Federal auditors target vaccine injury program amid surprise Oxaro office visit
A five-month-long Global News investigation of the VISP program triggered the audit and downtown Ottawa office visit by PHAC officials to check the consulting firm's work managing thousands of vaccine injury claims filed by Canadians, according to a confidential source familiar with the matter.
Staff from the Public Health Agency of Canada conducted a visit to Oxaro/VISP offices in downtown Ottawa on June 17. That was after Global started asking questions about program administration by its hired consultants and sent letters seeking comments.
Oxaro's five-year funding agreement with PHAC is up for renewal next year and the audit raises the possibility that the company could see a shorter contract extension, or not have it renewed at all if it does not pass the compliance audit. The government could also strengthen Oxaro staffing and training requirements.
Story continues below advertisement
The confidential source said that PHAC officials will continue to visit Oxaro's VISP offices 'on short notice and in-person to ensure that performance standards are met.'
Global News agreed to not identify the source because they are not authorized to speak publicly about the site visits or compliance audit, though they are familiar with details about them.
PHAC spokesman Mark Johnson confirmed the surprise June 17 Oxaro office visit by agency staff.
'PHAC has initiated the process for a compliance audit of the Oxaro-administered VISP,' he added.
Oxaro did not respond to an emailed request for comment about the audit and site visit.
The Vaccine Injury Support Program was created during the COVID-19 pandemic's early days.
The effort was designed to support and compensate people who have been seriously and permanently injured by any Health Canada-authorized vaccine administered in Canada on or after Dec. 8, 2020.
Get weekly health news
Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
The federal government invited companies and non-profits to submit proposals to administer the program in early 2021 and compete for a five-year contribution agreement to fund the effort.
Oxaro vowed it had the 'people, processes, and tools' to run the initiative with 'industry best practices.' PHAC subsequently picked Oxaro to administer the program.
Story continues below advertisement
But the Global News investigation into the program, involving more than 30 interviews with current and former Oxaro employees, injured claimants and their attorneys, uncovered complaints that VISP has failed to deliver on its promise of 'fair and timely' access to financial support.
Part 1 of the investigation revealed:
Oxaro Inc., has received $50.6 million in taxpayer money. $33.7 million has been spent on administrative costs, while Canadians injured by vaccine shots during the COVID-19 pandemic have received only $16.9 million.
PHAC and Oxaro underestimated the number of injury claims VISP would get, initially predicting 40 per year and then up to 400 valid claims annually. More than 3,000 applications have been filed — of those, 1,700 people are still waiting for their claim to be decided.
Some injured applicants say they face a revolving door of unreachable VISP case managers and fundraise online to survive.
Some said their applications were unfairly rejected by doctors they've never spoken to or met.
Despite decades of calls for a vaccine injury support program, the federal government cobbled it together during a pandemic.
4:04
'Chaos' inside Federal Vaccine Injury Support Program
Part 2 of the investigation uncovered allegations that Oxaro was unequipped to deliver fully on the program's mission and raised questions about why PHAC chose this company over others.
Story continues below advertisement
Global News also revealed internal documents suggesting VISP fell short due to poor planning from the start.
Global News also heard descriptions of a workplace that lacked the gravitas of a program meant to assist the seriously injured and chronically ill: drinking in the office, ping pong, slushies and Netflix streaming at desks. Some workers said the office distractions had improved in recent months, and emphasized that they had done their best with the resources they were given.
One worker added that: 'I don't think anyone actually understood the severity or the relevance of the program that was being contracted to the firm.
'I think they (injured claimants) were merely names on paper and nothing more than that.'
View image in full screen
The Ottawa consulting firm Oxaro Inc. was hired in 2021 to administer the federal government's Vaccine Injury Support Program. Global News
In a previous response to Global News, Oxaro stated: 'The VISP is a new and demand-based program with an unknown and fluctuating number of applications and appeals submitted by claimants.'
Story continues below advertisement
'The program processes, procedures and staffing were adapted to face the challenges linked to receiving substantially more applications than originally planned,' Oxaro added. 'Oxaro and PHAC have been collaborating closely to evaluate how the program can remain agile to handle the workload on hand while respecting budget constraints.'
The company declined to comment on statements by its former workers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
N.B. spa can have topless event without exotic entertainment licence, province apologizes
The New Brunswick government has backtracked on its previous position and now says a Nordic spa in a rural part of the province can go ahead with a women-only private event where guests are allowed to be topless. Hope-Wellness Eco-Resort, located in Edgett's Landing, N.B., had originally scheduled the event for last week. It had hosted similar events twice before without issue. But after advertising its latest event, it was contacted by the province's gaming control and licensing services department and informed that there had been complaints filed. It was told the event violated its liquor licence regulations and the spa would have to apply for an entertainment/exotic licence, which is typically used for strip clubs. There was also no guarantee the application, which costs $750, would be accepted. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The co-owners, Katie Carson and Ashley Ward, had already cancelled the event before speaking with Global News on Thursday. Story continues below advertisement The provincial government didn't provide a comment Thursday, but in a Friday update, a spokesperson said they now believed the event, 'as planned,' was 'within the conditions of their licence.' 'We have extended an apology to the owner of Hope Wellness Resort for the unintended stress and concern caused by the cancelation of the original event.' View image in full screen Katie Carson and Ashley Ward are co-owners of Hope-Wellness Eco-Resort in New Brunswick. They are taken aback by the backlash over an event they had scheduled for last week, and the province's labelling of it as exotic entertainment. Suzanne Lapointe/Global News Body positivity Ward and Carson described the event as a positive experience where a community can gather. 'It's just very liberating. You don't care about what your bathing suit looks like. There's no judgment. Everyone in the community that comes is very much on the same page,' Ward said. Carson said the fact the event was deemed 'entertainment' was the most upsetting part of their discussions with the provincial department, because it unfairly portrayed what the women were trying to achieve. Story continues below advertisement 'We honestly felt as if it was very sexist because we don't need a specific licence here at the spa for men to take their tops off. But in this case, we could potentially get fined for women having that option,' she said.
Global News
9 hours ago
- Global News
N.B. spa that wanted to host body positivity event told they need exotic entertainment licence
The co-owners of a Nordic spa in rural New Brunswick are taken aback by backlash over an event they had scheduled for last week, and the province's labelling of it as 'exotic entertainment.' Hope-Wellness Eco-Resort, located in Edgett's Landing, N.B., has hosted private events twice before where a small number of women enjoy the spa's facilities topless — and had no issues. 'It's just very liberating. You don't care about what your bathing suit looks like. There's no judgment. Everyone in the community that comes is very much on the same page,' said co-owner Ashley Ward. Ward and co-owner Katie Carson were surprised to see negative online responses to this latest event but were undeterred until they received a call from the province's gaming control and licensing services department, which handles liquor licences. Carson says a week before the event, an employee from the department informed them they had received complaints about the event and asked them to confirm whether women would be allowed to go topless. Story continues below advertisement 'He basically said, 'This does not fall in the regulations of your liquor licensing. If you move forward with the event, there will be repercussions,'' she recalled. Carson requested an email outlining the rules so she and Ward could make an informed decision on how to proceed. They decided to cancel the event two days prior since they still hadn't received clarification from the province, which they say was disappointing for those who had bought tickets. View image in full screen The owners of Hope-Wellness Eco-Resort, located in Edgett's Landing, N.B., say they've hosted private events twice before where a small number of women enjoy the spa's facilities topless. Suzanne Lapointe/Global News The day before the now-cancelled event was set to take place, Carson and Ward received an email that further clarified they would be violating regulations if they went ahead. They were told they could apply for an exotic entertainment licence — the same kind that is required for strip clubs. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Under the province's liquor licensing regulations, an entertainment/exotic licence is required for live entertainment within an existing liquor-licensed establishment. Story continues below advertisement The fee for an exotic entertainment licence is $750. Carson says paying for that licence would be a form of 'backing down' at this point, because they don't feel their event is an 'exotic experience.' As well, she says it feels as if applying for the licence is a 'trap' because they were told it's unlikely to be approved. 'They just said nothing's been done like this before and typically, it would not be approved,' she said. The owners say they offered to close the bar for the day of the event, but were told that was insufficient. A further email from the department said they could cancel their existing liquor licence if they didn't feel it met their business needs. Carson says the fact the event was deemed 'entertainment' was the most upsetting part of their discussions, because it unfairly portrayed what the women were trying to achieve. 'We honestly felt as if it was very sexist because we don't need a specific licence here at the spa for men to take their tops off. But in this case, we could potentially get fined for women having that option,' she said. 'This kind of moved beyond our little event. It became so much more than that. We're here to try to make changes so that other spas or other places (can be where) women can feel comfortable without thinking that this is exotic.' Story continues below advertisement Under the Criminal Code, it is not illegal for women to be topless in Canada, unless they are involved in an 'indecent act.' When the co-owners posted a video to social media explaining why they cancelled the event, they received supportive messages from around the world. 'We want things to be reviewed so that the government and (department of justice and public safety) can take into account that not every woman with their top off is exotic,' said Carson. 'That it's very natural, that it is completely within our rights.' Global News reached out to the provincial government for comment but did not receive a response by deadline.
Toronto Star
10 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Doug Ford extends term of Ontario's top civil servant
Premier Doug Ford, right, and then-Trillium Health Partners Hospital CEO and President Michelle DiEmanuele show off the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine at Trillium Health Partners during the COVID-19 pandemic in Mississauga on Dec. 30, 2020. Nathan Denette THE CANADIAN PRES
