Makeover of S.F. Chinatown park delayed as construction bids come in $10M too high
The bidding process for Portsmouth Square, the city's oldest park, will now start over with a call to be sent out in September, when construction was intended to begin. Bids will be due in late October, with groundbreaking anticipated for March.
'The cost overage is due to global tariffs, ongoing supply chain challenges and widespread construction inflation,' said Tamara Aparton, spokesperson for the Recreation and Park Department, which owns and operates the square.
Aparton said the renovation job is budgeted by the city engineer at a ceiling of $43 million, and the lowest of the three bids bid came in at $54.7 million. Rec and Park will try to bring the cost down by using cheaper construction materials and fencing, and cutting back on amenities that are not crucial to the experience in a heavily used 1.3-acre park known as 'Chinatown's living room.'
The fundamental features of the design, which include a new children's playground and neighborhood clubhouse, a rotating art wall and gathering spaces under a trellis, will not change. The park will not have to be redesigned, which would have potentially delayed the project for years, on top of a decade of delays already incurred. By staying close to schedule, access to city and state bond funds will not be threatened.
'The good news is that it is still on track,' Aparton said. 'Construction is still expected to begin in March 2026, right after the Lunar New Year and just 5½ months later than originally planned.'
Still to be determined is who will cover the $4 million to $5 million cost of removal for the pedestrian bridge that spans Kearny Street and connects the square to the Hilton Financial District hotel and the attached Chinese Culture Center. The demolition of the span, known as 'the bridge to nowhere,' is a major aspect to the park design, but funding for the removal has been in dispute for years.
'While the city works through the bid process for the project, we are separately continuing to negotiate the outstanding issues related to the allocation of demolition costs between the city and the Hilton,' said Jen Kwart, spokesperson for the city attorney of San Francisco. 'The bid process will continue to proceed independent of the negotiations regarding cost allocation.'
Counting the cost of studies, permits, outreach, project management, infrastructure improvements, and other ancillary expenses, the overall project has been valued at $71 million. Construction is expected to take 26 months and be completed in the summer of 2028.
Portsmouth Square is a vital community outdoor space used daily by Chinatown residents, many of whom live in small single-room occupancy apartments. Neighborhood activists were informed of the restart of the bidding process at a community meeting last week.
'They seem to be pretty certain that it will only delay the project by five months,' said Annie Cheung, president and CEO of Self-Help for the Elderly, which runs classes, workshops and training programs out of the Portsmouth Square Clubhouse. She's been involved in planning for the new park for at least 12 years, and is hopeful that this is the last of many false starts.
'The community has been waiting for a long time for the new park,' she said. 'Most of our Chinatown residents live in SROs, and Portsmouth Square is our only major park and open space. No more delay.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
10-07-2025
- San Francisco Chronicle
Controversial S.F. fountain not part of Embarcadero Plaza renovation plans, officials say
The fight for Vaillancourt Fountain heated up Tuesday night at a community meeting where a San Francisco city official said publicly for the first time that the controversial concrete sculpture is not part of the renovation plan for Embarcadero Plaza. 'We did look into keeping the fountain on-site,' Recreation and Park Department Project Manager Eoanna Harrison Goodwin told a decidedly pro-fountain audience, 'but once we got the cost estimate, it is beyond our project budget.' The revelation, while not the final word on the 710-ton sculpture, was perhaps the most discouraging sign yet for its ardent supporters that its days on Embarcadero Plaza may be numbered. The blocky Brutalist fountain, a lightning rod for public opinion since its debut a half-century ago, has deteriorated and broken down in recent years. In June, the park department fenced it off after declaring it a public hazard based on a report that concluded a full renovation would cost roughly $17 million. A new independent estimate now pegs the cost at $29 million, Goodwin said Tuesday — a dramatic jump that earned a collective groan from the crowd. That number did not include the cost of plans, permits and annual upkeep of at least $100,000. That means fixing the fountain would cost nearly as much as the entire Embarcadero Plaza makeover project, budgeted at $32.5 million, Goodwin said. The plan is to combine Embarcadero Plaza and the adjacent Sue Bierman Park to form a single 5-acre multiuse park, twice the size of Union Square. The complicated project is a public-private partnership between the Recreation and Park Department, which manages the land; BXP, which owns the four Embarcadero office towers; the Downtown SF Partnership; and the Office of Economic and Workforce Development. Though the park department maintains the fountain and is indicating it no longer wants it, it does not own the sculpture and has no authority over its possible removal. It is part of the Civic Art Collection, and its fate will eventually be determined by the San Francisco Arts Commission and possibly the Board of Supervisors. Tuesday's community forum at Codi, a meeting popup at Embarcadero Three, came just one month after the fountain's creator, 95-year-old artist Armand Vaillancourt, made a rare visit from his Montreal home to lobby the park department and the arts commission to preserve his namesake work. The fountain has been shut off for a year since its pumps broke, but Vaillancourt told the Chronicle that with some cleaning and repairs it would last another 50 years or more. Vaillancourt was not among the 200 people who RSVP'd for Tuesday's meeting, but his daughter, San Francisco resident Oceania Vaillancourt, attended and made an emotional plea for her father's creation. 'My dad asked me to help him,' said Vaillancourt during the Q&A session after the city's presentation, noting she lives two blocks away and goes by the fountain every day. 'I just can't imagine the fountain not being there,' she said through tears. 'I just hope we can gather the community and hopefully change the decision of removing the fountain.' Also in attendance were members of the Northern California chapter of Docomomo US, a modernist architecture preservation group that has been staging actions to save the fountain. The sculpture, which currently sits in the middle of the multiuse area, was not on any of the diagrams presented Tuesday by HOK, the design firm hired for the project. The diagrams showed a location for a 'permanent art piece,' though apparently not the one that is already there, Petra Marar of Docomomo noted. 'The fountain is not on any of the options,' said Marar. 'It feels like it is all or nothing, keeping it or removing it, and it feels like they are removing it.' Andrew Sullivan, a landscape architect who worked with the famed Embarcadero Plaza designer Lawrence Halprin, said, 'The process that the city went through to determine that the fountain needs to be removed is disingenuous. They predetermined that the demolition of the fountain is a given without any actual design. They just created excuses to get rid of it without any meaningful discussion.' The design of the park has also yet to be determined. The future unification of Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park will be continued at a third meeting to be scheduled this fall. The park will then enter the design phase.
San Francisco Chronicle
17-06-2025
- San Francisco Chronicle
Makeover of S.F. Chinatown park delayed as construction bids come in $10M too high
The long awaited makeover of the historic park at the heart of San Francisco's Chinatown has been set back six months due to construction bids coming in more than $10 million over budget, with anticipated tariffs on construction materials a major factor, officials said. The bidding process for Portsmouth Square, the city's oldest park, will now start over with a call to be sent out in September, when construction was intended to begin. Bids will be due in late October, with groundbreaking anticipated for March. 'The cost overage is due to global tariffs, ongoing supply chain challenges and widespread construction inflation,' said Tamara Aparton, spokesperson for the Recreation and Park Department, which owns and operates the square. Aparton said the renovation job is budgeted by the city engineer at a ceiling of $43 million, and the lowest of the three bids bid came in at $54.7 million. Rec and Park will try to bring the cost down by using cheaper construction materials and fencing, and cutting back on amenities that are not crucial to the experience in a heavily used 1.3-acre park known as 'Chinatown's living room.' The fundamental features of the design, which include a new children's playground and neighborhood clubhouse, a rotating art wall and gathering spaces under a trellis, will not change. The park will not have to be redesigned, which would have potentially delayed the project for years, on top of a decade of delays already incurred. By staying close to schedule, access to city and state bond funds will not be threatened. 'The good news is that it is still on track,' Aparton said. 'Construction is still expected to begin in March 2026, right after the Lunar New Year and just 5½ months later than originally planned.' Still to be determined is who will cover the $4 million to $5 million cost of removal for the pedestrian bridge that spans Kearny Street and connects the square to the Hilton Financial District hotel and the attached Chinese Culture Center. The demolition of the span, known as 'the bridge to nowhere,' is a major aspect to the park design, but funding for the removal has been in dispute for years. 'While the city works through the bid process for the project, we are separately continuing to negotiate the outstanding issues related to the allocation of demolition costs between the city and the Hilton,' said Jen Kwart, spokesperson for the city attorney of San Francisco. 'The bid process will continue to proceed independent of the negotiations regarding cost allocation.' Counting the cost of studies, permits, outreach, project management, infrastructure improvements, and other ancillary expenses, the overall project has been valued at $71 million. Construction is expected to take 26 months and be completed in the summer of 2028. Portsmouth Square is a vital community outdoor space used daily by Chinatown residents, many of whom live in small single-room occupancy apartments. Neighborhood activists were informed of the restart of the bidding process at a community meeting last week. 'They seem to be pretty certain that it will only delay the project by five months,' said Annie Cheung, president and CEO of Self-Help for the Elderly, which runs classes, workshops and training programs out of the Portsmouth Square Clubhouse. She's been involved in planning for the new park for at least 12 years, and is hopeful that this is the last of many false starts. 'The community has been waiting for a long time for the new park,' she said. 'Most of our Chinatown residents live in SROs, and Portsmouth Square is our only major park and open space. No more delay.'
Business Insider
15-06-2025
- Business Insider
My father and I work at AT&T together. On our hourlong commutes, he teaches me valuable lessons about life and my career.
This as-told-to essay is based on a conversation with Nicole Wen, 25, who works at AT&T. It has been edited for length and clarity. My dad got a job at AT&T more than 26 years ago. After college, he told me about the company's amazing internship programs. I ended up doing three summer internships there throughout college, so that's how I got my foot in the door with the company. Today, we're both at AT&T. He is in a leadership position within sales, and I am a principal project program manager. When I first started my full-time job about two years ago, I was living in a townhouse super close to my dad's house, so we would carpool together every day for an hour each way. The most time I've ever spent with him was in those car rides, and it was very special because we learned so much about each other. My dad moved to America from Taiwan when he was 14 years old. He had to learn English, went to high school in California, and then to college in New York, where he met my mom. He then started working with a company that eventually became part of the AT&T family. During those car rides, he also shared a lot of life advice with me. The importance of having a good circle The more I got to know my dad, the more I realized he's a pretty cool guy. I learned he has more friends than I do. He's part of several social groups, like a Porsche club and a coffee club. He even writes a newsletter for a car club. You would think I would know everything about him since he is my father, but no, I never knew any of this about my dad. He's just got so much going on outside work. He inspired me to join an employee resource group. We do a lot of charity work and fundraising events. Our main mission is to support high school students and offer college scholarships. My dad started joining the events too, and that's another thing that we do together now. Our favorite event is the Lunar New Year event, and it's very special coming from a mixed-race household. It teaches me a lot more about my culture. We try all the food together, and it's a really nice bonding experience. Never say 'no' to an opportunity My dad always says, "Never say no to an opportunity, big or small." He often explains to me that opportunities don't come around all the time. It's always a chance to learn something new, and being uncomfortable is OK. This advice has helped me a lot in my networking. I never say no, just like he told me. So if I randomly get invited to a happy hour, that's not even on my own team, I still go — even if I'm tired. I've met a lot of people that way. Have multiple areas of expertise My dad also always says you have to have multiple areas of expertise to elevate your career. If you are an expert in one thing, you're going to be known as an expert for that one thing, and you're going to stay there. He says that's something that he wishes he did differently — expand his expertise versus just siloing in one spot. That definitely stuck with me. I now remind myself that it's good to move around. When I now start to feel comfortable, I seek out discomfort. Three months ago, for example, I accepted a new role coming from one in finance. Now, I'm doing chief of staff work, which is all about planning internal events and thinking about our operations. It's under a whole new set of leaders and seeing a side of the business that I haven't even touched on yet. I've gotten very uncomfortable, and it's been so great — thanks to my dad.
