Route-and-branch transit overhaul maps city's devolution
Opinion
10 Wolseley. 11 Portage. 12 William. 14 Ellice. 15 Mountain. 16 Osborne. 17 MacGregor. 18 Corydon. 19 Notre Dame. 20 Academy…
Until this week, I hadn't realized I could recite just about the full set of Winnipeg Transit routes and numbers by memory.
Alas, this newly discovered party trick is destined to go unused as we bury these routes with the streetcar tracks they were originally designed to follow, the veins through a city that are remnants of a time when a much more closely-packed citizenry all needed the same things, and all of which were available in the heart of the city.
JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES
The revamped routes seek to deliver better commute times and less waiting to transfer in an effort to draw more users, but the Transit overhaul fails to give dedicated car users reason to get out of their vehicles.
I have mixed feelings about this evolution.
Obviously, changes are needed to transit. Declining ridership and rising safety issues are clear indicators that it's not fulfilling its role of getting us where we need to go. But the days of jumping on the bus for all of our needs are behind us. Even if we wanted to go shopping downtown, we largely couldn't, as there's nowhere left to shop.
A short walk down Portage or Graham will yield empty shopfront after empty shopfront. The mammoth department stores of two generations ago are gone, and many of the destinations that would have drawn us are now parking lots haunted by the ghosts of Winnipeggers past and the cars of Winnipeg present.
I'm worried our transit overhaul reflects our devolution, instead of our evolution, as a city. It seems to be a reflection and acceptance of our problematic sprawl.
With nothing to bump into on the outside margins of our town, we have nothing stopping us from expanding ever outward, trenching new sewer lines and paving new roads while the older ones rot and crumble, building new houses while addresses in older neighbourhoods are left as burnt skeletons or piles of rubble for months on end.
Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around.
While in some ways this redesign feels like an admission of defeat, a commitment to a future of further sprawl, it does give hope that somewhere in Winnipeg, someone involved in planning is acknowledging we cannot go on just waiting for our boomtown days to come back while more and more of our citizenry are making homes along river banks.
Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around.
In a rare example of cross-sector co-ordination, there are a few examples of this novel forward-thinking mindset.
The city is looking at adding housing along the new 'spine' routes, even incorporating residential units into transit infrastructure.
The lofty plans for Graham Avenue — a pedestrian mall and shopping district — promise to bring people downtown to socialize, shop and dine. The new routes promise quicker commutes, better coverage and short waits for transfers — all good reasons to pull someone onto the bus who hasn't considered it in some time.
All in all, it's a noble effort to make a rare and radical change to Winnipeg's public services in an effort to actually serve the needs of the citizenry.
But it's not going to work.
These noble 'pull' reasons to take the bus will fail if there aren't balanced and co-ordinated 'push' incentives to get people out of their cars.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city.
We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city.
The fact we're still entertaining the thought of widening Kenaston Boulevard is clear communication from the city itself that we don't believe in public transit to move people. No, we must make way for more cars instead. It's cars that move people in Winnipeg. And it's cars that occupy the ever-expanding network of surface parking lots in our downtown: cheap, plentiful spaces have made driving to work easy and comfortable. Why would anyone take the bus where there is very little advantage?
Transit is not just failing because the product itself isn't working well. It's failing because our city has planned for it to fail. There is no outcome for transit, in the current design of this city, that will strengthen its utility and usage, because we haven't considered factors beyond the service itself.
It's clear the reliability and safety of transit must be improved, and some of that will be addressed by the changes that go into effect tomorrow, but until the infrastructure surrounding car use makes it preferable, I can't imagine I'll be memorizing many new route numbers.
rebecca.chambers@freepress.mb.ca
Rebecca Chambers
Rebecca explores what it means to be a Winnipegger by layering experiences and reactions to current events upon our unique and sometimes contentious history and culture. Her column appears alternating Saturdays.
Read full biography
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Route-and-branch transit overhaul maps city's devolution
Opinion 10 Wolseley. 11 Portage. 12 William. 14 Ellice. 15 Mountain. 16 Osborne. 17 MacGregor. 18 Corydon. 19 Notre Dame. 20 Academy… Until this week, I hadn't realized I could recite just about the full set of Winnipeg Transit routes and numbers by memory. Alas, this newly discovered party trick is destined to go unused as we bury these routes with the streetcar tracks they were originally designed to follow, the veins through a city that are remnants of a time when a much more closely-packed citizenry all needed the same things, and all of which were available in the heart of the city. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES The revamped routes seek to deliver better commute times and less waiting to transfer in an effort to draw more users, but the Transit overhaul fails to give dedicated car users reason to get out of their vehicles. I have mixed feelings about this evolution. Obviously, changes are needed to transit. Declining ridership and rising safety issues are clear indicators that it's not fulfilling its role of getting us where we need to go. But the days of jumping on the bus for all of our needs are behind us. Even if we wanted to go shopping downtown, we largely couldn't, as there's nowhere left to shop. A short walk down Portage or Graham will yield empty shopfront after empty shopfront. The mammoth department stores of two generations ago are gone, and many of the destinations that would have drawn us are now parking lots haunted by the ghosts of Winnipeggers past and the cars of Winnipeg present. I'm worried our transit overhaul reflects our devolution, instead of our evolution, as a city. It seems to be a reflection and acceptance of our problematic sprawl. With nothing to bump into on the outside margins of our town, we have nothing stopping us from expanding ever outward, trenching new sewer lines and paving new roads while the older ones rot and crumble, building new houses while addresses in older neighbourhoods are left as burnt skeletons or piles of rubble for months on end. Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around. While in some ways this redesign feels like an admission of defeat, a commitment to a future of further sprawl, it does give hope that somewhere in Winnipeg, someone involved in planning is acknowledging we cannot go on just waiting for our boomtown days to come back while more and more of our citizenry are making homes along river banks. Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around. In a rare example of cross-sector co-ordination, there are a few examples of this novel forward-thinking mindset. The city is looking at adding housing along the new 'spine' routes, even incorporating residential units into transit infrastructure. The lofty plans for Graham Avenue — a pedestrian mall and shopping district — promise to bring people downtown to socialize, shop and dine. The new routes promise quicker commutes, better coverage and short waits for transfers — all good reasons to pull someone onto the bus who hasn't considered it in some time. All in all, it's a noble effort to make a rare and radical change to Winnipeg's public services in an effort to actually serve the needs of the citizenry. But it's not going to work. These noble 'pull' reasons to take the bus will fail if there aren't balanced and co-ordinated 'push' incentives to get people out of their cars. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city. We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city. The fact we're still entertaining the thought of widening Kenaston Boulevard is clear communication from the city itself that we don't believe in public transit to move people. No, we must make way for more cars instead. It's cars that move people in Winnipeg. And it's cars that occupy the ever-expanding network of surface parking lots in our downtown: cheap, plentiful spaces have made driving to work easy and comfortable. Why would anyone take the bus where there is very little advantage? Transit is not just failing because the product itself isn't working well. It's failing because our city has planned for it to fail. There is no outcome for transit, in the current design of this city, that will strengthen its utility and usage, because we haven't considered factors beyond the service itself. It's clear the reliability and safety of transit must be improved, and some of that will be addressed by the changes that go into effect tomorrow, but until the infrastructure surrounding car use makes it preferable, I can't imagine I'll be memorizing many new route numbers. Rebecca Chambers Rebecca explores what it means to be a Winnipegger by layering experiences and reactions to current events upon our unique and sometimes contentious history and culture. Her column appears alternating Saturdays. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Global News
2 days ago
- Global News
Decades after closure, Winnipeg's iconic intersection opens to pedestrians once more
It's been more than four and a half decades, but an intersection known in popular myth as Canada's coldest and windiest is finally reopening to pedestrian traffic. The iconic corner of Portage Avenue and Main Street in Winnipeg opens to foot traffic Friday morning, after a long and tumultuous journey, with plenty of controversy, leading up to this point. Portage and Main has played host to some key parts of the city's history, from indelible moments during the deadly Winnipeg General Strike of 1919, to the Winnipeg Jets signing future Hall of Famer Dale Hawerchuk there in 1981. Looking west on Portage Avenue prior to the opening of the Portage and Main underground pedestrian concourse on February 23, 1979. (Photo courtesy of the City of Winnipeg Archives.). Photo courtesy of the City of Winnipeg Archives.' The iconic intersection was initially closed to foot traffic in the late 1970s with the creation of the underground concourse linking four corner properties. A 40-year deal to permanently close Portage and Main to pedestrians came into effect around 1978. Story continues below advertisement The idea of potentially reopening the intersection has been a near-constant topic of conversation in Winnipeg ever since — coming to head when then-mayor Brian Bowman, who originally campaigned on reopening the famous intersection, issued a plebiscite on the matter as part of the 2018 civic election, coinciding with the expiration of the city's 40-year pact. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy That plebiscite led to a split among Winnipeggers — divided almost 65/35 — in favour of keeping the intersection vehicles-only, although later reports showed that the vast majority of the 'no' voters were those whose commute took them through the intersection, but didn't live in the immediate area. Those who lived nearby were overwhelmingly in support of pedestrian access. Winnipeg mayor Scott Gillingham, who admitted to being in favour of keeping the intersection closed to pedestrians during the plebiscite — when he was a city councillor — announced in March of 2024 that he'd had a change of heart, after a city report about the costs of replacing the waterproof membrane that protects the underground pedestrian concourse. Story continues below advertisement Gillingham said in 2024 that much more information about the state of the intersection had become available in the years since the plebiscite, and suggested many Winnipeggers might have voted 'yes' on opening Portage and Main had they known more details at the time. Council voted 'yes' to reopening the iconic intersection to pedestrians later that month, with the plan to coincide with the city's overhauled transit system, which launches this Sunday. Winnipeg launched additional pedestrian amenities earlier this week — starting the process to convert a stretch of downtown's Graham Avenue, previously a busy transit route, into a pedestrian and cyclist-friendly 'placemaking project'.
Winnipeg Free Press
4 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Long-awaited Winnipeg Transit network overhaul goes live Sunday
Winnipeg's bus network will undergo a massive one-day transformation on Sunday that alters virtually every route. A transit advocate expects Winnipeggers will benefit from the changes overall, especially the fact many more routes will see buses arrive every 15 minutes or less. 'Winnipeg absolutely deserves and needs the service improvements that this offers…. We're going to be able to go from one route to another with frequent service and that is a game-changer for reliability and consistency,' said Kyle Owens, president of Functional Transit Winnipeg. Ruth Bonneville / Free Press Student Winner Ninah at the bus stop on Portage Ave. at Polo Park Tuesday. Winnipeg's bus network will undergo a massive one-day transformation on Sunday that alters virtually every route. The network will use a spine-and-feeder concept, where direct spines along major corridors are supported by a network of feeder routes. Owens said some feeder routes have shorter operating hours than the main lines they connect to, which could prevent riders who return home in the late evening from transferring to the same route they used earlier in the day. 'Although the city is providing on-demand service to cover a lot of those gaps, that is an extra step that a lot of people may not have used before…. That has the potential to be very frustrating and confusing,' said Owens. Two Winnipeg Transit riders the Free Press spoke with Tuesday expressed concerns about the route overhaul. Winner Nnah, a recent graduate of Technical Vocational High School, believes the changes will take a while to get used to. 'I feel like everything was a bit too sudden,' said Nnah. 'I have to check the new schedules and times they posted on the app and do a lot of planning on my phone, so it will definitely take time to learn.' He said the lack of consistency with the revamped route scheduling will also cause him to walk close to 10 minutes some days. 'In the wintertime, that's obviously not ideal,' he said. Colleen Freund, a downtown employee, isn't convinced the major route changes are needed. 'It's not broken, so don't fix it,' Freund said. 'I'm not keen on this change.' Freund, a daily bus user from Transcona, said Transit added more stops to her route, so it will take longer to get to work. To call attention to the new network, the city posted schedules online May 1, so riders could start virtually planning trips. Winnipeg Transit also provided question-and-answer sessions for bus drivers, met with community groups, distributed cards with QR codes linked to route information, took out ads and posted signs explaining the changes at every bus stop throughout the city, said Bjorn Radstrom, Transit's manager of service development. 'Our biggest marketing push was actually changing every single bus stop sign in the city and that is what caught people's attention. Whenever we put up a new sign, there was also a notice board underneath that explained the routes,' said Radstrom. Riders will need to adjust their bus stops, as well, since the change will reduce the total number from 5,200 to 4,000, as the city amalgamates and repositions them, he said. Radstrom said Transit considered enacting the overhaul in phases but feared that would have been more difficult for riders. 'The route network is just so intertwined from neighbourhood to neighbourhood… it would've been incredibly confusing for everybody,' he said. The new network is designed to be more reliable and easier to navigate, while main routes should allow Winnipeggers to wait less time for their next bus to arrive, he said. As the new routes begin Sunday, about seven or eight 'travel trainers' and 30 other Transit staff will be posted along main routes and stops, he said. 'It's a massive learning curve and people are going to need help, so we'll be out there to answer questions,' said Radstrom. He urged bus riders to plan out routes ahead through Winnipeg Transit's website and app, noting people can also get printed route maps at Transit customer service centres or call 311 for help planning their routes. The head of council's public works committee said she expects Transit is about to become more convenient for many Winnipeggers. 'People are very concerned about the transfers but… you get on your feeder route to get you to your spine — the main line — and then it's just minutes (to get the next bus),' said Coun. Janice Lukes. Lukes (Waverley West) said extra 311 operators will work Sunday to help address any concerns. 'We can't flip an entire network and expect perfection, but people need to remember the goal is to provide efficient, convenient transit service,' she said. Chris Scott, president of the Amalgamated Transit Union Local 1505, said bus drivers are generally ready for the new network and Winnipeg Transit has done 'just about everything they can' to prepare the public. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. However, Scott asked riders to remember that the routes are new to drivers, too. 'We just ask for patience with the riding public. We're growing with this new system the same as they are,' he said. — With files from Massimo De Luca-Taronno X: @joyanne_pursaga Joyanne PursagaReporter Joyanne is city hall reporter for the Winnipeg Free Press. A reporter since 2004, she began covering politics exclusively in 2012, writing on city hall and the Manitoba Legislature for the Winnipeg Sun before joining the Free Press in early 2020. Read more about Joyanne. Every piece of reporting Joyanne produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
