Bring back the cane? Groenewald sparks debate with corporal punishment call
Correctional Services Minister Pieter Groenewald has put forward the suggestion of corporal punishment to be reintroduced as part of the national debate on crime and justice reform in South Africa.
Speaking during his budget vote debate in Parliament on Tuesday, Groenewald laid bare the depth of the crisis facing the Department of Correctional Services (DCS), pointing to overcrowded prisons, deteriorating infrastructure, and a strained parole system.
Groenewald turned to a controversial but deliberate proposal: the reinstatement of corporal punishment.
'We must start a debate to say, shouldn't we bring back corporal punishment?' he said.
Groenewald's proposal comes despite corporal punishment having been outlawed in South African schools since 1996, with subsequent legal rulings extending the ban to the home.
Groenewald tied this call to broader concerns about the effectiveness of the criminal justice system, especially about violent crime and gender-based violence. He highlighted the need for honest conversation around crime deterrence, particularly given the limitations of the current correctional model.
Groenewald described a prison system under intense strain, housing over 104,000 sentenced offenders with facilities designed for 108,000 inmates, and an additional 60,000 remand detainees, many of whom are in jail simply because they cannot afford bail.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
21 minutes ago
- The Citizen
‘The Cat' is no more: Tributes pour in for former deputy president David Mabuza
David Mabuza, fondly known as "The Cat", has died at 64. Political leaders remember his legacy and express condolences. Tributes have started pouring in for former South African deputy president David Dabede Mabuza, who passed away on Thursday after battling ill health. The Cat, as he was known, was 64 years old when he died. As the news of Mabuza's death came out, several politicians and political parties extended their condolences to his family, friends and loved ones. Mabuza described as 'master tactician' Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi described Mabuza as a master tactician, while RISE Mzansi national leader Songezo Zibi praised him as a 'freedom fighter, seasoned politician, unionist, and operator'. 'The Cat is no more. We wish to convey our heartfelt condolences to the Mabuza family and the ANC. Lala ngoxolo,' Zibi said. ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba said that, having served South Africa in various senior roles, including as premier of Mpumalanga and ultimately as deputy president, Mabuza was a significant figure in South African political life. ALSO READ: Former SA deputy president David Mabuza has died 'His contributions and influence spanned decades and will leave a lasting mark on our country's democratic journey,' Mashaba said. 'While varying reflections on his legacy will no doubt unfold in the days to come, ActionSA simply wishes to extend compassion to his family as they begin this difficult mourning journey. We pray for their strength, peace and comfort during this time of loss.' Fiercely loyal to ANC Bosa leader Mmusi Maimane said Mabuza proudly wore his ANC colours and consistently defended his party. 'When I think about his life and his contribution, I think history will be able to judge for itself what it meant. In my interactions with him, I remember the forthrightness of our engagement going backwards and forwards on different issues,' Maimane said. He extended his condolences to the Mabuza family and prayed for peace and comfort for them. 'I wish them strength because the public bits will come and go, but when it's said and done, they need comfort,' Maimane said. [WATCH] Condolences are pouring in for former Deputy President David Mabuza, who passed away at the age of 64. SABC News' Lulama Matya brings reactions from Members of Parliament. She is joined by BOSA leader Mmusi Maimane. July 3, 2025 ALSO READ: WATCH: 'ANC will survive impact of Zuma and MK party' – Mabuza Good Party leader Patricia de Lille said it was during Mabuza's tenure as deputy president that she served alongside him. 'He was an exemplary chair of intergovernmental forums; his meetings were marked by punctuality, clarity of purpose, and firm outcomes. I personally admired his respect for time and process, and it is a discipline we can all learn from in public service,' de Lille said. ANC deeply saddened Within the ANC, Gauteng MEC for Finance and Economic Development Lebogang Maile said he was at a loss for words. 'You always rose to the occasion without fail, always available to volunteer for the movement – this is our greatest memory of you. May your soul rest in peace,' the MEC said. ANC spokesperson Mahlengi Bhengu-Motsiri told SABC News that the party was deeply saddened by Mabuza's passing. 'This is the son of the people of Mpumalanga who rose from the ranks of the student movement to go on to also become one of the founding chairpersons of the South African Democratic Teachers Union when it was formed,' she said. ALSO READ: David Mabuza resigns as Member of Parliament Bhengu-Motsiri said the party is truly heartbroken and called on South Africans to offer space to the Mabuza family. [WATCH] ANC Spokesperson Mahlengi Bhengu-Motsiri says the party is deeply saddened by the death of former Deputy President of South Africa David Mabuza, who passed on today at the age of 64. — SABC News (@SABCNews) July 3, 2025 The ANCYL noted that Mabuza was known for his tactical skill and political resilience. From his early days as an educator and anti-apartheid activist to his tenure as deputy president, they said he remained committed to the people's aspirations. 'A former chairperson of the ANC in Mpumalanga and a long-time champion of unity within the movement, Cde Mabuza will be remembered for his quiet strength, his strategic discipline and his ability to navigate complex political terrains with remarkable calm,' the ANCYL said. End of a chapter The youth league said Mabuza's passing marks the end of a significant chapter in the life of the ANC and acknowledged his contribution to the democratic project and to the advancement of social-economic transformation. 'As the Youth League, we dip our revolutionary banners in honour of a leader whose commitment to the ANC and its renewal remained steadfast even in the most trying times,' the ANCYL said.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Tributes pour in for David Mabuza, described as a dominant figure in South African politics
Former deputy president David Mabuza has died, aged 64. Image: X Tributes are pouring in for former Deputy President David Mabuza, who served as Deputy President under Cyril Ramaphosa's first term, who died on Thursday afternoon, aged 64. Mabuza was remembered as a dominant politician and a committed and humble cadre who dedicated his life to the service of the people of South Africa. ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula on Thursday confirmed the news and extended his condolences to the Mabuza family. "It is with deep sorrow and a heavy heart that we learn of the passing of the former Deputy President of the Republic and stalwart of our movement, Comrade David Dabede Mabuza," Mbalula said. He described Mabuza as a patriot, freedom fighter, and leader who served with humility and conviction. "We have lost a patriot, a freedom fighter, and a leader who served with humility and conviction. May his soul rest in peace, and may we honour his legacy by continuing the work of building a united, non-racial, non-sexist, democratic, and prosperous South Africa," he said. Professor Somadoda Fikeni, a former political analyst who worked with Mabuza, described him as a dominant politician who could outwit political opponents. He compared Mabuza to ANC heavyweight Matthews Phosa, who he succeeded as Mpumalanga premier. "Mabuza was a person I followed a lot when I was a political analyst. He could outwit political opponents, and I could say he was the most dominant politician I know and want to compare him to Matthews Phosa," Fikeni said. Political parties have also paid tribute to Mabuza, including the GOOD Party, RISE Mzansi, ActionSA, the African Congress for Transformation (ACT) and Build One SA. The GOOD Party leader and Minister of Tourism Patricia de Lille said: 'He was an exemplary chair of intergovernmental forums, his meetings were marked by punctuality, clarity of purpose, and firm outcomes. I personally admired his respect for time and process, and it is a discipline we can all learn from in public service," Mmusi Maimane, BOSA leader remembered Mabuza as a significant figure in South African politics. "While we often found ourselves on opposing sides of policy and principle, today we pause to honour the life of a man who occupied one of the highest offices in our nation and played a significant role in its political life," Maimane said. RISE Mzansi remembered Mabuza as a freedom fighter. 'Mabuza was a freedom fighter, seasoned politician, unionist and operator. 'The Cat' is no more…We wish to convey our heartfelt condolences to the Mabuza family and the African National Congress.' ActionSA's Herman Mashaba said while varying reflections on his legacy will no doubt unfold in the days to come, he simply wished to extend compassion to Mabuza's family as they begin this difficult mourning journey. 'We pray for their strength, peace and comfort during this time of loss,' Mashaba said. His former friend and comrade Ace Magashule, the president of the African Congress for Transformation (ACT), said he had received the news with deep sadness and heartbreak. Mabuza's legacy is complex, with some viewing him as a power broker and others as a committed cadre. Cosatu spokesperson Matthew Parks said Mabuza was not perfect but played a major role in the growth of the country. Mabuza was born at Phola Trust, in Mpumalanga, on 25 August 1960 and earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology from the University of South Africa in 1989. He served as an MEC for Education in Mpumalanga from 1994 to 1998 and as a regional chairperson of the ANC during the same period.
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Watch – Flying too close to the sun(s): Floyd Shivambu, SA's political Icarus
Once a firebrand of the EFF, now a brief resident of Zuma's MK party, Floyd Shivambu is re-emerging, this time with plans to launch his own political movement. But after being sidelined in yet another party power struggle, is this a comeback or just more political wandering? Marianne Thamm unpacks the theatrics, the ideology, and the irony. Marianne Thamm is a South African journalist, author and stand-up comedian. She is the assistant editor of the Daily Maverick and has written several books. In 2016, she released the memoir, Hitler, Verwoerd, Mandela and me. If you like this video, subscribe to our YouTube channel for more. Would you like to become a Maverick Insider and support our journalism? Click here for all the details. DM
