Indian tech hub state pushes jail terms for 'fake news', sparks worries, Asia News
With nearly one billion internet users, the stakes are high in a sprawling country of many ethnic and religious communities where fake news risks stirring deadly strife and AI deepfake videos have alarmed officials during elections.
India's federal government already regulates social media content with legislation empowering it to order takedowns of disputed content. But some states such as Karnataka have begun taking their own measures.
Karnataka's bill, the strictest of its kind yet, stipulates that those posting "fake news" and "anti-feminist" content, or "promoting superstition", would face imprisonment along with potential fines.
The 11-page Karnataka Mis-Information And Fake News (Prohibition) Bill does not define such offences in practise, but said special courts and a regulatory committee would be set up to implement it.
Free speech advocates have cited what they say would be the risk of selective enforcement arising from Karnataka's measure and flagged concerns that people posting memes or making honest mistakes online could be prosecuted.
"Misinformation is fairly subjective and every person who uses the internet is susceptible to falling within the dragnet of this law," said Apar Gupta, founder of the Internet Freedom Foundation, a New Delhi-based digital advocacy group which first made the Karnataka draft legislation public.
The state government of Karnataka, home to the city of Bengaluru that hosts the offices or branches of many Indian and foreign tech giants, has said the bill will be released for public consultation before implementation.
Priyank Kharge, Karnataka's IT minister, said on Friday "there is a lot of misinformation on the proposed Misinformation Bill in public". He later added that the "sole objective is to address the growing digital information disorder" and the government's focus was to tackle misinformation and fake news, "and nothing beyond that".
He did not immediately respond to Reuters calls seeking further comment on Monday.
Karnataka's move could risk creating multiple regulations imposing conflicting obligations and regulatory challenges for companies, said Aman Taneja, partner at law and policy firm Ikigai.
Some Indian media have sharply criticised the draft bill.
The Deccan Herald newspaper on Monday titled an opinion piece "A remedy that's worse than the menace", saying the Karnataka government should "do away with the criminal provisions" in the legislation.
India has over the years held talks with US tech giants like Google it sees as having been slow to remove fake news posts, and New Delhi in 2019 set up a "Fact Check Unit" to debunk what it sees as misinformation.
[[nid:719675]]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
39 minutes ago
- CNA
US Senate strikes AI regulation ban passage from Trump megabill
WASHINGTON: The Republican-led US Senate voted overwhelmingly on Tuesday (July 1) to remove a 10-year federal moratorium on state regulation of artificial intelligence from President Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending bill. Lawmakers voted 99-1 to strike the ban from the bill by adopting an amendment offered by Republican Senator Marsha Blackburn. The action came during a marathon session known as a "vote-a-rama," in which lawmakers offered numerous amendments to the legislation that has now passed through the upper chamber of Congress. The Senate version of Trump's legislation would have only restricted states regulating AI from tapping a new $500 million fund to support AI infrastructure. The AI clause is part of the wide-ranging tax-cut and spending bill sought by President Donald Trump, which would cut Medicaid healthcare and food assistance programs for the poor and disabled. Vice President JD Vance cast the tie-breaking vote in the Senate to pass the bill, which now moves back to the House for consideration. Major AI companies, including Alphabet's Google and OpenAI, have expressed support for Congress taking AI regulation out of the hands of states to free innovation from a panoply of differing requirements. Blackburn presented her amendment to strike the provision a day after agreeing to compromise language with Senate Commerce Committee chair Ted Cruz that would have cut the ban to five years and allowed states to regulate issues such as protecting artists' voices or child online safety if they did not impose an "undue or disproportionate burden" on AI. But Blackburn withdrew her support for the compromise before the amendment vote. "The current language is not acceptable to those who need these protections the most," the Tennessee Republican said in a statement.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Iran warns against 'destructive approach' of European countries in call with EU foreign policy chief
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araqhchi looks on during a press conference in Istanbul, Turkey, June 22, 2025. REUTERS/Umit Bektas/File Photo CAIRO - Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi warned in a phone call with EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas against what he called the "destructive approach" of several European countries, he said in a statement on Telegram on Tuesday. Araqchi also criticised the stance of some European countries over the recent air war between Israel and Iran, saying it was supportive of Israel and the United States. He did not specify which countries he had in mind. Kallas said after the call that "negotiations on ending Iran's nuclear programme should restart as soon as possible". In a post on social media platform X, the EU's top diplomat said cooperation with the International Atomic Energy Agency "must resume" and that the bloc is ready to facilitate. "Any threats to pull out of the non-proliferation treaty don't help to lower tensions," she added. REUTERS
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
US Senate approves divisive Trump spending Bill
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Senate Majority Leader John Thune (centre) - accompanied by Republican senators John Barrasso (left) and Mike Crapo - speaking to reporters after the Senate passed US President Donald Trump's so-called "One, Big, Beautiful Bill," on July 1. WASHINGTON - The Republican-led US Senate approved President Donald Trump's mammoth domestic policy Bill on July 1 by the narrowest of margins, despite misgivings over delivering deep welfare cuts and another US$3 trillion (S$3.8 trillion) in national debt. Republican leaders had struggled to corral support during a record 24-hour 'vote-a-rama' amendment session on the Senate floor, as Democrats offered dozens of challenges to the most divisive aspects of the package. But Senate Majority Leader John Thune was able to turn around wavering moderates to deliver a 50-50 vote, with Vice-President JD Vance breaking the tie. The sprawling text now heads to the House of Representatives, where it faces unified Democratic opposition and multiple Republicans baulking at the budget-busting costs, as well as slashed health care and food aid programmes for poor Americans. Mr Trump's Bill proposes a US$4.5 trillion extension of his first term tax cuts, contentiously offset with US$1.2 trillion in savings mainly targeting the Medicaid health insurance programme, as well as federal food aid. The health care cuts could see an estimated 12 million low-income and disabled Americans lose coverage. The package also rolls back billions of dollars in green energy tax credits while providing a US$350 billion infusion for border security and Mr Trump's mass migrant deportation programme. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seniors can claim $800 SG60 vouchers from July 1; adults to get $600 in vouchers from July 22 Singapore NSman, 30, dies in hospital after collapsing outside Maju Camp Asia Thai PM's suspension could spell end of Shinawatra clan's era of political dominance Singapore Judge rejects woman's claim that she owns 99% of Bukit Timah condo mostly paid for by ex-boyfriend Singapore 'He fought till the end': Man who survived acid attack as a baby dies of cancer at 26 Singapore Trial opens for 3 women who allegedly organised procession outside Istana Business Do not overcommit to a single solution in a multi-polar world, says ex-foreign minister George Yeo Singapore 1MDB saga: Standard Chartered Bank disputes $3.4 billion claim by liquidators in Singapore The president made clear that the goal remains to get the Bill through the House in the coming days and sign it into law by the July 4 Independence Day holiday. 'It's going to get in, it's going to pass, and we're going to be very happy,' Mr Trump told reporters ahead of the vote. 'Utter shame' Polls show the Bill is among the most unpopular ever considered, and Democrats hope to leverage public anger ahead of the 2026 midterm elections when they aim to retake the House. Backed by extensive independent analysis, they say the Bill's tax cuts would disproportionately benefit the wealthy at the expense of social safety net programmes for the poorest Americans. 'Today, Senate Republicans betrayed the American people and covered the Senate in utter shame,' said Mr Chuck Schumer, the leader of the Senate Democratic minority. 'In one fell swoop, Republicans passed the biggest tax break for billionaires ever seen – paid for by ripping away health care for millions of people and taking food out of the mouths of hungry kids.' A handful of senators in the Republican majority had threatened to upset the apple cart, voicing concerns that the Bill would add more than US$3.3 trillion to the nation's already yawning budget deficits over a decade. The most high-profile opposition came in the shape of tech billionaire and estranged former Trump aide Elon Musk, who baulked at the Bill's debt implications and stripping of clean energy subsidies. A furious Mr Trump on July 1 said he would consider deporting Mr Musk – whose electric car company Tesla gives him extensive interests in green energy – and ending federal funds for his companies. 'Elon may get more subsidy than any human being in history, by far, and without subsidies, Elon would probably have to close up shop and head back home to South Africa,' Mr Trump posted on social media. Focus on House Although the House of Representatives has already passed its own version of the Bill, it will have to come back to the lower chamber for a final rubber stamp before it reaches Mr Trump's desk. House Republicans were watching anxiously from the sidelines to see if their Senate colleagues would adopt changes that would be hard for Speaker Mike Johnson to sell to his lawmakers. Fiscal hawks in the lower chamber are furious at what they say is US$651 billion of extra deficit spending in the Senate's tweaks. A House vote could come as early as July 2 but even with full attendance, House Republicans can only afford to lose three votes. 'The House will work quickly to pass the One Big Beautiful Bill that enacts President Trump's full America First agenda by the Fourth of July,' Mr Johnson said after the vote. 'The American people gave us a clear mandate, and after four years of Democrat failure, we intend to deliver without delay.' AFP
