State exams body defends ‘curveball' short story question in Junior Cycle English paper
In Wednesday's Junior Cycle English exam at higher level, candidates were asked to respond to a question about 'any short story they had studied'. It was worth 15 marks from a total of 180 marks for the exam.
[
Classroom to College: our essential newletter on the State exams for parents, guardians and students
]
However, many students reported that they had not studied any short stories during their three years of the Junior Cycle and left the question blank, while parents reported that children felt upset and confused in the middle of their first ever State exam.
While many teachers have covered short stories, others said they have not on the basis that they struggle to cover the full curriculum of the revised Junior Cycle English specification, which has been examined for all candidates since 2017. A question on short stories has not come up in the exam in recent years.
READ MORE
A SEC spokesman said it was assured that the questions was 'fully within the scope of the specification and in keeping with the aims, objectives and learning outcomes for Junior Cycle English.'
The spokesman said its exam papers and draft marking schemes are developed through a 'rigorous development process' and those involved are 'experts in the subject who are also experienced teachers.'
The spokesman also noted that the
Junior Cycle English specification
includes guidelines for teachers on the choice of texts which should be studied by students in first year, and by those in second and third year.
'The specification includes short stories among the texts which must be studied by students in both first and second/third year,' he said.
In addition, he pointed to the Department of Education list of
prescribed materials
for the second and third year of Junior Cycle English which issued to schools in 2022 for those sitting this year's exam.
This circular states that 'second and third year students MUST study texts as described' and includes 'a number of short stories' in the list of texts.
In the case of novels, films and dramas to be studied for examination, teachers choose from those on the prescribed lists as set out in the circular. In the case of poetry, short stories, and non-literary texts teachers have the freedom to choose specific examples.
The spokesman noted that 'commentary and correspondence on the examinations from students, parents, teachers, professional bodies, and other interested parties' will be reviewed by the subject's chief examiner in the context of preparing the marking scheme,
'The approach taken by the SEC to the development of marking schemes ensures consistency in the marking and fairness to all candidates. The marking scheme will be published, as will the marking schemes in all other subjects, after the issue of the Junior Cycle results.
About 60,000 students sat the higher level Junior Cycle English paper. While some teachers described the inclusion of the question as a 'curveball', most overall said they were happy with a 'balanced' and 'fair' exam.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Emergency response team called to rescue birds from two inland oil spills just days apart
A wildlife charity has responded to the aftermath of two oil spills, carrying out emergency operations to rescue birds in Laois and Dublin. Kildare Wildlife Rescue (KWR) responded last Friday to an oil spill in Kilminchy, Portlaoise, where severe oil pollution affected three connected lakes in a residential area. A family of swans, with four cygnets, along with ducks and other birds were affected. The emergency response team took the swans to safety and said 'the process of cleaning and rehabilitating them has begun.' Five days later, the team was alerted to a second oil spill in Kilbogget Park near Cabinteely, South Dublin. READ MORE An initial assessment following the spill on Wednesday found diesel oil on the water, which was emitting strong fumes. A severely oiled swan was rescued from Kilbogget Park, Dublin. Photograph: Kildare Wildlife Rescue Another family of swans, along with four cygnets, were rescued the following day. Volunteers have been trying to rescue other water birds from the area. 'Both swan families will have to remain in our care until their territories are clean and safe again. We hope the oil can be cleaned up soon so that the families can return home,' KWR manager Dan Donoher said. A cygnet is washed following an oil spill in Kilminchy. Photograph: Kildare Wildlife Rescue Rescue co-ordinator for KWR, Pearse Stokes, said while oil spills were 'very common' in Ireland, these were different as 'the amount of oil or contaminant is considerable'. 'This is very intense, and particularly Kilbogget Park. Just walking through that park you could smell the fumes', he said. He said it was 'great to see so many members of the public reaching out to us' regarding the oil spills. KWR said the sources of the spills were unknown and were being investigated by the local authorities. Mr Stoke said both county councils 'were on site pretty quick. They've put in the various mitigation measures to try and remove some of this oil'. Laois County Council and Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council have been contacted for comment.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Woman who died days before 109th birthday ‘lived life to the full', funeral hears
The woman believed to be Ireland's oldest person, who died just days before her 109th birthday, 'lived life to the full' and was a 'masterclass in resilience', her funeral has heard. Sarah Coyle , who was born in the year of the Easter Rising, died on Monday surrounded by her family. Fr John Gilligan, who led the Requiem Mass at St Brigid's Church in Blanchardstown in west Dublin on Friday, described her as a 'lady with a great sense of fun who loved chatting'. Fr Gilligan said Ms Coyle saw Ireland change 'through many seasons', while her advice was 'don't bear grudges and be kind to people'. READ MORE Ms Coyle was born in Knockatomcoyle, a townland in Co Wicklow, before her family moved to Coolkenno, near Tullow. She was working as a housekeeper in Foxrock when she met her husband Tom Coyle from Cavan at a dance. They lived in Drumcondra and had four children, though two of their daughters died as newborns. Mr Coyle died in 1968 while Ms Coyle began to lose her sight from her late 30s. She is survived by her daughter Marian, son Patrick and sister Lily, aged 103. Ms Coyle's granddaughter Anne-Marie said she was 'selfless and would do all she could for others'. She described her grandmother as 'an amazing host' while 'acts of service were her love language'. She spoke of Ms Coyle's self-deprecating nature saying she was 'never demanding, not one to hog the spotlight or be the centre of attention'. Anne-Marie said despite the 'much suffering and heartache in her life', her grandmother 'didn't dwell on it and refused to let it define her'. 'It would have been easy for her to grow bitter and angry at the world and nobody could have blamed her, but she actively chose happiness and love repeatedly,' she said. 'I always found it a testament to her strength and resolve that, despite living in total darkness for the majority of her long life, she brought light to many. She was a masterclass in resilience.' She added that the 'world was so much brighter' for her being in it and was 'the very best of nanas and the very best of women'. Anne-Marie said she would 'forever think of sunshine' when she thinks of her grandmother. Ms Coyle's son-in-law Anthony described her as a 'role model to all of us, an inspiration and an example of how we should all live our lives'. He said she had 'all the qualities of a saint here on earth' while recalling her 100th birthday celebrations. 'She used to say: 'I can't believe I'm 100 years old and I'm still here. I wonder has God forgotten about me?' And we would say: 'Far from it, he hasn't forgotten about you but you still have important work here on earth and he's leaving you here for more'. She would break into her lovely smile and say: 'I suppose he'll call me when he needs me'.'
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Brianna Parkins: People who get up early in the morning for no reason are a menace to society
I am deep in enemy territory. Surrounded by supporters of the very regime I've been railing against for years: the menace to society that is people who get up early in the morning for no good reason. When I first moved to Ireland I had jet lag. They say you need one day per timezone to get over it. I had just jumped nine. By day three I was so tired I could smell colours. My body was a cranky toddler that drifted off to sleep in the car and came to screaming in a pram being pushed around an Aldi . I fought off the desperate and dragging need to sleep, going to bed later in a bid to reset myself. But I shouldn't have bothered my hole. My circadian rhythm was way off . It didn't matter if I slept at 7pm or 1am, my eyes would spring open at 4am without fail, and I would be ready to greet the day in Dublin . Except my new city wasn't ready to greet me. READ MORE My plan was to pretend to be a morning person, get up, get a coffee and walk around the streets. Cafes open from around 6am in Sydney or even earlier. I'd just wait two hours and watch the sun rise, beverage in hand. Then I discovered the sun wouldn't show itself properly until 9am in winter and no cafe except the closest Starbucks would open until 7.30am (the Sydney equivalent of noon). So I waited, and as I made my way through the streets of Ringsend , which were empty enough to make me feel I'd survived an apocalypse, I felt profound joy. Finally I had found my people. I had found a culture that didn't compel people to leap out of bed predawn. I saw tradespeople going to work at 8am or sometimes 9am; in Australia the heat has most on site between 5am and 7am. My new boss told me to show up at 10am. Brunch – the meal that's meant to come between breakfast and lunch – was being offered at 2pm. All this would have been unthinkable just a short time and a long plane ride ago. Ireland does have a decent number of early risers who do so out of choice and not work requirements. The sea swimmers who like to slice through Dublin Bay while it looks like glass. Parents of small children who have too much inconvenient guilt about drugging them. Nuns. Runners. Busy mothers who just want 'one bloody hour of quiet to themselves before everybody wakes up, if that's not too much to ask'. [ Moving to another country is hard. You're not failing if you're not living up to a filtered social media standard Opens in new window ] But you don't catch them banging on about it. It's very much a case of 'your body, your choice'. They're happy in their way but they won't attempt to proselytise you. Sadly, my partner has farming child trauma and believes that if you get up at 8am a man in wellies will come stand by your bed and tut 'sure half the day is gone' at you in shame. But even he enjoys an occasional lie-in. A morning safe from being ripped from the warm blankets and the soft bed, where it is so, so cozy and you are so, so comfy. When I moved back to Australia I realised the false supremacy of morning people had taken my beloved country to new extremes. It's become an influencer trend after Covid to take photos at Bondi or any beach at sunrise, doing something that could easily be done at any point of the day – like running or walking. Or wearing tights. The problem with morning people is that they assign moral value to what happens to be their natural preference. Which you never catch night people doing, oddly. Depriving yourself of sleep is not labelled performative productiveness – 'it's a mindset for success'. The Puritans would have hated TikTok , but they would have loved the early morning propaganda being spread on it. Instead of leaving early mornings for the Protestants (like my dad), we have let them become the drag impersonation of work ethic. Getting up and journaling at 6am is seen as self-discipline, but writing things in a diary at 2am is a cry for help. Working into the night is bad time management even if those are your most productive and creative hours. But waking up four hours before you have to work to faff around is not. It's a marketing battle, and we are letting the morning people win. Just as I cannot be brilliant at breakfast, a person who wakes up at 5am every day will be no craic at midnight. But who would you rather have at your wedding?
