No pilot is stupid to play around with switches during takeoff: Aviation expert Mark Martin on AAIB report
Reacting to the preliminary findings by the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) into the fatal crash of Air India flight AI 171 — a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner that went down shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad on June 12, Martin, who is CEO of Martin Consulting, an aviation safety firm in Asia, said that for a pilot, two most critical phases of flight are the take off and landing.
'During this, all attention is on flight instruments and hand flying the aircraft to about (usually) 2000 feet then engaging the autopilot. Attention is on continuing flight and flight controls, never on the throttle quadrant, since thrust is set to MAX TAKE OFF THRUST,' he told IANS.
According to the AAIB preliminary report, both fuel control switches supplying fuel to the engines of Air India flight 171 were turned off in quick succession, shutting down both the engines.
One of the pilots can be heard on the cockpit voice recorder, asking the other why he cut off the fuel, to which the other pilot responded by saying that 'he did not', the report mentioned.
Martin said that the report 'will have a global ramification on all 787 operators'.
'It is highly unlikely that any pilot, especially during takeoff would want to meddle or fiddle around with switches behind the thrust levels. At best, you would focus on raising the landing gear which is located in the front panel of the cockpit, or raise the flaps,' the expert explained, adding that it is imperative that we wait for the entire, comprehensive investigation report. to come out.
The report said that both pilots had an adequate rest period before the flight. According to the 15-page report, the flight lasted around 30 seconds between lift-off and crash. The report noted that at this stage, there are no recommended actions to operators of Boeing 787-8 aircraft and GE GEnx-1B engines.
The air crash killed 260 people — 241 of the 242 people on board the ill-fated aircraft and 19 on the ground.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
Eight air accidents killed 274 people this year: Govt data
The government on Thursday said there have been eight air accidents that killed 274 people in the country so far this year. Apart from the Air India plane crash on June 12 that killed 260 people, there were three trainee aircraft accidents and four helicopter accidents. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category MBA Leadership Product Management Data Analytics Data Science Management Cybersecurity Finance Others others Healthcare Degree healthcare Data Science CXO Artificial Intelligence Technology Design Thinking PGDM Digital Marketing Project Management MCA Public Policy Skills you'll gain: Analytical Skills Financial Literacy Leadership and Management Skills Strategic Thinking Duration: 24 Months Vellore Institute of Technology VIT Online MBA Starts on Aug 14, 2024 Get Details Minister of State for Civil Aviation Murlidhar Mohol told the Lok Sabha that the cause of these accidents is under probe by the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB). by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo "There have been a total of 08 accidents (involving 1 scheduled aircraft, 3 trainee aircraft and 4 helicopters) reported in the year 2025 (till date)," he said in a written reply. On April 22, one person was killed in a helicopter accident in Gujarat, while on May 8, six people died in a chopper crash in Uttarakhand. In another helicopter accident in Uttarakhand, seven people were killed on June 15. Live Events As many as 84 people were injured in the eight accidents, including 81 persons in the Air India plane crash. In a separate written reply, Mohol said a total of 18 accidents involving Indian civil registered scheduled aircraft have been reported from 2015 till date. "Payment of compensation to the passenger or next of kin in case of death or bodily injury to the passenger, caused by air accident /incident is governed by the provisions of Carriage by Air Act, 1972. "India has ratified the Montreal Convention, 1999 by making amendments to the Carriage by Air Act, 1972 in 2009. As per the said act, the liability of payment of compensation in case of death, delay, damage or loss to persons, baggage or cargo for international carriage, is of the carriers," Mohol said.
Time of India
10 hours ago
- Time of India
Two generations, one goal: Mother-daughter duo cracks NEET, starts on medical journey
Tamil Nadu woman Amuthavalli Manivannan (R) cracks NEET at 49, joins daughter M. Samyuktha Krupalini on medical journey. (IANS Photo) In the quiet town of Tenkasi in Tamil Nadu, a dream that had been shelved for over three decades was brought back to life — not through chance, but through shared ambition, late nights of study, and the unwavering support of a family. At 49, Amuthavalli Manivannan, a physiotherapist by profession, did what very few would dare — she sat for NEET, the fiercely competitive national medical entrance exam, and passed. What makes this feat all the more remarkable is that she did it alongside her daughter. Her daughter, 18-year-old M. Samyuktha Krupalini, a CBSE student, had been preparing intensely for NEET, hoping to join a reputed medical college. Inspired by her daughter's dedication, Amuthavalli found herself drawn back to a dream she had once given up on. The dream of becoming a doctor. "I've been working as a physiotherapist for years, but I always wanted to study medicine. This dream started 15 years ago, but I never had the opportunity," Amuthavalli said, as quoted by IANS. "When I began preparing alongside my daughter, I realised it was now or never. She gave me the courage to try again." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The World's Oldest Living Actors. The Noodle Box Undo Late nights, shared books, and mutual encouragement Amuthavalli began borrowing her daughter's textbooks, revising concepts that had long changed, and navigating a syllabus that bore little resemblance to the one she had studied in her school days. The challenge was immense. "The syllabus was totally different from what I learnt in school. But I watched her prepare, and I thought, why not try? She was my greatest inspiration," she said, as reported by PTI. Their home turned into a hub of learning. Samyuktha, who had enrolled in a coaching centre, would often explain topics aloud as a way of revising—an approach that incidentally helped her mother understand complex medical subjects too. "I found it easy to memorise when I recount what I have studied to someone," Samyuktha told PTI. On July 30, the two attended NEET counselling sessions in Chennai. Amuthavalli, who scored 147 marks, qualified under the Persons with Benchmark Disabilities (PwD) category and chose to join the Government Medical College in Virudhunagar, near her native district of Tenkasi. Samyuktha, who scored 450 marks, is awaiting a seat through the general category and is also eligible under the SC quota. Different colleges, same path While their paths crossed during preparation, they have decided to take separate routes academically. "I don't want to study in the same college with my mother. I wish to compete in the general quota and study elsewhere, maybe outside the state," said Samyuktha, as quoted by PTI. Amuthavalli's journey into medicine had been interrupted years ago, not by a lack of ambition, but by circumstance. After finishing school, she had wanted to study medicine but couldn't due to financial and personal constraints. She pursued physiotherapy instead and went on to build a career in the field. But the desire to don a doctor's coat never truly left her. Now, after nearly 30 years, with a family of her own and a daughter following a similar path, she's returning to the lecture halls—this time, as a medical student. Her husband, a practising lawyer, has been a pillar of support throughout the process. "My husband was very supportive. He encouraged us to study for NEET," she added, as reported by PTI. Special counselling and a shared milestone The Selection Committee under the Directorate of Medical Education and Research conducted the offline counselling session on July 30 for candidates under special categories, including the 7.5% reservation for government school students, PwD, children of ex-servicemen, and eminent sports persons. As both mother and daughter prepare to don their white coats, they're not just stepping into medical colleges—they're stepping into a shared dream realised through perseverance, discipline, and the unique bond that only a mother and daughter can share. TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us here . Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
New Indian Express
a day ago
- New Indian Express
Going beyond blame game to address fear of flying
Not a day has passed since the Air India crash in Ahmedabad when there has not been an incident involving planes—takeoffs aborted, aircraft skidding off runways, engines catching fire, flights returning to base after takeoff, cancellations, and diversions to other airports due to technical glitches have almost become routine. We also had six helicopter crashes involving pilgrims in Uttarakhand in this period, out of which two were fatal accidents. No wonder a sense of foreboding pervades the public's mind. The vivid live video of the Boeing 787 Dreamliner fireball and images of its aftermath are still haunting the imagination of the nation and the world. Though more people die in road and train accidents in India than anywhere else in the world, people are asking, 'Is it safe to fly?' This is why we have to look at the larger picture of Indian aviation today. First, of course, is Air India. The preliminary investigation report into its flight 171 crash has raised more questions than answers. It has stoked conspiracy theories and TV-presenters-on-steroids are working overtime sowing confusion. Aspersions are being cast by the pilots' association on the integrity and fairness of the probe agencies. Charges are being levelled that the truth has already been made a casualty. Given the trepidation in the air, the aviation ministry and Directorate General of Civil Aviation must do everything to earn the confidence of the public and the aviation community. They must speedily conclude the full investigation and publish the report for public knowledge. The cause of the accident must be established without fear—to learn from and avoid future disasters. For itself, Air India has to get its act together fast and earn back the reputation of its glory days during JRD Tata's charismatic leadership in the pioneering phase before independence. The airline lost its sheen and glamour after nationalisation and JRD's exit from the airline. It has had never-ending woes ever since.
