HC quashes tax recovery against grocer, a victim of Aadhaar fraud
The court expressed distress that the
Unique Identification Authority of India
(UIDAI), the chief commissioner, Gujarat State, GST, and other authorities were at a 'standstill' for five years in the unique identity fraud case.
The HC division bench of Justices S M Sonak and Jitendra Jain directed the man, Vilas Lad, a 51-year-old Prabhadevi resident, to approach
Income Tax
Authorities, which are to then consider if it is possible to deactivate his old number and issue him a new one.
If impossible, the IT department is to state what steps can be adopted to prevent misuse of the PAN number. The HC also directed the GST authorities to delete his Aadhaar and PAN numbers from its portal against the company's name.
The HC expressed its displeasure at the Income Tax department, Mumbai, and the State Tax commissioner not being represented before it despite notices to them, and imposed costs of Rs 10,000 each on five authorities, including UIDAI, chief commissioner Gujarat state GST; chief commissioner IT, Mumbai; Union Bank of India; and State Tax Commissioner, Gujarat; for "dereliction of duty" and not initiating any criminal proceedings despite the fraud being discovered.
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
"When the fraud was committed on these very authorities, which should have awakened them, and they ought to have moved with lightning speed for discharging their duties to set criminal action in motion," the HC said.
The man petitioned the HC for directions to the IT department to probe into a "bogus PAN card", to the UIDAI to suspend and cancel his Aadhaar card, and other directions to banks and the GST department in Gujarat.
His counsel, Uday Warunjikar, said Lad received a legal notice in 2019 for Rs 75,000 towards unpaid rent in Rajkot, and in 2020 for almost Rs 14 lakh in an alleged dishonour of a cheque issued by a company.
JB Mishra, counsel for the Centre, informed the HC of the various steps the govt had initiated to prevent Aadhaar misuse, including securing enrolment and updating the ecosystem with biometric and demographic checks, among others.
The HC opined that shortcomings in the implementation of laws are the reason the frauds are perpetuated, and hence swift proactive action would be an effective deterrent.
The HC directed the Gujarat State Tax department not to initiate any proceedings against Lad "for transactions of Metro International Trading Company, the impersonator", and also directed that proceedings pending before a magistrate must not to go on till the Mumbai man's complaint made to Gujarat Police is taken to its logical conclusion and the culprits arrested.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Delay hits Scorpene retrofit to boost stealth, endurance
NEW DELHI: India has once again missed the boat to enhance the underwater operational endurance and stealth of its latest Scorpene or Kalvari-class conventional submarines, with the already delayed air independent propulsion (AIP) system developed by DRDO still not ready for integration with the vessels. The first Scorpene submarine to be built at the Mazagon Docks (MDL) with French collaboration, INS Kalvari, which was commissioned in Dec 2017, will now complete her ongoing maintenance refit at the Mumbai naval dockyard without being retrofitted with the AIP plug as was originally planned, defence ministry sources told TOI. "The fuel cell-based AIP system developed by DRDO's Naval Materials Research Lab, which has L&T as the prime industry partner, is still not yet operationally available. Hopefully, it should be ready by the time the second Scorpene (INS Khanderi) comes for her scheduled normal maintenance refit in mid-2026," a source said. The Navy after a long delay has inducted six diesel-electric Scorpene submarines, constructed by MDL in collaboration with the French Naval Group under Project-75 for over Rs 23,000 crore, with the sixth INS Vagsheer being commissioned in Jan this year. There is major concern about the continuing delay in the indigenous AIP project, which was originally slated for completion by June 2017 after being sanctioned in 2014 at an initial cost of Rs 270 crore. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Elegant New Scooters For Seniors In 2024: The Prices May Surprise You Mobility Scooter | Search Ads Learn More Undo Amid the delay, MDL and Naval Group signed an agreement for the integration of the indigenous AIP energy system plugs on the Scorpenes only on July 23. Under it, each submarine will undergo a complex project called "jumboisation", involving precision cutting of the hull, safe insertion of the AIP plug and then rejoining the structure to ensure the vessel is fully operational again. Unlike nuclear-powered submarines, which have unlimited underwater endurance, diesel-electric boats must surface or snorkel every couple of days to get oxygen to recharge their batteries. Those fitted with AIP, however, can stay submerged for around two weeks to significantly boost their stealth and combat capabilities. With Pakistan on course to induct eight Yuan or Hangor-class conventional submarines with AIP from China in a major capability jump, India's depleting conventional underwater combat arm has become a major worry. China, of course, now has the world's largest navy, which includes over 50 diesel-electric and 10 nuclear submarines. Apart from the six French-origin Scorpenes, India has seven very old Russian Kilo-class and four German HDW diesel-electric submarines at present. It also has two operational SSBNs (nuclear-powered submarines armed with nuclear ballistic missiles) in INS Arihant and INS Arighaat, with the third to be commissioned as INS Aridhaman this year, as reported by TOI earlier. The long-pending projects to build three additional Scorpenes for Rs 38,000 crore and six new-generation diesel-electric submarines, with both AIP and land-attack cruise missiles, for Rs 70,000 crore under Project-75-India at MDL, are also yet to be finalised and inked.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
HC stays conviction of vax scientist for wife's suicide; cites 'national interest'; allows returns to duty
. DEHRADUN: Uttarakhand HC has suspended the conviction and five-year rigorous imprisonment of a vaccine scientist found guilty of abetment to suicide following the death of his wife in 2015. Justice Ravindra Maithani granted the relief to Dr Akash Yadav during the pendency of his appeal, saying his role was "undoubtedly essential for public health and national interest" and his conviction had rendered him ineligible to continue contributing to vaccine programmes. Yadav, a vaccinologist with a PhD in biotechnology from IIT-Kgp, had been working as a senior manager at Indian Immunologicals Limited, a PSU that makes human and veterinary vaccines and plays a critical role in national immunisation efforts. tnn Court allows scientist to resume duties at IIL Yadav was convicted by a sessions court under IPC section 306 for abetment to suicide but was acquitted under section 304-B (dowry death) and the Dowry Prohibition Act. He married on May 7, 2015. His wife, who was employed at Pantnagar University, was taken to her maternal home by her brother on July 4, 2015, while Yadav was working in Hyderabad. She resumed her duties but died by suicide on Dec 14, 2015. In her suicide note, she stated that her husband would be responsible for her death. Yadav was arrested on May 11, 2017, and after spending more than three months in jail, he got bail on Aug 28. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: New Container Houses (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search ads Search Now Undo On Jan 21 this year, the sessions judge of Rudrapur sentenced him to five-year RI and a fine of Rs 20,000 under Section 306. After being granted bail, Yadav filed an interim application under section 389(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking suspension of his conviction. He submitted that because of the conviction, he had become disqualified from working with Indian Immunologicals Limited (IIL) and was unable to resume his scientific duties. His counsel argued that the case met the criteria for exceptional circumstances, as the conviction had a direct impact on "work of national importance." Justice Maithani noted that an appellate court can suspend a conviction if failure to do so would result in injustice or irreversible consequences. He cited the Supreme Court rulings in Navjot Singh Sidhu vs State of Punjab (2007) and Rama Narang vs Ramesh Narang (1995) and said that courts must examine whether maintaining the conviction would unfairly affect a person's professional standing or public interest responsibilities. The bench observed, "This was a greater issue of public health and national interest. In light of the afore-stated reasons, the court was of the view that this was a fit case in which the order of conviction as well as execution of sentence, appealed against, should be suspended." The high court suspended both the conviction and sentence during the appeal's pendency, allowing Yadav to resume his duties at IIL. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Click, buy & regret: Customers in Bengaluru struggle to return wrong & fake items
Bengaluru: What was once celebrated as a revolution in convenience has turned into a source of frustration for many online shoppers. As e-commerce has become a norm in urban India, a new kind of consumer complaints is becoming prevalent — defective or even fake products delivered, with little to no recourse for the customer. A pattern is evident: when buyers receive wrong or damaged products, their complaints are often dismissed or redirected to the delivery agents. Instead of redressal, many are asked to prove their claims — typically by sharing an unpacking video. In effect, the burden of proving fraud is pushed on to the consumer. Data reflects the scale of dissatisfaction. As of June 2025, the Karnataka State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (KSCDRC) had logged nearly 1.3 lakh complaints related to e-commerce and other miscellaneous categories — nearly 40% of the total 3.3 lakh consumer cases in the state since its inception in 1989. You Can Also Check: Bengaluru AQI | Weather in Bengaluru | Bank Holidays in Bengaluru | Public Holidays in Bengaluru Suneetra Datta, a 45-year-old resident of Kengeri, recounted her ordeal. She had ordered a branded kurta on a well-known online platform for her son, paying Rs 1,298 via UPI. What arrived instead was a bundle of torn cloth. "I was shocked. Every detail — product ID, payment method, invoice — matched. Yet no action was taken after I raised the issue. This is unacceptable," she said. Despite reaching out to the delivery partner and the e-commerce firm, she hasn't received a refund three months on. In another case, Pranay Poradanla, 25, ordered a hoodie from an online fashion retailer, only to have his return request denied on the grounds that the item wasn't officially marked as delivered. "It took 20 days of constant follow-ups just to get the correct product. For one hoodie, I was made to suffer. It's mentally draining," he said. Experts say the problem lies in a systemic lack of accountability. "Online platforms often act like neutral parties when something goes wrong, claiming they are only aggregators," said Shivashankare Gowda, president of KSCDRC. "Consumers trust these platforms thinking the sellers are vetted. But when issues arise, the platforms back away and direct buyers to deal with vendors directly." A Central Crime Branch official noted that while platforms have made shopping easier, consumer vigilance has not kept pace. "Always opt for payment on delivery and try to check the product in front of the agent or record an unboxing. These basic precautions now matter more than ever." Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
