Energy regulator ‘ignored' High Court ruling that could boost powers to restrict data centres
Ms Boylan sought documents under Freedom of Information (FOI) after the regulator, the Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU), issued a proposal last February on the regulations that should apply to new data centres.
Data centres currently use 22pc of all the country's electricity and multiple agencies and experts have warned that the electricity system cannot cope with their growing demand.
The CRU proposed that new data centres could be permitted if they generated all the power they needed themselves.
In theory, that could mean developing windfarms or solar parks, but because the proposal stated the generation plants must be on site, in reality they would be installing gas-fired generators.
Such a move would drive up gas use and emissions, contrary to the Climate Action Plan and legally-binding emission-reduction targets.
The CRU in its proposal said it had taken legal advice on potential measures such as requiring data centres to meet 'net zero' emissions standards.
'Following legal review, the CRU considers that the current provisions under the Climate Action Act do not provide a mandate to CRU to deliver a connections policy which requires explicit emissions reduction,' it said.
However, just days before this was published, the High Court delivered a landmark ruling on the climate action responsibilities of state agencies and public bodies.
It was made in relation to Coolglass Windfarm proposed for Co Laois, which An Bord Pleanála refused to grant planning permission for on the basis that it would contravene the Laois County Development Plan by being a visual intrusion on the landscape.
ADVERTISEMENT
Mr Justice Richard Humphreys said the grounds on which An Bord Pleanála based its decision were outweighed by the requirements of the Climate Act, specifically section 15 which deals with the responsibilities of public bodies to behave in accordance with the act.
It was the first time the strength of section 15 was tested and has potentially massive implications for all public bodies.
Yet the FOI documents show that a draft of the CRU proposal, drawn up before the highly publicised judgment, was the same as the decision made public after it.
"The Coolglass ruling gave the CRU a clear legal footing to act decisively on data centres, yet the CRU's policy reads like business as usual, as if ruling never happened,' Ms Boylan said.
"The claim that they lack the legal authority to act decisively on data centre emissions now rings hollow. The CRU must publish their legal advice.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
‘It would be a waste': Little appetite in Sinn Féin for Mary Lou McDonald to run for president
There is little appetite among Sinn Féin for Mary Lou McDonald to run for president as party figures move closer to the idea of backing Catherine Connolly . Sinn Féin's Ard Chomhairle has not yet considered a report consulting the party's membership on its views, and the party will not make a formal decision until September. But a number of figures in the party neither believe nor support the idea that Ms McDonald would run. 'I don't want her in the Áras,' one said. 'It would be a waste.' 'I don't see a universe where she would run.' READ MORE A number of sources within Sinn Féin said they would favour keeping Ms McDonald in the Dáil to lead the party's ongoing bid to get into government. There is a view emerging that to have Ms McDonald run for president could be read as a concession that Sinn Féin was losing its ambition for the office of an taoiseach. Ms McDonald prompted speculation on her possible candidacy for the upcoming presidential election when she declined to rule herself out of the race earlier this month. It was a marked change in position for the leader of the Opposition, who had definitively said she would not be running for president in March. It is understood Ms McDonald's recent comments may have been a recognition of a desire for her to run among party supporters, who were recently consulted on their views. Sinn Féin remains nervous about presidential elections following a bruising run for its then MEP Liadh Ní Riada in the 2018 contest. Ms Ní Riada came fourth with a little more than 6 per cent of first-preference votes. Though Ms McDonald is recognised as a very strong candidate with a massive national profile, party figures are privately reluctant to put 'our best vote getter' up for what can be a bruising and unpredictable contest. There are anxieties within the party that anything less than an overwhelming win for Ms McDonald could feed a media narrative about a dip in Sinn Féin's electoral fortunes. Sinn Féin is generally relaxed about the question of its presidential candidacy and is content to wait until as late as September to make a decision. If Sinn Féin does not run its own candidate, it is likely to support the campaign of Independent TD Ms Connolly. [ Who is Catherine Connolly? The outspoken left-wing campaigner running for president Opens in new window ] Launching her campaign earlier this month, Ms Connolly said 'I think we're going to have united Ireland very soon' but it would not be 'immediate'. This was widely perceived within the party to have been for the benefit of Sinn Féin and an open effort on the part of Ms Connolly to court the party. Few Sinn Féin TDs could remember ever having heard Ms Connolly talk about reunification in her nearly ten years in the Dáil. The independent TD did support a recent Sinn Féin motion which proposed extending voting rights to Northern Ireland. Will Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin abstain from the presidential race? Listen | 40:42
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Miriam Lord's Dáil end-of-term awards: from cute hoors to rookie errors and good operators
School's out for summer. Some TDs are skipping lightly home with their end-of-term report cards. Others are losing their schoolbags and hoping nobody notices. It's no big thing this year. Continuous assessment is how it goes in politics; and where the class of 2025 is concerned their Dáil and Seanad journeys are just beginning. The general election may have happened last November, but business in both Houses of the Oireachtas only started in January. Business proper took months to get going thanks to the mammoth opening schmozzle over independent deputies who signed up to support the Government muscling in on the Opposition's speaking rights. READ MORE The row derailed Micheál Martin's big day in the Dáil when his election as Taoiseach had to be abandoned amid chaotic scenes in the chamber. The rules were tweaked to allowed these independents, along with government backbenchers, a chance to table questions to the Taoiseach directly after the Opposition's slot. The controversy, which considerably delayed the working of the Dáil, has blown over for now, although the backbenchers and independents attempts at grilling the Boss have been such a damp squib one has to wonder why they bothered making such a fuss about it in the first place. Most unexpected controversy award went to skorts. Here Sinn Féin Oireachtas members stand in solidarity with camogie players who had called for the right to choose between shorts and skorts when playing. Photograph: Sinn Féin But this episode will be not forgotten by the Opposition. Unlike most of the term which followed. Just seven Bills have been enacted this year. That first one was a vital piece of emergency legislation, nobody said. It allowed the Government to increase the number of Junior Ministers on its books to mob proportions and festoon five of its domesticated independents with Super Junior status. The committees are only getting into their stride now. The sluggish start didn't give politicians much of a chance to shine. Much of the new intake barely got a look-in. Maybe some of them might have the makings of a report card by the end of the year. In the meantime, here's a few who made it on to the summer prizegiving list for their performance so far. Top of the class: Jim O'Callaghan Traditionally, this tends to go to a party leader. But none them has had a stellar start. The politician who has stood out in what has not been a particularly competitive field so far is Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan . He has proved the most proactive member of Cabinet so far, he doesn't tend to waffle and his Dáil performances have been measured and conciliatory. Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill is a close second in a very difficult portfolio. Best senator: Michael McDowell He's been at this politics lark forever now and maybe there are other Seanad performers who deserve a look in, but Michael McDowell has had a great term. Still busy on the legislative front, still the best speaker in the Upper House and still happily batting away the bouquets from people who want him to run for president. He was first senator elected to the 27th Seanad, topping the poll in the National University constituency. No wonder he's been padding contentedly around the Leinster House campus, smiling like a Chesire Cat. Opposition best boy: Alan Kelly The former Labour leader is full of beans these days and when he isn't asking probing questions about Garda accountability (he seems to have a terrific source or two), he's happy out chairing the showbiz Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport. Deputy leader of the Labour Party Alan Kelly is the standout Opposition figure. Photograph: Stephen Collins/Collins Guaranteed a few headlines there and AK-47 isn't going to miss them. Opposition best girl: Jennifer Whitmore The Social Democrat TD for Wicklow is more low-key than best boy Kelly, but that's not a bad thing. Jennifer is consistently good with her contributions across a range of issues and her Leaders' Questions clash with constituency colleague and Tánaiste Simon Harris on the last day of term showed she can mix it with the best of them as she called out a Government of 'epic wasters', which was 'reckless and feckless' with a giveaway budget before the election, but was now 'moralising' about financial restraint. Another Opposition TD who doesn't go in for showboating is Sinn Féin's Pat Buckley (Cork East) who is very considered and thoughtful in his contributions, particularly on social issues. Fianna Fáil's occasionally difficult backbencher, John McGuinness, also had an excellent term. He was elected Leas-Cheann Comhairle and had the satisfaction of hearing the State apology to Lucia O'Farrell, who had long campaigned for the truth surrounding the death of her son Shane, who was killed by a driver out on bail. McGuinness was one of Lucia's staunchest allies all through the years when most TDs had moved on. Cutest hoor in class: Micheál Martin/Michael Lowry This is a tie between Micheál Martin and the independent deputy formerly known (by the Taoiseach) as the disgraced TD for Tipperary North, Michael Lowry . Hard to imagine that Micheál once told the Dáil that Michael was not fit to be a member of that august house after the Moriarty tribunal found that Lowry, a former Fine Gael minister, attempted to help businessman Denis O'Brien secure the State's second mobile phone licence in 1995. This didn't stop the Taoiseach striking a deal with Lowry and his group of Regional Independent TDs who became, in the words of Mary Lou McDonald, 'the wobbly leg of the Coalition stool'. Taoiseach Micheál Martin struck a smart deal with independent TDs. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill Micheál bagged a cohort of supporters with benefits who will remain loyal once they are minded, further cementing his government's grip on power. As he will probably bow out at the next election, if not before, the Lowry stroke won't come back to bite him. As to the kingmaker formerly known as the disgraced deputy for Tipperary North, he's thrilled with himself. He couldn't look happier if he was giving the two fingers to that Dublin socialist, Paul Murphy. Mr Congeniality: Cian O'Callaghan The acting Social Democrat leader never seemed comfortable with the tricky situation surrounding prodigal TD Eoin Hayes, who pulled off a shock victory for the party in Dublin Bay South only to be exiled from the parliamentary party for misleading colleagues over when he got rid of shares he held in a company with links to the Israeli military. On one of the many occasions Cian was asked about the party's on-off relationship with Eoin (he came in very handy for ballast when they needed an extra body for committee appointments), he declared awkwardly: 'I said hello to Eoin just last week.' Happily, word came through on Friday that the suspension has been lifted. They have killed the fatted calf and now they can all say hello to each other whenever they want now. Prizes for honesty and courage: Minister of State and Chief Whip Mary Butler and Sinn Féin senator Nicole Ryan During statements on Pride Week, Mary was one of many TDs to speak on the subject. But as it was the penultimate day of the Dáil term, those statements got very little attention. The Fianna Fáil TD for Waterford said she was speaking not only as a minister, 'but as a proud mother, ally and advocate for the full inclusion of LGBTQ+ people in Irish life. I am especially proud of who I am and who my family is. My son is a transgender young man and seeing him grow into his own identity reminds me daily of the urgent need for compassion, dignity and fairness in public policy. 'Sometimes the debate in relation to trans issues rages on social media without facts or understanding. It can be very hurtful. We should all reject those nasty opinions from people who do not understand the hurt and pain for young trans people who have to navigate a difficult enough pathway in their lives.' Sinn Féin's Nicole Ryan won plaudits for speaking out in the Seanad about domestic violence. Photograph: Sam Boal/Collins Cork-based senator Nicole Ryan was loudly applauded by her colleagues in the Upper House for her moving contribution during a debate on the Domestic Violence Bill. She told how she witnessed domestic abuse as a child, living in a violent home from the age of four to seven. 'As a child, when you're developing through that stage, it shapes how you see the world' she said. 'For two decades, I lived in the shadow of shame.' She learned how to read people. 'I would know the kind of mood that he'd be in by the way that his foot crossed the threshold of the front door.' Her mother escaped, 'but none of us got out unscathed'. Senator Ryan said she was sharing her story 'to stand up for all the other young children that are out there that are living in these homes'. Best gaffe: Darragh O'Brien The Minister for Transport wowed all the guests at the British Ambassador's summer garden party with a lovely speech made all the more enjoyable by the many nice things he had to say about his friend Jonathan, His Majesty's envoy to Ireland. Except that the ambassador's name is Paul. Second place in this highly contested category is Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty, for delivering a high-decibel, passionate speech in the Dáil about rip-off grocery prices, fulminating about Irish-owned grocery chain SuperValu being owned by a major American food distribution company. He was one of three SF speakers who made the same mistake, having been fed the wrong information in their supplied scripts. Most unexpected controversy: skorts The row over allowing elite camogie players to choose between wearing shorts or skorts ended up in the Dáil. Minister of State Charlie McConalogue had to deal with it. 'It is important that they come together to find a resolution that is comfortable for everyone,' he wittered, oblivious to the reason why the athletes rebelled in the first place. Most unexpected venue for the launch of a presidential campaign: The High Court Michael Flatley's declared intention to run for the Áras was revealed by his barrister during a High Court case the choreographer has taken in relation to works carried out at his Castlehyde mansion in Co Cork. Flatley is even going to move back to Ireland in the coming weeks to push for a nomination. Rookie error prize for thinking out loud: James Lawless As he confidently breezed through a radio interview with RTÉ's Justin McCarthy at the end of June, the Minister for Higher Education addressed the one-off cash support which students heading to college had enjoyed for the last three years. To fee, or not to fee, that is the question. Well, James? He revealed that student fees 'as things stand' were likely to go up by a whopping €1,000. Chaos ensued. It could have been worse for James as angry constituents piled around the country with complaints about higher fees. But when Fine Gael began muttering about the increase, pressure eased on the Kildare North TD. Amid talk of a rift between the two coalition parties, the FF deputies circled the wagons around James and rallied to his defence. (Even if they were privately raging.)
Irish Examiner
14 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Plans for 280 apartments on campus of former Bessborough mother and baby home refused
A proposal for 280 apartments on part of the former Bessborough mother and baby home campus in Cork has been shot down. An Coimisiún Pleanála, formerly An Bord Pleanála, gave two key reasons, linked to concerns about housing mix and its design, for rejecting Estuary View's The Meadows scheme – one of two large residential schemes proposed by the company on separate sites it owns at Bessborough. The buy-to-sell Meadows scheme was earmarked for a landbank on the eastern side of the site, and included four buildings ranging in height from one to 10 storeys. It was submitted to the former Bord Pleanála in 2021 under the since-discontinued strategic housing development (SHD) process. It also proposed a new pedestrian and cycle way bridge connection with the Blackrock to Passage West greenway, which flanks the site's eastern boundary. The zoning in the area permits residential, but it is an area designated as high landscape value. However, in its ruling An Coimisiún Pleanála said the mix of units did not meet the target levels set out in the city development plan. It also said no "statement of housing mix" was submitted, and therefore no justification had been provided in relation to the proposed mix of units. Secondly, it said it considered its 'excessive and sustained scale, bulk and mass in combination with height, and the consequent plot ratio" would be visually obtrusive from several viewpoints within and adjoining the site. Burial ground The commission also noted a third recommended reason for refusal from its inspector – the presence of a potential burial ground immediately in front of the folly – which was among the reasons for its decision to refuse permission for a previous SHD application and another housing proposal on Bessborough. But it said it believes the Meadows site, could, subject to careful forensic monitoring of ground works, be more amenable to residential development, and it decided not to include this as a reason for refusal. Labour Cllr Peter Horgan said: "Given that this entire site is fraught with emotion and history, we need to put an end to the constant retrenching of concern that is brought whenever an application is provided here." Estuary View declined to comment.
