Starmer has run out of road on Palestinian statehood
The devastation of Gaza is something that obviously transcends politics – or at least it should. Yet, as the objective reality of the Palestinians' suffering is broadcast daily on television sets across the UK, Mr Starmer's political response to Israel's war could not be more exposed.
In the 22 months since the outbreak of the conflict, Mr Starmer has been entirely consistent to the extent that he has steadily lost almost the entirety of his supporters for his position. A letter late last week exposed how the Prime Minister had been reduced to playing for time. More than 200 MPs signed a letter calling on the UK to recognise Palestine statehood, as almost 150 nation states have done.
French President Emmanuel Macron has committed his country to declaring its recognition in September at the UN General Assembly annual meeting in New York. A conference this week co-hosted with Saudi Arabia at the UN sees Paris promote the two-state solution with recognition at its heart.
UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy is expected to attend. Yet Mr Starmer has so far withheld the decision to join the French in the new drive to make real recognition for Palestine among the most powerful countries of the G7 bloc.
For weeks, London's political calculation has been that pressure from the Knesset presented Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu with an opportunity to change course. There was also the arrival to Britain of US President Donald Trump, who is holding court on his Scottish golf courses.
These ultra-luxury venues have not only been a sporting paradise for Mr Trump, but also a diplomatic platform for him. On Sunday, he secured a trade deal with EU, which he called the biggest yet. On Monday, Mr Starmer spent the day with him. There, aides said Mr Starmer would use his good standing with the American leader to press his point on Gaza.
The British leader said he was working with Mr Trump to find a way to address the starvation of Gazans. Mr Trump said, for the first time, that the hunger in the Strip was real and couldn't be faked. 'We can work not just on the pressing issues of the ceasefire, but also on this issue of getting humanitarian aid in at volume, at speed,' Mr Starmer said.
The US President said he was pressing Mr Netanyahu to find a different way to bring the plight of the hostages to a resolution. 'I'm going to say it's a very difficult situation,' Mr Trump said. 'If they didn't have the hostages, things would go very quickly, but they do, and we know where they have them, in some cases, and you don't want to go riding roughshod over that area, because that means those hostages will be killed.'
The reckoning, as the UK House of Commons' Foreign Affairs Committee put it, was that Mr Netanyahu listens to only one foreign leader: Mr Trump. Even then the Israeli Prime Minister defies Washington, so only a big pep talk from Mr Starmer could get the US leader into a frame of mind to intervene meaningfully.
All that was a calculation rather than a guaranteed outcome. Mr Starmer's team did not want to alienate Mr Trump by announcing the UK's recognition in advance of their meeting. Alienating the US President would provide some poor dynamics for the Scotland meetings, something Mr Starmer was not prepared to countenance.
UK Secretary of State for Business and Trade Jonathan Reynolds – the cabinet minister among the closest to Mr Starmer – echoed the judgment that only the US has leverage in the current situation. He pointed out that two temporary ceasefires were brought about by US involvement. Downing Street has said the same thing, although it appears to be ignoring the fact that US envoy Steve Witkoff withdrew from the process last week.
Mr Reynolds was asked repeatedly about the prospect of the Prime Minister caving into political pressure this week. Despite the recess, the cabinet is set to meet for a discussion on Palestine, setting speculation off that a U-turn was coming. In advance of any new approach emerging, Mr Reynolds raised the standing concern from Mr Starmer's camp that recognition must not be a 'tokenistic' exercise. Deploying the decision once should have a tangible impact.
'It is a case of when, not if,' he said. 'It's about how we use this moment, because you can only do it once to have a meaningful breakthrough.'
That line has held sway at Westminster for quite some time. However, not only has the number of MPs in the Labour party rejecting it openly now into the hundreds, but up to half the cabinet are now holding private briefings that this cannot stand.
For most, there is a moral and humanitarian imperative that cannot wait. History, too, is powerful here. As the country that intervened through the Balfour Declaration to endorse Zionism's project to settle in Palestine, there are many in London who believe that Britain has a historic responsibility to promote equal rights for Palestinians and Israelis.
The Labour government that took power last year was overtly committed to 'leading on international law issues', something that suggested a spirit of rebalancing how the UK developed its policies.
Most remarkably, however, Attorney General Richard Hermer has not developed a response to the International Court of Justice's provisional measures on the Gaza conflict. Mr Starmer is a distinguished lawyer in this field and if his political skills have come under scrutiny on this issue, then it is a double indictment that his legal expertise appears to have disappeared as well.
There is ultimately no riddle here. Mr Starmer has played for time for so long on this issue that he has utterly run out of road for his position on Palestine.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
'No Other Land' murder: Women in Awdah Hathaleen's village launch hunger strike
More than 70 women in the village where Awdah Hathaleen was killed on Monday have launched a hunger strike, calling for Israeli police to return his body and release residents arrested in the wake of his murder. Their protest comes as they say Israeli forces have raided family homes in the village each night since the killing, arresting their husbands and brothers and beating other family members. "A woman would be not properly dressed, lying in bed, and they would come in and open the door and say, 'We want your husband, we want your brother'," Ikhlas Hazalin, Hathaleen's sister-in-law, told Middle East Eye on Thursday. "Whenever they didn't find whom they were looking for, other family members would be beaten – his brother, or one of his family members – until the wanted person was brought in." Hazalin added: "I've never seen such brutality." New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Awdah Hathaleen was a 31-year-old English teacher and peaceful anti-settlement activist. He was allegedly shot by an Israeli settler, previously sanctioned by the US, in a confrontation captured on video. A consultant for the Oscar-winning documentary No Other Land, Hathaleen's murder has made global headlines and drawn international condemnation. He is one of 16 Palestinians who have been killed by Israeli civilians in the West Bank since the 7 October 2023 attacks, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (Ocha). Ten more Palestinians have been killed in circumstances in which the UN could not determine whether the perpetrator was a member of the Israeli forces or a settler. Israeli authorities are holding his body, preventing residents in Umm al-Khair – one of a string of communities in the South Hebron Hills – and his family from holding a funeral. 'By God, we won't eat until he arrives' - Ikhlas Hazalin, Awdah Hathaleen's sister-in-law For three days, his wife and nieces have been on hunger strike, saying they will refuse to eat until Hathaleen's body is returned. At midnight on Thursday, dozens of women in the village, including teenagers and those in their 70s, joined the protest, according to local reports and Hathaleen's sister-in-law. The women were compelled to participate after Israeli authorities offered to return Hathaleen's body on Wednesday evening, but under conditions: he would be handed over at 1am and only 15 people could attend his funeral. 'We saw that they were stubborn about not releasing him and wouldn't hand him over to us except on their terms,' Hazalin said. 'These are terms we will never accept. We, the people of Umm al-Khair, will never accept them.' Escalating violence Hathaleen's killing comes as observers and human rights organisations warn of state-backed settler violence displacing Palestinian communities across the occupied West Bank, which has escalated dramatically following the Hamas-led attacks on southern Israel on 7 October 2023. At least 2,894 Palestinians have been displaced by settler violence since January 2023, with 740 settler violence incidents recorded between January and June of this year, according to Ocha. Allegra Pacheco, head of the West Bank Protection Consortium, a group of international NGOs focused on protecting vulnerable Palestinian communities in the West Bank from forced displacement and attacks, said settler violence in the West Bank is 'completely connected' to Gaza. "The inhumanity and impunity in the West Bank are spillovers from the Gaza genocide,' Pacheco told MEE. 'What the soldiers and settlers are allowed to do, what the politicians are allowed to say… The call for destroying Gaza, for settling Gaza - all of that and the lack of public rejection of that. This is what you hear all the time on Israeli media. That's what reigns in the West Bank too.' 'The inhumanity and impunity in the West Bank are spillovers from the Gaza genocide' - Allegra Pacheco, West Bank Protection Consortium The current residents in Umm al-Khair are refugees from the Nakba, the forced expulsion of Palestinians in 1948 which led to the creation of Israel, and have been living in the village on land they purchased for over 50 years. The neighbouring Israeli settlement of Carmel was built in the 1980s on land belonging to residents. Pacheco, who was in Umm al-Khair on Thursday morning, said the residents have been facing a 'coercive environment' for years. 'No planning, water restrictions, no building, 16 rounds of house demolitions. Everything has a demolition order,' she said. 'But they've stayed. And they committed today firmly: we will stay until the last martyr.' In addition to their hunger strike, the women in the village also told Pacheco that they guarded their homes and land by themselves on Wednesday evening because there were so few men left to do it. "The Israelis arrested community members every night. They effectively were emptying the community of men and the women, in the last few nights, were on their own more and more,' she said. 'Every night, the men have this guard shift where they guard the houses from settlers. Last night, there were so few men that the women decided as a group [that] we have to do one of these shifts because there are no men left.' She added: 'I said to them, 'What would you have done if a settler had come?' A woman said, 'I don't know, but God gave me this sense of power that I could do anything and I just did it.'' West Bank 'emergency' Yinon Levi, the settler accused of killing Hathaleen, was previously sanctioned by the US under the Biden administration, but sanctions were lifted by President Donald Trump in January. The UK and the EU still have sanctions on Levi in place. On Tuesday, a court in Jerusalem released Levi from custody and placed him under house arrest. Israeli settler accused of killing No Other Land activist released under house arrest Read More » "This is the perversion of justice and of the narrative,' Pacheco said. 'The people who were injured are in prison. The people who tried to prevent this are in prison. The people who acted in self-defence are in prison. And the guy with the smoking gun - the guy who shot the gun on video - is sitting at home and drinking coffee.' She called on international leaders to provide a protection force for Palestinians in the West Bank immediately and not wait until September, when France, the UK, Canada and others are set to formally recognise a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly. 'People will be dead by then. We are in an emergency in the West Bank,' she said. In Umm al-Khair, the women say they hope their hunger strike will be effective for this moment. "Perhaps, God willing, we can pressure them and there will be pressure to hand him over to us. The men also supported us and said they would join us within 24 hours if they don't hand him over," Hazalin said. "By God, we won't eat until he arrives."
The National
an hour ago
- The National
UK tax authority warns of fake social media posts
Claims in a social media video that the British government is tracking taxpayers who travel overseas more than three times a year have been rejected as a fake by the UK 's tax authority, HM Revenue and Customs. The video has been circulated widely in the Middle East, causing alarm among British nationals overseas and UK residents. It claims that from August 4, a new branch of HMRC and the Home Office – called the Mobility Oversight Unit – will check whether a person's employment status and tax record match their lifestyle. This is part of an 'enhanced customs monitoring' programme to tackle benefit fraud and tax evasion, the video and other related social media posts claim. HMRC said the information contained in the video was false. 'This video is disinformation, designed to cause undue alarm and fear. Anyone wanting information on rules around taxation should go to or seek advice from a tax professional,' an HMRC spokesperson said. Many social media users commented under the video that the information was false, but that did not stop it being widely shared. Fact-checking charity Full Fact traced the video back to a TikTok account, where the post had been shared more than 66,000 times and liked by 57,200 accounts. The video claimed the information was first reported by The Guardian, but there was no evidence of this on the newspaper's website. Full Fact added that while there are existing restrictions on the length of travel for people claiming benefits, the system in described in the video does not exist. The Home Office was contacted for comment. British government departments are being targeted with misinformation. One widely shared post on social media says 'the UK government is hiring' for a 'Shariah law administrator'. A separate post claimed 'the role is for the Department of Work and Pensions' alongside a screenshot of a – now deleted – listing for Manchester Community Centre. The job description says the successful candidate will 'provide all admin and secretarial work for Manchester Shariah Council'. In fact, the advert was not for a government job and the administrator was being hired using money a mosque said it had raised through donations. The job was advertised on a portal run by the government, where private employers can post. It is not known whether any of the posts are part of a hostile state-backed cyber campaign. UK government bodies have repeatedly warned of threats from online and phishing operations by actors in Russia and Iran. Earlier this year the UK's National Cyber Security Centre exposed a cyber campaign by military unit 26165 of Russia's GRU intelligence directorate against western logistics providers and technology companies that had been running since 2022.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Iranian press review: Construction industry hit hard by Afghan workers' deportation
Construction stalls amid mass deportations The mass deportation of undocumented Afghan migrants from Iran has caused serious problems for the country's construction industry, which relies heavily on low-wage Afghan labour. The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) reported that daily returns of Afghans from Iran - which launched a mass deportation campaign earlier this year - had surged from around 5,000 to 30,000 since the start of the war with Israel. It noted that most of those returning had been forcibly deported. Iranian authorities say nearly 800,000 Afghans have been expelled since the campaign began in March. On 7 July, the UNHCR reported that nearly 450,000 Afghans had returned from Iran since the beginning of June. Local media quoted Iraj Rahbar, head of the Tehran Real Estate Developers Association, saying that the removal of Afghan workers has lowered productivity and led to the suspension of some building projects. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Rahbar said that about 50 percent of construction workers in Tehran were Afghan, working as general labourers, builders, cement workers and stonemasons. He added that many employers preferred to hire Afghan workers because they accepted lower wages and were not insured, as they lacked legal immigration documents. Official Iranian figures show that more than five million Afghan migrants live in Iran. Some Iranian sources have accused Afghan refugees of spying for Israel. Spike in arrests of Iranians in the US Since Donald Trump returned to office, arrests and deportations of Iranian migrants in the United States have risen sharply. The number of arrests surged in the days following Washington's strikes on Iran's nuclear sites. Iran: Anti-Afghan sentiment is on the rise Read More » According to a report by BBC Persian, deportations of Iranians have increased more than tenfold since the start of Trump's new term and the rollout of his immigration policies, compared with the previous six years. From January to the end of June 2025, 92 Iran-born migrants were deported from the US. About a quarter of all Iranians arrested in the first half of the year were detained in the four days after the US strike on Iran's nuclear facilities during Israel's war on Iran. The report also notes that while 76 Iranians were arrested in the first 20 days of June, that number jumped to 303 in just four days following the US attack. In contrast, only nine Iranians were arrested in June of last year. Journalists face layoffs and pay cuts after war The Tehran Province Journalists' Association (TPJA), one of Iran's most influential media unions, has reported a rise in job losses and salary cuts among journalists following Israel's 12-day war on Iran. According to the association, more than 150 journalists from various media outlets, many of them well known, were laid off after the ceasefire, as economic pressures from the war took hold. By allowing Israel to bomb Iran, Trump is pushing Tehran to go nuclear Read More » Employers cited 'cost reduction', 'financial restructuring' and 'force consolidation' as reasons for the dismissals. News outlets affected include Rahpardakht, KhabarOnline, Eqtesad News, TejaratNews, Donyaye Eqtesad, EqtesadOnline, Eco-Iran, and Shahrvand. These organisations also implemented salary cuts for many remaining staff. The TPJA condemned the wave of layoffs, pointing out that many of the affected journalists had continued working during the war, reporting on conditions despite the dangers. In its report, the association said: 'While many journalists took on the responsibility of providing information with courage and commitment during the days of crisis, after the war they were met with a wave of ingratitude, job insecurity, reduced professional protection, and rushed decisions to cut wages and staff.' Environmental activists die in forest fires Khabat Amini has become the third environmental activist to die after wildfires swept through the Abidar forests. Amini was one of several volunteers who suffered serious burns while trying to contain the fire in the Abidar mountain area of western Iran last Thursday. He died four days later, on Monday, at Kowsar Hospital in Sanandaj. Before him, Chiako Yousefinejad, an activist from Sanandaj, and Hamid Moradi also succumbed to burns injuries. At least three other volunteers were severely injured and remain in the hospital. Despite the risks environmental activists face in Iran, including the threat of arrest and lengthy prison sentences, the Kurdistan Provincial Government has declared two days of public mourning in the province. Jamal Qaderi, an activist with the Chia Environmental Association in Kurdistan, criticised the government for failing to provide the resources needed to fight such fires. He told the Sharq daily: 'Government institutions are responsible for preventing fires in the Zagros forests, including in Kurdistan, and for putting them out by setting up and deploying air bases… We cannot tolerate another disaster like this.' *Iranian press review is a digest of news reports not independently verified as accurate by Middle East Eye.
