Mariah Carey wins copyright case over All I Want For Christmas Is You
Mr Stone and his lawyers had not "met their burden of showing that [the songs by] Carey and Vance are substantially similar", she wrote.Judge Almandi also ruled that Mr Stone and his lawyers should face sanctions for filing "frivolous" arguments, that included "vague... and incomprehensible mixtures of factual assertions and conclusions, subjective opinions, and other irrelevant evidence".She ordered Mr Stone and his lawyers to repay the legal bills Carey incurred in defending the case.
The case was originally filed in 2022, with Mr Stone claiming Carey's hit was copied from a song he'd recorded under the name Vince Vance and the Valiants.In court papers, he claimed his track had received "extensive airplay" during the 1993 holiday season - a year before Carey's song was recorded and released.In her 2020 memoir, Carey said she had composed "most of the song on a cheap little Casio keyboard", while playing the movie It's A Wonderful Life for inspiration, before completing it in the studio with her co-writer Walter Afanasieff.But Mr Stone rejected that account."[Carey] palmed off these works with her incredulous origin story, as if those works were her own," he said in court papers. "Her hubris knowing no bounds, even her co-credited songwriter doesn't believe the story she has spun."The initial complaint was dropped in December 2022, but refiled a month later.Mr Stone had hoped to share in the song's runaway success. All I Want For Christmas Is You earns about $8.5 million (£6.6 million) every year; and has spent 140 weeks in the UK's top 100.
'No similarities'
Carey's lawyers asked the court to dismiss the case last August, arguing that Mr Stone had failed to establish copyright infringement."The claimed similarities are an unprotectable jumble of elements: A title and hook phrase used by many earlier Christmas songs, other commonplace words, phrases, and Christmas tropes like 'Santa Claus' and 'mistletoe'," they wrote.In Wednesday's ruling, Judge Almadani endorsed two reports from musicologists hired by Carey's team.In one, New York University professor Lawrence Ferrara testified there were "no significant melodic similarities" between the two tracks.He added he'd discovered "at least 19 songs" predating Mr Stone's track that had similar lyrical ideas - several of which were also called All I Want For Christmas Is You.A similar report filed by the defence was ruled inadmissible - especially after its author admitted in a deposition that the melodies of the two songs were incomparable because "the rhythms are different".On that basis, Judge Almadani ruled in favour of the motion to dismiss.Neither Mariah Carey nor Mr Stone were immediately available for comment on the ruling.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
3 hours ago
- Metro
Phlur, Anthropologie & M&S — where our shopping expert's spending this weekend
Metro journalists select and curate the products that feature on our site. If you make a purchase via links on this page we will earn commission – learn more Sorry, but where has the time gone? One minute it was July, now it's August — and while we wait (impatiently) for the heatwave to make its grand return, here's your latest edition of Trend Trove, aka your go-to for everything HOT from the high street. Our shopping expert's been out doing the Lord's work again, and she's uncovered the best of the best — from the return of Dusk's five-time sell-out lamp to FACEGYM's new skincare that we need to buy immediately. PHLUR's dropped another dreamy scent (warning: it's addictive AF), and Smythson's already thinking ahead with their 2026 diaries. Yes, really. She's also found jewellery that'll make your group chat scream, pjs to keep you cool for heatwave 2.0 (we're manifesting), IT girl trainers, and the trench coat everyone will be wearing this AW25. Oh, and plenty of shoes, homeware and beauty bits that'll have your bank account crying — or just bookmark for payday, birthdays, or Christmas (because it's never too early, right?). And while we cling to our favourite summer dress hoping for a sunny encore, Pret is bringing the vibes with limited-edition beaded cup holders to match their new iced lattes — available for one day only on Monday 4 August at three UK shops. Think Matcha, Ube Brûlée and Spirulina Macaron, with just 20 holders per location. It's first-come, first-served, so latte lovers, be quick. In other sweet news, Moonpig and Millie's Cookies are teaming up to celebrate exam results day with a delicious little freebie. From Monday 4 August, grab any treat in-store at Millie's and you'll get a code for a free Moonpig card — perfect for congratulating the smart cookie in your life. Whether it's a giant personalised bake or a box of their faves, you'll be able to send a card online or via the app, with designs for everything from results day to weddings and uni send-offs. Cute, right? FACEGYM is back with a glow-up for your skincare shelf — meet POWERLIFT , the new EMS Activator Gel that does way more than just conduct. Designed to supercharge your facial workouts and your skin, this multitasking gel is packed with heavy-hitting ingredients like Hyaluronic Acid, Tripeptide-5 and Vegan Collagen to hydrate, firm and sculpt in one silky swipe. Think of it as your skin's new PT — lifting, plumping and giving you that post-gym glow, minus the sweat — hurrah! Oh, and Symprove's cult gut health supplement just got a tropical upgrade — say hello to the brand-new Pineapple flavour. Packed with 10 billion live bacteria from four key strains in every 70ml shot, it's designed to support digestion, ease bloating and boost your gut game — all while tasting like summer in a bottle. More Trending It's vegan, gluten- and sugar-free, and cleverly formulated to reach your gut alive (unlike some other probiotics we won't name). After topping taste tests, Pineapple joins the fruity line-up alongside Mango & Passion Fruit and Strawberry & Raspberry — and yes, it's available now at Holland & Barrett. So get the kettle on, take five, maybe crack open that can of Coke Zero you've been saving, and get your debit card details ready… Add a little polish to your off-duty wardrobe with this waisted denim mini. Made from pure cotton for that effortless, lived-in feel, it features a flattering V-neck, voluminous sleeves and a tie belt to cinch you in. Easy, breezy, and endlessly wearable. Buy Now for £39.50 The Adidas Originals trainers get a bold cow print update exclusive to ASOS. Made with a gum sole, brown and white print, and a comfy pink insole, these retro-inspired trainers are a cool take on the Western trend. Comfy, low profile and fashion-forward, we're suggesting you add to basket, fast. Buy now for £90 Meet your new signature scent. The Nue Co. US Pheromone+ adapts to your body chemistry to enhance your natural pheromones, creating a fragrance that's uniquely yours. Expect soft notes of bergamot, patchouli, moss and musk — blended into something only you can wear. Buy Now for £125 Lightweight, foldable and made from recycled nylon canvas, this backpack is built for busy days and spontaneous getaways. It's roomy enough for a 16-inch laptop, with wide straps that won't dig in. The sporty shape is finished with a bold Russian leather flap and signature Longchamp medal — a sleek nod to life on the go. Buy Now for £140 Denim done right. The Ricky Rope Stitch Straight Jean nails that laid-back, lived-in look with its classic medium wash, signature rope stitching and standout horseshoe detail on the back pockets. A 34' inseam keeps things sleek and streamlined. Buy Now for £270 Hand-pressed glass beads and handblown glass give the Icon collection its charm — think one-of-a-kind designs that are as giftable as they are gorgeous. Whether it's for you or your best mate, these exclusive pieces are made to toast life's little moments in style. Buy Now for £14 Made from a modal blend fabric that's 21% more breathable than regular cotton jersey, this PJ top is silky-soft, lightweight, and designed to keep you cool all night long. It features four-way stretch for extra comfort, is pre-shrunk so it holds its shape wash after wash, and the fade-resistant fabric means it stays looking fresh. BUY NOW FOR £27.30 (WAS £39) – SAVE 30% Step into the stillness of night with Orb of Night — a scent that captures quiet romance and dawn's first light. Cherry-almond and caramel swirl over soft florals, warm sandalwood and a whisper of white musk. It's dreamy, magnetic, and made for moments that linger. Buy Now for £55 Add a pop of personality with the Lucia table lamp. Available in bold red and white or classic blue and white, this striped stunner is all about playful charm. The matching base and shade create a sleek, modern silhouette — perfect for perking up your bedside, desk or reading nook. Just add an E14 Candle LED bulb (not included) and let it glow. Buy Now for £35 Shield your strands with K18's HeatBounce Conditioning Heat Protectant. This lightweight mist defends against heat up to 232°C while softening, detangling and boosting shine. Powered by patented Resilicore™ tech, it's your go-to for smoother, healthier-looking hair — whether you're blow-drying or styling straighteners. Buy Now for £48 Stay organised on the move with the Wafer diary and pencil, crafted in signature Panama leather. Compact and portable, it's perfect for jotting down ideas or appointments on the go. The week-to-view layout and tear-off corners make keeping track of your schedule refreshingly simple. Buy Now for £90 Make a splash with the Ocean Cluster Charm Necklace. From starfish to sunbursts, build your own seaside story with up to five charms — including semi-precious stones. Plated in 18k gold, it's the ultimate personalised piece to gift (or keep). Buy Now for £59 Phlur's Mrs Smith Hair and Body Mist is fruity, floral and seriously refreshing. It opens with a juicy hit of Granny Smith apple, pear and watermelon — bright, playful and perfect for a quick pick-me-up. Apple blossom, violet and Pink Lady apple add a soft floral twist, while pink praline and musk nectar bring a warm, sweet finish that lingers on skin and hair. Bonus: it's vegan too. Buy Now from £25 Classic trench, meet modern drama. This Karen Millen number reworks a wardrobe icon with bold cape detailing and a sculptural silhouette. Crafted from breathable cotton and cinched at the waist, it's a statement layer that moves effortlessly from city streets to countryside escapes. Buy Now for £119.20 (was £149) Step into the cowboy trend with the Iria ankle boots in tan. With a sleek Western-inspired shape, they're made to go from casual brunches to nights out with ease. The versatile silhouette works with everything from jeans to floaty dresses — the perfect way to add a little edge to your everyday look. Buy Now for £100 Sweeten up your pout with Too Faced's Kissing Jelly Tint. This juicy lip tint delivers kiss-proof colour, lasting hydration and a glossy finish — all in one swipe. Wear it solo or layer under gloss for a custom combo that'll have everyone asking, 'What's on your lips?' Buy Now for £24 Follow Metro across our social channels, on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram Share your views in the comments below MORE: Adidas' sell-out cow print Sambas are back — buy them now from ASOS (whilst stock lasts) MORE: Too hot at night? These cooling PJs fixed that and now they're 30% off MORE: 'I tried Charlotte Tilbury's new Unreal Blush Stick – and it may just be my new make-up must have'
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Mrs Brown's Boys viewers left in utter disbelief as controversial show returns to BBC
Fans have reacted sharply to the return of Mrs Brown's Boys, with many on social media branding it unfunny and questioning why it was ever commissioned BBC sitcom Mrs Brown's Boys returned to screens tonight for the start of its fifth full-length series, despite enduring a turbulent few years marked by falling ratings and a high-profile racism controversy involving its creator and star, Brendan O'Carroll. First aired in 2011, the comedy became a holiday fixture and enjoyed huge popularity in its early years. Its 2013 Christmas Day special drew 11.52 million viewers, making it one of the most-watched festive programmes of the decade. However, viewership has steadily declined. The show last appeared in the top ten on Christmas Day in 2020, attracting 3.8 million viewers. It comes after Brendan, 69, finally announced the future of Mrs Brown to fans. The series has long divided audiences and critics, and was recently labelled the 'worst ever BBC show' by some viewers on social media. Comments on X during tonight's broadcast included: 'Worst programme in human history should've never been commissioned' and 'Just speechless… I honestly don't know one person who thinks this show is remotely funny.' Another insisted: "This show needs to be axed asap. It's not one bit funny." Someone else fumed: "I actually hate this show with a passion and I'm Irish and from Dublin and I GET that kind of sense of humour." In 2023, Mrs Brown's Boys faced further scrutiny after O'Carroll made a racial slur during rehearsals for the Christmas special. Crew members were reportedly 'shocked' by the remark and lodged complaints with BBC bosses. The broadcaster suspended production and launched an investigation. O'Carroll later apologised, expressing 'deep regret' over what he called a 'clumsy attempt at a joke.' Speaking publicly about the incident for the first time on Irish YouTube programme Conversations With Gerry Kelly, O'Carroll claimed his words had been 'completely taken out of context.' He also argued that the episode ultimately had a positive impact. 'The one thing that that incident did is give great awareness about racism, and great awareness about the BBC, they don't take any messing… However, I think in the long run it was a good thing, because it got people talking about it.' O'Carroll, who has won the National Television Award for Best Comedy six times for Mrs Brown's Boys, has made it clear he is unfazed by negative feedback. 'The ones that love me, I love them, and the ones that don't, f*** them,' he told Kelly, adding that those who dislike the show should simply 'pick up the remote and change the station.' Despite its dwindling audience, the series maintains a loyal fan base and continues to be a fixture in the BBC's comedy line-up. The new series, which began tonight, marks a fresh chapter for the show as it seeks to recapture some of its former success in the face of ongoing criticism.
Metro
13 hours ago
- Metro
Mathew Horne fights back tears over sudden death of Gavin and Stacey colleague
Mathew Horne fought back tears while telling crowds he'd just been told a crew member from Gavin and Stacey had died. The actor, 46, starred as Gavin Shipman in the BBC comedy alongside Joanna Page, James Corden, and Ruth Jones since it began in 2007 until its final episode on Christmas Day 2024. He was being interviewed on stage for an In Conversation With session in Taunton, Somerset, when he suddenly became emotional and told the audience he'd only just received the news when it had been shared on the cast WhatsApp group. Horne said, via The Sun: 'Sorry. I got distracted. Earlier on… we had a driver on the finale called Rob and he was in his early 40s… and I found out via the Whatsapp group earlier that he has passed away and I got slightly distracted there. 'It's really, really sad. I got distracted by losing Rob. 'He was a really lovely guy and he's left a four-year-old behind and that is really, really, really sad.' Horne also shared how close the cast had become since bonding 'like a family' over the last 18 years. For the main actors, their lives changed beyond recognition and the show became one of the most popular British comedies of all time. He explained: 'In 2019, before the Christmas special – part one of the finale if you like – aired, I lost my mother and Alison really stepped up and she became my surrogate mother off screen as well. 'Whenever she texts me even now she signs it 'Mum'. And that is cool. That is so beautiful. And she says, 'How are you, my little prince?' It means the world to me.' Gavin and Stacey ended on Christmas Day, 2024, with a feature-length episode that attracted a staggering 19.1million viewers. Fans waited five years to find out if Smithy accepted Nessa's proposal to quickly discover he was getting married – but not to her. Instead, the episode followed Smithy gearing up to marry Sonia – his insufferable girlfriend who his friends and family couldn't stand. Thankfully, fans got their happy ending, Smithy jilted Sonia at the aisle and raced across the country to find Nessa and get down on one knee. There has, however, been talk of potential spin-offs with other characters such as Dawn and Pete, played by Julia Davis and Adrian Scarborough respectively, keeping the spirit of Gavin and Stacey alive. View More » Gavin and Stacey is available to stream on BBC iPlayer. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Gavin and Stacey's Larry Lamb, 77, retires from acting – and final show already aired
