Israel outlines plans to pack Gaza's population into closed border zone
Critics say that would amount to forcible displacement in violation of international law because Israel's offensive and blockade have made Gaza largely uninhabitable.
Israeli officials say the aim is to separate the civilian population from Hamas, which still controls parts of Gaza and holds dozens of hostages abducted in the October 7 attack that triggered the war 21 months ago.
Palestinians would then be given the option of emigrating, they say.
US President Donald Trump, who has said he is narrowing in on a ceasefire and hopes to eventually end the war, has also voiced support for the mass transfer of Palestinians out of Gaza.
Defence minister Israel Katz outlined the latest plans in a closed briefing with Israeli military reporters on Monday.
His office did not respond to a request for comment on their reports, which appeared in several Israeli media outlets.
Mr Katz reportedly said he had ordered Israel's military to draw up plans to build what he called a 'humanitarian city' in Rafah, Gaza's southern-most city, which has been heavily damaged in the war and is now largely uninhabited.
Mr Katz reportedly said that Palestinians would not be able to leave once they enter the zone.
The military would initially move 600,000 Palestinians from an existing so-called humanitarian zone along the coast, with the aim of eventually transferring the whole population to Rafah.
Mr Katz said Israel was searching for an unspecified international body to deliver aid as Israeli troops secured the perimeter.
He said the military could start building the 'city' during a 60-day ceasefire that Mr Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu are discussing in Washington this week.
Hamas has said it will only release the remaining hostages in exchange for a lasting ceasefire and the withdrawal of Israeli forces.
Palestinians view Gaza as an integral part of their national homeland and oppose any plans to uproot them.
– Rights groups see preparations for mass expulsion
Both Mr Trump and Mr Netanyahu have said Gaza's population should be relocated to other countries through what they refer to as voluntary emigration.
During their meeting on Monday at the White House, Mr Netanyahu said Palestinians should have a 'free choice' on whether to stay or leave.
Palestinians fear that even if they leave temporarily to escape the war, Israel will never allow them to return — a possible repeat of the mass exodus that occurred before and during the 1948 war surrounding Israel's creation.
Mr Katz expressed hope that the 'emigration plan' would happen and said Mr Netanyahu was already leading efforts to find countries willing to take in Palestinians, according to Israel's Haaretz newspaper.
Rights groups fear that concentrating the population along the border with Egypt would create catastrophic conditions that leave Palestinians with no choice but to leave.
'Forcing people into what amounts to a large concentration camp echoes dark chapters of history,' said Tania Hary, executive director of Gisha, an Israeli group advocating Palestinians' right to freedom of movement.
'Israel's leadership hasn't been shy about the goal to expel Palestinians from Gaza and maintain permanent control over wide swathes of the territory,' she said.
– Israeli-backed aid system already in place
Israel and the US have already rolled out an aid distribution programme in Rafah that has been marred by violence and controversy.
Hundreds of Palestinians have been killed or wounded while trying to reach sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a contractor supported by Israel and the US, according to local hospitals.
Palestinian witnesses and health officials say Israeli forces have repeatedly opened fire toward crowds of people heading to the sites. The military says it has fired warning shots at people who approached its forces in what it describes as a suspicious manner.
GHF denies there has been any violence in or around the sites themselves, which are in Israeli military zones off limits to independent media.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Nearly 800 Palestinians killed near Gaza aid sites in six weeks
Almost 800 Palestinians have been killed near aid sites in Gaza over the past six weeks, according to the United Nations, most of them near locations run by a divisive Israeli and American-backed group. Of the 798 Palestinians who died, 615 were killed 'in the vicinity of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) sites, and 183 presumably on the route of aid convoys,' said Ravina Shamdasani, spokeswoman for the OHCHR, the UN human rights office. The GHF, which hires armed contractors to dispense aid, has seen executives quit and consultants pull out over the casualties and allegations that the group serves the interests of an Israeli plan to relocate Palestinians to southern Gaza, and from there possibly to other countries. Shortly after the UN's announcement, the Israeli military issued instructions to soldiers from 'lessons learnt' following a review of the incidents. The European Union said on Friday that it was contemplating action against Israel after finding that it had breached international law. 'Our aim is to really improve the situation on the ground [in Gaza], because the humanitarian situation is untenable,' said Kaja Kallas, the EU foreign policy chief. Britain has already suspended a trade agreement with Israel and sanctioned two extremist government ministers over the offensive that started in March, after a ceasefire unravelled. • The five obstacles to a Gaza ceasefire deal Earlier in the week, the EU and Israel agreed a deal to bring more food and fuel into the territory and open up more border crossings. It is not clear, however, when the agreement will come into effect or how much more aid it will provide. Israeli media have previously reported that troops were instructed to fire at aid seekers as a form of crowd control, if they showed up early to the sites or stayed after they closed. The Yediot Ahronoth newspaper claimed on Friday that Israel's navy had also fired shells at crowds in several incidents. It quoted the military acknowledging the actions, but saying the intent was not to harm civilians. Earlier, Haaretz, another Israeli daily, cited soldiers saying they were ordered to open fire on aid seekers who had assembled near the sites too early, or stayed behind. Witnesses have said that they came under fire from soldiers, tanks and navy gunboats. The GHF is meant to ensure that Hamas does not commandeer aid, but it has been shunned by the UN and other aid agencies who say its methods place aid seekers in danger. • IDF defies Netanyahu's plan for 'humanitarian city' in Gaza The US hopes to mediate another ceasefire soon to end the war, which started in October 2023 after Hamas attacked Israel, killing more than 1,100 people and taking more than 200 hostages. More than 56,000 Palestinians have been killed since, according to the Gaza health ministry. The ministry is run by Hamas, but its death tolls are seen as generally reliable by the UN.
Rhyl Journal
4 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
Four presumed dead and 11 missing after Houthi attack on cargo ship
The update from the EU's Operation Aspides came as private security forces continue to search for survivors from the Eternity C, a Greek-owned bulk carrier that sank on Wednesday. Ten people were recovered alive from the attack, including eight Filipino crew members and a Greek and Indian from the vessel's three-man security team. Fifteen people remain unaccounted for, including the four presumed dead, the EU mission said. 'All nearby vessels are advised to have a sharp look out,' a spokesman added. The Houthis have said they hold some of the crew. The US Embassy in Yemen — which has operated from Saudi Arabia for about a decade — has described the Houthis as having 'kidnapped' the mariners. The death toll is the highest from any seaborne assault carried out by the Iranian-backed Houthis in the crucial maritime trade route where 1 trillion dollars in cargo once passed through annually. The rebels say they are attacking ships to support Palestinians in the Gaza Strip during the Israel-Hamas war, and have in total sunk four vessels and killed sailors who had no direct role in the war. The attack on the Eternity C followed the sinking of the bulk carrier Magic Seas in a similar attack last weekend. Neither the European naval force nor the US had been escorting the two vessels when they were attacked. The Houthis have held mariners in the past. After seizing the vehicle carrier Galaxy Leader in November 2023, the rebels held the crew until January this year. From November 2023 to December 2024, the Houthis targeted more than 100 ships with missiles and drones. They stopped their attacks during a brief ceasefire in the war. They later became the target of an intense weeks-long campaign of air strikes ordered by US President Donald Trump before he declared a ceasefire had been reached with the rebels. A new possible ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas war — as well as the future of talks between the US and Iran over Tehran's battered nuclear programme — remain in the balance.
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
Netanyahu flies home without a Gaza peace deal but still keeps Trump onside
Benjamin Netanyahu arrived back in Israel on Friday without a ceasefire in the Gaza war despite heady predictions from US and Israeli officials that this week could provide a breakthrough in negotiations. But he did not come home completely empty-handed. The Israeli PM's visit was his third since Donald Trump's inauguration, with several high-profile meetings at the White House, a nomination for Trump to receive the Nobel peace prize, and suggestions from Trump and the special envoy to the Middle East, Steve Witkoff, that peace could be achieved in a week. But as Netanyahu's trip ended, no clear results had been achieved. Witkoff postponed a trip to Doha on Tuesday as it became clear that the negotiations had not reached a point where they could produce a ceasefire agreement. While Netanyahu repeated a refrain that a ceasefire could be announced within days, a deal to bring peace to more than 2 million Palestinians in the Gaza Strip remained elusive. 'I hope we can complete it in a few days,' Netanyahu said during an appearance on Newsmax, a conservative, pro-Trump news network on Wednesday. 'We'll probably have a 60-day ceasefire. Get the first batch [of hostages] out and then use the 60 days to try to negotiate an end to this.' By Thursday, when he attended a memorial service for two Israeli embassy staff killed in Washington, Netanyahu said Israel would not compromise on its demands for Hamas to disband. 'I am promoting a move that will result in a significant liberation, but only on the conditions Israel demands: Hamas disarm, Gaza demilitarise,' he said. 'If it is not achieved through diplomacy, it will be achieved by force.' Several officials suggested during the week that only a single sticking point remained between negotiators in Doha: the extent of a withdrawal by the Israel Defense Forces that would follow the release of some of the hostages being held by Hamas. The White House had pushed back against an initial map that would have left Israel with significant zones of control in Gaza, which Witkoff had compared to a 'Smotrich plan', referring to the hardline Israeli finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich. Israel reportedly redrew that map to make it more palatable to the US administration. But Hamas has said there were other disagreements, including negotiations over whether the Gaza Humanitarian Fund, an Israeli and US-backed logistics group, would be allowed to continue to deliver food to the territory (the UN said on Friday that 798 people had been killed trying to reach GHF sites since its introduction in May) and whether Israel would agree to a permanent truce, which it has said it would not. US mediators sought to bridge the gap by telling Qatari intermediaries they would guarantee the ceasefire's continuation after 60 days as negotiations continued. The upshot is that while Netanyahu leaves the US without a ceasefire, he has managed his relationship with Trump through high-profile assurances that he is seeking a peace in Gaza, while maintaining a status quo that members of his rightwing coalition, including the ministers Smotrich and Itamar Ben-Gvir, have said is preferable to a peace deal. For Netanyahu, the trip produced images that reinforced Israeli claims there was 'no daylight' between him and Trump, and came as the US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, announced a decision to impose sanctions on Francesca Albanese, a UN expert on the occupied Palestinian territories, for urging the international criminal court to investigate Israeli officials and US companies over the Gaza war. Trump's frustrations with Netanyahu appeared to be boiling over a month ago as the US president sought to negotiate a truce between Iran and Israel, which had been trading airstrikes and missile barrages as Israel sought to dismantle the Iranian nuclear programme. 'I'm not happy with Israel,' he said on the White House lawn. 'We basically have two countries that have been fighting so long and so hard that they don't know what the fuck they're doing.' That recalled remarks by Robert Gates, a former US secretary of defence, about successive White House administrations' difficulties in managing an ally in the region that also had considerable political influence in the US. 'Every president I worked for, at some point in his presidency, would get so pissed off at the Israelis that he couldn't speak,' Gates said. But a full breach with the US would have been disastrous for Netanyahu, who is managing his own difficult coalition and has been targeted in a graft investigation at home that was again delayed as a result of his international travel. And, after joint strikes against Iran, the Israeli PM was keen to show that the two men were in lockstep, while giving the Trump administration an opportunity to show it was working toward a Gaza peace. Elliott Abrams, the senior fellow for Middle Eastern studies at the Council on Foreign Relations in Washington, said the Trump administration had sought, as it did during the first short-lived ceasefire, to bring 'pressure to bear on Israel directly' through discussions with Netanyahu and his chief lieutenant, Ron Dermer, and 'trying to bring pressure on Hamas mostly through the Qataris, when there are these talks in Doha'. He added: 'Whether that pressure is effective is unclear.'
