‘This isn't just poor policy, it is economic self-sabotage'
Not profit, revenue. This is how FBR meets its tax targets: by squeezing those already in the formal economy. Tax refunds as a consequence of these policies continue to mount and are never refunded. 10% of my capital is stuck in tax refunds for years.
Every year, formal businesses in Pakistan are battered down by excessive corporate and advance taxes. When you add it all up, the effective corporate tax burden exceeds 40% and that is before you even account for the cost of compliance and withholding distortions.
Pakistan is perhaps the only country where both exist simultaneously: exorbitant corporate taxes and an inequitable personal tax regime. This isn't just poor policy, it is economic self-sabotage.
As long as such predatory taxation continues, don't expect meaningful investment or GDP growth. The system is rigged against those trying to play fair.
Najam Ali (Karachi)
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
Traders call off strike after agreement with govt over tax penalties
The business community has postponed the countrywide strike after successful talks with the government over certain budgetary measures introduced through the Finance Act 2025. A day earlier, the federal government invited representatives of all trade bodies for negotiations after Karachi's business community and transporters announced a countrywide wheel-jam strike scheduled for July 19. The Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) had called the strike in protest against five key measures incorporated into the federal budget for the current fiscal year, along with 32 anomalies in the Finance Act. KCCI opposes Sections 37A and 37B of the Finance Act, which, it claims, grant the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) arbitrary arrest powers. It also objects to Section 21(S), which imposes harsh penalties on cash transactions of Rs200,000 or more; mandatory digital invoicing under SRO 709; and the imposition of E-Bilty under Section 40. Read More: Aurangzeb offers talks to avert July 19 strike According to the Ministry of Finance, a joint meeting was held on Tuesday between government officials and business community representatives. The meeting was chaired by Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb and attended by members of chambers of commerce, trade organisations, and senior government officials. The meeting included a detailed review of the traders' concerns, particularly regarding Section 37A and other contentious provisions of the Finance Act 2025. During the session, a committee was formed under Prime Minister's Special Assistant Haroon Akhtar Khan to address the business community's reservations. It was also decided that the strike would be postponed until the committee completes its work. Also Read: SCCI backs strike against tax measures The finance minister assured traders of the government's full cooperation and transparency, stating: 'The government's objective is to curb large-scale tax fraud, not to harass honest businesses.' The committee will also include Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani, Prime Minister's Coordinator Rana Ehsan Afzal, the Chairman of the FBR, and representatives nominated by the business community. The committee is expected to conduct detailed consultations over the next 30 days and present a consensus-based, practical solution to the federal cabinet. It was agreed that the traders' concerns regarding transactions will be addressed, and efforts will be made to ensure that the business community does not face unnecessary difficulties.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Traders agree to defer strike after progress in talks with govt, says Finance Ministry
The government on Tuesday agreed to form a high-powered committee to address the business community's concerns over Section 37A of the Finance Act 2025, prompting traders to defer their planned nationwide strike for 30 days. The decision was made during a meeting chaired by Finance Minister Senator Muhammad Aurangzeb in Islamabad, attended by representatives of major chambers of commerce, trade bodies, and business associations, the Finance Ministry said in a statement. The minister assured the business community that the government's intention is to curb tax evasion, not to harass honest businesses. To facilitate dialogue, a committee will be constituted under Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Industries and Production, Haroon Akhtar Khan. The body will also include Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani, PM's Coordinator on Trade Rana Ehsan Afzal Khan, FBR Chairman, and nominated business leaders. KCCI, transporters announce July 19 strike against Finance Act provisions The committee will hold detailed consultations over the next 30 days and submit a consensus-based proposal to the Prime Minister and federal cabinet. Business representatives voiced strong reservations regarding Section 37A and its implications for transactions. The government acknowledged these concerns and pledged to ensure that no undue burden is placed on legitimate enterprises. The strike call will remain suspended while the committee completes its work.
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
‘This isn't just poor policy, it is economic self-sabotage'
Doing honest, formal business in Pakistan has become untenable. The latest move of raising withholding tax on services from 9% to 15% means you are now paying 15% of gross revenue upfront to the government. Not profit, revenue. This is how FBR meets its tax targets: by squeezing those already in the formal economy. Tax refunds as a consequence of these policies continue to mount and are never refunded. 10% of my capital is stuck in tax refunds for years. Every year, formal businesses in Pakistan are battered down by excessive corporate and advance taxes. When you add it all up, the effective corporate tax burden exceeds 40% and that is before you even account for the cost of compliance and withholding distortions. Pakistan is perhaps the only country where both exist simultaneously: exorbitant corporate taxes and an inequitable personal tax regime. This isn't just poor policy, it is economic self-sabotage. As long as such predatory taxation continues, don't expect meaningful investment or GDP growth. The system is rigged against those trying to play fair. Najam Ali (Karachi) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
