Do dogs need people to survive? The truth might hurt.
Surprisingly, Valerie, who had become separated from her family during a vacation to the island in November 2023, had even gained about four pounds in the wild.
'She went out as a skinny little sausage dog and came back as a rippling mass of muscle,' says Jared Karran, a director at the nonprofit Kangala Wildlife Rescue, who released footage of Valerie's rescue. 'Just the healthiest dog you'd ever want to see—perfect teeth, perfect hair, perfect skin.'
During her time in the bush, Valerie became somewhat of a celebrity, and fans rejoiced when they learned she had reunited with her family in May.
But some wondered how she did it. Was she just lucky, or can pet dogs—animals that have lived and evolved alongside humans for thousands of years—really survive without us?
Well, it depends on who you ask.
'I don't think that [the story] is that outrageously surprising or amazing,' says Jessica Pierce, a bioethicist who focuses on the human-animal relationship. Pierce wrote 'A Dog's World,' which delves into what might happen to dogs if humans disappeared from Earth.
'It is amazing that she did this because she lived the first part of her life as a pampered pet dog, so really hadn't developed the skills that she would have needed to survive on her own,' Pierce clarifies. 'But obviously those were instinctually intact.'
Vanessa Woods, the director of the Duke Puppy Kindergarten at the Duke Canine Cognition Lab, and author of 'Genius of Dogs,' isn't so sure.
'I have a dog right now who would probably not last a minute in the wild,' she says, adding that she believes some dogs would adapt while others would sit and wait for their owners to rescue them. 'I think some dogs would be great and some dogs would die.'
Pierce and Woods agree that certain characteristics would make an individual dog more apt to survive without people.
First off, Valerie would have needed a pretty high IQ to protect herself from predators, secure food and water, and shelter herself from the elements, Pierce says.
'Figuring those things out in a new environment is something a lot of humans would find challenging,' she adds.
Luckily, there probably weren't any large predators for Valerie to deal with on Kangaroo Island, Woods says, but she likely would have had to dodge serpents like the venomous tiger snake and pygmy copperhead.
'She kind of had a natural aptitude,' surmises the Australian-born Woods. 'But then she also would have gotten lucky because let me tell you, there are parts of the Australian bush where she would have lasted about two days.'
In most places, dogs with stronger hunting drives would generally fare better, Woods says. For instance, a Jack Russell terrier that's been bred and trained to use this skill regularly would be more successful than a show husky that hasn't honed the art of catching prey, she notes.
'You don't really want dogs to hunt and kill every living thing in your neighborhood, including a neighbor's cat,' she says. 'So there would be some dogs [where] the skills that would help them survive have been watered down, really bred out of them.'
However, Pierce emphasizes that these instincts have never truly disappeared.
'Even a pet dog who's never had to hunt for food, but always just had a bowl of kibble placed in front of her twice a day, still knows how to hunt,' she says. 'Those instincts are still there.'
Dogs bred for extreme traits, such as short legs or long or large bodies, might not do well either, Pierce hypothesizes. For instance, it's generally harder for short-legged dogs like dachshunds to run long distances. Plus, these extreme traits can eventually lead to genetic health issues like hip dysplasia and chronic pain, she says.
On the other hand, smaller dogs like Valerie could have more of an advantage in some settings, Pierce adds.
'They're not going to be quite as visible and easy to spot for a predator,' she says. Plus, small dogs need fewer calories and could potentially survive on small insects like grasshoppers instead of relying on taking down larger prey, she explains.
In general, dogs also possess a few traits helpful to wilderness survival. For instance, they 'can and will eat anything they can get their paws on,' Pierce notes. Plus, their behavior is flexible, making them more adaptable to new environments and situations.
But Valerie's success could have also come down to personality.
'It's hard to put your finger on exactly what it is about her, but she obviously has this belief in herself,' Karran says. 'Nothing seems to faze her.'
Stray dogs, which number around 200 million worldwide, according to the World Health Organization, live fairly independent of humans.
'A relatively small slice of the world's dogs live as pets, as captive animals,' Pierce says, noting that stray dogs use their instinct to survive in the wild.
But Woods says life isn't easy for these free-ranging pups. For one, young strays have a high mortality rate—one study from India found that only about 19 percent made it to reproductive age (which is generally around 6 months old).
Still, Pierce believes that if humans disappeared from the planet tomorrow, dogs would do just fine.
'Dogs would have a pretty good shot because of how adaptive they are,' she says. 'They'd have, I would say, as good a shot as any other animal in making it without us.'
Woods questions, though, how long they would make it without our waste to pick at. After all, early dogs survived by scavenging trash around human settlements, and that's how most feral dogs make it today.
'The last 14 to 40,000 years, that's what they've been surviving on, basically,' she says.
But regardless of whether dogs could survive without us, would these social animals miss our companionship?
'I think a lack of any social interaction would probably be felt as something missing,' Pierce says. 'I'm not sure there would be loneliness, but there might be.' However, she says dogs don't need humans to meet their social quota. They can also bond with other dogs and even other animals.
Still, 'your dog who's curled up next to the couch with you would certainly miss you,' she says. 'But dogs as a species…would be okay without us.'
This paradox might be best summed up by the way Valerie—a dog who did just fine for herself in the wild for nearly a year and a half—warmed up to her family immediately during their reunion.
'It just took a split second and you could see her recognize each one individually,' Karran says. 'She was so happy; she jumped up on them licking them, cuddling them, running around. It was just such a beautiful moment.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CNN
17 hours ago
- CNN
Peter Phillips, grandson of late Queen Elizabeth II, is engaged
Peter Phillips, the son of Britain's Princess Anne and eldest grandchild of the late Queen Elizabeth II, announced his engagement to nurse Harriet Sperling on Friday. 'Mr Peter Phillips, the son of HRH The Princess Royal and Captain Mark Phillips and Ms Harriet Sperling, daughter of the late Mr Rupert Sanders and Mrs Mary Sanders of Gloucestershire, have today confirmed their official engagement,' the couple's spokesperson told CNN in a statement. 'Both families were informed jointly of the announcement and were delighted with the wonderful news of their engagement. Their Majesties The King and Queen, The Prince and Princess of Wales have been informed of the announcement. 'No date has officially been set for the wedding,' the statement added. The couple first announced their engagement with a photo shoot in UK celebrity magazine Hello!, in which they were pictured in a field, with Sperling's ring prominent. They have been a couple since at least May 2024, when they were pictured together at the Badminton Horse Trials alongside Phillips' daughters and Queen Camilla. Sperling is a pediatric nurse for Britain's National Health Service and a freelance writer, according to an online biography attached to an article she wrote for Christian magazine Woman Alive last year. Phillips, 47, was previously married to Canadian-born Autumn Kelly with whom he shares two daughters – Savannah, 14, and Isla, 13. They announced their 'amicable' divorce and decision to share custody of their children in 2020.


New York Post
19 hours ago
- New York Post
Pope Leo ‘devours' pizza shipped from his favorite Chicago pie shop — here's what toppings he got
Call him Pope Pieus. Pope Leo XIV recently received a special delivery at the Vatican which came all the way from Chicago. The Illinois-born pontiff, 69, was treated to a personal-size pepperoni pizza from Aurelio's Pizza, a chain he's reportedly loved since he was a boy. Advertisement 3 Pope Leo XIV was gifted a personal-size pepperoni pizza from Aurelio's Pizza. REUTERS/Carlos Osorio Pope Leo XIV, formerly known as Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost before he was elected the first American pope earlier this year, received the gift as he rode through Saint Peter's Square in Rome on Wednesday, July 30. His brother, John Prevost, told Chicago TV station WGN that the pontiff 'devoured' the personal pepperoni pie. Advertisement According to NBC News, friends from the Midwest came up with the idea to get the pope a box of his favorite pie. 'It started 30 days ago when I started a challenge to deliver a pizza to the pope,' Catholic content creator Jayden Remias, from Ohio, told WGN. He drove to Chicago to pick up a frozen Aurelio's pizza and delivered it to Madeline Daley from Cincinnati, with whom he connected online, before she left for Rome. Advertisement 3 Pope Leo XIV received the gift as he rode through Saint Peter's Square in Rome on Wednesday, July 30. Instagram / @jaydenremias Daley, 22, made the final leg of the trek to deliver the pizza to the pope as he toured the historical plaza. She got his attention by waving the pie's box and holding a sign that read 'We have Aurelio's pizza.' Leo appeared to signal to his security guard to accept the slice of home. As he accepted the cheesy gift, the leader of the Catholic Church gave a thumbs up and had a big smile on his face. Advertisement 'When Pope Leo came around, he kept grabbing babies to bless them, but as soon as he saw the pizza, he had babies in his hand, but he's still saying, like, 'Get me that pizza, I want that pizza,'' Daley told NBC News. 'And seeing the logo made him light up, and his smile was from ear to ear and he was extremely excited about it.' 3 As Pope Leo accepted the cheesy gift, he gave a thumbs up and had a big smile on his face. Instagram / @jaydenremias Joe Aurelio, president and CEO of Aurelio's Pizza, said it was 'amazing' to be able to deliver the Chicago pizza to the pope. 'Pope Leo has been a lifetime Aurelio's fan and going to Aurelio's Pizza in Homewood, Illinois, since the 1960s,' he said. 'So it's been part of his life and for him to recognize [the pizza] and actually stop there in the audience was amazing.'


Newsweek
20 hours ago
- Newsweek
Moment Dog Admits Why She Really Loves Owner Seen by 20 Million: 'Honest'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A dog owner accused her pet of only using her to get snacks, and was shocked at the dog's hilarious response. Erin Lynne Anderson, who posts to TikTok under the username @erinlynneandersonnn, is the owner of Australian shepherd Reya, who like many dogs, will use everything she has to beg for treats and snacks. And recently, when Reya was pushing her face up against Anderson while she was eating, her owner had had enough. In a video boasting more than 5 million likes, Anderson accuses her dog: "You don't even love me, you just want my snacks." And right at that moment, Reya decides to smile brightly and nod her head up and down, as though understanding Anderson and completely agreeing. The short video cuts off just as Anderson bursts out laughing. Since being posted on July 11, it's been viewed a whopping 23 million times. One commenter declared this was "proof dogs can understand you," as another joked Reya was saying: "Yeah, now give it." "It's the smile and wink together that gets me," another laughed, while one joked: "Good, I'm glad we're on the same page." And as one user put it: "At least she's honest." Dozens of commenters compared Reya's white face, pink nose and fluffy ears to the dragon Falkor of The Neverending Story, with one comment saying she looked just like the character, racking up 16,000 likes of its own. The video does make it seem like Reya completely heard and understood Anderson's accusation. But as unlikely as this would already be, Reya is deaf, and unless she picked up incredibly lip-reading skills, it's likely it was just a brilliantly coincidental moment caught on camera. However, as one commenter suggested "your dog may not be deaf after all," Anderson responded, admitting: "Sometimes I think she's been messing with me for the past three years and she just ignores me." Reeya appearing to smile and nod when her owner accuses her of only using her for snacks. Reeya appearing to smile and nod when her owner accuses her of only using her for snacks. TikTok @erinlynneandersonnn Dogs and language is a topic long studied by researchers: in a 2024 study by researchers at Eötvös Loránd University, Hungary, using non-invasive brain scans, it was found that dogs activate a memory of an object when they hear their name. The study involved 18 dog owners saying words they knew their dog understood, sometimes showing their dog a matching toy while saying its name, and sometimes showing a completely different toy. Researchers found that the dogs' brain recordings gave different patterns when they were presented with an object that matched the word, suggesting dogs can associate words with certain objects. Newsweek has contacted @erinlynneandersonnn via TikTok for comment on this story. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.