'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise MOM's appreciation coins for migrant workers in sinkhole rescue
A thread posted on the r/Singapore subreddit captioned "That's so sad, wish they were given something more useful", featuring a video of Minister of State (MOS) for Manpower Dinesh Vasu Dash presenting commemorative coins to the workers, has quickly gained traction.
Mr Dinsh, who paid a personal visit to the workers' dormitory on the evening of July 27, said the coins are a small token of appreciation that goes a long way in recognising the contributions of migrant workers in Singapore.
The coins, presented in red boxes and akin certificates of commendation, are similar to those given to four migrant workers who helped rescue children from a shophouse fire in River Valley in April.
'It's embarrassing': Netizens criticise coins
But many commentors on the Reddit thread expressed frustration and disappointment over the gesture.
One called it "embarrassing", suggesting that the workers should have been given something more official, such as formal certificates that could support them in future job applications.
Others questioned why the workers were not offered something more practical such as cash or vouchers.
"Does this coin mean anything to the workers?" one asked, adding that a monetary reward, even if modest, "would mean the world to them".
Should good deeds always be rewarded with money?
While public sentiment appears to have been largely critical, it also raises a broader question: should good deeds be rewarded with money?
Associate Professor Tan Ern Ser, a sociologist at the National University of Singapore (NUS), told The New Paper that he believes it is "inappropriate" for acts of bravery or civic responsibility to be routinely rewarded with cash.
Financial incentives and rewards like cash gifts "could undermine the intrinsic rewards of helpfulness," said A/P Tan.
Financial support is what workers value: IRR
Local charity ItsRainingRaincoats (IRR) recently launched a fundraiser that has since exceeded its target of raising $70,000 for the migrant workers involved in the sinkhole rescue.
In an interview with The New Paper, IRR founder Dipa Swaminathan said she believes financial support is what the workers truly value, and is "incredibly proud" of the amount raised.
Ms Swaminathan also highlighted the emotional significance of the support: the validation the workers would feel, and the goodwill such gestures could foster. "It would be tremendous for them," she said.
MOM had not responded to TNP's queries as of press time.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
19 hours ago
- CNA
From fear to friendship: Seniors find confidence through horses
From fear to friendship: Seniors find confidence through horses By CNA/Nuria Ling Once scared of horses, Mdm Chow May Ho kisses Harley, gently whispering 'sayang'. Her heart was racing because it was the first time she had ever kissed an animal. Mdm Chow is one of the seniors participating in a pilot equine-assisted programme run by charity group EQUAL. Her husband, Mr Tan Choon How, is confidently cleaning Falco's nostrils and eyes - a far cry from his first few sessions. 'Even though each session is two hours, it passes by very quickly, like there's not enough time," said Mr Tan, who was initially afraid of the horses. Another participant, Mr Ang Tee Hiom, hugging Harley (above) and standing beside Matahari (below), his favourite horse. 'Feels sad that I won't be able to see her again.' His daughter, Ms Doreen Ang, took leave to join her father on the programme's last day. 'He looked forward to the sessions every week,' she said. Next Story
Independent Singapore
20 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
'I have a degree but no job, and toxic parents — is it just me, or is adulthood in Singapore broken?'
A young man seemingly lost and dont know what to do (for illustration purposes only) SINGAPORE: 'I'm still so lost on what to do with my life.' A young man posted on Reddit. According to many, the 'correct path' was to get a college degree in user experience and game design, a practicum that should last for at least a year. He did all that and even secured some freelance work in childcare. On paper, it appears like a rock-hard groundwork, but after graduation, the truth sets in. The job market was vicious. Not a single discussion with potential employers had come through, even for entry-level roles. And soon, the sense of being trapped—not just career-wise, but personally—began to weigh heavily. The silent weight of expectations The poster opened up about his home life, where 'noxious' family outlooks have seriously surfaced. His parents didn't appreciate the value of his chosen field of study and dismissed its significance. Arguments bubbled up, and for the first time, he began to see how deeply his immediate environment had affected his mental health and sense of self. The solution in his mind was clear: 'I need to leave or I will never be able to grow and become stronger.' The post kindled a wave of responses. There were no judgments, just empathy and reassurance. You're not alone in feeling lost One commenter mildly reminded, 'Feeling lost in your early twenties is incredibly common, perhaps more so than you realize.' Others boomed the sentiment: even netizens who are in their thirties admitted they still haven't figured things out. 'Every age can feel lost,' someone noted, 'and it's not unique to Singapore.' The existing job market, more than a few pointed out, is exacting across industries. Even with a 1.5-year practicum under his name—an extensive experience for any fresh graduate—many young professionals are struggling to find a position. It's not about the lack or absence of talent or the non-existence of ambition. It's just the ill-fated reality of a competitive and volatile economy. Redefining success and self-worth What emerged in the responses was a joint call to redefine what achievement and success look like. One netizen said, 'Sometimes knowing what you want to do with your life can be simply accepting the flow… It doesn't have to be something grand.' In a world infatuated with 5-year campaigns and instantaneous success stories, that reminder is like a breath of fresh air. There was also a robust hint of encouragement to make mental well-being a top priority. Many of the Redditors advised the original poster to contemplate moving out if at all possible, knowing the mental and emotional toll of a toxic home atmosphere. 'If given an opportunity, move out at once,' one netizen recommended. 'I think staying with your family is affecting your mental health.' It's okay not to have it all figured out The thread, originating from one individual's candid admission of doubt and indecision, turned into a digital campfire where unfamiliar persons congregated to say, in different ways: 'You're not crazy. You're not alone, and you're not failing.' For anyone in their twenties—or beyond—feeling 'jammed,' behind, or lost — it's normal. It's human, and it's okay. Growth seldom tracks a straight line. From time to time, the boldest thing people can do is acknowledge uncertainty and insecurity. But keep going anyway. () => { const trigger = if ('IntersectionObserver' in window && trigger) { const observer = new IntersectionObserver((entries, observer) => { => { if ( { lazyLoader(); // You should define lazyLoader() elsewhere or inline here // Run once } }); }, { rootMargin: '800px', threshold: 0.1 }); } else { // Fallback setTimeout(lazyLoader, 3000); } });
Independent Singapore
20 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
'Too young for a flat, too broke for rent — where do you go when you're homeless in your own country?'
SINGAPORE: In the muted corner of Reddit, a Singaporean user posted a plain question: 'Does anyone have any experience as to where to sleep and maintain basic hygiene without a permanent roof and without seeking help from agencies?' While the post was brief, the story it implied was profound and complex. The original poster—a local citizen under 35—is in a risky spot. Jobless, with no family support to rely upon, and unqualified for public housing because of age limitations. In addition, acquiring private property is improbable and out of reach, and with rent becoming too expensive, he's now facing a life without a permanent living accommodation. What ensued was a wave of lived experiences, not expressions of pity or shame, only practical advice and sympathetic words of reassurance from fellow Singaporeans, some of whom had walked the same path. Sleeping under the radar One commenter shared a recollection from childhood – poor and dispossessed, 'taking showers at public swimming pool facilities, and sleeping at Changi Airport,' a real shelter for many in moments of silent desperation. The airport, with its 24/7 lights and comparatively harmless setting, has long been a viable option, a last resort for the homeless. Another shared a more mature version of that narrative: 'six months living inside a rented car, parking close to the workplace or public grounds, sleeping in the steamy uneasiness of a parked vehicle, and taking a bath at community swimming pools or workplace amenities when possible.' East Coast Park was a vital location—free public baths and virtual inconspicuousness, but sleep was elusive. 'Sometimes cannot sleep and the next day have to work—damn difficult.' Working for shelter One response provided another possible lifeline — consider 'working at Resorts World Sentosa (RWS), particularly in F&B roles.' A former casino server narrated how part-time staff got not only salaries (occasionally paid every day) but also food. It was tough work, but for someone who needs fast cash and nourishment, it could bridge the gap. Platforms like FastJobs list short-range and daily-paid gigs, critical for someone with no monetary safeguards. The key, another Redditor pointed out, was flexibility. Keeping one's head above water necessitates readiness to take whatever work comes and making acts of survival a routine. The reluctance to seek help What stood out in the original post was an inaudible struggle to ask for help, not out of pride, but the anxiety to burden others. However, one commenter gently pushed back: 'If the only reason you don't want to reach out to social services is because you don't want to bother anyone, I suggest you just do it. They exist for a reason.' Singapore has agencies, interventions, and facilities for rough sleepers, even if they're not always visible. One such option is the Safe Sound Sleeping Places (S3P) system, set up all over the island. These are nominated accommodations supervised by community groups and charitable organisations. They often have shower facilities, offer meals, and most importantly, safety. Some of these living quarters are faith-based, but anyone can avail of their services. The objective isn't conversion, but compassion. It's available, without judgment. Dignity in hard times For most, homelessness isn't a choice; it's a condition that occurs, often slowly, until unexpectedly one is already navigating where to sleep at night and how to stay clean. Yet, in these online threads, there's a sense of resilience. A certainty that even in one of the world's well-heeled cities, one can survive and endure without disappearing into gloom and desperation, provided that one adapts, accepts help, and holds on to some hope. 'Use your imagination and compromise where you can,' one former homeless netizen wrote. 'That's how I survived.' To the original poster—and others in similar situations—help exists, even if you have to reach a little further than you're used to, and if you're reading this from a place of ease, maybe you now know a little more about those who aren't—and what it takes to get through another night.
