Why are Italy's left-wing parties struggling to win support?
The prime minister herself tops polls of party leaders with an approval rating of 45 percent, according to Ipsos.
The traditional left is struggling across Europe, where populist parties – particularly the far right – have gained ground in recent years.
And in Italy, which once had Western Europe's largest Communist Party, "there is a crisis in the left", commented Paolo Borioni, professor of political science at Rome's Sapienza University.
He said left-wing parties had "severed their historical class ties", notably with those on lower incomes.
The opposition is dominated by the centre-left Democratic Party (PD), currently polling at around 22 percent, and the Five Star Movement, with around 13 percent.
Marc Lazar, a professor at Sciences Po Paris and Luiss University in Rome, said both are paying the price for their record in government, where they "disappointed" as they "did not address social issues."
The PD adopted several measures that liberalised the labour market and cut public spending while in power after the 2013 election. Since then, they have lost over three million votes.
For its part, the Five Star triumphed in 2018 elections on an anti-establishment message, only to ally with its declared enemies while in government.
Gaza, Ukraine
The PD chose a new leader after the 2022 elections, Elly Schlein, who has tacked further left, championing a national minimum wage and increased spending on education and healthcare.
The Five Star under former premier Giuseppe Conte is also pushing for a minimum wage and a basic income for the most vulnerable.
"Meloni, like all the right, claims to defend the people but only defends the big hedge funds, the big banks," Riccardo Ricciardi, president of the Five Star parliamentary group in the Chamber of Deputies, told AFP.
Both parties have also sought to mobilise public concern about rising defence budgets and Israel's offensive in Gaza.
Five Star threw its weight behind a large protest in Rome last month against rearmament, an issue that Lazar noted "poses a challenge to Giorgia Meloni" in a country with a long tradition of peace movements.
But divisions on the issue within the PD have undermined the opposition's ability to attack the government.
Both the PD and Five Star also backed a huge protest on Gaza, but some PD supporters accused Schlein of being slow to take up the issue.
"They lack courage," lamented Arianna D'Archivio, a 23-year-old student organiser at the rearmament protest.
A third large demonstration took place for Pride, an explicit challenge to Meloni's socially conservative agenda.
Vote alliances
Meloni shares government with the smaller far-right League party and the centre-right Forza Italia, which gives her a majority in parliament.
Despite their differences, PD and Five Star have tried teaming up at the ballot box, with joint candidates winning regional elections in Emilia-Romagna and Umbria in 2024, as well as the northern city of Genoa in May.
They also both supported a recent referendum on labour market reform, although it failed due to low turnout.
Schlein insisted the PD was making progress.
"We will happily leave the polls to Meloni's right, but we are winning elections," she told AFP at a recent event.
The PD performed better than expected in last year's European Parliament elections, winning 24 percent of the vote, compared to 29 percent for Meloni's party – but with a historically low turnout.
Disconnected
For Dario Salvetti, an auto industry worker from Florence, the left is "broken" and "disconnected from the masses" in a country where salaries have been stalled for decades and one in ten Italians is classified as living in poverty.
For analyst Borioni, there is "no rightward shift in the population in Italy," just more people are abandoning the left.
Activists meanwhile see the problem as politics, not the left itself.
Francesca Ciuffi, a 27-year-old trade unionist in the textile hub of Prato, noted their recent successes in improving conditions for workers following strikes.
"The big unions and left-wing parties have abandoned their role," she said.
By AFP's Piera ROCCO DI TORREPADULA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Italy
17-07-2025
- Local Italy
Why are Italy's left-wing parties struggling to win support?
Almost three years after its historic election victory, Meloni's far-right Brothers of Italy party remains the most popular, polling at 29 percent – above the 26 percent it secured in the September 2022 vote, according to the latest YouTrend survey. The prime minister herself tops polls of party leaders with an approval rating of 45 percent, according to Ipsos. The traditional left is struggling across Europe, where populist parties – particularly the far right – have gained ground in recent years. And in Italy, which once had Western Europe's largest Communist Party, "there is a crisis in the left", commented Paolo Borioni, professor of political science at Rome's Sapienza University. He said left-wing parties had "severed their historical class ties", notably with those on lower incomes. The opposition is dominated by the centre-left Democratic Party (PD), currently polling at around 22 percent, and the Five Star Movement, with around 13 percent. Marc Lazar, a professor at Sciences Po Paris and Luiss University in Rome, said both are paying the price for their record in government, where they "disappointed" as they "did not address social issues." The PD adopted several measures that liberalised the labour market and cut public spending while in power after the 2013 election. Since then, they have lost over three million votes. For its part, the Five Star triumphed in 2018 elections on an anti-establishment message, only to ally with its declared enemies while in government. Gaza, Ukraine The PD chose a new leader after the 2022 elections, Elly Schlein, who has tacked further left, championing a national minimum wage and increased spending on education and healthcare. The Five Star under former premier Giuseppe Conte is also pushing for a minimum wage and a basic income for the most vulnerable. "Meloni, like all the right, claims to defend the people but only defends the big hedge funds, the big banks," Riccardo Ricciardi, president of the Five Star parliamentary group in the Chamber of Deputies, told AFP. Both parties have also sought to mobilise public concern about rising defence budgets and Israel's offensive in Gaza. Five Star threw its weight behind a large protest in Rome last month against rearmament, an issue that Lazar noted "poses a challenge to Giorgia Meloni" in a country with a long tradition of peace movements. But divisions on the issue within the PD have undermined the opposition's ability to attack the government. Both the PD and Five Star also backed a huge protest on Gaza, but some PD supporters accused Schlein of being slow to take up the issue. "They lack courage," lamented Arianna D'Archivio, a 23-year-old student organiser at the rearmament protest. A third large demonstration took place for Pride, an explicit challenge to Meloni's socially conservative agenda. Vote alliances Meloni shares government with the smaller far-right League party and the centre-right Forza Italia, which gives her a majority in parliament. Despite their differences, PD and Five Star have tried teaming up at the ballot box, with joint candidates winning regional elections in Emilia-Romagna and Umbria in 2024, as well as the northern city of Genoa in May. They also both supported a recent referendum on labour market reform, although it failed due to low turnout. Schlein insisted the PD was making progress. "We will happily leave the polls to Meloni's right, but we are winning elections," she told AFP at a recent event. The PD performed better than expected in last year's European Parliament elections, winning 24 percent of the vote, compared to 29 percent for Meloni's party – but with a historically low turnout. Disconnected For Dario Salvetti, an auto industry worker from Florence, the left is "broken" and "disconnected from the masses" in a country where salaries have been stalled for decades and one in ten Italians is classified as living in poverty. For analyst Borioni, there is "no rightward shift in the population in Italy," just more people are abandoning the left. Activists meanwhile see the problem as politics, not the left itself. Francesca Ciuffi, a 27-year-old trade unionist in the textile hub of Prato, noted their recent successes in improving conditions for workers following strikes. "The big unions and left-wing parties have abandoned their role," she said. By AFP's Piera ROCCO DI TORREPADULA
Local Italy
01-07-2025
- Local Italy
Italy to issue close to 500,000 non-EU work visas over next three years
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's government said a total of 497,550 work visas would be issued over the 2026-2028 period, starting with around 165,000 in 2026. This was up from the 450,000 visa quota set by the government for the 2023-2025 period. Meloni, the leader of Italy's Brothers of Italy party, has sought to reduce the number of undocumented migrants entering Italy. But her government has also increased pathways for legal migration for non-EU workers in a bid to tackle labour shortages in an ageing country with a sluggish birth rate. Over half (around 267,000) of the total number of visas set to be made available over the next three years would be destined for seasonal workers in the agricultural and tourism sectors, the government said. Italy's main agricultural lobby, Coldiretti, welcomed the new visa plan as an "important step forward to ensure the availability of workers in the fields [and] food production". But a top official of Italy's largest trade union, CGIL, said the new quota did not address migration dynamics and labour needs. Maria Grazia Gabrielli stressed that the number of visa applications has been far lower than the available quotas in recent years. Between 2023 and 2024, only 7.5 to 7.8 percent of the visas made available by Italy's Ministry of Labour were converted into residency permits, she said in a statement. Gabrielli criticised the government's policy of prioritising applicants from countries that discourage their nationals from illegally migrating to Italy. A 2023 decree established special immigration quotas for nations helping Italy fight human traffickers and conduct media campaigns warning of the dangers of crossing the Mediterranean. Gabrielli said the system "takes no account whatsoever of migration dynamics and the need for a response that does not focus on punitive logic and rewards". Italy's immigration policies have long been fraught with weak spots and vulnerabilities, with criminal networks known to exploit the system to bring migrants into the country illegally. Gabrielli said a structural reform was needed to help employers recruit foreign labour and protect workers from traffickers.
Local Italy
14-06-2025
- Local Italy
Inside Italy: Why building a bridge to Sicily won't unite Italians
Inside Italy For Members In this week's Inside Italy newsletter, we look at why the government is so enthusiastic about the Messina Strait bridge project, and why work may begin soon despite the challenges threatening to blow it off course. Inside Italy is our weekly look at some of the news and talking points from Italy that you might not have heard about. It's published each Saturday and members can receive it directly to their inbox, by going to their newsletter preferences or adding their email to the sign-up box in this article. Is construction work finally about to begin on the long-promised Messina Strait bridge? The Italian government is expected to give its final approval to the plans within the next two weeks. An enormous amount has been written about this contested bridge project and its viability over the years. Anyone who follows Italian current affairs will be aware of the long list of convincing arguments against the plan, which include a risk of major earthquakes at exactly the point it is set to be built, and the frequent high winds (of up to 140 kilometres per hour) that the Strait is notorious for. Then there's the cost to the Italian state, currently estimated at 13.5 billion euros, and the fact that a lot of that money is widely expected to be siphoned off by the mafia. Practical problems with building a bridge over the Strait have in the past thwarted everyone from the emperor Charlemagne, the Bourbon King of the Two Sicilies Ferdinand II, Italy's first King Victor Emmanuel, the fascist dictator Benito Mussolini, and more recently, Silvio Berlusconi. The idea is said to date back to the Roman Empire. Powerful men are well known for wanting to build physical monuments to their own greatness. And this particularly difficult construction challenge seems to attract them like a magnet. Enter Matteo Salvini, the latest champion of the bridge project, who seems to genuinely believe that he will succeed where so many others could not. In his position as Giorgia Meloni's deputy prime minister and infrastructure minister, he intends to make his late ally Berlusconi's plans a reality - and to name the bridge after him. And, after recent changes to the design, this is now set to be the longest suspension bridge in the world, at 3.3 kilometres. Salvini now insists that construction work will begin this summer, and that the bridge will be ready to use by 2032. Although he did say work would start last summer, as well. He has been accused of backing the attention-grabbing bridge project in order to remain in the spotlight, as his League party has been eclipsed by Meloni's Brothers of Italy. But it doesn't seem like a wildly popular policy to stake his career on. There's significant opposition to the project in Sicily itself, while it's not thought to be popular among Salvini's traditional support base in northern Italy, either. In fact, it seems that few people outside of the government are enthusiastic. Media reports often use the aphorism 'the bridge that divides Italy' when talking about the project, but I find most Italians I talk to are instead united in resignation over the fact that the state is, yet again, spending enormous sums of money on something no-one asked for. Do people think a bridge will actually be built? ' Boh, chissà?' To most of those I've asked, it hardly seems to matter. Residents of Messina and Reggio Calabria say they haven't been involved in consultations over the project planned to connect their cities. The mayor of Messina complained at the time that the government didn't even contact him before announcing the project's revival. Many people would like better transport links between Sicily and the mainland, as well as better infrastructure within Sicily itself. But the government in Rome doesn't seem overly concerned with, for example, replacing the old diesel trains still running on many stretches of track. Salvini meanwhile has described the bridge as 'a model for the Italy that believes in itself.' Looking at history, it seems more like a project for leaders who believe in their own exceptional power. The idea surfaced at the birth of a kingdom, and then of a dictatorship, at the peak of the post-war economic boom, and now again amid the rise and rise of the political right in Europe and beyond. Giorgia Meloni's hard-right government at the moment appears to feel untouchable, confident that it will reach its full term and then serve another, where so many Italian administrations have failed after just a year or two (an average of 18 months, to be precise). So why not build a bridge? To succeed, they'll have to defy both the gale-force winds on the Messina Strait, and the equally powerful and unpredictable winds of change in Italian politics, for the next seven years at least. Inside Italy is our weekly look at some of the news and talking points in Italy that you might not have heard about. It's published each Saturday and members can receive it directly to their inbox by going to their newsletter preferences or adding their email to the sign-up box in this article.
