Teenage waitress convicted in fast-track courts over mix-up with surprise 18th birthday gift
The waitress, from Poole in Dorset, said her family bought the Fiat as a present to celebrate her landmark birthday, but mistakenly did not insure it immediately.
Last month, the DVLA charged her with keeping an uninsured vehicle and brought a criminal prosecution over the unpaid bill.
She explained the mix-up in a letter to Ipswich magistrates court, saying she had never driven the vehicle as she does not yet have a licence and at the time of the offence she did not even know the car was hers.
But it was not enough to spare her from a criminal conviction.
It is the latest piece of harsh justice to emerge from the Single Justice Procedure, an under-fire fast-track court process where magistrates hand out convictions in private court hearings.
The Labour government is dragging its feet on reforming the court process, despite lobbying from prosecutors, lawyers, and even magistrates themselves that the system is broken.
The teenager wrote in her letter: 'My family got the car for me as my 18th birthday present. I was still 17 at the time of the offence and had not actually been given the keys to the car and was not aware that it would be mine.'
She set out that she and her father have reading difficulties, and it was only when a friend read an official letter for them that they realised the car needed to be insured even if it was not being driven.
She said they received a rebate on car tax after declaring the 17-year-old Fiat 'off road' with a Statutory Off Road Notification (SORN), and did not realise she could pay a fine to avoid a criminal case.
'I have never used the car as I have still not passed my driving test', she continued. 'My dad is willing to pay the fine for me as he thinks this is his fault.
'He receives Universal Credit and PIP for his mental health, and I have just finished college and currently have a part-time job as a waitress on the minimum wage for an 18-year-old.'
She pleaded guilty to the offence, dated in January and just under four weeks before her 18th birthday, and added: 'I was a good student in school and college studying art and have never been in any trouble in my life. We just misunderstood the letter, I thought it said I had to SORN it or pay a fine if it doesn't get sorted.
'I am very sorry.'
One of the flaws in the Single Justice Procedure is that prosecutors do not see mitigation letters, due to the fast-track nature of the process.
It means they do not get the chance to assess the personal circumstances of defendants, and cannot decide if a prosecution continues to be in the public interest.
The DVLA itself has called on the government to change the system, so that prosecutors see all mitigation before a magistrate is called on to decide a case.
This reform has been backed by the Magistrates Association and the Bar Council, but is opposed by the BBC.
The government closed a consultation on Single Justice Procedure reform in early May, and has repeatedly refused to set out a timetable for reform. In a statement to The Standard, it said it is 'currently evaluating responses' to the consultation.
The system operates every week at magistrates courts across England and Wales, dealing with around 800,000 low-level criminal cases a year.
It was also the subject of a damning recent report by think tank Transform Justice.
Responding to the report, the Ministry of Justice claimed that there has never been a recorded miscarriage of justice due to the Single Justice Procedure.
In the teenage waitress' case, a magistrate gave her a 12-month conditional discharge instead of a fine. But she chose not to send the case back to the DVLA for an extra public interest check.
The teen will now have a criminal conviction, and must also pay a £20 court fee.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
16 minutes ago
- CNN
Tycoon who helped bring F1 to Singapore pleads guilty in graft case
AsiaFacebookTweetLink Follow Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng pleaded guilty to one charge of abetting the obstruction of justice on Monday in part of a landmark case that led to the jailing of former transport minister S. Iswaran for obtaining valuable items as a public servant last year. However, both the prosecution and defence agreed to grant Ong judicial mercy given his chronic illness, and argued for him to be fined in lieu of imprisonment. He will be sentenced on Aug 15. A second charge of abetting an offence was also taken into consideration. Judicial mercy gives courts the authority to give a more lenient sentence in exceptional mitigating circumstances, such as a terminal illness or when imprisonment could pose a high risk of endangering a life. The defence submitted that Ong suffers from multiple myeloma, an incurable cancer that affects his blood plasma cells and renders him immuno-compromised. The case has been the subject of major intrigue in Singapore, a wealthy financial hub that offers ministers salaries of more than S$1 million ($775,000) to deter graft and prides itself on its reputation for clean governance. Ong had informed Iswaran that his associates had been questioned and a private flight manifest with Iswaran's name on it for a flight from Singapore to Doha had been seized by the corruption watchdog during investigations. This led Iswaran to ask Ong to issue an invoice through Singapore GP, promoter of the Singapore F1 Grand Prix, to bill him for the trip, which prosecutors say Iswaran knew would make it less likely that he would be investigated. Iswaran was sentenced to 12 months in prison in October 2024, the first time a former cabinet member had ever been jailed in Singapore, on charges of obstructing justice and receiving more than $300,000 worth of gifts. In February, Iswaran was put under house arrest for the remainder of his sentence. Ong gave Iswaran tickets to English Premier League soccer matches, the Singapore Formula 1 Grand Prix, London musicals and a ride on a private jet among other favours. Iswaran was an adviser to the Singapore Grand Prix's steering committee, while Ong, 79, owns the rights to the race. The billionaire stepped down as managing director of Singapore-listed Hotel Properties in April.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Man who fell victim to modern slavery speaks of his journey from homelessness to hope
A MAN who found himself living on the streets of Bradford has spoken about his journey from homelessness to hope. Elvis Punculis had been working in the construction industry before his job was uncovered as being modern slavery. His perpetrators were jailed, but Elvis found himself homeless and without a passport. Elvis says he was rough sleeping for around three years across London and Bradford. 'The case was finished because I was a victim of modern slavery,' he told the T&A. 'I had some drug and alcohol issues. 'It came from homelessness mostly. Homelessness makes people do silly things. 'It's quite dangerous to sleep at night because some homeless people, they are on drugs, they can attack you. 'My nervous system really went down, especially with the drugs that I did, [it] was very bad for my brain and nervous system.' Hope Housing - a charity working with homeless people in Bradford - helped Elvis into recovery. 'I got in touch with my family back in my country,' he said. 'This helped me to stop doing drugs and drinking. My family, plus the support workers at Hope Housing, with their help, I've got clean from drugs and alcohol. 'I was isolated because I didn't really hang around with other homeless people. 'Society needs to help homeless people, but different homeless people have different problems. Every single person needs personal help. 'What makes me proud? I'm proud I have family and that I got over all the bad things. 'I'm grateful to these people.' The former hospital porter is now looking towards the future and living in shared accommodation. He hopes to build a life alongside his partner and her child, as well as reunite with his father in Latvia. It would be the first time Elvis has seen his family in almost 20 years. A fundraiser with a target of £500 has been created on Just Giving by housing support worker Inayah Sher. To donate visit The fundraiser reads: 'Elvis dreams of getting married and helping raise his partner's young child, creating the kind of safe, supportive family he never thought possible. His strength, honesty, and determination have brought him this far, but he now faces one final barrier: he simply can't afford the travel costs to reach his family. 'Once a hospital porter, Elvis is kind, intelligent, and deeply compassionate. He's worked hard to get where he is, and he's ready for a fresh start surrounded by love and stability. 'He doesn't want a handout, just a helping hand from a community that believes in second chances. 'This fundraiser, through Hope Housing, is a way for all of us to say: we see you, Elvis and we believe in you. 'Our goal is to raise £500 to cover the cost of travel and help Elvis begin this next chapter.'
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
MTG urges Donald Trump to commute George Santos' prison sentence
Georgia Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene is calling on the Trump administration to commute the sentence of former Congressman George Santos, who was sentenced to seven years in prison earlier this year after pleading guilty to wire fraud and identity theft. 'George Santos has taken responsibility,' Greene wrote on X, sharing a letter she sent to the Justice Department's Office of the Pardon Attorney. 'He's shown remorse. It's time to correct this injustice.' 'I wholeheartedly believe in justice and the rule of the law, and I understand the gravity of such actions,' the letter reads. 'However, I believe a seven-year sentence for such campaign-related matters for an individual with no prior criminal record extends far beyond what is warranted.' Greene claimed Santos, who has sold Cameo videos speaking to fans and hosted a podcast playing on his reputation called Pants on Fire, was 'sincerely remorseful and has accepted full responsibility for his actions.' In April, Santos was sentenced to 87 months in prison for wire fraud and identity theft after pleading guilty last year and agreeing to nearly $374,000 in restitution payments. The following month, the former New York representative, who prosecutors accused of pocketing thousands of dollars in donor funds, appealed to the president for a full pardon. 'Previously, I was not entertaining a pardon because I didn't know what my judgment would be. Now, I am in the process of filling an application to a pardon for the president. I'll take a commutation, a clemency, whatever the president is willing to give me,' Santos said in an interview with Piers Morgan. 'I do believe this is an unfair judgment handed down to me,' he added. 'There was a lot of politicization over the process.' Santos, 37, is now in custody at a federal prison in Fairton, New Jersey. He was expelled from Congress in December 2023, following the release of a damning ethics report. He shared a goodbye post on X before entering prison thanking his allies and critics alike. 'Well, darlings…The curtain falls, the spotlight dims, and the rhinestones are packed,' he wrote. 'From the halls of Congress to the chaos of cable news what a ride it's been! Was it messy? Always. Glamorous? Occasionally. Honest? I tried… most days.' Santos was charged with 23 felony counts for three alleged schemes to use donor money and government assistance funds to enrich himself while running for Congress. He initially pleaded not guilty to the charges. The Republican, who was elected in 2022, also grabbed headlines for exaggerating details about his education and work experience, as well as his mother's whereabouts during 9/11 and his Jewish heritage. Greene has sought presidential intervention for controversial figures before. In May, she asked the president to pardon Derek Chauvin, the then-Minneapolis police officer who murdered George Floyd in a widely seen 2020 incident that set off national protests.
