A Trick of the Mind by Daniel Yon review – explaining psychology's most important theory
The process of perception feels quite passive. We open our eyes and light floods in; the world is just there, waiting to be seen. But in reality there is an active element that we don't notice. Our brains are always 'filling in' our perceptual experience, supplementing incoming information with existing knowledge. For example, each of us has a spot at the back of our eye where there are no light receptors. We don't see the resulting hole in our field of vision because our brains ignore it. The phenomenon we call 'seeing' is the result of a continuously updated model in your mind, made up partly of incoming sensory information, but partly of pre-existing expectations. This is what is meant by the counterintuitive slogan of contemporary cognitive science: 'perception is a controlled hallucination'.
A century ago, someone with an interest in psychology might have turned to the work of Freud for an overarching vision of how the mind works. To the extent there is a psychological theory even remotely as significant today, it is the 'predictive processing' hypothesis. The brain is a prediction machine and our perceptual experiences consist of our prior experiences as well as new data. Daniel Yon's A Trick of the Mind is just the latest popularisation of these ideas, but he makes an excellent guide, both as a scientist working at the leading edge of this field and as a writer of great clarity. Your brain is a 'skull bound scientist', he proposes, forming hypotheses about the world and collecting data to test them.
The fascinating, often ingenious research reviewed here is sorely in need of an audience beyond dusty scientific journals. In 2017 a Yale lab recruited voice-hearing psychics and people with psychosis to take part in an experiment alongside non-voice-hearing controls. Participants were trained to experience auditory hallucinations when they saw a simple visual pattern (an unnervingly easy thing for psychologists to do). The team was able to demonstrate that the voice-hearers in their sample relied more heavily on prior experience than the non-voice-hearers. In other words, we can all cultivate the ability to conjure illusory sound based on our expectations, but some people already have that propensity, and it can have a dramatic effect on their lives.
To illustrate how expectations seep into visual experience, Yon's PhD student Helen Olawole Scott managed to manipulate people's ratings of the clarity of moving images they had seen. The key detail is that when participants had been led to expect less clarity in their perception, that is exactly what they reported. But the clarity of the image on the screen wasn't really any poorer.
It's sometimes a shame that Yon's book doesn't delve deeper. In Olawole Scott's experiments, for example, does Yon believe that it was participants' visual experience itself that became less clear, or just their judgments about the experience? Is there a meaningful difference? He also avoids engaging with some of the limitations of the predictive processing approach, including how it accounts for abstract thought. Challenges to a hypothesis are interesting, and help illuminate its details. In an otherwise theoretically sophisticated discussion this feels like an oversight.
One of the most enjoyable things popular science can do is surprise us with a new angle on how the world operates. Yon's book does this often as he draws out the implications of the predictive brain. Our introspection is unreliable ('we see ourselves dimly, through a cloud of noise'); the boundary between belief and perception is vaguer than it seems ('your brain begins to perceive what it expects'); and conspiracy theories are probably an adaptive result of a mind more open to unusual explanations during periods of greater uncertainty. This is a complex area of psychology, with a huge amount of new work being published all the time. To fold it into such a lively read is an admirable feat.
A Trick of the Mind: How the Brain Invents Your Reality by Daniel Yon is published by Cornerstone (£22). To support the Guardian, order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Archaeologists make surprising discovery at hidden ancient city site
Archaeologists have uncovered a bombshell at a hidden ancient city that had been buried for thousands of years - evidence that women, not men, may have ruled society there 9,000 years ago. The discovery could rewrite what we know about the earliest days of civilization and about gender roles throughout history. In a landmark study published in Science, researchers analyzing ancient DNA from nearly 400 skeletons at Çatalhöyük, a remarkably well-preserved Neolithic settlement in southern Turkey, revealed powerful clues that this early civilization was built around maternal ancestry, possibly operating under a matriarchal system. Çatalhöyük, a warren of mudbrick homes and goddess-like statues dating back to 9000 BCE, has long been a source of mystery and wonder. But the DNA analysis turned those legends into hard science, showing that women were buried with far more grave goods than men - and that daughters stayed with their maternal households, while sons often left. The astonishing find has electrified the archaeological world, challenging generations of assumptions about who held power in humanity's earliest cities and suggesting that the world's first great urban cultures may have rested on the shoulders of women. This remarkable Neolithic city has long fascinated scholars for its sprawling homes, elaborate art, and mysterious goddess-like figurines. But the latest genetic evidence has jolted the field of archaeology with clues that women were not only the spiritual symbols of Çatalhöyük but may have been its true rulers. In a painstaking investigation spanning more than a decade, a team of geneticists, archaeologists, and biological anthropologists extracted DNA from the skeletons of over 130 people buried beneath the floors of 35 separate houses at the site. In total, nearly 400 individuals have been recovered in graves at Çatalhöyük, a city once bustling with life for more than a thousand years. What they found was extraordinary: a strong genetic pattern showing maternal connections within the buildings. Women and their daughters were consistently buried together, while men seemed to arrive from outside, suggesting they married into the households of their wives. Researchers believe that as many as 70 to 100 percent of female offspring stayed attached to their maternal homes across generations, while males moved away. And the evidence of women's elevated status does not end there. Grave goods such as precious ornaments, tools, and other offerings were found five times more often in female burials than in male ones, a clear sign of preferential treatment and status in death that mirrored social power in life. Dr. Eline Schotsmans, a co-author of the study and research fellow at the University of Wollongong's School of Science in Australia, urged modern audiences to rethink outdated assumptions about ancient gender roles. The idea that a Neolithic city could have been matriarchal is not new in myth or folklore. The research is a culmination of 31 years of excavation and the analysis and marks one of the most important geological studies in recent history In total, nearly 400 individuals have been recovered in graves at Çatalhöyük, a city once bustling with life for more than a thousand years. Bones found at the site can be seen above Çatalhöyük's iconic clay statues depicting rounded, powerful female figures have long teased the possibility of a society with women at the helm. But this new DNA evidence offers the first scientifically grounded window into how such a social structure might have worked in practice. The implications go far beyond Turkey. Only months ago, a separate team of researchers studying the late Iron Age in Britain published evidence in Nature showing that women in Celtic communities also held powerful positions through maternal kinship. Analyzing DNA from 57 graves in Dorset, scientists revealed that two-thirds of the buried individuals came from a single maternal lineage - suggesting that women maintained community ties while men likely migrated in after marriage.
Daily Mail
17 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Millionaires' island is plagued with 'toxic' drinking water that's slowing infecting its inhabitants
Water supplies across a wealthy Massachusetts island have been plagued with toxic 'forever chemicals' that cause a slew of health complications. Nantucket environmental officials have been discovering alarming levels of PFAS in the ritzy enclave's drinking water. PFAS, known as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, are long-lasting chemicals that linger in the air, soil and water. They also build up in the human body - causing cancer, high cholesterol, liver damage and pregnancy complications, according to the CDC. Before experts realized their detrimental health and environmental impact, PFAS were used in various everyday products. Starting around the 1940s, they were commonly present in non-stick cookware, cleaning supplies, dental floss, candy wrappers and firefighting foam - which easily makes its way into groundwater. While certain types of PFAS are no longer used in the US, other variations of the potentially poisoning man-made chemicals are actually FDA approved for limited use, according to the agency. Nantucket has been grappling with concerning levels of PFAS contamination for years, but experts have noticed the problem is more widespread than they thought. 'The more we test, the more we're going to detect,' Andrew Shapero, Nantucket's new environmental contamination administrator, told the Boston Globe. It was previously understood that tainted areas included Nantucket Memorial Airport and Toms Way, located mid-island. But a recent Department of Environmental Protection investigation revealed private wells are also contaminated. Last month, Shaper warned the Board of Health one particular location - the intersection Hummock Pond Road and Burnt Swamp Lane - had PFAS levels 'above the imminent hazard threshold,' the Nantucket Current reported. The state standard for the maximum amount of the substances found in drinking water is 20 nanograms of per liter. At the Hummock Pond and Burnt Swamp intersection, 124 nanograms per liter were detected. 'That is an extremely concerning concentration to see in drinking water,' Shapero told the board. Shapero has been hired with the sole intent of tackling the island's PFAS problem and minimizing its harm. While addressing the water supply contamination, Shapero contextualized the issue, explaining places across the country are in the same worrying situation. 'PFAS have been detected in many wells on the island,' he told the outlet. 'PFAS have also been detected in many water sources throughout the country. 'And so from that perspective, Nantucket has a PFAS problem that is similar to the rest of the country.' Anywhere from 71 million to 95 million Americans rely on groundwater riddled with detectable levels of the substances, according to the US Geological Survey. But what makes Nantucket's dilemma unique is the island's dependency on groundwater. 'One is that Nantucket is a sole source aquifer, so all of the water on Nantucket comes from the ground that residents live on top of, whether that's private wells or the public water supply,' Shapero told the Boston Globe. 'So Nantucket really has no alternative options.' In 1984, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) decided the Nantucket Island Aquifer would be the area's sole source of drinking water, according to the agency. 'Certainly, to some extent, there is PFAS in the aquifer,' Shapero admitted, adding it is no easy feat trying to remove some of those compounds. 'Getting it out of the aquifer is challenging. Out of people's water is a little bit easier. These are forever chemicals, as you know, but filtration is an option.' The environmental official urged residents to get their blood tested to gauge if they have consumed dangerous amounts. Two nanograms per milliliter or less of PFAS in one's blood is considerably safe, he explained. But if someone has two to 20 nanograms detected - like 91 percent of Americans do - they 'might have some effects from PFAS,' Shapero said. 'On top of that, they have a threshold of 20, where you are in kind of the elevated area,' he told the outlet. 'And so that's about 9 percent of Americans who really should be keeping an eye on potential health effects from PFAS.' Ultimately, he encouraged people to test their privately owned wells, as he believes a 'substantial portion' of them have contaminated water. 'It's not just a Nantucket problem; it is a statewide and a countrywide problem,' he asserted.
The Independent
20 hours ago
- The Independent
People in six states see mystery ‘fireball' streak across sky
A mysterious object streaking across the sky has left hundreds of residents across the southern United States baffled, with over 200 reports pouring in from at least six states. The unidentified phenomenon, witnessed on Thursday around 12:30 p.m., prompted widespread speculation, though authorities suggest it was likely either a meteor or space junk. The majority of sightings, described as a streak of light and a fireball, originated from Georgia and South Carolina, according to a report from the National Weather Service office in Peachtree City, Georgia. As of Friday afternoon, the American Meteor Society had received at least 215 reports from people expressing a mix of wonder and amazement. Witnesses recounted vivid details of the event. A woman in Bethlehem, Georgia, described it as "a bright fireball." She added, "It did have a bright tail that disappeared with it, and left behind a smoke trail. I've never seen anything like it before." Meanwhile, a man in Milledgeville, Georgia, said "I believe it hit the ground." The roof of a Georgia home is pierced A resident of Henry County, Georgia, reported a rock coming through their roof around the time they heard the sonic boom from the fireball. It left behind a hole in the ceiling about the size of a golf ball and a crack in a laminate floor at the home southeast of Atlanta, according to the National Weather Service office in Peachtree City, Georgia. 'We are presuming that a piece of the object fell through their roof,' the weather service said in a brief statement on social media. Dashboard and doorbell cameras across several states in the southeastern U.S. states caught glimpses of the fireball that appeared to be plummeting straight down. Broad daylight sighting is rare Meteors and other space debris frequently enter Earth's atmosphere, but it is rare for an object to be so bright it can easily be seen in broad daylight. Videos of the event showed clear skies on Thursday, allowing many to see the object falling. 'First time to ever see an event in daylight like this,' a man in Cumming, Georgia, north of Atlanta, said in his report to the meteor society. 'It was so bright in the middle of the day... brighter than the sun,' a woman in Dublin, Georgia reported. Bright fireballs are caused by friction as an object enters the atmosphere and slows down considerably. Almost all objects break into minuscule pieces before striking the ground, according to Nasa.
