South D residents don't want ‘status quo'
Clear signals have been sent about what South Dunedin people want for their future amid climate challenges, Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich says.
"The No 1 thing they don't want is the status quo," he said.
"The infrastructure we have got simply cannot cope with the amount of inundation that we are prone to getting — so we have to install more."
Large-scale retreat because of climate change and flooding threats was also unpopular and another version of managed retreat — letting water in and relocating to raised land — was not well supported either.
People wished to continue to live in South Dunedin, he said.
If the least popular options were discounted, a mix of what remained — making space for water while keeping the "liveable, workable" land dry — was what they favoured.
Immediate action to enhance drainage infrastructure was key, which was why the council approved an additional "pipes and pumps" package in its 2025-34 long-term plan, Mr Radich said.
The mayor's comments came after a report from the South Dunedin Future programme about community engagement results relating to a hazard risk assessment and seven approaches for adaptation.
The programme is run jointly with the Otago Regional Council and it is principally aimed at establishing a comprehensive long-term plan for adapting to climate change.
Feedback about the potential approaches was received from more than 1200 people and organisations.
An option described as "space for water" was the most preferred overall.
There was "mixed support" for several other options.
"This suggests an openness from community and stakeholders to different approaches for managing risk and adapting to the impacts of climate change," the report for councillors said.
An initial shortlist of three approaches is expected to be available this month.
The regional council discussed the South Dunedin Future report last week.
City councillors had a wide-ranging discussion on Wednesday about the feedback, the property market, insurance, risk and climate adaptation.
Cr Christine Garey said there was a strong public mandate for change.
Cr Brent Weatherall said the full options for adaptation were "mainly cost-prohibitive" unless central government came on board, but this was "clearly not yet on the horizon".
Cr Carmen Houlahan said hazard information appearing on Lim reports was causing significant concern for some property owners.
Cr Lee Vandervis — the only city councillor who voted against noting the report — criticised "planning for its own sake".
grant.miller@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Dry period likely until Sept in South
Warmer temperatures and lower than average rainfall are expected to impact snow accumulation and storage in Central Otago and Southland, increasing the likelihood of dry conditions as spring approaches. Earth Sciences New Zealand principal scientist Chris Brandolino said more frequent northeasterly-to-easterly air flows were expected over the next three months (August-October), elevating the likelihood of tropical and subtropical systems affecting New Zealand. "This is associated with an increased risk of heavy rainfall events, including those linked to atmospheric rivers, and flooding." However, in the South Island, a shift towards more persistent easterly flow anomalies was expected as the season progressed, increasing the likelihood of dry conditions in the southwest. On the West Coast, the Southern Alps and foothills, inland Otago, and Southland, temperatures were very likely to be above average, he said. Rainfall totals were about equally likely to be below normal or near normal, and soil moisture levels and river flows were about equally likely to be near normal or above normal. "However, warmer temperatures and an increasing likelihood of dry conditions may continue to impact snow accumulation and storage in the region as spring approaches," he said. "These factors could have implications for water availability and seasonal run-off beyond the August-October period," he said. Along coastal Otago, temperatures were about equally likely to be above average or near average, rainfall totals were equally likely to be near normal or above normal, and soil moisture levels and river flows were about equally likely to be near normal or above normal. Cold snaps and frosts could still occur across the southern regions, but they would be less frequent than usual. While conditions in the tropical Pacific remained officially Enso-neutral, oceanic trends throughout July had moved closer to La Nina territory, he said. "Subsurface temperatures and ocean heat content are showing clear signs of change, boosting the chances of a La Nina developing later in 2025. "The chances for La Nina increase to 41% by the end of the calendar year. "Sea surface temperatures remain above average around New Zealand, particularly off the west coasts of both islands, where marine heatwave conditions persist."
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
South D residents don't want ‘status quo'
Dunedin mayor Jules Radich. PHOTO: ODT FILES Clear signals have been sent about what South Dunedin people want for their future amid climate challenges, Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich says. "The No 1 thing they don't want is the status quo," he said. "The infrastructure we have got simply cannot cope with the amount of inundation that we are prone to getting — so we have to install more." Large-scale retreat because of climate change and flooding threats was also unpopular and another version of managed retreat — letting water in and relocating to raised land — was not well supported either. People wished to continue to live in South Dunedin, he said. If the least popular options were discounted, a mix of what remained — making space for water while keeping the "liveable, workable" land dry — was what they favoured. Immediate action to enhance drainage infrastructure was key, which was why the council approved an additional "pipes and pumps" package in its 2025-34 long-term plan, Mr Radich said. The mayor's comments came after a report from the South Dunedin Future programme about community engagement results relating to a hazard risk assessment and seven approaches for adaptation. The programme is run jointly with the Otago Regional Council and it is principally aimed at establishing a comprehensive long-term plan for adapting to climate change. Feedback about the potential approaches was received from more than 1200 people and organisations. An option described as "space for water" was the most preferred overall. There was "mixed support" for several other options. "This suggests an openness from community and stakeholders to different approaches for managing risk and adapting to the impacts of climate change," the report for councillors said. An initial shortlist of three approaches is expected to be available this month. The regional council discussed the South Dunedin Future report last week. City councillors had a wide-ranging discussion on Wednesday about the feedback, the property market, insurance, risk and climate adaptation. Cr Christine Garey said there was a strong public mandate for change. Cr Brent Weatherall said the full options for adaptation were "mainly cost-prohibitive" unless central government came on board, but this was "clearly not yet on the horizon". Cr Carmen Houlahan said hazard information appearing on Lim reports was causing significant concern for some property owners. Cr Lee Vandervis — the only city councillor who voted against noting the report — criticised "planning for its own sake".
Otago Daily Times
23-07-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Debris on river a flood threat, council hears
Debris piled high enough to cover cattle in the Waihemo River is an imminent flood threat to the area, the Otago Regional Council has been told. Waihemo farmer Jim Thomson's property is spilt by the Waihemo/Shag River. Mr Thomson is the Waihemo ward representative on the Waitaki District Council and an approved RMA hearings commissioner. He said he was speaking as a concerned ORC ratepayer. At the ORC meeting in Oamaru yesterday, he told the council he has seen the river deteriorate "badly" over the past five years. "There's been no maintenance, no spraying for weeds and in actual fact, now seeing the results of previous spraying which was excessive, large willow trees are now dead and falling over and will, I suggest, end up in the river during the next large flood. "The lack of that maintenance, as I say, is going to affect future flood events. I know historically the floods in the Waihemo peaked at 440 cubics and during my 12 years there it was at 298 and that was scary enough." Mr Thomson suggested the issue could be traced back to the "travesty" of the Otago Regional Plan Change 7, which implemented the same irrigation rules for all Otago, with no recognition of the different weather between central and eastern Otago. "However, 75 years of rainfall records in my district show an 800mm variation, in that rainfall. As low as during the 1998 drought of 286mm but as high as 1100mm in the last two years. "I haven't turned the irrigation pump on because Mother Nature has done it for us but in actual fact, that will show as a non-use and will result in the reduction of water allocated to me." He suggested a solution to prevent trees being an issue in floods was to, at the Maheno area, remove the debris and the alluvial deposits between the rail and road bridges in the Kakanui and allow the water to flow where it wants to. Failing to do so would mean ratepayers would face more flood events in the future, he said. "I would challenge some members around this table as to whether they have served the whole community or been caught up in spheres of specific local interest. "Local and regional government would have more effect if we engaged with the practical people in our communities. Let's be proactive rather than reactive. "I would like to urge the council to continue to engage with practical people dealing daily with issues in our community for far better outcomes in the long term. Let's engage, educate and empower our communities to achieve outcomes, rather to try and impose and enforce upon them." Moeraki representative Cr Kevin Malcolm asked what would prevent the issue from being an imminent threat. "Well, the first thing is the clogging of the river with lupins, gorse brush," Mr Thomson said. "When I arrived, I sprayed up from the river banks. I also farm in a way that the areas that are flood plain will have temporary feeds in and I normally set back 10 to 15 metres to make sure that stock don't have access to the river. "But over time, with the neglect last year, I actually sent Cr Malcolm a photo of where I shifted the fence up and put two year old cattle in to try and break down that debris and you couldn't actually see the cattle in amongst it."
