Dorcha Lee: Israel lets Trump take charge in Gaza talks
But this gesture from Netanyahu is all about Trump's declaration, last week, that he wants agreement this week on a 60 day ceasefire in Gaza.
It means that, this time, Netanyahu may not jeopardise the ceasefire agreement by introducing last minute additional pre-conditions to stall the US plan. It is also an Israeli acknowledgement that 'Daddy' Trump is in charge of the process.
During the recent Nato Summit, Nato secretary general Mark Rutte's sycophantic reference to Trump as 'Daddy', was a bit weird, but, in a strange way, appropriate. The reality is that the former real estate man in the White House, is not just 'primus inter pares', in Washington DC, he is also first among equals everywhere, as the Americans say, period.
Things are moving fast. As before, the US cleared the latest revised text of the ceasefire agreement proposals with the Israelis, which was passed on to Hamas. Hamas basically accepted the proposals with three reservations. First, they want a guarantee that Israel would not delay the negotiations as an excuse to resume the war. Secondly, they want the UN back in the role of humanitarian aid without the flow of aid being controlled by Israel. Thirdly, they want the IDF to withdraw to the positions they held before the ceasefire ended in March.
Fresh from receiving the 2024 Tipperary Peace Award, in Ballykisteen, Co Tipperary, Sheik Mohammed Al Thani, prime minister of Qatar, is now back in Doha, in charge of the Israel-Hamas peace process.
The Qataris signalled last Tuesday that they will need more time to bridge the gaps between both sides on the US proposals. On Friday, they proposed this Sunday as the deadline to conclude the agreement.
The objective is to get the framework for the agreement agreed this week, so that proximity talks on the truce can begin next week. Proximity talks are where the belligerents do not meet face-to-face but where a third party passes messages between them.
One technical point that remains unclear is whether US special envoy Steve Witkoff's proposals are
considered to be a fresh start in the talks, or the continuation of the ceasefire suspended in March. These 13-point proposals were outlined in the Examiner's previous analysis, on June 19.
Before going further on the ceasefire agreement, an update on the military situation will help to understand the context.
The IDF has an estimated 30,000 to 50,000 personnel committed to the Gaza operation. The IDF main formations are three to five mixed armour/mechanised infantry divisions, reinforced with specialist units, including combat engineering companies able to fight underground. They are mostly regulars and comprise the main fighting units of the regular army. This commitment would limit any additional extended operation by Israel, in Lebanon or Syria, at least for the time being.
The IDF ground offensive, which began with the objective of reoccupying 75% of Gaza, has reached the 65% target. Unlike previous ground operations, they are systematically neutralising selected sections of the tunnels' system. Probably for the first time in the war, the IDF is manoeuvring underground in synchronisation with the above ground offensive. However, the tunnels are turning out to be far more extensive and deeper than previously estimated. To destroy them all is now estimated to take many years.
Air support is being directed at Hamas fighters who appear on the surface, but also at suspect concentrations of civilians close to the IDF advance. The IDF action is mainly in Central and South Gaza, up to about the week before last, when they advanced into the North at Jabalia.
On Monday, the ultraorthodox Yehuda Battalion lost 5 KIA (killed in action)+ 14 WIA (wounded inaction) by a roadside bomb in Northern Gaza. Last week, a Hamas fighter managed to open the back door of an IDF armoured personnel carrier, throw in an explosive device, and close the door. Seven IDF soldiers were killed. The door was secured only by a rope, which seriously questions the issue of the maintenance of Israeli fighting vehicles.
In late January, before he left the Middle East, yesterday's man, former US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, made a seemingly casual observation, which contradicted IDF claims that Hamas was effectively degraded. Blinken said that Hamas had already replaced almost all their casualties. During the subsequent ceasefire (Phase 1), Hamas had ample opportunity to restore their losses. This means that they are probably back up to a strength estimated at 25,000.
US president Donald Trump with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House in April. Picture: Mark Schiefelbein/AP
Hamas fighters are unable to move about as easily in the tunnels systems as heretofore. They must be short of ammunition although they can decant explosive material from the numerous unexploded shells lying about. The simplest roadside bomb consists of an unexploded shell and a detonator.
The Israeli objective in breaking the ceasefire in March was to degrade Hamas's military capabilities and disrupt their ability to govern the enclave.
The combination of the disruption of communications ,and the reoccupying of urban areas of Gaza by the IDF, will effectively remove Hamas's ability to govern Gaza, but they can still fight on in small but uncoordinated units.
However, while Israeli officials are negotiating in Doha, the hawks back in Jerusalem are talking about Israel governing Gaza for the immediate future. This means that the IDF's presence in Gaza will be prolonged indefinitely.
By yesterday morning, the two main issues unresolved are: who will organise the humanitarian aid distribution, and, to what extent will the IDF withdraw from Gaza?
The gap between both sides on these issues is wide and may stall the talks for some more days. US Envoy Witkoff's return to Doha has been delayed. When the gap has narrowed, the plan is for Witkoff to return and bring the agreement across the line. American diplomacy takes a leaf from those Western movies, where, just when the cowboys are about to be massacred by the Indians, the US Cavalry (Witkoff, Trump's representative on Earth) comes to the rescue.
But who will supervise the ceasefire and the 60-day truce? Governance of Gaza by Israel will lead to martial law implemented by the IDF. With over 57,800 dead, of which 85% to 90% are innocent civilians, are we now to witness another Srebrenica as the 25,000 Hamas fighters emerge from the catacombs into the daylight? Up to now the Israelis have never agreed to a peacekeeping mission for Gaza, but Trump could persuade them, especially if US troops participate. Watch this space.
Dorcha Lee is a retired army colonel and defence analyst, with extensive experience of UN peacekeeping in the Middle East.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
24 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Trump envoy arrives in Kyiv as US pledges Patriot missiles to Ukraine
US president Donald Trump's special envoy to Ukraine and Russia has arrived in Kyiv, a senior Ukrainian official said, as anticipation grew over possible changes in the Trump administration's policies on the more than three-year war. Mr Trump teased last week that he would make a 'major statement' on Russia on Monday. The president made quickly stopping the war one of his diplomatic priorities, and has increasingly expressed frustration about Russian president Vladimir Putin's unbudging stance. US president Donald Trump confirmed America was sending Ukraine Patriot air defence missiles to help it fend off Russia's intensifying aerial attacks (Jacquelyn Martin/AP) Mr Putin 'talks nice and then he bombs everybody', Mr Trump said late on Sunday, as he confirmed America was sending Ukraine badly needed US-made Patriot air defence missiles to help it fend off Russia's intensifying aerial attacks. A top ally of Mr Trump, Republican senator Lindsey Graham, said on Sunday that the conflict was nearing an inflection point as Mr Trump showed growing interest in helping Ukraine fight back against Russia's full-scale invasion. It was a cause that Mr Trump had previously dismissed as being a waste of US taxpayer money. Meanwhile, Nato Secretary-General Mark Rutte was due in Washington on Monday and Tuesday. He planned to hold talks with Mr Trump, secretary of state Marco Rubio and defence secretary Pete Hegseth as well as members of Congress. Talks during the visit by Mr Trump's special envoy to Ukraine and Russia, retired general Keith Kellogg, would cover 'defence, strengthening security, weapons, sanctions, protection of our people and enhancing co-operation between Ukraine and the United States', the head of Ukraine's presidential office, Andrii Yermak, said. 'Russia does not want a ceasefire. Peace through strength is President Donald Trump's principle, and we support this approach,' Mr Yermak said.
RTÉ News
37 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Irish missionary recalls effort to close naval base in Philippines over abuse
One of the last remaining Irish missionaries has spoken of his work in the Philippines where he has been since the 1960s. Fr Shay Cullen set up the Preda Foundation to rescue children from exploitation in the Philippines 50 years ago. The four-time Nobel Peace Prize nominee features in the RTÉ documentary 'The Last Irish Missionaries', which charts the history of the Irish missionary movement. At the peak of the Irish missionary movement, in the 1960s, over 6,000 Irish Catholic missionaries were dispersed to over 80 countries. Now, with vocations evaporating and the last Irish missionaries ageing and dying, the movement is coming to a close. Ahead of the broadcast of the documentary's first episode, Fr Cullen said his organisation in the Philippines is still working to help the victims of sexual exploitation, some as young as six years old. He said they bring court cases against abusers, many of whom are relatives of the children. "We were quite successful in healing the kids through our emotional release therapy, which is a very healing process," he said, adding "the kids become very self-confident, very outspoken". The children, he said, "want to get justice". "So they testify in the court and we win," he said. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Fr Cullen said that the organisation secured 27 convictions last year, adding that up to July, the foundation reached "another 112 already". He said there is another programme for boys, who are rescued from prison. The missionary said the Juvenile Justice Welfare Act was passed after a ten-year campaign. Fr Cullen explained that he also campaigned for a US naval base in the Philippines to be closed after he discovered a child sex syndicate linked to its Navy personnel. "I exposed this in a newspaper at that time because we didn't have facilities and the city covered it all up," he said. "So, I broke the news. It became an international story and that began an awareness," he added. Fr Cullen said he was going to be deported and was threatened that the children's homes would be closed. He said in the aftermath, he was threatened with deportation and the closure of his children's home. The missionary said he subsequently suggested he military base be converted to an economic zone. This started a campaign and eight years later the Philippine Senate closed the base, he said, calling it a "big success". He said "all those women, 1,000 women in the sex industry" were all freed. He added that such women "were in debt bondage" and "could never leave" until the campaign. Broadcaster Bryan Dobson, who so-presents the documentary, said he was drawn to the project because like everybody in Ireland he grew up being aware of the Irish missionary story. Speaking on the same programme, he said the missionaries are described as "the best of us". He said Fr Cullen "really exemplifies part of this extraordinary Irish missionary story". Mr Dobson said at its height, the missionary movement's "numbers were enormous", adding that "something like 6,000 or 7,000" people were involved. He said "hundreds of young men and women every year" through the 1950s and the 1960s went into missionary orders. Such people, he said, were then "dispatched to the Philippines or east Africa or wherever it might be, South America". "So, I was fascinated to find out what motivated them, what drove them," he said. "The sense of vocation they had, that's clearly the case," he added.
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Israeli drone strike on Gaza kills eight children at a water point
A DRONE STRIKE at a refugee camp in Gaza killed ten people, including eight children, who were collecting water earlier yesterday. Israel's military admitted to the incident at the Nuseirat camp, claiming a technical error caused munitions to fall 'dozes of metres from the target'. More than 40 people were killed by Israeli strikes yesterday in Gaza . Despite previous positive pronouncements claiming ceasefire talks between Israel and militant group Hamas were progressing, the negotiations have now all but stalled. Delegations have spent a week trying to reach a truce agreement. Advertisement There was no immediate sign an end to the fighting was near. Strikes across the Gaza killed at least 43 people yesterday, including 11 at a Gaza City market, the region's civil defence agency said. The Israeli military, which has recently intensified operations across Gaza, said that in the past 24 hours the air force 'struck more than 150 terror targets'. It released aerial footage of what it said were fighter jet strikes attacking Hamas targets around Beit Hanoun, in northern Gaza, showing explosions on the ground and thick smoke in the sky. More than 58,000 people, most of them civilians, have been killed by Israel's counteroffensive on Gaza following an attack by Hamas in October 2023. - © AFP 2025
