Day two of testimony underway for Shawn Cranston murder trial
On Tuesday, a state police forensic DNA analyst testified that the DNA found on that rubber-like material is 790 septillion times more likely to be Shawn Cranston's. That's 790 with 24 zeros after it. The DNA expert said anything over 1,000 is considered strong.
About 25 members of the Amish community filled the courtroom while only three people were sitting in the area designed for Craston's family and friends.
The most emotional testimony came from Julie Warner, Andy and Rebekah Byler's primary driver.
She testified that on February 26, she dropped Andy off at his home on Fish Flats Road just a little after noon. He went to his house, and she went to the barn to use the restroom.
Moments later, Warner said Andy came running to the barn, he was frantic, and said someone had killed his wife. He then ran to her truck and 'lost it.'
Warner told Andy he needed to go into the house and get the kids out, but he said he couldn't.
Warner knew she couldn't leave the kids in the house alone with their mother if she was dead or injured, so she was going to go in and get them. That's when she saw Rebekah's body and called 911.
That call was played for the jury — Warner was heard saying, 'She's lying on the floor. I don't know if she's alive. Should I go in and check on her?'
The dispatcher told Warner to go inside and see if she's beyond medical help. Warner is then heard saying, 'There's a big pool of blood. Blood coming out of her nose and ears and it looks like her throat was slit.'
The 911 dispatcher asked if Rebecka's body was cold. Warner said, 'I don't know, I didn't touch her.' Warner then touched her leg and said it 'was cold.'
While the 911 call was being played, many Amish sat in the courtroom, leaning forward with their heads in their hands. Some were crying and wiping away tears.
Meanwhile, Cranston sat at the defense table, showing no emotion.
Jurors also saw key pieces of evidence, like tires and shoes, that prosecutors said put Cranston at Byler's house the day of the murder.
The jury also saw efforts to allegedly destroy evidence at Shawn Cranstons' home. There was also expert testimony from a forensic DNA analyst, along with a forensic serologist, which is someone who studies blood and other body fluids.
Cranston is facing charges of criminal homicide, criminal homicide of an unborn child, burglary, and criminal trespass.
Testimony will continue on Wednesday,
Related Stories:
Trial begins for man accused of murdering pregnant Amish woman
Trial for man accused of killing pregnant Amish woman pushed to 2025
2024 Amish murder case transferred to Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office
New information takes center stage in Rebekah Byler murder trial
Daughter of arrested suspect reacts to pregnant Amish woman murder case
List of seized items released in pregnant Amish woman homicide case
Murdered Amish woman suffered injuries to head, neck: investigators
Community remains in shock following Amish woman's death, Corry man's arrest
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Confusion Mounts As Conflicting Statements Emerge In Malcolm-Jamal Warner's Death
Conflicting accounts are surfacing in the aftermath of 's tragic death in Costa Rica, with a local police chief standing firm on his claim that the beloved actor drowned while trying to save his young daughter. Warner, best known for his role as Theo Huxtable on "The Cosby Show," died on July 20 at age 54 after being caught in a powerful rip current while swimming off Cocles Beach in Limón. Initial reports from authorities indicated that Malcolm-Jamal Warner had been in the water with his eight-year-old daughter when the tragedy struck, and that surfers rushed to help bring them to shore. Police Chief Doubles Down On Malcolm-Jamal Warner Claim Now, Elberth León, Chief of the Tourist Police of the Atlantic Region, is doubling down on that version of events despite conflicting statements from Costa Rica's Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ). 'I responded to the incident and I know what I saw,' León told Us Weekly on July 28. 'The Red Cross also treated the girl [on site] and she didn't need to go to the clinic.' However, the OIJ released a separate account last Thursday, saying Warner's daughter was not in the water at the time of his drowning. 'Mr. Warner was playing with his daughter at the seashore at one point. He then left her out of the water, and he and a friend of his entered the sea,' their statement read. 'It was at that moment that they were swept away by the current, and the friend managed to get out. However, Mr. Warner was unable to get out and was pulled out by several people on the beach.' His Cause Of Death Revealed Red Cross officials confirmed they treated two adult men who were pulled from the water that day. One was transported in critical condition to a nearby clinic, while Warner was given CPR on the beach but tragically pronounced dead at the scene. The OIJ later confirmed Warner's autopsy was completed on July 22, ruling his cause of death as 'asphyxia due to submersion.' His death has been classified as accidental. Bill Cosby Recalls Malcolm-Jamal Warner's Work Ethic In Resurfaced Interview In a resurfaced interview with CBS News' Jericka Duncan, Bill Cosby praised Warner's dedication to his craft, remembering the late actor as someone who always took his work seriously. 'He was never afraid to go to his room and study and make sure he followed whatever he had learned in the acting school he went to,' Cosby recalled. Warner himself often spoke about the significance, and later the loss, of "The Cosby Show"'s cultural weight. In a 2015 interview with the Associated Press, amid the sexual assault allegations against Cosby, Warner admitted he was heartbroken by the show's fall from grace. 'The fact that we no longer have that, that's the thing that saddens me the most because in a few generations the Huxtables will have been just a fairy tale,' he said at the time. Years later, Warner doubled down on that sentiment in an interview with CBS News Pittsburgh, reflecting on the show's enduring global reach. 'That show had such an impact on the culture here in America but also a global impact on how, you know, Black people saw ourselves globally and how the rest of the world saw us,' Warner explained. 'So I'm proud to have been part of that legacy, and it's been a great ride ever since.' Angelique Bates Heartbroken Over Her Former Co-Star's Death Actress Angelique Bates has shared an emotional tribute to Warner, exclusively telling The Blast that the late actor was her 'only true hero' in Hollywood. Bates reflected on how Warner's kindness and courage left a lasting mark on her life, especially during a difficult period in her childhood acting career. She said the news of his sudden passing at 54 has left her heartbroken. "This morning, I woke up to the devastating news that I've lost the only true hero I've ever had in this twisted industry," she expressed. " I still can't believe I'm even writing these words. Malcolm-Jamal Warner's name is the very last one I ever imagined hearing in this context." Raven-Symoné Pays Heartfelt Tribute To Malcolm-Jamal Warner Raven-Symoné is also grieving the loss of her former "Cosby Show" co-star, Warner. On July 22, the actress, 39, shared a simple yet powerful tribute on Instagram, posting a black screen with the words 'I love you' alongside a dove emoji. The understated message spoke volumes, reflecting the deep bond she shared with Warner and the heartbreak she feels in the wake of his sudden passing. RIP.
New York Post
2 days ago
- New York Post
NY cops on hunt for stolen horse as they worry it might break its diet — with deadly consequences
There's a horse thief on the loose. New York State police launched a search for a horse named Koda that was stolen from an upstate farm last week — and has 'special dietary restrictions' that could spell his demise if he's not found soon. ''Koda' is a neutered male, called a gelding,' troopers said in a press release Wednesday. 'He is a flea-bitten grey color, which means he is grey with flecks of red and has a darker muzzle. 3 State police said Koda the horse was stolen from a farm in the upstate town of Union on July 24 or 25. New York State Police 'Koda's owners are also concerned about him because he has special dietary restrictions.' The horse was plucked from an enclosure in the farm in the Endicott and Union area, police said. Koda has two brands that could help identify him — a Roman letter L that resembles an upside Y on the front left shoulder, and an arrow pointing upward with a line underneath on the rear left flank. Troopers believe the horse was stolen on July 23 or 24 from the fenced-in property on Struble Road in the town of Union. 3 Koda has two brands, including this one on the left rear flank, according to police. 3 Koda, a horse stolen from an upstate farm last week, has a second brand in the right front shoulder. Anyone with information should call police at 607-561-7400, and cite case NY2500671337. Although it sounds like the Wild West, horse thieves still make off with four-legged booty now and again — including an Amish horse and buggy snatched from a Michigan Walmart last year. In 2023, a trio of teens riding stolen horses rode into a tragic traffic mishap that left one boy and two of the horses dead near a Dallas, Texas freeway. And in 2025 in St. Petersburg, Florida, a stolen championship horse was not only stolen, but later butchered before the owners could track down the gelding.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Costa Rican Police Chief Stands by Statement That Malcolm J. Warner Tried to Save Daughter
A Costa Rican police chief is standing by his statement regarding the moments that led up to Malcolm-Jamal Warner's death, insisting the late actor's daughter was in the water at the time of his drowning and that the actor tried to save her. 'I responded to the incident and I know what I saw,' Elberth León, Chief of the Tourist Police of the Atlantic Region, exclusively told Us Weekly. 'The Red Cross also treated the girl [on site] and she didn't need to go to the clinic.' According to information from the Regional Subdelegation of Bribri of the Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ), obtained by Us on Saturday, July 27, the agency is contesting the police chief's statements. 'It appears that at one point, Mr. Warner was playing with his daughter at the shoreline,' the agency claimed in part. 'He later left her out of the water and supposedly entered the sea along with a friend. It was at that moment that the current pulled them in; the friend managed to get out, but unfortunately, Mr. Warner did not.' Malcolm-Jamal Warner Was Trying to Save His Daughter From Riptide Before Drowning, Police Say According to the OIJ, the late actor was 'pulled from the water by several people who were on the beach,' received immediate medical attention from Red Cross personnel but was ultimately declared 'dead at the scene.' The OIJ's account of the incident was first reported by several outlets on Thursday, July 24. 'I don't know why the OIJ is saying that, since they weren't present at the scene,' León told Us of the agency's conclusion. 'They interviewed Malcom's family, but they also weren't there at the time of the accident.' The Costa Rica Red Cross confirmed to Us on July 21 that emergency personnel attended to two adult male patients near Cocles, a beach in Limon, Costa Rica, after they were caught by a high current in the water. One man was transported in critical condition to the local clinic, while CPR was performed on Warner at the scene. The Cosby Show alum was pronounced dead shortly after. He was 54. The second individual was later discharged, according to local authorities. The OIJ confirmed that Warner's autopsy was completed on July 22. The late actor's cause of death was ruled as "asphyxia due to submersion.' His death was ruled accidental. León told Us on Thursday that both Warner and his daughter were in the water when they were 'dragged by the current.' 'They were bathing together and were caught by a rip current,' he said. 'Obviously, as a father, he fought for his daughter, but the current in that area is very strong, and they couldn't accomplish the objective.' Doctor Who Attempted to Save Malcolm-Jamal Warner Speaks Out for the 1st Time He continued, 'Two people who were there at the location went in with a surfboard and a boogie board to help rescue the people who were caught in the current. They managed to stay with the girl, managed to get her onto the board, but due to the strength of the current, one of them, from Nicaragua, had to let go of the board and push it toward the shore so the girl could make it to land or the coast.' Despite the OIJ's conflicting report, León told Us he doesn't see any issue with his version of the tragic events because 'it's the truth about what happened.' 'I feel the OIJ failed to interview the Police and the Red Cross, and those are crucial interviews that should be part of any investigation,' he continued. 'But sometimes, for all kinds of reasons, they don't do them.' OIJ journalist Pablo Alvarado claimed to Us on Saturday that the agency's officers did include interviews with several eyewitnesses at the scene and that their report reflects 'the hypothesis currently being considered regarding how the events may have occurred.' According to Alvarado, the 'report will be submitted to the public Prosecutor's Office in the coming days.' 'The people who were involved are being interviewed,' he said, adding that the report includes accounts from the police, eye witnesses and members of the Red Cross. Solve the daily Crossword
