"No Need To Protect Anyone...": Supreme Court On Manipur Violence Audio Leaks
The Supreme Court on Monday underlined its resolve to not protect any individual "involved in wrongdoings in relation to the communal violence" that erupted in Manipur in May 2023.
A bench led by Chief Justice Sanjiv Khanna said this as it heard a plea by the Kuki Organisation for Human Rights Trust, or KOHUR, for a court-monitored probe against ex-Chief Minister N Biren Singh over leaked audio clips in which he can allegedly be heard instigating the violence.
The remark was made after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the central government, questioned the credibility of the KOHUR, calling it a "rookie" group.
The court, however, dismissed such arguments, stressing, "We are not concerned. Let us ignore the petitioner... but if something wrong has been done, we don't have to protect the wrongdoer."
In today's hearing the Chief Justice-led bench was going through a Central Forensic Science Laboratory report on the authenticity of those audio clips. The report had been requested by the court after the government questioned the credibility of an earlier report, from a private lab.
The contents of the report - sealed for the court - have not been made public but, interestingly, after examining it, the court told Mr Mehta he would have to "speak to your officers about it".
"I have not seen it...have to respond to content," Mr Mehta said, to which the court said, "Read the content and then talk (to the government). Please examine and bring fresh report."
The court then set the week beginning July 21 for the next hearing, noting that in the meantime investigations against N Biren Singh will continue and that this will take about a month more.
"Now we have President's Rule there... it should not be a problem," the Chief Justice said.
Earlier KOHUR, represented by lawyer Prashant Bhushan, termed the contents of the leaks a "very serious matter", and said Mr Singh was purportedly heard saying Meitei groups were allowed to loot arms and ammunition of the state.
The petitioner cited a report by a private lab - Truth Labs - that confirmed a 93 per cent match between the voice on the tapes and that of ex-Chief Minister Biren Singh.
"Truth Labs reports are far more reliable than the FSL reports," Mr Bhushan had argued.
The government's lawyer, however, questioned the veracity of the Truth Labs report.
More than 260 people have been killed and thousands displaced since the ethnic violence broke out between the Meitei community and the Kuki tribes in May 2023.
Mr Bhushan alleged the recorded conversation prima facie showed the complicity and involvement of the state machinery in the violence against the Kuki Zo community.
And KOHUR's plea alleged that Mr Singh - who resigned in February - was instrumental in "inciting, organising and thereafter centrally orchestrating the large-scale murder, destruction and other forms of violence against the Kuki-dominated areas in Manipur".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
25 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
El Salvador approves indefinite presidential reelection, extends presidential terms to six years
SAN SALVADOR: The party of El Salvador President Nayib Bukele approved constitutional changes in the country's Legislative Assembly on Thursday that will allow indefinite presidential reelection and extend presidential terms to six years. Lawmaker Ana Figueroa from the New Ideas party had proposed the changes to five articles of the constitution. The proposal also included eliminating the second round of the election where the two top vote-getters from the first round face off. New Ideas and its allies in the Legislative Assembly quickly approved the proposals with the supermajority they hold. The vote passed with 57 in favor and three opposed. Bukele overwhelmingly won reelection last year despite a constitutional ban, after Supreme Court justices selected by his party ruled in 2021 to allow reelection to a second five-year term. Observers have worried that Bukele had a plan to consolidate power since at least 2021, when a newly elected Congress with a strong governing party majority voted to remove the magistrates of the constitutional chamber of the Supreme Court. Those justices had been seen as the last check on the popular president. Since then, Bukele has only grown more popular. The Biden administration's initial expressions of concern gave way to quiet acceptance as Bukele announced his run for reelection. With the return of Donald Trump to the White House in January, Bukele had a new powerful ally and quickly offered Trump help by taking more than 200 deportees from other countries into a newly built prison for gang members. Figueroa argued Thursday that federal lawmakers and mayors can already seek reelection as many times as they want. 'All of them have had the possibility of reelection through popular vote, the only exception until now has been the presidency,' Figueroa said. She also proposed that Bukele's current term, scheduled to end June 1, 2029, instead finish June 1, 2027, to put presidential and congressional elections on the same schedule. It would also allow Bukele to seek reelection to a longer term two years earlier. Marcela Villatoro of the Nationalist Republican Alliance (Arena), one of three votes against the proposals, told her fellow lawmakers that 'Democracy in El Salvador has died!' 'You don't realize what indefinite reelection brings: It brings an accumulation of power and weakens democracy... there's corruption and clientelism because nepotism grows and halts democracy and political participation,' she said. Suecy Callejas, the assembly's vice president, said that 'power has returned to the only place that it truly belongs ... to the Salvadoran people.' Bukele did not immediately comment. Bukele, who once dubbed himself 'the world's coolest dictator,' is highly popular, largely because of his heavy-handed fight against the country's powerful street gangs. Voters have been willing to overlook evidence that his administration, like others before it had negotiated with the gangs before seeking a state of emergency that suspended some constitutional rights and allowed authorities to arrest and jail tens of thousands of people. His success with security and politically has inspired imitators in the region who seek to replicate his style. Most recently, Bukele's government has faced international criticism for the arrests of high-profile lawyers who have been outspoken critics of his administration. One of the country's most prominent human rights group announced in July it was moving its operations out of El Salvador for the safety of its people, accusing the government of a 'wave of repression.'
Hans India
25 minutes ago
- Hans India
US tariffs work as opportunity for India's supply chain: Industry
New Delhi: The United States' decision to impose a 25 per cent tariff on India should be seen not just as a challenge, but also as a major opportunity for the country, industry leaders said on Thursday. Speaking on the development, Ranjeet Mehta, CEO and Secretary General of the PHD Chamber of Commerce and Industry (PHDCCI) said that the higher duty is not limited to India, but also targets other major exporting nations such as China, Vietnam, and Bangladesh, with China and Vietnam facing even steeper tariffs. He noted that the US is recalibrating its trade policy, leading to a shift in global supply chains. Mehta admitted that Indian MSMEs and industries may face short-term difficulties due to the tariff, but in the long run, it could help India strengthen its position as a trusted global partner.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Dalmandi Road widening kicks off amid ₹882 crore Varanasi infra push
Advt Advt Join the community of 2M+ industry professionals. Subscribe to Newsletter to get latest insights & analysis in your inbox. Get updates on your preferred social platform Follow us for the latest news, insider access to events and more. The projects include smart distribution and underground electrical infrastructure at a cost of ₹881.56 crore, widening and strengthening of Dalmandi Road at ₹215 crore, homeopathic college and hospital worth ₹85.72 crore, Kachhwa-Kapsethi-Chaubeypur Road worth ₹51 crore, Chhittampur-Rajwadi-Dhaurahra road worth ₹30.67 crore, Harsos-Suichak-Gangapur road worth ₹24.99 crore, Gangapur-Rohania Road worth ₹20.29 crore, the Lehartara-Kotwa-Koraut-Akelwa Road worth ₹21.7 crore, beautification and tourism development at Karkhiyao village and development of a memorial for 26 freedom fighters at a cost of ₹18.76 crore and the Varanasi-Ghazipur highway to Swarved Temple at ₹11.46 these, other sectors and components include urban Miyawaki forests, floating platforms and changing rooms at ghats along the Ganga, facility centres, garbage transfer stations, a new district library, rejuvenation of government high schools and redevelopment of the long list of new projects, all eyes are on Dalmandi Road widening project. After opening of the rejuvenated Kashi Vishwanath Dham by the PM in December 2021, footfall of devotees increased the recent Maha Kumbh in Prayagraj and the ongoing Shrawan month, managing crowd proved difficult for police and district administration. Exploring ways to divide the crowd, the plan for widening Dalmandi was CM Yogi Adityanath's instruction issued to officials on July 17 to ensure execution of Dalmandi Road widening project and financial and administrative approval given by state cabinet on July 22 for easy access to Gate No. 4 of Kashi Vishwanath Dham from Naisadak, PWD started demarcation of 184 identified ₹215.88 crore project will finish demarcation in the 650-metre-long Dalmandi, a narrow street full of bottlenecks, to convert it into a 17.4-metre-wide developments caused worry to the Muslim-dominated commercial-cum-residential area of Dalmandi.
