Bryan Kohberger's plea deal leaves these burning questions unanswered
Prosecutors gave a step-by-step timeline of the 30-year-old killer's actions before, during, and after the pre-dawn attack in Moscow, Idaho, they failed to explain Kohberger's possible motive.
But the 'why?' wasn't the only burning question that has tantalized followers of the case for two and a half years.
Where is the knife?
Kohberger purchased a KA-BAR military-style knife, sheath, and sharpener from Amazon in March, 2022 – months before he even moved to the area, prosecutors said.
8 Bryan Kohberger at his extradition hearing.
Paul Martinka
8 Final photo of the victims, pictured just hours before their untimely deaths.
Police recovered the knife sheath at the crime scene with his DNA on it, but the murder weapon itself was nowhere to be found.
Cell phone tower records place Kohberger's phone near a rural village outside Moscow at around 4:45 a.m., roughly a half hour after the killings, which means he could have ditched it in any number of Idaho fields and pastures along the way.
Did Kohberger know any of the victims, and why did he target them?
Kohberger didn't break into a random house: Cell phone tower records placed Kohberger in the victims' neighborhood 23 times in the months before the murders, and security camera footage shows his car circling their block like a shark before finally moving in for the kill.
Early reports claimed Kohberger had cyberstalked one of the victims and bombarded her with Instagram messages, but his lawyers later insisted he had no connection to the victims at all.
So how did he know about Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen and Ethan Chapin?
The only hint prosecutors offered on Wednesday was suggesting Kohberger might not have entered the house intending to kill all four victims.
8 The house in Moscow, ID, where four University of Idaho students were knifed to death.
Kevin C. Downs for NY Post
8 The four victims: Kaylee Goncalves, top left; Xana Kernodle, top right; Ethan Chapin, bottom left; and Madison Mogen, bottom right.
ZUMAPRESS.com
Whose ID did Kohberger have hidden at his parents' house?
In 2023, a police source told NewsNation investigators had found an ID 'connected to someone from the quadruple homicide' carefully hidden at Kohberger's parents' house.
The report prompted frenzied speculation that Kohberger had kept a victim's ID as a souvenir.
That now seems unlikely: A victim's ID would have been a major piece of physical evidence and would likely have come up in the courtroom.
But the ID could have been any number of things: A fake ID for a potential escape off the grid, or even just the Amazon gift card prosecutors said he used to purchase the knife.
One colorful theory suggests Kohberer had a Joker-style calling card to leave at the scenes of future murders.
Whatever it was, we'll likely never know.
Is Kohberger a psychopath?
Kohberger's defense revealed that he had OCD and mild autism, but they said those traits has no bearing on the crimes he was accused of.
8 Judge Steven Hippler rejecting a motion to drop the death penalty.
TNS
8 Kohberger at a court hearing. His defense used an autism diagnosis to explain his distinctive, dead-eyed stare.
AP
A jury trial could have involved psychological evaluations of Kohberger and evidence for what psychologists call 'dark tetrad' personality traits: Narcissism, sadism, Machiavellian manipulativeness, and, of course, psychopathy.
8 Bryan Kohberger appears for his July 2 plea hearing.
AP
8 Two University of Idaho victims, Madison Mogen and Xana Kernodle.
Instagram / @xanakernodle
Why did Kohberger return to the scene of the crime?
Cell phone tower records suggest Kohberger went back to his victim's neighborhood roughly five hours after the bloody deed.
Was it to recover a piece of evidence, perhaps even the missing knife? Or just to admire his deadly handiwork?
He certainly seemed to be proud of himself, as evidenced by a grinning, 'thumbs up' selfie he took when he got home.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bryan Kohberger Did Not Plan to Murder All 4 Victims, Suggests Prosecutor as He Fights Back Tears in Court
Prosecutor Bill Thompson said during a plea hearing on July 2 that the state could not offer evidence that Bryan Kohberger planned to kill all four of his victims Thompson said Kohberger first killed Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves, but Goncalves had moved out of the home by the time of the murders and was just visiting for the weekend Xana Kernodle was killed after crossing paths with Kohberger as he was likely trying to leave the home, said Thompson, at which point she and Ethan Chapin were murderedBryan Kohberger did not plan to murder all four of his victims on the night of Nov. 13, 2022, according to the lead prosecutor in the case. The former criminology student, 30, entered the off-campus home of a group of University of Idaho students with the intention of killing one or two of his young victims, Latah County Prosecutor Bill Thompson suggested in court on July 2. Thompson detailed how events transpired on the night of the murders after Kohberger confessed to killing the four victims: Madison Mogen, 21; Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Xana Kernodle, 20; and Ethan Chapin, 20. Towards the end of his 10-minute presentation, Thompson suddenly became overwhelmed with emotion and, after a brief pause, began to cry. He then finished his remarks trying to fight back those tears while telling Judge Steven Hippler: "As the defendant has just admitted and pleaded guilty, on November 13, 2022, Mr. Kohberger entered the residence at 1122 King Road in Moscow, Idaho. He did that with the intent to kill." Thompson then added: "We will not represent that he intended to commit all of the murders that he did that night, but we know that that is what resulted." The lawyer then finished his remarks by saying that even if Kohberger's actions were not planned, he did kill his four victims "intentionally, willfully, deliberately, with premeditation and with malice aforethought." Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. Thompson explained to the court that on the night of the murders, Kohberger entered the victims' house through a sliding door on the second floor and immediately went to the third floor, where Mogen and Goncalves were laying in bed together. While not mentioned in Thompson's remarks, the family of Goncalves has previously said she had moved out of the home because she had lined up a job in Austin, but then decided to return to see her friends. This, and the fact that Kohberger went right to the third floor when there were two bedrooms on the second floor where he entered, suggests that Mogen, and possibly Goncalves, were Kohberger's initial targets. The other murders may have just been a result of an individual being in the wrong place at the wrong time. "The state's evidence would show that Xana Kernodle was still awake [when Mogen and Goncalves were stabbed]. In fact, Xana had taken a Door Dash order not long before this started." Thompson said that while Kohberger was either "coming down the stairs or leaving" he ran into Kernodle and stabbed her to death. Then he went into Kernodle's bedroom, said Thompson, where her boyfriend Ethan Chapin was asleep and killed him. "Each victim suffered multiple wounds," Thompson said, while also stressing there was no evidence or proof of sexual assault. Then, on his way out, Kohberger spared a life. Thompson said one of the two surviving roommates watched Kohberger exit through the second-floor sliding door with a container in his hand. That young woman then ran downstairs to the bedroom of the other surviving roommate, where they spent the night together, unaware that four people were dead upstairs. The man who ended the lives of those four victims will now spend the rest of his life in prison after making a deal with prosecutors, sparing him the death penalty. Kohberger's sentencing is scheduled for July 23. Read the original article on People
New York Post
13 hours ago
- New York Post
Social media influencer sentenced for child porn
A social media influencer who gained a following sharing his picturesque Gulf Coast lifestyle with his wife online has been sentenced to five years behind bars for child pornography. Georgia native Joshua David Stapleton, 39, received a 20-year sentence, with five years served in jail and another 15 years on probation after pleading guilty to 20 counts of sexual exploitation of children, according to court documents obtained by Fox 5 Atlanta. Stapleton and his wife run the 'Gulf Coast Stapletons' social media account, which has racked up more than 86,000 followers and over a million likes on TikTok and Instagram. Investigators learned that between 2018 and 2020, Stapleton downloaded images of prepubescent children in sexually abusive situations. 3 Joshua David Stapleton, 39, received a 20-year sentence, with 5 years to be served in custody and the remaining 15 on probation. Bartow County Sheriff's Office 3 Josh and Brittani Stapleton ran 'The Gulf Coast Stapletons' TikTok account together. Instagram/brittanimorris_stapleton He was initially charged with 15 counts of child porn possession, but was later indicted on 40 counts of sexual exploitation of children. He entered a non-negotiable plea deal in which he pleaded guilty to just 20 counts. The 'Gulf Coast Stapletons' lifestyle content features the couple working out, eating food and going on vacations. Just last week they posted several videos from their trip to Orange Beach, Alabama. Stapleton's wife, Brittani Morris Stapleton, has been attempting to correct what she's called 'misinformation' online about her husband after news of his case spread. The pair were married in 2023 after he'd been charged. 'Josh was absolutely up front with me about everything in the charges, there were no secrets,' she said in a recent TikTok post. 3 'The Gulf Coast Stapletons' have more than 86,000 followers on TikTok. Instagram/brittanimorris_stapleton She also pushed back on accusations that the pair were projecting 'fake lives' on their social media accounts. 'There's nothing fake about it. It was our lives, we are still happy, he and I have no issues,' Brittani posted. Stapleton is currently being held in the Bartow County Sheriff's Office Jail.
14 hours ago
What to know about Julio César Chávez Jr.'s arrest by U.S. immigration officials
LOS ANGELES -- U.S. immigration officials have arrested famous Mexican boxer Julio César Chávez Jr. — days after his high-profile fight with Jake Paul — for overstaying his visa and lying on a green card application, officials said Thursday. Chávez was detained in front of his home on Wednesday and will be deported to Mexico, where he faces organized crime charges, authorities said. Here's what to know about this arrest: The 39-year-old boxer is a former middleweight champion hails from Mexico. His father, Julio César Chávez, is one of the most beloved athletes in Mexican history and a member of the International Boxing Hall of Fame. The son has battled drug addiction for much of his lengthy boxing career, failing drug tests, serving suspensions and egregiously missing weight while being widely criticized for his intermittent dedication to the sport. The younger Chavez still rose to the heights, winning the WBC middleweight title in 2011 and defending it three times. Chávez shared the ring with generational greats Canelo Álvarez and Sergio Martinez, losing to both. In 2012, he was convicted of drunken driving in Los Angeles and sentenced to 13 days in jail. Then in January 2024, he was arrested on gun charges. Police said he possessed two AR-style ghost rifles. He was later freed on a $50,000 bond and on condition he went to a residential drug treatment facility. The case is still pending, with Chávez reporting his progress regularly. Chávez was away from the ring for three years before his return late last year, but Paul's invitation brought him back again. According to his attorney, Michael Goldstein, Chávez was picked up Wednesday by a large number of federal agents while he was riding a scooter in front of a home where he resides in the upscale Los Angeles neighborhood of Studio City, near Hollywood. Goldstein said officials blocked off the street and took Chávez into custody without informing his family. TV stations staked out his home Thursday afternoon and did not see anyone leave his home. Just days before, Chávez had faced off against influencer-turned-boxer Paul and lost in a highly anticipated fight in Anaheim, California. The Department of Homeland Security said officials had determined Chávez should be arrested June 27, a day before the fight. It was unclear why they waited to act for days after the high-profile event. Federal officials said in a news release that Chávez overstayed a tourist visa that he entered the U.S. with in August 2023. The visa expired in February 2024, they said. Homeland Security said Chávez submitted multiple fraudulent statements when he applied for permanent residency on April 2, 2024, based on his marriage to a U.S. citizen, Frida Muñoz. She is the mother of a granddaughter of imprisoned Sinaloa cartel kingpin Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzman. U.S. officials said he is believed to be affiliated with the powerful Sinaloa Cartel that is blamed for a significant portion of Mexico's drug violence. Mexico's Attorney General's Office said that an arrest warrant against 'Julio 'C was issued in March 2023 in an investigation of organized crime and arms trafficking allegations, and that Mexico initiated extradition proceedings on Thursday. A federal agent who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly on the matter confirmed to The Associated Press that 'Julio C' is Chávez. Goldstein, Chávez's attorney, said he did not know where Chávez was being detained as of Thursday morning. DHS said Thursday that he was being processed for 'expedited removal' from the country. Chávez's family issued a statement Thursday afternoon in support of him, the Los Angeles Times reported. 'We have full confidence in his innocence,' the statement said. 'We firmly believe that the proper course is to allow the competent authorities to carry out their work without external pressure or speculation.'
