logo
DWP disability cuts branded 'catastrophic' as Liz Kendall unveils major changes

DWP disability cuts branded 'catastrophic' as Liz Kendall unveils major changes

Daily Mirror18-06-2025

Charities urged MPs to reject changes to the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Universal Credit, which the Government's own assessment said risked pushing people into poverty
The Government has been accused of turning its back on sick and disabled people after pressing ahead with "catastrophic" benefit cuts.
Charities urged MPs to reject changes to the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Universal Credit (UC), which the Government's own assessment said risked pushing an extra 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, into poverty.

Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall argued she was taking "the road of compassion, opportunity and dignity" as she sought to soften the impact by introducing a 13-week transition period so existing claimants avoid a cliff edge. But campaigners said the last-minute changes to the plans would do little to mitigate the devastating impact.

Around 3.2 million families could be hit by the overall reforms by 2030, with an average loss of £1,720 per year, according to the Government's analysis in March. The document said estimates did not include the impact of the £1 billion employment support package "which we expect to mitigate the poverty impact".
Around 800,000 people are expected to be impacted by PIP changes, including 370,000 current claimants and 430,000 future recipients, with an average loss of £4,500 per year.
READ MORE: 'Spend a day in our life, PM' says mum whose disabled daughter may lose PIP benefits
The tightening of eligibility will mean those who can't wash half of their body or cook a meal unaided no longer qualify for the daily living element - unless they have another condition.
The UC health element, which is claimed by more than two million people, will be frozen at £97 a week for existing claimants until 2029/30, and reduced to £50 a week for new claimants from 2026/27.
Ms Kendall has previously said people under 22 will no longer be able to access the health top up of UC - and instead will be offered a 'youth guarantee' of training or work, with threats of benefit cuts if they reject the offer.

The 13-week grace period will apply to existing claimants who lose the PIP daily living component, including those who lose eligibility to Carers Allowance and the carer's element of Universal Credit. More than 200,000 people with the most severe, lifelong conditions to be protected from future reassessment for UC.
Food bank network Trussell said: "The reality of this Bill is still record cuts in support for disabled people, and the biggest cuts to social security since 2015."
Mencap, the learning disability charity, accused the Government of having "confirmed the choice to turn its back on thousands of disabled people".

Carers UK said at least 150,000 people will lose their Carer's Allowance, while nearly 100,000 carers who receive both PIP and Carer's Allowance will lose their disability benefit.
Keir Starmer is braced for the biggest revolt of his premiership of the legislation, with dozens of Labour MPs poised to rebel when it faces its first Commons test in the coming weeks.
Labour MP Steve Witherden, who represents Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr, told the Mirror: "I find the proposals deeply concerning, particularly at a time when poverty levels across the UK are already alarmingly high.

"Millions of children live in households where parents are struggling to afford basic necessities such as food, heating, or even sterilising baby bottles.
"This Bill risks exacerbating these difficulties, with cuts that could push disabled households into even deeper hardship - especially in Wales, which currently has the highest poverty rates among disabled people in the UK. I will be voting against this Bill.'
Ms Kendall said the system was broken - and would fail to deliver for those who need it most without reform. "Our social security system is at a crossroads," she said. "Unless we reform it, more people will be denied opportunities, and it may not be there for those who need it.

"This legislation represents a new social contract and marks the moment we take the road of compassion, opportunity and dignity.
"This will give people peace of mind, while also fixing our broken social security system so it supports those who can work to do so while protecting those who cannot - putting welfare spending on a more sustainable path to unlock growth as part of our Plan for Change."
Ministers say the plans - designed to slash £5billion from the welfare bill by 2030 - are designed to drive down spiralling costs and help more people back into work.

One in 10 people of working age now claiming a sickness or disability benefit and some one million young people are not in education, employment or training - around one in eight.
The number of people claiming PIP is expected to double from 2 million to 4 million over this decade, sending the bill for working-age sickness and disability benefit to £70billion a year by the end of this Parliament. A record 3.74 million people in England and Wales were claiming PIP in April.

Helen Barnard, Director of policy at Trussell, said: 'This bill will push nearly half a million more people into severe hardship and towards the doors of food banks." She added: 'The last minute details on protections offer something for a small proportion of people, but even they will still see a real-terms cut."
Mencap's Jackie O'Sullivan said: 'Today the Government confirmed the choice to turn its back on thousands of disabled people and by pushing ahead with these welfare reforms, they are causing a huge amount of anxiety.
'Mencap's recent survey of people with a learning disability found an alarming 70% would need to cut down on food if they lose PIP, while over half (60%) said they would need to cut back on heating and nearly half (45%) were worried they would be unable to leave their home."

Charlotte Gill, Head of Campaigns and Public Affairs at the MS Society, said: "The government claims this Bill is about protecting people, but in reality it will take thousands of pounds a year from disabled people, including many living with MS – pushing more into poverty and worsening people's health.
'PIP is a lifeline not a luxury. If these cuts go ahead, many will be forced to reduce spending on essentials like food and heating. And some have told us they would have to leave work."
James Taylor, Director of Strategy at disability equality charity Scope said: 'This bill will be catastrophic for disabled people.Cutting benefits will plunge hundreds of thousands into poverty."
Louise Murphy, senior economist at the Resolution Foundation, said the longer period of protection for those affected by Pip cuts would ease the blow but said extra funding for employment support wasn't coming into effect until 2029.
She added: "While ministers have softened the stick of welfare cuts, they have not strengthened the carrot of greater employment support."

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Disabled people ‘could face extra costs of £15k a year by end of the decade' as welfare vote looms
Disabled people ‘could face extra costs of £15k a year by end of the decade' as welfare vote looms

The Independent

time21 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Disabled people ‘could face extra costs of £15k a year by end of the decade' as welfare vote looms

Disabled people could face extra costs of almost £15,000 a year by the end of the decade, according to charity analysis published ahead of a vote on controversial welfare reforms. Analysis from disability equality charity Scope estimated that average monthly costs – not taking into account welfare reforms – to cover the extra needs of disabled people will rise to £1,244, totalling almost £15,000 a year, by April 2029. The current extra costs for disabled people are estimated to be £1,095 a month. People with disabilities often have higher household costs, such as higher energy bills, and extra costs for specialist mobility equipment. Scope has warned that, despite a government U-turn on welfare cuts, disabled people will still be subjected to a 'two-tier system' where 'huge numbers' of people are still out of pocket. The government's welfare bill, which will be voted on on Tuesday, included a major package of cuts to social security payments. Changes to the Personal Independence Payment (Pip) include a higher bar for eligibility, with claimants having to score four points in one category to be eligible. Many Labour MPs wanted these changes scrapped, but the government has offered a compromise it they would only apply the new rules to new claimants, and conduct a review of the criteria. The health element of universal credit was also due to be frozen in cash terms; however, ministers have now agreed to lift it in line with inflation. Ministers were forced into the 11th-hour climbdown on Friday as they were facing a major backbench rebellion by more than 100 MPs. Prime minister Sir Keir Starmer has said that he did not turn his attention fully to the welfare bill rebellion until Wednesday night last week, as he was 'heavily focused on what was happening with Nato and the Middle East all weekend'. He told The Sunday Times: 'I turned my attention fully to it when I got back from Nato on Wednesday night. Obviously, in the course of the early part of this week we were busy trying to make sure Nato was a success. 'From the moment I got back from the G7, I went straight into a Cobra meeting. My full attention really bore down on this on Thursday. At that point, we were able to move relatively quickly.' While Sir Keir has said his welfare reforms now strike "the right balance", Scope argued the changes will still result in "catastrophic cuts", with some disabled people protected and supported but others not. The charity's latest report is based on analysis of the Family Resources Survey (FRS) and makes calculations using Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) inflation forecasts to show the likely extra costs faced by disabled people in the coming years. It does not take into account the impact of the welfare reforms, with the charity warning that the figures highlight that those people who do not get Pip could end up in a 'precarious financial position and will still face high extra costs'. It estimated extra costs for disabled people are currently at £1,095 a month, up from last year's level of £1,010. Scope said benefits do not cover the entirety of these costs, with a current monthly shortfall of around £630, likely to rise to a £704 shortfall by the end of the decade. James Taylor, executive director of strategy at Scope, said: 'Life costs an enormous amount more when you're disabled. Whether it's higher electricity bills because of medical equipment to power, or higher heating bills because of health conditions affected by the cold. 'Our latest analysis finds the price tag of disability is now £1,095 a month. A figure only set to increase in the coming years unless action is taken. 'The government must change course on these catastrophic cuts now, and properly co-produce with disabled people on how to reform our welfare system.' A government spokesperson said: 'We're delivering one of the biggest packages of welfare reforms in a generation – including scrapping the work capability assessment, rebalancing universal credit, and investing in tailored employment support. 'Protecting people is a principle we will never compromise on, which is why we're delivering long-lasting and meaningful change that puts the welfare system on sustainable footing so the safety net will always be there for those who need it.'

MPs on fence ahead of crunch welfare vote as 'costs facing disabled people soar'
MPs on fence ahead of crunch welfare vote as 'costs facing disabled people soar'

Daily Mirror

time21 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

MPs on fence ahead of crunch welfare vote as 'costs facing disabled people soar'

Dozens of Labour MPs are still said to be on the fence about whether to support plans to reform the welfare system in a crunch vote on Tuesday, despite major concessions Disabled people could face extra costs of almost £15,000 a year by the end of the decade, grim research shows, as the row over the Government's welfare cuts drags on. Dozens of Labour MPs are still said to be on the fence about whether to support plans to reform the welfare system in a crunch vote on Tuesday. ‌ Many MPs spent the weekend mulling over a major package of concessions offered by Keir Starmer last week. In a dramatic climbdown on Thursday, the PM agreed to protect all existing claimants from losing Personal Independence Payments (PIP). ‌ Plans to tighten eligibility will now only apply to new claimants from November 2026, in a reprieve to around 370,000 people who were due to lose around £4,150-a-year. And existing recipients of the health element of Universal Credit will have their incomes protected in real terms. 'PIP reforms are unnerving' A teenager in remission from cancer said he has found the rows over welfare reforms 'unnerving' and 'worrying'. Daniel Evans, 19, who was diagnosed with stage four lymphoma when he was 17, is currently having his Personal Independence Payments reassessed. He should be assessed under the old system after the latest concessions but said he fears for those in the future if they do not qualify for PIP. Daniel said he is no longer able to do things he enjoys, including playing football. 'It's mainly my breathing, my heart, and tiredness. I'm just like a shadow of my former self,' he said. 'I think it's just the new reality. You have to come to terms with it.' PIP helps him pay for transport, such as taxis, or fuel for his mum to take him back and forth to appointments. Asked about the potential tightening of PIP eligibility rules, he said: 'It's a bit unnerving, because what I say is, for anyone who has had treatment and gone through it and are technically better, let's say in remission, just because someone is in remission, it doesn't mean they're instantly able to do a lot of things, like being able to go to work instantly. 'So they still have to get support. It's not like things get better and you can just go to work five days a week, things are still difficult.' Plans for a major review of PIP will also be set out today, which will be co-produced by disabled people, organisations who represent them and MPs. It is hoped that the terms of the review - which will place disabled people at the heart of it - will persuade nervy MPs that the legislation is now heading in the right direction. Meanwhile, research released by disability charity Scope has estimated the extra monthly costs related to a person's disability have now risen to £1,095. Even for those who receive benefits, there is an average shortfall of £630 every month, as the payments don't go far enough, Scope said. The Disability Price Tag report, which is released annually by Scope and does not take into account the welfare reforms, estimates this is set to rise to £1,224 by 2029/30, totalling almost £15,000 a year. It would mean those with a disability would see a £704 shortfall in their benefits income by 2029, the study said. The charity said the Government's concessions 'will just create a two-tier system, where huge numbers of disabled people face the disability price tag with little or no support from PIP'. ‌ Meanwhile Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham told an event at Glastonbury Festival that MPs should still vote against the welfare bill tomorrow. 'It's simply wrong and I will never, ever support what is being proposed,' he said. 'This reminds me why I left Westminster because the default mindset of the two parties is to be tough on benefits. That mentality creates a deficit model that is distrustful of people… a system I know many disabled people fear interacting with." ‌ Mr Starmer faced a humiliating defeat in the Commons after more than 120 Labour MPs signed an amendment to block his welfare plans last week. The Prime Minister this weekend said he wished he had reached a 'better position' with Labour MPs earlier over welfare cuts but was distracted by international affairs, which he admitted was not an 'excuse'. In an interview with the Sunday Times, he said: 'I'd have liked to get to a better position with colleagues sooner than we did — that's for sure. I'm putting this as context rather than excuse: I was heavily focused on what was happening with Nato and the Middle East all weekend. I turned my attention fully to it [the welfare bill] when I got back from Nato on Wednesday night.' ‌ Health Secretary Wes Streeting stopped short of saying he was confident the Government will win tomorrow's vote. But he said that the changes "have put us in a much better position". "As a result of the changes, it means anyone watching this morning who's in receipt of personal independence payments now has the peace of mind of knowing that their situation is protected," he said. Labour MP and former Cabinet minister Louise Haigh meanwhile said she planned to back the Bill but needed to see the full detail of the new plans today. She also said it was a moment for the Government to "reset'. ‌ "I think this is a moment and an opportunity to reset the Government's relationship with the British public and to move forward, to adopt a different approach to our economic policy and our political strategy," she told the BBC. But disabled Labour MP Olivia Blake said the proposed concessions had been "plucked from the air". Echoing Scope, she told The Guardian: "This could form an unethical two-tier system that treats two people with the exact same injury or illness differently.' Fresh details on the welfare reforms will be published on Monday, including the terms of reference for a review, led by Disability Minister Stephen Timms, of the PIP assessment. ‌ Alongside the review, draft regulations for the new Right to Try Guarantee will be laid in Parliament. It will enshrine in law the right for people receiving health and disability benefits to try work without fear of reassessment. The Department for Work and Pensions also said £300million will be brought forward over the next three years to help disabled people and those with health conditions get into work. It will mean the total employment support will have increased by £2.2billion over four years. Officials say that the Bill, while criticised for having tightened some benefits eligibility, will protect the most vulnerable by uprating of Universal Credit standard rate. Nearly four million households will see an income boost with the main rate of UC set to increase above inflation every year for the next four years - estimated to be worth £725 by 2029/30 for a single household. This is said to be the largest, permanent real-terms increase to basic out of work support since 1980, according to the IFS. ‌ James Taylor, executive director of strategy at Scope, said: 'Life costs an enormous amount more when you're disabled. Whether it's higher electricity bills because of medical equipment to power. Or higher heating bills because of health conditions affected by the cold. 'The concessions put forward by government will just create a two-tier system, where huge numbers of disabled people face the disability price tag with little or no support from PIP. The government must change course on these catastrophic cuts now, and properly co-produce with disabled people on how to reform our welfare system.' Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall said the changes were about 'delivering a fairer, more compassionate system'. ‌ 'We must build a welfare system that provides security for those who cannot work and the right support for those who can,' she said. 'Too often, disabled people feel trapped—worried that if they try to work, they could lose the support they depend on. 'That is why we are taking action to remove those barriers, support disabled people to live with dignity and independence, and open routes into employment for those who want to pursue it. 'This is about delivering a fairer, more compassionate system as part of our Plan for Change which supports people to thrive, whatever their circumstances.'

Labour's planned PIP disability cuts are cruel, say two-thirds of UK
Labour's planned PIP disability cuts are cruel, say two-thirds of UK

The Independent

time26 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Labour's planned PIP disability cuts are cruel, say two-thirds of UK

Some 75 per cent of the UK think the government's plan to remove Personal Independent Payments (PIP) from those with long-term disabilities is 'cruel', A new poll, commissioned by human rights charity Amnesty International UK, found the majority of people surveyed - 54 per cent - did not support the government's changes to restrict the number of people claiming PIP. Under plans in the controversial new welfare bill, a higher bar for eligibility will be introduced for PIP, the main disability benefit in England. PIP is given to support disabled people with extra costs, such as higher energy bills or mobility equipment. People who claim it are awarded points depending on their ability to do certain things, such as washing. New measures introduced in the welfare bill, which will be voted on on Tuesday (1 July), will require claimants to score a minimum of eight points across a range of tasks to qualify for the daily living allowance. In a concession to Labour MPs, Liz Kendall has exempted existing PIP claimants from these new requirements. A Savanta poll of 2,080 people, weighted by age and region, found that 69 per cent of respondents would prefer the UK government to tax the super-rich rather than cut social security. 59 per cent also said that cutting PIP would not help more people get into work. Those respondents living in the North West were the most likely to label the cuts as 'cruel' - with 82 per cent of people agreeing with the statement. This was closely followed by 80 per cent of people in the South East. The polling comes ahead of a crunch vote in parliament on Tuesday. The government has made concessions to rebel Labour MPs over the welfare bill after more than 120 MPs decided to vote against it. Jen Clark, from Amnesty International, said: 'The message from the public is clear: poverty is a political choice, and this government is dangerously close to choosing poverty and party politics over people's rights. 'Across every age group, background, and political belief, people agree that cutting PIP is cruel and they can see these proposals for what they are - unfair, unnecessary, and unjust.' Disability charity Scope has also criticised the planned changes, with executive director of strategy James Taylor accusing the government of subjecting disabled people to a 'two-tier system' where 'huge numbers' of people are still out of pocket. He added: 'The government must change course on these catastrophic cuts now'. A government spokesperson said: "We're delivering one of the biggest packages of welfare reforms in a generation - including scrapping the Work Capability Assessment, rebalancing Universal Credit, and investing in tailored employment support. "Protecting people is a principle we will never compromise on, which is why we're delivering long-lasting and meaningful change that puts the welfare system on sustainable footing so the safety net will always be there for those who need it.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store