Why the Big Ten desperately wants to rig College Football Playoff
Petitti, as he plainly stated in a recent interview with Joel Klatt of Fox Sports, works at the behest of one conference.
"Representing the Big Ten," Petitti said, "that's my job."
If Petitti's playoff plan seems rigged in favor of the Big Ten, that's only because it is.
Petitti wants a playoff format that's all upside, no risk, for the Big Ten. Shocking, right?
Herein lies the persistent problem in determining a playoff format for 2026 and beyond. It's not that the conference commissioners who shape the playoff lack ideas. It's that their ideas are so self-serving.
With no overarching commissioner looking out for the good of the game or its postseason, the individual conferences hit an impasse in their playoff format negotiations.
Big Ten wants to reduce role of playoff selection committee
Petitti, in his interview with Klatt, outlined the Big Ten's preference for a 4+4+2+2+1 playoff format. In this 16-team playoff plan, 13 of the 16 spots would be dispersed via automatic bids. The Big Ten and SEC would be assigned four automatic bids apiece. Two apiece would go to the ACC and Big 12, with another auto bid going to the next-best conference champion, leaving just three at-large bids for a selection committee to determine.
"We're not asking to be handed anything," Petitti said.
Actually, you are. You're asking to be handed 25% of the playoff spots before the season begins.
Why should the Big Ten and SEC start with twice as many bids as the ACC and Big 12? Well, because "of historic strength and where we think programs are," Petitti explained.
If history is our guide, how about a bid for 18-time national champion Yale?
I'm kidding, of course. Yale shouldn't receive a bid based on history, no more than the Big Ten should be guaranteed twice as many auto bids as the ACC, which has produced as many national champions as the Big Ten since the start of the Bowl Championship Series era.
The ACC and Big 12 quickly balked at Petitti's stacked-deck plan, and the SEC later soured on the idea. It's not that the SEC felt sorry for the ACC and Big 12. It's more that the SEC worries the auto-bid plan would not reward it enough. The SEC recast its desires toward a 16-team playoff featuring 11 at-large bids, and the SEC is campaigning for the selection committee to more heavily weight strength of schedule metrics, which tend to reflect well on SEC teams.
And, so, here we stand, with no approved playoff format past this season, with each conference angling for a plan they think serves them best.
Tony Petitti playoff plan all upside, no risk for Big Ten
While I dislike any idea, like Petitti's plan, that would stack the deck and award bids based on a conference's preseason clout, I acknowledge the 4+4+2+2+1 format must look pretty good from where the Big Ten commissioner sits. It would achieve Petitti's objectives on how to reshape college football.
Petitti wants to:
∎ Reduce the role of the selection committee. As Petitti puts it: "Let them focus on seeding. Let them focus on the last three at-larges." In other words, he wants to reduce the subjectivity of the selection process at the end of the season, in favor of a stacked deck that awards bids based on conference affiliation and conference standings. But, his plan won't succeed in curtailing controversy, because debates will rage about the committee's last-three-in and how they seed the field.
∎ Encourage Big Ten teams to play tougher non-conference games. In Petitti's plan, most bids would be awarded based on conference performance, so, teams could schedule tough non-conference matchups without worrying about the effect of a loss. "You've got to have a postseason format that makes the regular season better," Petitti said. The problem with that line of thinking: If playoff access is based mostly on conference standings, then non-conference games would become glorified exhibitions.
∎ Install play-in games. If Petitti's playoff plan got approved, the Big Ten could earmark two auto bids for its top two teams, and decide its two remaining auto bids with play-in games: No. 3 vs. No. 6 and No. 4 vs. No. 5. I never thought I'd hear someone argue that the lack of play-in games is holding back college football, but here we are.
∎ Prop up mediocre Big Ten teams. The Big Ten's eighth-place team would be in the playoff hunt entering November in the 4+4+2+2+1 plan. If that team could climb into sixth place, it would reach a play-in game. Win that, and it's playoff bound. To hear Petitti tell it, that's a plus: "We've done some modeling that you could have somewhere between 40 and 50 teams after Week 13 that are" still alive for the playoff. Sorry, but if you're college football's 50th-best team after 13 weeks, you probably shouldn't be alive for the playoff.
True, allowing a selection committee to pick most of the qualifiers and seed the bracket produces uncomfortable decisions, but a dose of drama, a plateful of debate, and a dash of controversy are good for business.
Petitti, though, views this through the Big Ten lens. If he achieved his playoff vision, his conference could strengthen its schedule and enhance its television inventory, while avoiding risk to its postseason prospects. If the Big Ten got trounced in non-conference matchups, no big deal. It still would be guaranteed at least four playoff bids in Petitti's model.
From Petitti's perch, why not try to stack the deck and rig the playoff to favor his league? As a conference commissioner, he must view that as part of his job.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.
This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: Why Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti wants to rig College Football Playoff
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Falcons lose starting WR Darnell Mooney for several weeks with shoulder injury and sign D.J. Chark
FLOWERY BRANCH, Ga. (AP) — Darnell Mooney's status for the start of the season is uncertain as the Atlanta Falcons' second-leading receiver in 2024 is expected to miss several weeks of training camp with a shoulder injury. Mooney suffered the injury in Thursday's first practice of training camp. The Falcons bolstered their depth chart at wide receiver by signing veteran D.J. Chark Jr., who joined the team for Saturday's practice. Chark worked out for the Falcons on Friday. 'That workout was already set up,' Falcons assistant general manager Kyle Smith said Saturday, referring to the visit from Chark being scheduled before Mooney's injury. Smith said Mooney's injury is 'part of the deal' and the front office is 'always ready to find solutions and add to the roster whenever we can.' Smith provided no details on the severity of Mooney's injury. Chark, 29, began the 2024 season on injured reserve with a hip injury and was limited to four catches for 31 yards with one touchdown in seven games with the Los Angeles Chargers. Chark, a second-round draft pick by Jacksonville in 2018, set career highs with 73 catches for 1,008 yards and eight touchdowns for the Jaguars in 2019. Following four seasons with Jacksonville, Chark played for Detroit in 2022 and Carolina in 2023. Mooney had 64 catches for 992 yards and five touchdowns in 2024. Drake London led the team with 100 receptions for 1,271 yards and nine touchdowns. London, Mooney and Ray-Ray McCloud III opened training camp as Atlanta's top wide receivers. KhaDarel Hodge returns as a top backup after starting two games last season. The injury will force Mooney to miss valuable practice time with second-year quarterback Michael Penix Jr., who is entering his first full season as the starter following a three-game audition to close the 2024 season. ___ AP NFL:
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Dolphins sign ex-Patriots star to fill big void
The Miami Dolphins are turning over every stone to try to improve their cornerback depth. They were dealt a big blow this week when Artie Burns tore his ACL, and multiple signings have followed. The latest came Saturday, as the Dolphins announced they had signed free agent Jack Jones. Jones was a fourth-round pick by the Patriots in 2022 who stayed with New England until midway through 2023, when he missed curfew before a game and was released. He joined the Raiders, for whom he played the rest of 2023 and all of 2024. In 2024, Jones set career highs in tackles (69), passes defensed (16) and interceptions (3). MORE: Bills' James Cook contract saga doesn't lessen his importance to Super Bowl aspirations Jones is 27 years old and has seven interceptions through his first three NFL seasons since leaving Arizona State. The Raiders spent the first month of the offseason trying to trade Jones but released him in April after not finding any takers. Now, the Dolphins were desperate and are giving Jones a chance. MORE NFL NEWS: Micah Parsons risks temporary retirement, frozen contract if he leaves training camp Buccaneers holding rookie out because he weighs too much Browns' 10-year NFL veteran retires days into training camp Raiders' 325-pound rookie is the scariest Wildcat quarterback ever Shedeur Sanders could 'realistically' end up in the CFL A toilet is helping Aaron Rodgers and DK Metcalf build chemistry
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Atletico Madrid officially announces the departure of one of its most prominent midfielders!
Rojiblancos want some changes for next season. Getty Images This weekend was a tumultuous one for the red and white Madrid club. Atletico Madrid has already announced the departure of one of its most prominent first-team players, veteran Argentine Rodri de Paul, after a successful spell under his compatriot Diego Simeone. Playing alongside his close friend, Leo Messi The world champion has chosen to complete the next phase of his professional career alongside his close friend in the Argentine national team, the legendary Leo Messi, who is performing magically in Miami alongside Luis Suarez, Sergio Busquets, and Jordi Alba. Today, they have a new member of the inner circle of friends of the legend who wears the number ten shirt. It seems that the Argentine international, who won the Copa America twice with his country, in the 2022 World Cup and the 2022 Finalismo, wants to be close to the venue of the next major event in the United States, the 2026 World Cup, to acclimatize to the atmosphere and prepare for his participation with the Argentine national team as well.