
Council failings a factor in death of foster carer run over by child, inquest finds
Marcia Grant, 60, suffered catastrophic injuries as she tried to stop the boy taking her car outside her home in the Greenhill area of Sheffield in April 2023.
The boy, referred to as Child X, was jailed for two years in November 2023. He pleaded guilty to causing her death by dangerous driving, after a murder charge was dropped.
On Tuesday, the South Yorkshire coroner Marilyn Whittle recorded a narrative conclusion after an inquest into Grant's death.
She said the circumstances that led to the fatal incident 'were contributed to by the failings of the Rotherham metropolitan borough council to have appropriate systems and processes in place when placing foster children, including but not limited to the lack of accurate and complete documentation, failure to communicate risks and concerns appropriately, failure to conduct appropriate risk assessments and failing to safeguard those in their care'.
The coroner said she would be writing a prevention of future deaths report, addressing issues including the council's lack of documentation, and failure to complete forms as well as a shortage of placements, although she said this was a national issue and not limited to Rotherham.
The inquest heard Grant had been fostering for seven years, and she and her husband, Delroy, were highly regarded by the council's fostering team.
They were caring for another child, referred to as Child Y, when the council put out a call for an emergency placement for Child X. The inquest heard the couple volunteered to take him, despite them being categorised as only able to take in one child at a time, because of Child Y's complexities.
The inquest heard that Child X had a youth caution for possessing a knife and had at times talked about wanting to be part of gang culture, but this information was not included on the 'deficient' initial placement referral form, and that Grant's decision to take him 'was made without her full knowledge of Child X's risks'.
After the inquest, Grant's son Shaun Grant said his mother deserved better and would not have taken Child X if she had known his full history.
He said the family 'wholly welcome the coroner's findings that our mum was failed on numerous fronts and that these failures directly contributed to her death'.
'We have been on an agonising journey to uncover the truth behind the events and systemic failings that led to the death of our beloved mum, Marcia Grant,' he said, reading a statement alongside his sister Gemma Grant.
'What has become evident over the last few weeks leaves us with no doubt that our mum was failed, our family was failed, and so too the foster child that was in our long-term care.'
'Whilst this leaves us with a sense of vindication, it also serves to reinforce to us how badly she was failed,' he added. 'If not for these failures, our mum would still be with us here today.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
23 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Oisin Murphy fined £70,000 for drink-driving offence which led to car accident
Oisin Murphy, the reigning champion jockey on the Flat, was fined £70,000 with an additional £2,000 surcharge and £85 in costs at Reading magistrates court on Thursday after pleading guilty to a drink-driving charge following a crash in the early hours of 27 April. Murphy, 29, who was also banned from driving for 20 months, was described in court as having tested 'just shy' of twice the legal limit for alcohol around seven hours after the crash. He returned a reading of 66 micrograms of alcohol per 100ml of breath, well above the legal limit of 35 micrograms per 100ml of breath. He was not required to plead to an additional charge of failing to provide a test sample at the roadside, following what was described as 'a misunderstanding between him and the police officers' by Richard Atkins, representing the Crown Prosecution Service. The court heard that Murphy admitted to police at the scene that he had been the driver of the grey Mercedes A-Class car, which left the road near Hermitage, West Berkshire, and collided with a tree. A female passenger in the car was subsequently taken to hospital. Murphy missed four booked rides at Southwell later the same day, but returned to race-riding at Windsor on the evening of 28 April, where he rode a double. Doncaster 1.43 Dream Pirate 2.15 Mon Na Slieve 2.50 Bahadur 3.25 Elsass (nap) 4.00 Alondra 4.35 Pearly Squirrel 5.10 Sugar Baby Sandown 1.50 Warning Sign 2.25 Key Of Magic 3.00 Staya 3.35 Getreadytorumble 4.10 Checkandchallenge 4.45 Al Nayyir 5.20 Triple Gee Newton Abbot 1.58 Isle Of Sark 2.33 Keel Strand 3.08 Kenmya 3.43 Shillanavogy 4.18 Max Of Stars 4.53 Jony Max Haydock 5.30 U Turn 6.05 Kingmaker 6.40 Dream Angel 7.15 Artanis 7.50 Indian Springs 8.25 Desert Falcon Beverley 5.42 Soca Star 6.15 Emeralds Pride 6.50 Orbaan 7.25 Atmosphere (nb) 8.00 Tara Iti 8.35 Overlooked Bangor 5.56 Tango Theatre 6.30 Herja 7.05 Barranco 7.40 Donnie Azoff 8.15 Land Girl's Luck 8.50 Elusive Power Passing sentence, district judge Sam Goozee told Murphy that he was 'lucky that neither you nor your passenger nor any member of the public was injured' in the crash.'


The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Activists remanded in custody after RAF aircraft break-in
Four people have been remanded in custody after two Voyager aircraft were damaged at RAF Brize Norton in a protest reportedly carried out by members of Palestine Action. Amy Gardiner-Gibson, 29, Jony Cink, 24, Daniel Jeronymides-Norie, 36, and Lewis Chiaramello, 22, appeared at Westminster Magistrates' Court in custody on Thursday. The defendants spoke only to confirm their names and were not asked to enter pleas. The incident in Oxfordshire caused about £7 million worth of damage to the aircraft on June 20, police said previously. Counter Terrorism Policing South East (CTPSE) on Wednesday charged the defendants with conspiracy to enter a prohibited place knowingly for a purpose prejudicial to the safety or interests of the United Kingdom, and conspiracy to commit criminal damage, under the Criminal Law Act 1977. Prosecutor Richard Link said the charges came after a serious incident of criminal damage was reported on June 20. Each defendant is heavily involved in Palestine Action, he added. He told the court that as far as the prosecution is aware, they live 'transient lifestyles'. There was applause and chants of 'free Palestine' from the packed public gallery as the defendants were led away. One kissed his hands towards the supporters as people shouted 'We love you Daniel'. CTPSE on Wednesday said a 41-year-old woman arrested on suspicion of assisting an offender had been released on bail until September 19. A 23-year-old man was arrested and released without charge, it added. They will next appear at the Old Bailey on July 18.


The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Murderer who planned gun attack on prison officer given 10-year sentence
A convicted murderer who plotted a gun attack on a prison guard has been given a sentence of more than 10 years. Robert Paterson, 45, planned the attack in an act of 'revenge', believing the officer at HMP Edinburgh had put his life at risk with a delay in sending him to hospital after he swallowed seven bags of cocaine. The plot was foiled when police eavesdropped on conversations Paterson was having about the plan through 'covert' surveillance equipment they had installed in his cell in early 2023. At a sentencing hearing at the High Court in Edinburgh on Thursday, judge Lord Harrower explained the origins of Paterson's 'animus' towards the officer. The judge said that shortly before 2am on November 15, 2022, the officer heard Paterson 'scream he was having a heart attack' from inside his cell, and 'demanded' he be taken to hospital. He said the officer had seen Paterson swallowing a sim card he had just removed from a mobile phone, and staff at the prison were surprised to see an ambulance arrive when none of them had ordered it. Paterson's 'vital signs' were deemed healthy so he was kept in prison under observation for a few hours, before being taken to the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh shortly before 8am. Lord Harrower added the officer had been 'aware' of an attempt by Paterson to escape when admitted to hospital in 2012, but said there was no indication the episode had been 'another attempt' to break out of jail. Once at hospital Paterson was given a CT scan, and underwent surgery to remove seven plastic bags of cocaine from his stomach. The judge told Paterson that following his return to prison he began to 'seek revenge' against the officer, believing he had been the cause of an 'unnecessary delay' in sending him to hospital. He set about obtaining a handgun and ammunition, and 'identified an individual who was prepared to carry out an assault' in return for 'drugs or money'. He also discussed procuring a vehicle and driver to be used in the assault. Thanks to the surveillance equipment police had installed in Paterson's cell, police got wind of the plan and 'intervened before an assault had been attempted'. Lord Harrower told Paterson: 'It is clear your proper purpose was conspiring to commit a serious crime.' Paterson's advocate Thomas Ross KC earlier told the court his client had reacted after deeming 'the manner in which the medical emergency was handled increased the risk of a fatal outcome'. On May 2 this year, Paterson pleaded guilty to directing others to carry out an assault, and obtaining for that purpose a handgun, ammunition and a vehicle. He also admitted directing and arranging the supply of drugs, and to directing others to steal drugs, watches and money. He is currently serving a life sentence for murder and is not due to become eligible for parole until 2027. Lord Harrower sentenced Paterson to 10-and-a-half years in prison for his latest offending, with the sentence to begin immediately. Paterson, who appeared in court dressed in a pale brown fleece, showed no reaction as the sentence was handed down. He nodded and waved to people in the public gallery as he was led from court. Speaking after the sentencing hearing, Scottish Prison Service chief executive Teresa Medhurst said: 'We welcome the significant custodial sentences passed today at Edinburgh High Court. 'As Lord Harrower rightly identified, the officer in this case acted 'entirely appropriately' and it is completely unacceptable that he, or any other member of SPS staff, be targeted in this way. 'The safety of our staff is absolutely paramount. We will continue to work closely with partners across the justice sector, to ensure that all necessary action is taken to protect those who play a vital role in keeping Scotland safe.'