non-compliance with the law. They shared that despite these clear directions, PPCB officials continued to allow the illegal discharge of toxic waste into Buddha Dariya. They alleged that even after giving official undertakings, the state govt has not submitted a compliance report to the NGT, while pollution continues unchecked under official protection. The members claimed that it is on these grounds that they filed this contempt petition under the NGT Act, which allows for up to ₹10 crore in fines or three years' imprisonment, or both. PAC called on the Chief Minister of Punjab to break official silence, stop shielding violators, and take meaningful action to restore public faith in governance and environmental justice. However, when contacted, the PPCB Chief Engineer RK Ratra said, "The matter is pending in the tribunal, so it is difficult to comment on the same, and moreover, I am unaware of any such contempt petition. I can only comment after verifying things." April 2024 - NGT took suo moto notice of media reports about Buddha Dariya pollution and failure of samples collected from the drain. August 2024 - A team from the Central Pollution Control Board conducted an inspection, and as per the environment clearance granted to the CETPs, the treated water shall not be discharged into Buddha Nullah, so it ordered PPCB to take appropriate action. September 2024 - PPCB issued orders to CETPs to close their outlets, but when they did not follow the directions, PPCB also filed three criminal cases against directors of three CETPs at a local court. November 2024 - NGT issued orders to CETPs to comply with EC conditions. December 2024 - Kale Pani Morcha activists staged a massive protest at Ferozepur Road. December 2024 - NGT clarified its own orders that it is not a blanket stay and compliance with EC is a must. After that, multiple orders were issued, but no action was taken by the govt or CETPs; therefore, now contempt is filed.

Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Opposition may raise revision of electoral rolls in Parliament
Opposition INDIA bloc partners may raise the Election Commission of India's (ECI) move to conduct a door-to-door special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, just months before the crucial assembly polls, in the upcoming monsoon session of Parliament, two senior leaders of the Opposition grouping said on Sunday. Two days after the ECI's announcement to start the SIR of electoral rolls, West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee said the move was more dangerous than the National Register of Citizens (NRC).(File Photo) A senior Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader said the issue will be also taken up politically by the INDIA bloc parties. 'The talks among INDIA bloc allies have already started on this issue,' the leader said. Also read: EC 'clarifies' rules as Bihar voter roll drive starts today In Patna, senior Congress leader Digvijaya Singh said all constituents of INDIA bloc may knock the door of judiciary against the ongoing SIR if the poll body does not accept opposition parties' objections about the drive. 'The SIR drive of the EC is a deliberate attempt to disenfranchise poor, tribal, young, flood-affected, and migrant voters in the upcoming Bihar Assembly elections. All constituents of INDIA bloc may knock the door of judiciary against the ongoing SIR of the electoral roll in Bihar if the EC does not accept the opposition's objections about the drive,' the Rajya Sabha member said. ECI on June 24 announced it will undertake SIR of the electoral roll across the country, beginning with Bihar, to weed out ineligible names, citing rapid urbanisation, frequent migration, young citizens becoming eligible to vote, non-reporting of deaths and inclusion of the names of foreign illegal immigrants. The announcement met with strong criticism from Bihar's opposition Mahagathbandhan, which claimed the move was aimed at electorally benefiting the ruling NDA in the poll-bound state. Singh said he spoke to RJD chief Lalu Prasad on the issue and urged him to speak to Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge. The SIR drive has been launched just a few months before the state polls, Singh said, adding, 'The EC should have taken the opinion of all political parties before launching this drive.' Two days after the ECI's announcement to start the SIR of electoral rolls, West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee said the move was more dangerous than the National Register of Citizens (NRC). 'I don't understand the reason behind the ECI move or the rationale behind selecting these dates. This is nothing short of a scam. I seek clarification from the commission on whether they are trying to implement the NRC through the back door. In fact, this looks to be more dangerous than the NRC which every political party in Opposition must resist,' Banerjee, who is also the TMC chief, said. A leader of a non-Congress party said the ongoing drive might impact other states as well. 'Next year, three states which are ruled by INDIA bloc parties will go to poll. Therefore, we need to be united to tackle the issue,' the leader said, also declining to be named. In 2026, TMC-ruled West Bengal, DMK-ruled Tamil Nadu and the Left parties-led Kerala will go to polls along with Assam and Puducherry.