
Italian lawyers warn of rights violations against Palestinians facing terror charges
The three men, Anan Kamal Afif Yaeesh, Mansour Doghmosh and Ali Irar, were living in the central Italian city, northeast of Rome, when they were arrested.
They are accused of setting up a cell linked to Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades, an armed group associated with the Palestinian Authority's ruling Fatah party.
Authorities claim they were planning attacks "against civilian and military targets on foreign territory".
Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades is considered a terrorist group by Israel, the EU and the US and the charges the trio face carry sentences of up to 15 years imprisonment.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
But the men's lawyers say the preliminary hearing, which in Italy determines which evidence is admissible, included serious violations of due process.
They reported that the court refused their request to exclude transcripts of interrogations of Palestinian prisoners conducted by Israeli intelligence agency Shin Bet as evidence.
Majority of Israelis want censorship of social media posts sympathetic to Palestinians in Gaza Read More »
That was despite the transcripts previously being deemed inadmissible by another judge.
The defence said in a press release that the move constitutes a violation of the men's right to defence, as the witnesses could not be cross examined by the defence.
Article 111 of the Italian constitution stipulates that: "The defendant shall have the right to cross-examine or to have cross-examined before a judge the persons making accusations and to summon and examine persons for the defence in the same conditions as the prosecution."
The lawyers further highlighted that Palestinian detainees are subjected to multiple abuses during interrogations by Israeli forces, including torture and denial of legal access, in violation of Italian law.
"The court has pretended there are no problems," lawyer Flavio Rossi Albertini told Middle East Eye.
"The judges have shown that they do not want anything to emerge from the trial that would lead to unfavourable judgements against Israel".
Witnesses rejected
The court also rejected 46 out of 49 witnesses proposed by the defence, including UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese, international humanitarian law experts, aid workers and volunteers involved in projects in the occupied West Bank.
The only three witnesses admitted by the court were all drawn from the list relating to a single defendant, including an Italian volunteer, the defendant's wife and a linguistic consultant, denying any possibility of defence to the other two defendants.
Defence lawyers highlighted that the only testimony about the situation in the occupied West Bank is being provided by Italy's state police anti-terrorism unit, Digos.
Israel-Palestine war: Egyptian writer banned from speaking in Italy for calling Netanyahu 'serial killer' Read More »
According to Albertini, this will obscure crucial context about the nature of Israeli occupation in the occupied West Bank, where settlers often conduct attacks against Palestinians under military protection.
Israeli settlements are illegal under international law, however, Israeli civilians living in unlawful settlements in the occupied territory do not lose their civilian protections under the laws of war.
When settlers actively take part in hostilities, however, they lose their immunity from attack and become legitimate military targets.
"The court thinks it can judge Palestinians for acts committed in the West Bank, through testimonies provided by the Italian police," he said.
"We are talking about a small town in Abruzzo, 100km from Rome in the middle of the mountains. According to the judges, the local police are the only ones able to describe what is happening in the West Bank".
Albertini said the court's decisions were unprecedented in his legal experience.
"I haven't seen a court reject the evidence presented by the defence before, nor have I seen a court admit evidence produced in another country," he said.
According to Albertini, it is unlikely the men will face extradition if charged.
In March, an Italian appeals court rejected an Israel extradition request for one of the defendants, Yaeesh, arguing that he would face "acts constituting a violation of human rights" if the request were granted.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sharjah 24
4 minutes ago
- Sharjah 24
Guterres warns of ‘immoral humanitarian crisis' in Gaza
No justification for the scale of destruction In a video address to Amnesty International's Global Assembly in Prague, Czech Republic, Guterres acknowledged the attacks launched by Hamas on October 7, 2023, but stressed: 'There is no justification for the explosion of death and destruction that has unfolded since then.' He described the magnitude of the crisis as surpassing anything the international community has witnessed in recent times. Alarm over global indifference Guterres voiced deep concern over the international community's lack of response, stating: 'I cannot explain the level of indifference and paralysis we are seeing – a complete lack of compassion, truth and humanity.' Gaza's civilian suffering in full view of the world The Secretary-General highlighted the dire conditions in Gaza, where civilians and UN staff alike face extreme hunger. 'Their unimaginable hardship has left them numb and exhausted to the point that they can no longer tell whether they are alive or dead,' he said. He spoke movingly of children in Gaza who reportedly express a wish to go to heaven, believing they may at least find food there. Over 1,000 killed seeking food Citing United Nations data, Guterres noted that since May 27, more than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed while trying to obtain food. 'These people were not killed in combat, but in a desperate effort to secure basic sustenance amid mass starvation,' he added. Call for ceasefire and humanitarian access Guterres reiterated the urgent need for an immediate and lasting ceasefire, the unconditional release of all hostages, and unimpeded humanitarian access to all parts of Gaza. He affirmed the UN's readiness to scale up humanitarian operations during any truce, as was done during previous ceasefires. A broader global battle for human rights In his address, Guterres warned that powerful forces are working against the principles of human rights and international law, including efforts to undermine the International Criminal Court. 'We are in a global battle for human dignity, for human rights, for justice and multilateralism,' he declared. He called attention to rising repressive tactics and the growing manipulation of digital spaces by authoritarian regimes. A call to action: Uphold rights and demand justice Guterres urged nations to uphold human rights universally and without exception, even when it is politically inconvenient. He concluded by calling for legal accountability, climate justice, and resistance to disinformation and digital manipulation. 'We must build on the hard-won gains, including the recent advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice,' he said.


Sharjah 24
8 minutes ago
- Sharjah 24
Abdullah bin Zayed welcomes France's move to recognise Palestine
Support for advancing the two-state solution Sheikh Abdullah stated that this move strengthens international efforts to promote the two-state solution and achieve a just and lasting peace in the region. UAE commends France's timely decision The UAE appreciates this important step, which comes at a crucial moment. Sheikh Abdullah stressed the importance of the international community taking responsibility to revive the political process and help end the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Call for regional stability and peace According to Sheikh Abdullah, such efforts are vital for enhancing regional security and stability, and for supporting the Palestinian people's legitimate right to an independent, sovereign state in line with UN resolutions and international law. UAE reaffirms commitment to Palestinian Cause His Highness reiterated the UAE's unwavering support for the rights and aspirations of the Palestinian people. He emphasised the country's ongoing collaboration with regional and global partners to reach a just and sustainable resolution that ends the conflict and fosters long-term stability and prosperity in the region.


Middle East Eye
9 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
International Committee of the Red Cross: 'No excuse' for 'abhorrent' Gaza starvation
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in New York issued a statement on Friday decrying conditions in Gaza and calling on 'states' to uphold international legal obligations. The statement does not name Israel except for one mention: that Israel allow for the ICRC to resume visits to Palestinian detainees. " There is no excuse for what is happening in Gaza. The scale of human suffering and the stripping of human dignity have long exceeded every acceptable standard – both legal and moral," the ICRC said. " This tragedy must end now – immediately and decisively. Every political hesitation, every attempt at justification of the horrors being committed under international watch will forever be judged as a collective failure to preserve humanity in war," it warned. "States must uphold their obligation under the Geneva Conventions to respect and ensure respect for international humanitarian law (IHL), including by ensuring that the arms they transfer do not contribute to violations of IHL," the statement said. "This means resuming the rapid, unimpeded and impartial delivery of humanitarian relief across Gaza. This means releasing all remaining hostages immediately and unconditionally. This means allowing the ICRC to resume visits to Palestinian detainees in Israeli places of detention."