Exclusive: EU to offer five options over Israeli Human Rights breaches
The sources told Euronews that the options will include the full or partial suspension of the Association Agreement, sanctions on individuals such as members of Israeli government, military or extremist Settlers, trade measures, an arms embargo, or a suspension of scientific cooperation such as Horizon Europe Research and Innovation programme.
The UK, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Norway last month sanctioned Israeli ministers Ben Gvir and Smotrich for "incitements of violence against Palestinian communities".
However, the sources acknowledged that with member states at odds over the issue it is unlikely that there will be agreement on any of the five options.
Depending on the course of action EU rules oblige countries to agree unanimously or through qualified majority voting (QMV).
The EU agreed to review it's association agreement with Israel in May after the country's military offensive in Gaza and the West Bank as well as its blocking of food, fuel, water and basic medical supplies to the besieged population.
But since Tel Aviv launched strikes against Iran last month, and in the face of a potential cease-fire in Gaza, there is even less appetite in Europe to take any action against Israel. Despite the eight-page review listing Israel's human rights violations, the 27 European leaders agreed at their Council summit last week to only continue discussions...taking into account the evolution of the situation on the ground."
A full suspension of the association agreement would be impossible as it would require unanimity and many countries such as Hungary, the Czech Republic but also Germany have opposed that option.
Diplomats also doubt that the European Commission, which has full competence over trade, would agree to a partial suspension on the trade elements of the agreement. Such suspension would require a qualified majority vote and if one or several large countries are against such decision, the vote fails.
Euronews can also reveal that in a recent top-secret meeting of the college of 27 Commissioners, including President Von der Leyen, EU Commissioners refused to support trade measures against Israel.
Currently, Germany is the largest EU country selling arms to Israel - most countries have reduced or officially ended arms sales to Israel.
However, a formal arms embargo is unlikely to pass as Germany - alongside Hungary, Austria and Czechia and potentially others such as Italy would not support it.
Sanctions against Israeli individuals require unanimous support and several sources confirm this to be an 'impossible' motion due to the member states' positions.
Suspending Israel's membership of Horizon Europe's research programme only requires a qualified majority, but sources from member states admit there is currently 'no momentum' within the EU to act against Israel. One commission official also said there was "no appetite" to sanction the Israeli population.
'To cause such suffering to the civilian population, as has increasingly been the case in recent days, can no longer be justified by the fight against Hamas terrorism,' German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has said criticising the Israeli action. According to several EU officials who spoke to Euronews on condition of anonymity, however, the German government is now fully supportive of Tel Aviv.
An EU official from a member state which opposes taking action said they would consider "measures that can improve the situation on the ground – we don't feel these [options] would help to make things better", the official said.
A source close to Kallas told Euronews her ambition is to "'stop the killing and get the food, medicine and aid into Gaza – she doesn't care how it's done."
Last week she dispatched Christophe Bigot, the EU's Special Representative (EUSR) for the Middle East Peace Process to Israel and the Palestinian Territories to engage with Israeli authorities and examine the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the West Bank.
EU Officials are also taking into account ongoing talks between the Trump administration and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu to initiate a ceasefire, and whether this may influence decisions at an EU level.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
2 hours ago
- LeMonde
Israeli negotiators due in Qatar for Gaza truce talks
An Israeli delegation was expected in Doha on Sunday, July 6, for talks on a Gaza truce and hostage release deal, ahead of a visit by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to the White House. Netanyahu had earlier announced he was sending a team to Qatar, a key mediator in the conflict, though he said that Hamas's response to a draft US-backed ceasefire deal included some "unacceptable" demands. Faced with mounting calls to end the war that is nearing its 22 nd month, Netanyahu is due to meet on Monday with US President Donald Trump, who has been making a renewed push to end the fighting. On Saturday, protesters gathered in Israel's coastal hub of Tel Aviv for a weekly rally demanding the return of hostages still in the Gaza Strip since Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack that triggered the war. Macabit Mayer, the aunt of captives Gali and Ziv Berman, called for a deal "that saves everyone." Hamas said Friday it was ready "to engage immediately and seriously" in negotiations. A statement from Netanyahu's office said that "the changes that Hamas is seeking to make in the Qatari proposal... are unacceptable to Israel", while also sending negotiators to discuss "the Qatari proposal that Israel has agreed to." On the ground, Gaza's civil defence agency said 14 people were killed by Israeli forces on Sunday. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties in accessing many areas mean Le Monde and Agence France-Presse (AFP) are unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defence agency. Contacted by AFP, the Israeli military said it could not comment on specific strikes without precise coordinates. 60-day truce Hamas has not publicly detailed its responses to the US-sponsored proposal, which was transmitted by mediators from Qatar and Egypt. Two Palestinian sources close to the discussions told AFP the proposal included a 60-day truce, during which Hamas would release 10 living hostages and several bodies in exchange for Palestinians detained by Israel. However, they said, the group was also demanding certain conditions for Israel's withdrawal, guarantees against a resumption of fighting during negotiations, and the return of the UN-led aid distribution system. Since the Hamas attack sparked a massive Israeli offensive with the aim of destroying the group, mediators have brokered two temporary halts in fighting, during which hostages were freed in exchange for Palestinian prisoners in Israeli custody. Of the 251 hostages taken by Palestinian militants during the October 2023 attack, 49 are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. The Egyptian foreign ministry said Saturday that top diplomat Badr Abdelatty held a phone call with Washington's main representative in the truce talks, Steve Witkoff, to discuss "preparations for holding indirect meetings between the two parties concerned to reach an agreement." But recent efforts to broker a new truce have repeatedly failed, with the primary point of contention being Israel's rejection of Hamas's demand for a lasting ceasefire. The war has created dire humanitarian conditions for the more than two million people in the Gaza Strip. A US- and Israel-backed group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, took the lead in food distribution in the territory in late May, when Israel partially lifted a more than two-month blockade on aid deliveries. UN agencies and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with the GHF over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives. UN human rights office spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani said Friday that more than 500 people have been killed waiting to access food from GHF distribution points.
Euronews
7 hours ago
- Euronews
Ireland, Lithuania and Spain: Who will lead the Eurogroup next?
Ireland, Lithuania and Spain are vying for leadership of the Eurogroup on Monday, which chairs the monthly meetings of the 20 eurozone finance ministers and plays a key role in coordinating and influencing the Council's economic policy decisions. Over the past two decades, the Eurogroup has had only four permanent presidents: Luxembourg's Jean-Claude Juncker (2005–2013), the Netherlands' Jeroen Dijsselbloem (2013–2018), Portugal's Mário Centeno (2018–2020), and Ireland's Paschal Donohoe. Since 2020, the position has been held by Donohoe, a member of the influential European People's Party (EPP). But for his potential third term, the Irishman is being challenged by the socialist finance ministers of Spain and Lithuania, Carlos Cuerpo and Rimantas Šadžius, who are offering an alternative vision for the next two and a half years. The vote on Monday will be held in secret. To win, a candidate must secure at least eleven out of twenty votes. Cuerpo offers a 'renewed' and ambitious agenda The Spanish contender, Carlos Cuerpo, is an economist with a PhD and previous experience at the European Commission and Spain's fiscal watchdog, AIReF. He has served as Spain's finance minister since late 2023, when he succeeded Nadia Calviño, who now leads the Luxembourg-based European Investment Bank. Cuerpo is not the first Spaniard to seek leadership of this informal group. Calviño ran against Donohoe in 2022, and Luis de Guindos—now Vice President of the European Central Bank—also tried to secure the role during his time as economy minister under a Spanish Popular Party government. In his motivation letter to fellow ministers, Cuerpo laid out an 'ambitious' and renewed agenda aimed at strengthening the eurozone's long-term growth, completing the capital markets union, boosting the international role of the euro, and finalizing the banking union. 'The time has come to move from discussion to delivery. The credibility of our collective project depends not on what we say, but on what we achieve—together, and without delay,' Cuerpo wrote. Earlier this month, Spain—along with Germany, France, and Italy—presented a discussion paper arguing that although the Eurogroup has been effective during crises, it has often lacked decisiveness in other areas, particularly in advancing the capital markets union. As a Spanish socialist, the 44-year-old finance minister has also supported issuing new common debt to strengthen Europe's defence capabilities. He has called for doubling the EU's next long-term budget—from 1% of the bloc's GDP—to fund both traditional priorities, such as agriculture and cohesion, and new ones, including security, defence, and the green and digital transitions. Several diplomatic sources suggest the real contest is between Cuerpo and Donohoe. However, Cuerpo's political family is in the minority within the Eurogroup, and his more transformative proposals may face resistance from fiscally conservative countries like Germany and the Netherlands. Paschal Donohoe: 'predictability' in times of crisis Amid soaring trade tensions and a war on the EU's borders, Paschal Donohoe tells his 19 finance peers in a letter seeking their support that the global economy is at 'a pivotal juncture'. Despite all the challenges, the Irishman argues that the Eurogroup remains a source of predictability, stability and transparency. He also praised the achievements of recent years under his leadership, while warning that more work is needed. "The changing external environment gives us the impetus and imperative to progress on long-standing issues and deliver on our shared priorities," he said, promising to remain an honest broker in the group's negotiations. If he is re-elected, he plans to deepen the European capital markets, make progress on the digital euro, promote greater dynamism in integration, and continue to invest in security cooperation. 'An awful lot can happen in a number of weeks in the world that we're in, but I am encouraged by the support I've currently received,' the Irish finance minister told Euronews in a recent interview. Šadžius calls for a less concentrated capital markets union In the race for the presidency of the Eurogroup, Rimantas Šadžius is the wild card. Despite being a highly experienced finance minister from Lithuania, he faces two main disadvantages: he belongs to the socialist political family—meaning he competes for the same pool of votes as Carlos Cuerpo—and he is seeking the backing of smaller countries, a constituency Paschal Donohoe has long cultivated. Šadžius has served as a member of the Luxembourg-based European Court of Auditors, and has played a leading role in Lithuania's accession to the eurozone since 2015. He also chaired ECOFIN during Lithuania's presidency of the Council of the EU in 2013, a period marked by key decisions on the creation of the Banking Union. Diplomatic sources suggest Šadžius could attract support from EU member states closest to Russia's border, but he is not expected to gain enough votes to win the race. In his letter to fellow ministers, the Lithuanian candidate pledges to promote deeper integration of member states into the euro area, avoid overlaps with the European Council's agenda, ensure fiscal sustainability, and accelerate the rollout of the digital euro. Like his rivals, Šadžius commits to completing both the banking union and the capital markets union. However, he stresses the need to address the fact that the latter remains 'heterogeneous and more concentrated in Western and Northern Europe.'
Euronews
14 hours ago
- Euronews
Israeli demonstrators call for ceasefire deal and return of hostages
Thousands rallied on the streets of Tel Aviv on Saturday, demanding a ceasefire in Gaza and a deal to release the remaining captives held by Hamas. Protesters carried banners reading 'Bring them home now' as they demanded that the Israeli government bring about an end to the conflict. The relatives and supporters of Israeli hostages gathered following reports that both Hamas and Israel have reacted positively the outlines of a US-brokered truce deal. Israeli media reported on Saturday that a decision was made to dispatch a delegation to Qatar to hold hostage deal talks with Hamas amid the ongoing diplomatic efforts. Hamas on Friday said it had given a 'positive' response to the latest proposal, but said further talks were needed on implementation. It was not clear whether their statement meant they accepted a proposal from US President Donald Trump for a 60-day ceasefire. Hamas has been seeking guarantees that any ceasefire would bring about a permanent end to the war – now nearly 21 months old. Trump has been pushing hard for a deal and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is set to visit him in the White House next week. The war began when Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing some 1,200 people and taking 251 others hostage. About 50 of them still in captivity in Gaza. Israel responded with an offensive that has killed over 57,000 Palestinians, more than half of them women and children, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which is led by medical professionals employed by the Hamas government.
