logo
Consumers pay Rs69b for idle plants

Consumers pay Rs69b for idle plants

Express Tribune10-05-2025
Listen to article
The inefficiencies in the country's electricity transmission system have burdened consumers with capacity payments of Rs69 billion in the quarterly tariff adjustment (QTA) for ex-Wapda distribution companies (DISCOs) for the third quarter of financial year 2024-25.
Three power plants had been operating at lower capacity during the period under review, but they received Rs69 billion in capacity payments, which the electricity consumers had to pay.
National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) Member (Technical) Rafique Ahmad Shaikh has pointed out inefficiencies in the country's transmission system due to which Rs69 billion was paid to three coal-fired plants in capacity charges despite extremely low utilisation. He submitted these comments in his additional note on the QTA for the third quarter of 2024-25, in which a reduction of Rs1.55 per unit was allowed to refund Rs52.6 billion to the consumers of DSICOs and K-Electric (KE) in the bills for May, June and July 2025.
According to him, transmission constraints continue to limit the utilisation of several cost-effective power plants located in the southern region, notably Port Qasim, China Power and Lucky Electric. Despite their potential to provide affordable electricity, these plants reported extremely low utilisation factors – approximately 1% for Port Qasim, 10% for China Power and 0% for Lucky Electric – during the quarter.
Nevertheless, they claimed substantial capacity payments amounting to Rs26.95 billion, Rs30.88 billion and Rs11.26 billion, respectively. In total, around Rs69.09 billion was claimed in capacity charges despite minimal generation.
This reflects a major inefficiency in the system and underscores the urgent need to address transmission bottlenecks and improve generation dispatch practices to ensure the optimal use of the available low-cost generation resources.
It is noted that the capacity claimed by DISCOs for the third quarter of FY 2024-25 amounted to Rs362.395 billion, which was significantly lower than the reference figure of Rs459.286 billion. During the same period, electricity sales stood at 19,968 gigawatt hours (GWh) compared to reference sales of 21,846 GWh in the corresponding period.
Ordinarily, a decline in electricity sales would result in an upward adjustment in capacity charges due to the fixed-cost nature of capacity payments.
However, during this quarter, the termination of certain power purchase agreements (PPAs) and other adjustments related to the independent power producers (IPPs) operating within the system have contributed to a reduction against the projected capacity payment. Consequently, this led to a negative adjustment in the third quarter of FY 2024-25.
Although the quarterly adjustment for the third quarter decreased significantly, he said that enhanced governance and more efficient system operations could have further improved electricity sales, potentially leading to an even greater reduction in the adjustment amount. In that regard, several key observations were highlighted for consideration and focused action by the relevant stakeholders.
Genco-II (Guddu old), Genco-III (TPS Muzaffargarh) and Genco-I (Jamshoro Power Company) collectively claimed capacity payments of Rs1.237 billion during the quarter – Rs469 million, Rs350 million and Rs418 million respectively – despite generating no electricity during the period.
These plants are characterised by high generation costs and poor operational efficiency, with little-to-no likelihood of receiving dispatch orders from the system operator in the future, given the availability of abundant and more cost-effective surplus capacity in the system. Continuing capacity payments to such non-operational and inefficient assets imposes an unnecessary financial burden on both the power sector and end consumers. A targeted and strategic review is, therefore, essential to rationalise these expenditures and improve the overall sector efficiency.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

DISCOs overbill consumers by Rs244b
DISCOs overbill consumers by Rs244b

Express Tribune

timea day ago

  • Express Tribune

DISCOs overbill consumers by Rs244b

Iesco stood on top in the wake of its plausible performance to curb losses, improve recoveries and act in line with the time frame for new connections. PHOTO: FILE An audit has unearthed a massive overbilling scam involving eight electricity distribution companies (DISCOs), which collectively extorted over Rs244 billion from consumers in an attempt to mask inefficiencies, losses and theft in the system. According to documents obtained by The Express Tribune, the audit report exposes serious financial irregularities in the operations of DISCOs in Islamabad, Lahore, Hyderabad, Multan, Peshawar, Quetta, Sukkur and the former tribal areas. The report reveals that no action was taken against any officials responsible for the illegal billing, even though overbilling was carried out systematically to cover up transmission losses, power theft and poor operational performance. In a shocking revelation, even agricultural tube wells and deceased individuals were not spared. Multan Electric Power Company (MEPCO) alone sent power bills worth Rs496 million to dead customers. Additionally, zero-unit consumers were charged for over 1.22 million units. The report states that in just one month, five of these companies slapped 278,649 consumers with overbilled amounts totalling Rs47.81 billion. For the entire fiscal year 2023–24, consumers were billed for an extra 904.6 million electricity units. Despite the companies' claims that the overcharged amounts have been refunded, no documentary evidence was provided to audit authorities. The audit observed that these companies failed to produce any records verifying refunds, raising concerns about transparency and accountability. Among the most egregious cases was Quetta Electric Supply Company (QESCO), which overbilled agricultural consumers by over Rs148 billion during FY2023–24, purportedly to hide operational lapses. Similarly, ten DISCOs billed an additional Rs18.64 billion across 1,432 feeders. In total, Rs22 billion worth of overbilling was imposed solely to offset line losses, the audit reveals. While some refunds were issued, such as Rs5.29 billion for incorrect meter readings and Rs2.18 billion in multiple credit adjustments by Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO), the lack of supporting documentation continues to cast doubt on the credibility of these claims. Audit authorities have now formally sought clarifications from all eight DISCOs, but so far, the distribution companies have failed to provide the requested records.

World Bank urges Pakistan to expedite $55mn power efficiency project
World Bank urges Pakistan to expedite $55mn power efficiency project

Business Recorder

time3 days ago

  • Business Recorder

World Bank urges Pakistan to expedite $55mn power efficiency project

ISLAMABAD: The World Bank has urged Pakistan's Power Division and three major Distribution Companies (Discos) to fast-track implementation of the Additional Financing (AF) for the Electricity Distribution Efficiency Improvement Project (EDEIP), warning that continued delays could hamper the timely and effective use of the $55 million credit facility. In a letter addressed to Secretary Economic Affairs Dr. Kazim Niaz, the World Bank's new Country Director for Pakistan, Bolormaa Amgaabazar, noted a significant uptick in disbursements and commitments as of June 30, 2025—with disbursements rising to $18.09 million (9.3%) from 3.6% in November 2024, and commitments to $18.28 million (20.7%) from 9.0%. Still, the Bank flagged that targets for the quarter were not fully met due to rebidding of key contracts, procurement strategy revisions, and delays in grievance resolution. Wolrd Bank approves $55m in additional financing to Discos Despite these hurdles, the Bank remains optimistic. 'The project is now on track to meet its development goals by closure,' the letter stated, projecting end-FY26 disbursement and commitment levels at 30% and 95%, respectively. The World Bank lauded the Economic Affairs Division and Power Division for securing the AF package but emphasized that further momentum depends on meeting several immediate conditions—including finalizing the Financing Agreement and triggering its effectiveness within the 90-day window post-signature. The three Discos—Hyderabad Electric Supply Company (HESCO), Multan Electric Power Company (MEPCO), and Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO)—have been told to promptly roll out activities under the new funding. During the Bank's May 2025 Appraisal Mission, all stakeholders agreed on a roadmap to eliminate project bottlenecks and enhance implementation speed. The World Bank stressed the importance of updating the Project Enhancement Action Plan (PEAP) by July 21, 2025, to reflect on-the-ground realities and lessons learned. Similarly, the Project Procurement Strategy for Development (PPSD) must be revised in line with the Bank's 2025 Procurement Regulations to address persistent contract delays. Key improvements must also be made in procurement quality, bid evaluation speed, complaint management, and oversight of contract execution. All high-value contracts must incorporate rated criteria and early market engagement to ensure transparency and efficiency. Revised procurement plans and bid documents are due to the Bank by July 31, 2025. On the Environmental and Social (E&S) front, the Bank flagged slow progress in preparing key documents like Environmental and Social Impact Assessments (ESIAs) and Resettlement Action Plans (RAPs). These are to be submitted by the end of July. The Bank warned that continued inaction could stall broader project progress. While the capacity of Project Implementation Units (PIUs) has improved—with support from the Project Implementation and Management Support Consultant (PIMSC)—gaps remain. The Bank highlighted the need for greater stability in project teams, urging against frequent changes in PIMSC personnel. DISCOs have been instructed to submit a detailed FY26 work plan for consultant engagement by July 31 and to fill all key PIU vacancies with qualified personnel by August 31. 'With focused effort and leadership, the project can still meet its targets and deliver long-term impact on Pakistan's power distribution performance,' the Country Director noted, reiterating the Bank's commitment to the country's reform agenda. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

AF implementation for EDEIP: PD, Discos urged to speed up
AF implementation for EDEIP: PD, Discos urged to speed up

Business Recorder

time3 days ago

  • Business Recorder

AF implementation for EDEIP: PD, Discos urged to speed up

ISLAMABAD: The World Bank has urged Pakistan's Power Division and three major Distribution Companies (Discos) to fast-track implementation of the Additional Financing (AF) for the Electricity Distribution Efficiency Improvement Project (EDEIP), warning that continued delays could hamper the timely and effective use of the $55 million credit facility. In a letter addressed to Secretary Economic Affairs Dr. Kazim Niaz, the World Bank's new Country Director for Pakistan, Bolormaa Amgaabazar, noted a significant uptick in disbursements and commitments as of June 30, 2025—with disbursements rising to $18.09 million (9.3%) from 3.6% in November 2024, and commitments to $18.28 million (20.7%) from 9.0%. Still, the Bank flagged that targets for the quarter were not fully met due to rebidding of key contracts, procurement strategy revisions, and delays in grievance resolution. Wolrd Bank approves $55m in additional financing to Discos Despite these hurdles, the Bank remains optimistic. 'The project is now on track to meet its development goals by closure,' the letter stated, projecting end-FY26 disbursement and commitment levels at 30% and 95%, respectively. The World Bank lauded the Economic Affairs Division and Power Division for securing the AF package but emphasized that further momentum depends on meeting several immediate conditions—including finalizing the Financing Agreement and triggering its effectiveness within the 90-day window post-signature. The three Discos—Hyderabad Electric Supply Company (HESCO), Multan Electric Power Company (MEPCO), and Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO)—have been told to promptly roll out activities under the new funding. During the Bank's May 2025 Appraisal Mission, all stakeholders agreed on a roadmap to eliminate project bottlenecks and enhance implementation speed. The World Bank stressed the importance of updating the Project Enhancement Action Plan (PEAP) by July 21, 2025, to reflect on-the-ground realities and lessons learned. Similarly, the Project Procurement Strategy for Development (PPSD) must be revised in line with the Bank's 2025 Procurement Regulations to address persistent contract delays. Key improvements must also be made in procurement quality, bid evaluation speed, complaint management, and oversight of contract execution. All high-value contracts must incorporate rated criteria and early market engagement to ensure transparency and efficiency. Revised procurement plans and bid documents are due to the Bank by July 31, 2025. On the Environmental and Social (E&S) front, the Bank flagged slow progress in preparing key documents like Environmental and Social Impact Assessments (ESIAs) and Resettlement Action Plans (RAPs). These are to be submitted by the end of July. The Bank warned that continued inaction could stall broader project progress. While the capacity of Project Implementation Units (PIUs) has improved—with support from the Project Implementation and Management Support Consultant (PIMSC)—gaps remain. The Bank highlighted the need for greater stability in project teams, urging against frequent changes in PIMSC personnel. DISCOs have been instructed to submit a detailed FY26 work plan for consultant engagement by July 31 and to fill all key PIU vacancies with qualified personnel by August 31. 'With focused effort and leadership, the project can still meet its targets and deliver long-term impact on Pakistan's power distribution performance,' the Country Director noted, reiterating the Bank's commitment to the country's reform agenda. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store