CIA review finds flaws but does not dispute finding Putin sought to sway 2016 vote to Trump
WASHINGTON — A CIA review released on Wednesday found flaws in the production of a U.S. intelligence assessment that Russian President Vladimir Putin sought to sway the 2016 U.S. presidential vote to Donald Trump, but it did not contest that conclusion.
The review 'does not dispute the quality and credibility' of a highly classified CIA report that the assessment's authors relied on to reach that conclusion, it said.
But the review questioned the 'high confidence' level that the CIA and FBI assigned the conclusion. It should have instead been given the 'moderate confidence' rating reached by the communications-monitoring U.S. National Security Agency, the review said.
Trump, who has a history of quarreling with U.S. intelligence analyzes, has previously rejected that intelligence assessment, which was made public in an unclassified version in January 2017. After a November 2017 meeting with Putin, he said that he believed the Russian leader's election meddling denials.
CIA Director John Ratcliffe, a former congressman who served as director of national intelligence in Trump's first term, ordered the review and its 'lessons learned' section 'to promote analytic objectivity and transparency,' said a CIA statement.
The CIA's Directorate of Analysis, which conducted the review, 'identified multiple procedural anomalies' in how the December 2016 classified assessment of Russian election interference was prepared.
They included 'a highly compressed timeline ... and excessive involvement of agency heads' and 'led to departures from standard practices in the drafting, coordination, and reviewing' of the report, it said.
'These departures impeded efforts to apply rigorous tradecraft, particularly to the assessment's most contentious judgment,' it continued.
The review, however, did not overturn the judgment that Putin employed a disinformation and cyber campaign to sway the 2016 vote to Trump over his Democratic challenger, Hillary Clinton.
A 2018 bipartisan U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee report reached the same conclusion.
Jonathan Landay, Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canada News.Net
2 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
U.S. stocks extend gains to conclude first half of 2025
NEW YORK, June 30 (Xinhua) -- U.S. stocks continued to climb higher on Monday as signs of progress in trade negotiations buoyed investor sentiment, closing out one of the most volatile first halves in recent years. The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 275.50 points, or 0.63 percent, to 44,094.77. The S&P 500 added 31.88 points, or 0.52 percent, to 6,204.95. The Nasdaq Composite Index increased 96.28 points, or 0.47 percent, to 20,369.73. Nine of the 11 primary S&P 500 sectors ended higher, with technology and financials leading the advance by rising 0.98 percent and 0.86 percent, respectively. Consumer discretionary and energy lagged behind, falling 0.86 percent and 0.66 percent. Monday's gains came after Canada announced it would withdraw its digital services tax, a move widely seen as an effort to smooth relations with the United States just days after U.S. President Donald Trump declared an end to all trade discussions with Ottawa. The tax, which was set to take effect Monday, would have targeted major tech firms such as Google, Meta, and Amazon. Market participants are now looking ahead to the expiration of Trump's 90-day tariff pause next week. Also on Monday, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said some countries are "negotiating in good faith," though he warned that tariffs could return to previously announced levels if talks falter. Meanwhile, attention turned to the U.S. Senate, where lawmakers began a marathon session to debate amendments to Trump's proposed 4.5 trillion U.S. dollars tax package. The Congressional Budget Office projected the bill could add 3.3 trillion dollars to the federal deficit over the next ten years. Despite the looming tariff deadline and uncertainty surrounding the tax legislation, analysts believe strong equity fundamentals and broader market participation could sustain the recent rally. Terry Sandven, chief equity strategist at U.S. Bank Wealth Management, noted that improving breadth supports the view that gains may continue into the second half of the year. "While the market has had much to digest the first six months of 2025, resiliency has prevailed," Leslie Falconio, head of taxable fixed income strategy at UBS Financial Services, wrote last Friday. "However, we are not out of the woods just yet, as bouts of volatility and pockets of vulnerability are expected in the second half of the year." Among individual movers, Apple surged 2.03 percent after Bloomberg reported the company may integrate AI technology from OpenAI or Anthropic into its Siri voice assistant. Broadcom rose 2.34 percent, while Nvidia, Microsoft, and Meta Platforms posted modest gains. On the downside, Amazon and Tesla fell nearly 2 percent, and Alphabet declined 0.49 percent.
Canada News.Net
2 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
Trump, Netanyahu to hold talks on ending Gaza war
WASHINGTON, D.C.: President Donald Trump will meet Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House on Monday. President Trump is trying to help Israel and Hamas agree to a ceasefire and a deal to free hostages, in hopes of ending the war in Gaza. Two U.S. officials confirmed the visit, but asked not to be named because they were not allowed to speak publicly. This will be Netanyahu's third visit to the White House since Trump returned to office in January. The visit comes after the U.S. attacked Iranian nuclear sites and helped stop fighting between Israel and Iran. Now, Trump wants to focus on ending the war between Israel and Hamas. Late last week, Trump told reporters, "We think within the next week we're going to get a ceasefire," but he did not explain why he believed that. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said Trump and his team are talking regularly with Israeli leaders, and ending the Gaza war is a top goal for the president. "It's heartbreaking to see the images from both Israel and Gaza," Leavitt said. "The president wants the war to end and wants to save lives." Israeli Minister for Strategic Affairs Ron Dermer is also in Washington this week to discuss the Gaza war, Iran, and other vital issues with U.S. officials.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Meet the U.S. climate resistance
Hello, Earthlings! This is our weekly newsletter on all things environmental, where we highlight trends and solutions that are moving us to a more sustainable world. Keep up with the latest news on our Climate and Environment page. Meet the U.S. climate resistance U.S. climate advocates have faced a dizzying number of environmental policy rollbacks and funding cuts in the almost six months since Donald Trump took office. Now, activists, academics and lobbyists across American society are gearing up to once again galvanize public opinion in favour of climate action, ahead of the U.S. midterm elections in 2026. The academic resistance Brandon Jones is the president of the American Geophysical Union (AGU) who worked as a federal scientist in the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for 12 years. Jones says he was initially overwhelmed by the "surreal" barrage of changes. But now, Jones says, his organization is finding ways to push back. "You get to a point where yes, you are going to have emotions about the decisions, but you also need to start thinking clearly about how to stand up against what you know is not right," he said. In April, the U.S. president dismissed hundreds of scientists working to compile the country's flagship report on global warming and its impacts. The National Climate Assessment, which is released every four years, informs everything from agricultural policy that impacts food security to disaster mitigation that saves lives. These dismissals prompted the AGU to create a special collection of journals that would house all the important climate research that was suddenly left homeless. Jones says it's important for U.S. scientists today to find new ways to keep climate science alive in the face of federal funding cuts and shifting political priorities. Equally, he says, it's important to continue to get climate data out to decision makers and the general public, and he says many researchers in his circle feel the same. "They are so impassioned about continuing their work and doing the right thing in the face of what they see as an infringement on science … that they're just ready to do it with no pay. It's about ethics and morality now and humanity." The street-level resistance Youth organizations are putting their energy into more visible forms of resistance, like street protests and direct action. One example is the Sunrise Movement. Executive Director Aru Shiney-Ajay says they are currently forming a "youth army to combat the climate crisis." Sunrise's strategy is to carry out social media campaigns and hold rallies to draw attention to Donald Trump's support of fossil fuel industries ahead of the midterms. "Environment is the issue where Trump is least trusted," she said. "I think because of that, there's a real role to make climate a more urgent political priority for everyday people, and [it] actually can result in big shifts in the electorate." Peaceful protesters, however, are becoming increasingly vulnerable to criminal punishment in the U.S. Since January, an expanding list of bills have been introduced aimed at banning political demonstrations, according to The International Center for Not-for-Profit Law, a civic freedoms watchdog based in the U.S. capital. Shiney-Ajay says she's thought a lot about the consequences of organizing protests, but she hopes taking to the streets can inspire others to take smaller actions, like voicing support for climate policy in their workplaces, schools or online. "The question of whether or not we will be able to get out of this political situation really relies on how many people we can inspire to take everyday acts of courage, over and over and over again." Resistance by lobbying Climate organizations are also working to lobby Republican politicians on policies that reduce greenhouse gas emissions from industry. Glen Brand, director of policy and advocacy at the non-profit Solar United Neighbours, says the best way to do that is to focus on the economic benefits of renewable energy, rather than try to bring climate change into the conversation. The U.S. has recently experienced a boom in solar and wind energy uptake, especially in Republican leaning states. Brand attributes this boom to the rising cost of fossil fuel energy sources as well as tax credits brought in under former President Joe Biden that incentivize renewable energy infrastructure. While the Trump administration plans to phase those tax credits out, Brand hopes to convince Republicans to fight for the future of solar in their constituencies. "I think it makes total common sense, considering the state of the Republican Party and climate protection, to focus on pocketbook issues," he said. Dominque Browning, co-founder of the advocacy group Moms Clean Air Force, says her organization plans to lobby in favour of The Endangerment Finding. That's a 2009 decision by the EPA that acknowledges the public health dangers of greenhouse gas emissions and its responsibility to protect Americans from climate change. The current head of the EPA says he will consider reversing the finding altogether. Browning says she thinks about her grandson's future when preparing to push back against a reversal of the finding, and that parents across the U.S. are engaging with lawmakers to pressure the government to uphold the principles of the Endangerment Finding. "We will continue to fight on all fronts. In fact, we find that our work actually helps give us hope and solace, because at least we're trying to do something." Check out our podcast and radio show. In one of our newest episodes: If Canada wants to be net-zero by 2050, more than a million small businesses will have to make the green transition. And while some intrepid business owners are already trying their best to navigate a more eco-friendly path, others say it's a big ask, especially when many are already struggling to balance the needs of price-wary shoppers with a thin bottom line. We'll dive into their journey, and learn more about the supports that could change the game. What On Earth drops new podcast episodes every Wednesday and Saturday. You can find them on your favourite podcast app or on demand at CBC Listen. The radio show airs Sundays at 11 a.m., 11:30 a.m. in Newfoundland and Labrador. Reader Feedback We got another response to our request for photos of your native plant gardens! Amanda Blain wrote: "I have naturalized over five acres into trees, wetlands and native flowers and grasses BUT this is what I call my 'Landscaped Area.' I chose this to show even on a small scale you can make an impact. Instead of planting non-native plants as most landscapers do, I decided to take it into my own hands. I am located in Chatham-Kent, [Ont.,] where tree cover and natural areas are less than five per cent of the total land area. Here I planted: black-eyed Susan (Rudbeckia hirta), smooth oxeye or false sunflower (Heliopsis helianthoides), wild bergamot (Monarda fistulosa), common evening primrose (Oenothera biennis), purple coneflower (Echinacea purpurea), lanceleaf coreopsis (Coreopsis lanceolate) amongst others. I truly believe there is no reason to plant non-native flowers since there are so many beautiful native options." We also heard back from Boston's Office of Green Infrastructure about Sara Scharf's comment about the impact of road salt on Boston's roadside bioswales. Rachel Luna, the office's interim director and principal engineer, responds: "For our roadside bioswales, we select plant species tolerant of higher salt conditions. The first flush of runoff usually has the highest concentration of salt, but as additional ice and snow melts, it flushes the salt through the soil. We use well draining bioretention soil that helps the salt flush through easier." Feel free to send more photos of your native plant gardens — when you send them in, please include your location and what plants are included in the photo so other readers know what works in their region. The Big Picture: What your summer will feel like in 2100 By 2100, with a medium emissions scenario (similar to the trajectory we're on), Montreal summers could feel like ones already experienced in Chicago, Columbus, Ohio, or Queens, N.Y. CBC News published a new interactive analysis in which you can pick your city and see what cities have a present-day climate similar to the one your city will experience at the end of the century. These kinds of comparisons, called spatial analogues by scientists, are a useful way to transform sometimes abstract projections into concrete examples. — Nael Shiab British singer Ed Sheeran can afford a private jet. But he recently explained in an online interview why he doesn't own one, and prefers to travel by train (hint: it has to do with his views on the environment), The Cool Down reports. Hotels have stringent hygiene protocols that require toiletries, even if they're unopened, to be thrown out at the end of a guest's stay, reports Reasons to be Cheerful. But a number of organizations now collect hotel soap, reprocessing it if necessary, and redistribute it to those in need, including Canada-based Soap for Hope. Artificial light is extending the growing season in cities. On average, it's more than 12 days earlier and 11 days later, according to a new study looking at 428 cities across the northern hemisphere, compared to surrounding rural locations. The extra time for trees and plants means they could potentially absorb more CO2, but the extended season means that they are also susceptible to frost damage and could disrupt pollinator patterns. Find out more in Nature Cities. The town of Adjuntas has Puerto Rico's first community-owned solar microgrid, putting an end to high electricity costs and regular blackouts. The Guardian takes us on a photo tour of the town. China is already the global leader in electric car production. could boost China's dominance even more. (Paywalled) Sask. company using flax waste to create sustainable cat litter The Regina Humane Society is partnering with Prairie Clean Energy (PCE) to introduce a locally made, environmentally friendly kitty litter made from flax straw. Prairie Clean Cat Litter is made entirely from flax straw, a waste product left over when flax is harvested. "It is completely biodegradable, completely natural, and it eliminates the cat pee smell," said Mark Cooper, CEO of PCE in Regina. "Your houses are going to smell cleaner, your cats are gonna be happier, you're gonna have less ammonia in your home, and it is all Saskatchewan-made flax." Cooper said the company was looking for innovative ways to recycle flax straw. "We really focus on stopping the burning of flax straw, creating new revenue streams for farmers processing that straw, and creating multiple product streams that we sell around the world, only one of which is cat litter, but it's an important one," he said. Its other products include flax fibre for making pulp and paper, biomass fuel pellets and animal bedding. Cooper said PCE has been working with the Humane Society for a year testing out the litter and received positive feedback. "Once they were satisfied that we had a good product on our hands," he said. "We started putting together a partnership that would make sense for them to help reduce their operational costs, and would connect the cats and cat people with a great litter option." Now when people adopt a cat from the humane society, they can also take some of the Prairie Clean Cat Litter home. It's not yet available in stores. "So we've really structured a partnership to benefit cats and the people that love their cats," Cooper said. Dr. Catherine Ball, director of veterinary care at the Regina Humane Society, said it used the litter for 40 cats. "We observed what happened with those cats, as well as with a similar group of cats that had clay litter, and we were able to find out that this product from PCE performed very well," she said. Traditional clay litters can get stuck onto the bottom of cats' paws. Ball said that happened less using the flax straw litter. According to the company's website, the flax absorbs liquids rather than clumps like clay litter. Cooper said the humane society adopts out 1,500 cats per year. "We know that those cats will be using our litter and that every single person who adopts a cat from the Humane Society will leave with a free bag," he said. "Our intention is to roll out this partnership to humane societies everywhere." — Darla Ponace
